No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Cold War Austria and Migration from Eastern Europe: Refugees and Labor Migrants
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 May 2024
Abstract
This article revisits Austria's migration history from the end of World War II until the end of the Cold War. Recent research has challenged the persistently commemorated welcoming Austrian attitude toward refugees who had been living under communism. The initial humanitarian efforts in 1956 and 1968, respectively, were remarkable. However, an analysis beyond the first weeks of both events reveals that (though to different degrees) public and political attitudes toward refugees took a negative turn. Throughout the 1970s, asylum for dissidents was portrayed as a continuation of the country's humanitarian tradition. However, in 1981, refugees from Poland were immediately perceived as unwanted labor migrants. In 1989/90, the scenario was similar: while the transiting East German refugees were welcomed, migrants from other countries (like Romania) were not. In the early 1990s, Austria decided on a reform of its asylum and foreigner policies. But when and why did the (supposedly welcome) refugees from countries under communist rule turn into unwelcome labor migrants? The analysis in this article explores the potential impact of the age of détente and the repercussions of the 1970s economic crises and the resulting end to active recruitment of foreign workers.
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Masaryk Institute and Archives of the Czech Academy of Sciences, 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Regents of the University of Minnesota
References
1 Rupnow, Dirk, “The History and Memory of Migration in Post-War Austria: Current Trends and Future Challenges,” in Migration in Austria (Contemporary Austrian Studies 26), eds. Bischof, Günter and Rupnow, Dirk (New Orleans, 2017), 37–65Google Scholar.
2 For critical reassessments, see Graf, Maximilian and Knoll, Sarah, “Das Ende eines Mythos? Österreich und die Kommunismusflüchtlinge,” in Aufnahmeland Österreich. Über den Umgang mit Massenflucht seit dem 18. Jahrhundert eds. Börries Kuzmany and Rita Garstenauer (Vienna, 2017), 206–29Google Scholar; Maximilian Graf and Sarah Knoll, “In Transit or Asylum Seekers? Austria and the Cold War Refugees from the Communist Bloc,” in Migration in Austria, eds. Bischof and Rupnow, 91–111. For a full review of the state of the field, see Graf, Maximilian, “Austria as a Cold War Refuge: Reassessing the Historiography,” Zeitschrift für Ostmitteleuropaforschung 71, no. 4 (2022): 619–49Google Scholar.
3 Graf, Maximilian, “Humanitarianism with Limits: The Reception of Refugees from the Global South in Austria in the 1970s,” zeitgeschichte 49, no. 3 (2022): 367–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Maximilian Graf, “Beyond Victims of Communism? Austria and the Human Rights Question in the 1970s,” in The Human Rights Breakthrough of the 1970s. The European Community and International Relations, eds. Sara Lorenzini et al. (London, 2022), 178–95.
4 Sarah Knoll, “Flucht oder Migration? Polnische Flüchtlinge in Österreich 1981/82,” in Österreich – Polen. Stationen gemeinsamer Geschichte im 20. Jahrhundert, eds. Peter Ruggenthaler and Wanda Jarząbek (Graz, 2020), 215–30; Maximilian Graf, “Fluchtbewegungen nach Österreich im Zuge der ‘polnischen Krise’ 1980–1982,” in Migration. Flucht – Vertreibung – Integration, eds. Stefan Karner and Barbara Stelzl-Marx (Graz, 2019), 123–36.
5 Knoll, Sarah, “Eine ‘Völkerwanderung’? Die Flucht aus Rumänien und die Flüchtlingspolitik in Österreich um 1990,” Studies in Contemporary History 19, no. 3 (2022): 511–36Google Scholar.
6 For brief research-based overviews, see Thomas Albrich, “Asylland wider Willen: Die Problematik der Displaced Persons in Österreich 1945–1948,” in Die bevormundete Nation: Österreich und die Alliierten 1945–1949, eds. Günter Bischof and Josef Leidenfrost (Innsbruck, 1988), 217–44; Gabriela Stieber, “Die Lösung des Flüchtlingsproblems 1945–1960,” in Österreich in den Fünfzigern, eds. Thomas Albrich et al. (Innsbruck, 1995), 67–93.
7 Gatrell, Peter, Free World? The Campaign to save the World's Refugees 1956–1963 (Cambridge, 2011), 109–10Google Scholar, 214–15.
8 Zahra, Tara, “‘Prisoners of the Postwar’: Expellees, Displaced Persons, and Jews in Austria after World War II,” Austrian History Yearbook 41 (2010): 191–215CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
9 For a recent assessment, see Strobl, Philipp and Hagen, Nikolaus, “New Perspectives on Displaced Persons (DPs) in Austria,” zeitgeschichte 47, no. 2 (2020): 165–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10 Kern, Friedrich, Österreich: Offene Grenze der Menschlichkeit. Die Bewältigung des ungarischen Flüchtlingsproblems im Geiste internationaler Solidarität (Vienna, 1959), 26–27Google Scholar.
11 Francesca Rolandi, “Escaping Yugoslavia: Italian and Austrian Refugee Policy toward Yugoslav Asylum Seekers after World War II,” in The Alps-Adriatic Region 1945–1955. International and Transnational Perspectives on a Conflicted European Region, eds. Wolfgang Mueller et al. (Vienna, 2018), 85–109; Maximilian Graf, “Upside-down: Bilateral and transnational relations between Austria and Yugoslavia before and after 1948,” in The Tito-Stalin split 1948. 70 Years After, eds. Tvrtko Jakovina and Martin Previšić (Zagreb, 2020), 197–206.
12 Schemper, Lukas, “Der Hohe Flüchtlingskommissar der Vereinten Nationen, Österreich und die Repatriierung sowjetischer Flüchtlinge,” in Österreich im Kalten Krieg. Neue Forschungen im internationalen Kontext, eds. Maximilian Graf and Agnes Meisinger (Göttingen, 2016), 49–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 Volf, Patrik-Paul, “Der politische Flüchtling als Symbol der Zweiten Republik: Zur Asyl- und Flüchtlingspolitik seit 1945,” zeitgeschichte 22, no. 11/12 (1995): 415–36Google Scholar.
14 See the chapters by Ferenc Cseresnyés, Edda Engelke, Peter Eppel, András Lénárt, Ibolya Murber, and Kornél Zipernovszky in Die ungarische Revolution und Österreich 1956, eds. Ibolya Murber and Zoltán Fónagy (Vienna, 2006). Also, see Andreas Gémes: Austria and the 1956 Hungarian Revolution: Between Solidarity and Neutrality (Pisa, 2008)Google Scholar; for a concise and recent summary, see Murber, Ibolya, “Betreuung und Integration von Ungarnflüchtlingen in Österreich 1956/57,” in Migration. Flucht – Vertreibung – Integration, eds. Stefan Karner and Barbara Stelzl-Marx (Graz, 2019), 103–20Google Scholar.
15 Knoll, Sarah, “Calling for Support: International Aid for Refugees in Austria during the Cold War,” zeitgeschichte 48, no. 3 (2021): 395–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
16 Brigitta Zierer, “Willkommen Ungarnflüchtlinge 1956?,” in Asylland wider Willen: Flüchtlinge in Österreich im europäischen Kontext seit 1914, eds. Gernot Heiss and Oliver Rathkolb (Vienna, 1995), 157–71.
17 Silke Stern, “Die tschechoslowakische Emigration: Österreich als Erstaufnahme- und Asylland,” in Prager Frühling: Das internationale Krisenjahr 1968, eds. Stefan Karner et al. (Vienna, 2008), 1025–43.
18 Recently, see Mueller, Wolfgang, Leidinger, Hannes, and Ishchenko, Viktor, “‘When Israel Was in Egypt's Land.’ Jewish Emigration from the USSR, 1968–1991,” zeitgeschichte 49, no. 3 (2022), 343–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
19 On this and the next paragraph, see Hakan Gürses et al., eds., Gastarbajteri: 40 Jahre Arbeitsmigration (Vienna, 2004); Vida Bakondy, ed., Viel Glück! Migration heute. Wien, Belgrad, Zagreb, Istanbul (Vienna, 2010); Ivanović, Vladimir, “Die Beschäftigung jugoslawischer Arbeitskräfte in Österreich in den 1960er und 1970er Jahren,” zeitgeschichte 40, no. 1 (2013): 35–48Google Scholar; Lorber, Verena, Angeworben: GastarbeiterInnen in Österreich in den 1960er und 1970er Jahren (Göttingen, 2016)Google Scholar.
20 Memcon Kreisky – Bashev, 22.7.1965, Österreichisches Staatsarchiv (ÖStA)/Archiv der Republik (AdR), Bundesministerium für Auswärtige Angelegenheiten (BMAA)/II-Pol, Bulgarien 2, GZ. 131.851-6/65, Zl. 139.853-6/65.
21 Maximilian Graf, “The Opening of the Austrian-Hungarian Border Revisited: How European Détente Contributed to Overcoming the ‘Iron Curtain,’” in New Perspectives on the End of the Cold War. Unexpected Transformations? eds. Bernhard Blumenau et al. (London, 2018), 138–58. The author intends to publish a comparative critical reassessment of the Western Cold War demand for greater “freedom of movement” and corresponding visa policies by considering the example of Austria and Eastern Europe.
22 Stanek, Eduard, Verfolgt Verjagt Vertrieben. Flüchtlinge in Österreich von 1945–1984 (Vienna, 1985), 146–47Google Scholar.
23 On Austria and the Polish crisis, see Maximilian Graf, “Österreich und die ‘polnische Krise’ im Kontext 1980–1983,” in Österreich – Polen. Stationen gemeinsamer Geschichte im 20. Jahrhundert, eds. Peter Ruggenthaler and Wanda Jarząbek (Graz, 2020), 201–21.
24 Graf, “Fluchtbewegungen nach Österreich im Zuge der ‘polnischen Krise’ 1980–1982,” 127–30.
25 Transcript in “Information für den Herrn Bundesminister,” ÖStA/AdR, BMAA/II-Pol, GZ. 166.03.00/355-II.3/81.
26 Graf, “Fluchtbewegungen nach Österreich im Zuge der ‘polnischen Krise’ 1980–1982,” 131–36.
27 A more detailed analysis of this development will be published by Maximilian Graf, “From Refugees to Labor Migrants: Cold War Austria in the Central European Context,” in Unlikely Refuge (working title), ed. Michal Frankl (forthcoming 2025). For further details, see https://www.unlikely-refuge.eu/.
28 Knoll, “Eine ‘Völkerwanderung’?” 511–36.
29 Memcon. Vranitzky – Gorbatschow, 30.9.1991, ÖStA/AdR, BMAA/II-Pol, GZ. 518.01.225/14-II.3/91.
30 On the government's position as portrayed by the Minister of the Interior, see Löschnak, Franz, Menschen aus der Fremde: Flüchtlinge, Vertriebene, Gastarbeiter (Vienna, 1993)Google Scholar. For a critical study, see Franz, Barbara, Uprooted and Unwanted: Bosnian Refugees in Austria and the United States (College Station, 2005)Google Scholar.
31 Softić, Hasan, “Arbeit – Neubeginn – Flucht. Die Entstehung der bosnischen Community in Enns,” in Aufnahmeland Österreich. Über den Umgang mit Massenflucht seit dem 18. Jahrhundert, eds. Börries Kuzmany and Rita Garstenauer (Vienna, 2017), 230–52Google Scholar.
32 For a more detailed summary, see Weigl, Andreas, Migration und Integration. Eine widersprüchliche Geschichte (Innsbruck, 2009), 43–47, 67–68Google Scholar, 83–85.
33 Graf, Maximilian, “The Accession of the Neutrals: (Re)assessing the First Post-Cold War Enlargement of the EU,” in European Integration and the Global Financial Crisis. Looking Back on the Maastricht Years, 1980s–1990s, eds. Michele Di Donato and Silvio Pons (Cham, 2023), 91–111CrossRefGoogle Scholar.