Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-nr4z6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-21T22:28:11.325Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Human Rights Trials in an Era of Democratic Stagnation: The Case of Turkey

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Jessica G. Mecellem
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Domestic human rights trials are often conceptualized within the context of transition toward democracy. Yet, a recent cascade of trials in Turkey defies this argument. Between 2008 and 2015, Turkish courts oversaw fifteen trials examining individual criminal accountability for human rights violations carried out by the Turkish military during the conflict with the PKK in the 1990s. The cascade of trials has emerged and remained ongoing while the Turkish regime has become steadily more authoritarian. This article explains the emergence of these trials by the redistribution of power among elite actors, which created a window of opportunity allowing for ongoing legal mobilization to result in prosecutions. Drawing on original data from interviews conducted in Turkey between 2014–2015, this study demonstrates the importance of power redistribution for human rights during periods of democratic stagnation, while emphasizing the ability of trials to contribute to the contestation of hegemonic narratives.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 43 , Issue 1 , Winter 2018 , pp. 119 - 151
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aeyal, Gross. 2004. The Constitution, Reconciliation and Transitional Justice: Lessons from South Africa and Israel. Stanford Journal of International Law 40 (47): 47–104.Google Scholar
Alpkaya, Gökçen, Altıntaş, İlkem, Sevdiren, Öznur, and Sevimli, Emel Ataktürk. 2013. Enforced Disappearances and the Conduct of the Judiciary. Hafiza Merkezi (Truth Justice Memory Center), Istanbul, Turkey. http://www.hakikatadalethafiza.org/kaynak.aspx?GResourceId=86&LngId=5 (accessed June 1, 2015).Google Scholar
Amicus Curiae Brief. 2014. To the Presidency of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Turkey. In conjunction with file number 13/260 before the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Turkey, submitted by Truth Justice and Memory Center, the Turkish Economic and Social Studies Foundation, Human Rights Foundation of Turkey, Human Rights Association, Human Rights Agenda Association, Helsinki Citizens Assembly, Human Rights Research Association, European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights. On file with the author.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 2015/2016. Annual Report. https://www.amnesty.org/en/countries/europe-and-central-asia/turkey/report-turkey/ (accessed March 2, 2016).Google Scholar
Arthur, Paige. 2009. How “Transitions” Reshaped Human Rights: A Conceptual History of Transitional Justice. Human Rights Quarterly 31:321–67.Google Scholar
Atılgan, M., and Işık, S. 2012. Disrupting the Shield of Impunity: Security Officials and Rights Violations in Turkey. TESEV Publications. http://www.tesev.org.tr/Upload/Publication/383a90be-696-7bc-85b8-5a771d6132c/1171ENGcezasizlik12_03_12Rev1.pdf (accessed October 2, 2015).Google Scholar
Avsar, Gülcin, Özdil, Koray, and Kirmizidag, Nur. 2013. The Other Side of the Ergenekon: Extrajudicial Killings and Forced Disappearances. Democratization Program, Istanbul, Turkey, Turkish Economic and Social Studies Foundation. http://www.tesev.org.tr/assets/publications/file/1302201105122.pdf (accessed June 2, 2015).Google Scholar
Bakiner, Onur. 2016. Judges Discover Politics: Sources of Judges' Off‐Bench Mobilization in Turkey. Journal of Law and Courts Spring.Google Scholar
Barahona de Brito, Alexandra, González‐Enríquez, Carmen, and Aguilar, Paloma, eds. 2001. The Politics of Memory: Transitional Justice in Democratizing Societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Belge, Ceren. 2006. Friends of the Court: The Republican Alliance and Selective Activism of the Constitutional Court of Turkey. Law & Society Review 40 (3): 653–92.Google Scholar
Bia News Desk. December 29, 2014. Roboski Massacre Commemorated on its Third Anniversary. http://www.bianet.org/english/human-rights/161159-roboski-massacre-commemorated-on-its-third-anniversary (accessed June 6, 2015).Google Scholar
Bilsky, Leora Y. 2004. Transformative Justice: Israeli Identity on Trial. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Bozkurt, Hatice, and Özlem, Kaya. 2014. “‘Holding Up the Photograph’ Experiences of Women Whose Husbands were Forcibly Disappeared”. Hafiza Merkezi (Truth Justice Memory Center), Istanbul, Turkey. http://dealingwiththepast.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Holding_Up_the_Photograph-Hafiza_Merkezi_2014.pdf (accessed October 25, 2016).Google Scholar
Budak, Yeliz. 2015. Dealing with the Past: Transitional Justice, Ongoing Conflict and the Kurdish issue in Turkey. International Journal of Transitional Justice, published online April 1, 2015.Google Scholar
Burstein, Paul. 1991. Legal Mobilization as a Social Movement Tactic: The Struggle for Equal Employment Opportunity. American Journal of Sociology 96 (5): 1201–25.Google Scholar
Çali, Basak. 2010. The Logic of Supranational Human Rights Litigation, Official Acknowledgement, and Human Rights Reform: The Southeast Turkey Cases Before the European Court of Human Rights, 1996–2006. Law & Social Inquiry 35 (2): 311–37.Google Scholar
Carothers, Thomas. 1999. Aiding Democracy Abroad: The Learning Curve. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.Google Scholar
Carothers, Thomas. 2002. The End of the Transition Paradigm. Journal of Democracy 13 (2): 5–21.Google Scholar
Cingrinelli, David L., and Richards, David L. 1999. Measuring the Level, Pattern, and Sequence of Government Respect for Physical Integrity Rights. International Studies Quarterly 43 (2): 407–17.Google Scholar
Dagi, Ihsan. 2008. Turkey's AKP in Power. Journal of Democracy 19 (3): 25–30.Google Scholar
Diamond, Larry. 1995. Promoting Democracy in the 1990s: Actors and Instruments, Issues and Imperatives. New York: Carnegie Corporation.Google Scholar
El‐Ghobashy, Mona. 2008. Constitutionalist Contention in Contemporary Egypt. American Behavioral Scientist 51:1590–1610.Google Scholar
Epp, Charles R. 1996. Do Bills of Rights Matter? The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. American Political Science Review 90 (4): 765–79.Google Scholar
Faili, Belli. 2016. Musa Çitil Davası. http://failibelli.org/dava/musa-citil-davasi/(accessed February 10, 2016).Google Scholar
Finnemore, Martha, and Sikkink, Kathryn. 1998. International Norm Dynamics and Political Change. International Organization 52 (4): 887–917.Google Scholar
Freedom House. Turkey. https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2016/turkey (accessed March 2, 2016).Google Scholar
Freedom House. 2016. Emerging Threats in Turkey: Political Trends in 2016. Written testimony by Nate Schenkkan, Project Director, Nations in Transit. https://freedomhouse.org/article/emerging-threats-turkey-political-trends-2016 (accessed February 9, 2016).Google Scholar
Goodman, L. A. 1961. Snowball Sampling. Annals of Mathematical Statistics 32 (1): 148–70.Google Scholar
Göral, Özgür Sevgi, Işık, Ayhan, and Kaya, Özlem. 2013. Unspoken Truth: Enforced Disappearances. Istanbul: Hafıza Merkezi—The Truth Justice Memory Center. http://dealingwiththepast.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Unspoken_Truth-Hafiza_Merkezi_2013.pdf (accessed June 1, 2015).Google Scholar
Güncelleme, Son. 2008. Turkey's Court Decides Not to Close AKP, Urges Unity and Compromise, Hürriyet, July 30.Google Scholar
Merkezi, Hafiza. 2016. Turkey's New Ordinary Rule: Curfews. http://hakikatadalethafiza.org/en/turkeys-new-ordinary-rule-curfews/ (accessed February 9, 2016).Google Scholar
Hale, William. 1994. Turkish Politics and the Military. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Harris, George. 1988. The Role of the Military in Turkey in the 1980s: Guardians or Decision‐Makers? In State, Democracy and the Military: Turkey in the 1980s, ed. Heper, Metin and Evin, Ahmet. New York: Walter deGruyter.Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch. 2014. Turkey's Human Rights Rollback: Recommendations for Reform. http://www.hrw.org/reports/2014/09/29/turkey-s-human-rights-rollback (accessed June 1, 2015).Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch. 2016. World Report 2016. https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/world_report_download/wr2016_web.pdf (accessed March 2, 2016).Google Scholar
Huntington, Samuel. 1991. Democracy's Third Wave. Journal of Democracy 2 (2): 12–13.Google Scholar
Hurriyet Daily News. 2015. 236 Acquitted in Balyoz Coup Case. Hurriyet Daily News, March 31. http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/236-acquitted-in-balyoz-coup-case.aspx?PageID=238&NID=8008&NewsCatID=338 (accessed June 2, 2015).Google Scholar
Huyse, Luc. 1995. Justice After Transition: On the Choices Successor Elites Make in Dealing with the Past. Law & Social Inquiry 20 (1): 51–78.Google Scholar
Jelin, Elizabeth. 2007. Public Memorialization in Perspective: Truth, Justice and Memory of Past Repression in the Southern Cone of South America. International Journal of Transitional Justice 1 (1): 138–56.Google Scholar
Jenkins, Gareth. 2007. Continuity and Change: Prospects for Civil‐Military Relations in Turkey. International Affairs 83 (2): 339–55.Google Scholar
Jenkins, Gareth. 2009. Between Fact & Fantasy: Turkey's Ergenekon Investigation. Silk Road Paper, Central Asia‐Caucuses Institute, Silk Road Studies Program. http://www.silkroadstudies.org/resources/pdf/SilkRoadPapers/2009_08_SRP_Jenkins_Turkey-Ergenekon.pdf (accessed March 2, 2016).Google Scholar
Jenkins, Gareth. 2015. Stoking the Fires: Crises, Conspiracies and Miscalculations. Turkey Analyst, December 1. http://www.turkeyanalyst.org/publications/turkey-analyst-articles/item/493-stoking-the-fires-crises-conspiracies-and-miscalculations.html (accessed February 9, 2016).Google Scholar
Karakaya, Naim, and Özhabes, Hande. 2013. Judicial Reform Packages: Evaluating Their Effect on Rights and Freedoms. Democratization Program Policy Report Series (5). Istanbul: Turkish Economic and Social Studies Foundation.Google Scholar
Katzenstein, Peter J. 1996. The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Keck, Margaret E., and Sikkink, Kathryn. 1998. Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Keck, Margaret E., and Sikkink, Kathryn. 1999. Transnational Advocacy Networks in International and Regional Politics. International Social Science Journal 159:89–101.Google Scholar
Kim, Hun Joon. 2010. Explaining the Deterrence Effect of Human Rights Prosecution for Transitional Countries. International Studies Quarterly 5:939–63.Google Scholar
Kim, Hun Joon. 2012. Structural Determinants of Human Rights Prosecutions After Democratic Transition. Journal of Peace Research 9 (2): 305–20.Google Scholar
Kim, Hun Joon, and Sikkink, Kathryn. 2010. Explaining the Deterrence Effect of Human Rights Prosecutions for Transitional Countries. International Studies Quarterly 54: 939–63.Google Scholar
Kim, Hun Joon, and Sikkink, Kathryn. 2013. How Do Human Rights Prosecutions Improve Human Rights After Transition? Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Rights Law 7 (1): 69–90.Google Scholar
Kovras, Iosif. 2014. Truth Recovery and Transitional Justice: Deferring Human Rights Issues. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Kritz, Neil J. 1995. Transitional Justice: How Emerging Democracies Recon with Former Regimes: Volume 1 General Considerations. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press.Google Scholar
Lessa, Francesca. 2013. Memory and Transitional Justice in Argentina and Uruguay, Against Impunity. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Levitsky, Steven, and Way, Lucan A. 2006. Linkage Versus Leverage. Rethinking the International Dimension of Regime Change. Comparative Politics 38 (4): 379–400.Google Scholar
Levitsky, Steven, and Way, Lucan A. 2010. Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes After the Cold War. Cambridge: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Lutz, Ellen, and Sikkink, Kathryn. 2001. The Justice Cascade: The Evolution and Impact of Foreign Human Rights Trials in Latin America. Chicago Journal of International Law 2 (1): 1–33.Google Scholar
McAdam, Doug, Tarrow, Sidney, and Tilly, Charles. 2001. Dynamics of Contention. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
McCarthy, John D., and Zald, Mayer N. 1977. Resource Mobilization and Social Movements: A Partial Theory. American Journal of Sociology 82 (6): 1212–21.Google Scholar
Michel, Verónica, and Sikkink, Kathryn. 2013. Human Rights Prosecutions and the Participation Rights of Victims in Latin America. Law & Society Review 7 (4): 873–907.Google Scholar
Moustafa, Tamir. 2003. Law Versus the State: The Judicialization of Politics in Egypt. Law & Social Inquiry 28 (4): 883–930.Google Scholar
Moustafa, Tamir. 2007. The Struggle for Constitutional Power: Law, Politics and Economic Development in Egypt. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Mustafa, Faizen. 2015. Judicial Independence: What Turkey Must Learn from India. Today's Zaman, November 17. http://www.todayszaman.com/op-ed_judicial-independence-what-turkey-must-learn-from-india_404521.html (accessed February 6, 2016).Google Scholar
Ní Aoláin, Fionnuala, and Campbell, Colm. 2005. The Paradox of Transition in Conflicted Democracies. Human Rights Quarterly 27 (1): 172–213.Google Scholar
Nino, Carlos Santiago. 1996. Radical Evil on Trial. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
O'Donnell, Guillermo, and Schmitter, Philippe C. 1986. Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Tentative Conclusions About Uncertain Democracies. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Olsen, Tricia D., Payne, Leigh A., and Reiter, Andrew. 2010. Transitional Justice In Balance: Comparing Processes, Weighing Efficacy. Washington, DC: USIP Press Books.Google Scholar
Osiel, Mark. 1986. The Making of Human Rights Policy in Argentina: The Impact of Ideas and Interests on a Legal Conflict. Journal of Latin American Studies 18 (1): 135–80.Google Scholar
Özbudun, Ergun. 2015. Turkey's Judiciary and the Drift Toward Competitive Authoritarianism. International Spectator, Italian Journal of International Affairs 50 (2): 42–55.Google Scholar
Risse, Thomas, Ropp, Stephen C., and Sikkink, Kathryn, eds. 1999. The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change, 1st ed. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Roht‐Arriaza, Naomi. 2002 . Civil Society in Processes of Accountability. In Post‐Conflict Justice, International and Comparative Criminal Law Series, Ardsley, NY: Transnational Publishers.Google Scholar
Pion‐Berlin, David. 1994. To Prosecute or Pardon? Human Rights Decisions in the Latin American Southern Cone. Human Rights Quarterly 16 (1): 105–30.Google Scholar
Saglam, Servet. 2013. The Turkish High Council of Judges and Prosecutors in the Context of Judicial Independence and Accountability. Law & Justice Review 4 (2): 165–224.Google Scholar
Sarigil, Zeki. 2014. The Turkish Military: Principle or Agent. Armed Forces & Society 40 (1): 168–90.Google Scholar
Shamir, Ronen. 1990. “Landmark Cases” and the Reproduction of Legitimacy: The Case of Israel's High Court of Justice. Law & Society Review 24 (3): 781–806.Google Scholar
Sikkink, Kathryn. 2011. The Justice Cascade: How Human Rights Prosecutions are Changing World Politics. New York: W.W. Norton & Company.Google Scholar
Sikkink, Kathryn, and Walling, Carrie Booth. 2007. The Impact of Human Rights Trials in Latin America. Journal of Peace Research 4: 27–25.Google Scholar
Sikkink, Kathryn, and Kim, Hun Joon. 2013. The Justice Cascade: The Origins and Effectiveness of Prosecutions of Human Rights Violations. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 9:269–85.Google Scholar
Skaar, Elin. 1999. Truth Commissions, Trials—Or Nothing? Policy Options in Democratic Transitions. Third World Quarterly 20 (6): 1109–28.Google Scholar
Skaar, Elin. 2007. Legal Development and Human Rights in Uruguay: 1985–2002. Human Rights Review 8 (2): 52–70.Google Scholar
Skaar, Elin. 2011. Judicial Independence and Human Rights in Latin America: Violations, Politics and Prosecution. New York: Palgrave MacMillan.Google Scholar
Snyder, Jack, and Vinjamuri, Leslie. 2003. Trials and Errors: Principle and Pragmatism in Strategies of International Justice. 28 (3): 5–44.Google Scholar
Strang, David. 1991. Adding Social Structure to Diffusion Models: An Event History Framework. Sociological Methods & Research 19 (3): 32–53.Google Scholar
Teitel, Ruti G. 2003. Transitional Justice Genealogy. Harvard Human Rights Journal 16: 69–94.Google Scholar
Tezcür, Gunes Murat. 2009. Judicial Activism in Perilous Times: The Turkish Case. Law & Society Review 3 (2): 305–36.Google Scholar
Tezcür, Gunes Murat. 2010. Muslim Reformers in Iran and Turkey: The Paradox of Moderation. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Tezcür, Gunes Murat. 2015. Violence and Nationalist Mobilization: The Onset of the Kurdish Insurgency in Turkey. Nationalities Papers: The Journal of Nationalism and Ethnicity 3 (2): 28–66.Google Scholar
Tilly, Charles. 2007. Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Tilly, Charles, and Tarrow, Sidney. 2011. Contentious Politics. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Truth, Justice and Memory Center. 2015. Case Summaries as of January 2015. On file with the author.Google Scholar
Yildiz, Karim, and Muller, Mark. 2008. The European Union and Turkish Accession. London: Pluto Press.Google Scholar
Zalaquett, José. 1992. Balancing Ethical Imperatives and Political Constraints: The Dilemma of New Democracies Confronting Past Human Rights Violations. Hastings Law Journal 3:1425–38.Google Scholar
Zaman. 2013. Her savcıya bin faili meçhul dosyası [A Thousand Files on Murders by Unknown Assailants for Every Prosecutor. Zaman, September 20. http://www.zaman.com.tr/gundem_her-savciya-bin-faili-mechuldosyasi_2138832.html (accessed June 6, 2015).Google Scholar
Zemans, Frances Kahn. 1983. Legal Mobilization: The Neglected Role of the Law in the Political System. American Political Science Review 77 (3): 690–703.Google Scholar
Zürcher, Erik J. 2004. Turkey: A Modern History, 3rd ed. New York: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar