No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
‘I am safer in Hong Kong’: Transimperial entanglements in Filipino nationalist explorations
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 13 May 2024
Abstract
Between 1907 and 1914, Filipino lawyer, journalist, and nationalist Vicente Sotto found in Hong Kong a sanctuary from the clutches of the Americans. The city also provided him with a space in which to explore alternative ideas for both his own development and the future of the Philippine Islands beyond the confines of pan-Asianism and anti-imperialism. Using Sotto’s experience in Hong Kong as a point of access, this article demonstrates modern Asia’s anti-imperial era as a product of transimperial ‘connectivities’ and ‘ruptures’ wherein new political affinities were forged between like-minded Asians, while interstitial imperial spaces between colony and metropole carved space for radical, yet nuanced and inconsistent, visions of national independence to materialize—at the expense of abutting empires. It serves to decentralize the role of empire, conflating instead the activities of local, colonial, and imperial actors as a singular experience that shaped modern Asia’s revolutionary decades.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press.
References
1 Copies of The Philippine Republic are unavailable; this was cited in ‘The Philippine Republic: Sotto’s views on the extradition case’, South China Morning Post, 6 May 1912.
2 It should be noted that Sotto’s idea of Philippine independence shifted throughout the first few decades of the twentieth century. His ultimate goal, however, remained consistent: to re-establish the Philippine Republic by any means.
3 Throughout this article, ‘empire’ comprises ‘large political units, expansionist or with a memory of power extended over space, polities that maintain distinction and hierarchy as they incorporate new people’: Burbank, J. and Cooper, F., Empire in world history: Power politics and the politics of difference (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2010), p. . The idea that transimperialism decentralizes empires is from Daniel Hedinger and Nadin Heé, ‘Transimperial history—connectivity, cooperation and competition’, Journal of Modern European History, vol. 16, no. 4, 2018, p. 430.Google Scholar
4 See, for instance, Talbot, I., A history of modern South Asia: Politics, states, diasporas (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2016), pp. 117–129Google Scholar; Zhu, Qian, ‘Exile to the equator: Chinese anti-colonialism and nationalism in Southeast Asia, 1939–1946’, China and Asia, vol. 4, no. 1, 2022, pp. 112–146CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Aydin, C., The politics of anti-Westernism in Asia: Visions of world order in pan-Islamic and pan-Asian thought (Columbia: Columbia University Press, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Manela, E., The Wilsonian movement: Self-determination and the international origins of anticolonial nationalism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009)Google Scholar.
5 See, for instance, Harper, T., Underground Asia: Global revolutionaries and the assault on empire (Harvard, MA: Harvard University Press, 2020)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; un Nisa Aziz, Zaib, ‘Passages from India: Indian anti-colonial activism in exile, 1905–20’, Historical Research, vol. 90, no. 248, 2017, pp. 404–421Google Scholar; Zachariah, Benjamin, ‘A long, strange trip: The lives in exile of Har Dayal’, South Asian History and Culture, vol. 4, no. 4, 2013, pp. 574–592CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Davis, Andrew, ‘Exile in the homeland? Anti-colonialism, subaltern geographies and the politics of friendship in the early 20th century Pondicherry, India’, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, vol. 35, no. 3, 2017, pp. 457–474.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
6 See, for instance, Lin Lewis, Su, ‘Print culture and the new maritime frontier in Rangoon and Penang’, Moussons, vol. 17, 2011, pp. 127–144CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lin Lewis, Su, ‘Print and colonial port cultures of the Indian Ocean littoral: Penang and Rangoon’, Journal of the Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, vol. 82, no. 2, 2009, pp. 9–24Google Scholar; Limapichart, Thanapol, ‘The emergence of the Siamese public sphere: Colonial modernity, print culture and the practice of criticism (1860s–1910s)’, South East Asia Research, vol. 17, no. 3, 2009, pp. 361–399CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Shani, Giorgio, ‘From “critical” nationalism to “Asia as method”: Tagore’s quest for a moral imaginary’ and its implications for post-western international relations’, Global Studies Quarterly, vol. 2, 2022, pp. 1–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ei Thandar Aung, ‘Japan–Myanmar relations in political, economic and cultural contexts during 1930s’, PhD thesis, Okayama University, 2020, pp. 6–9.
7 Condos, Mark, ‘The Indian “Alsatia”: Sovereignty, extradition, and the limits of Franco-British colonial policing’, The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, vol. 48, no. 1, 2020, pp. 101–126CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sripana, Thanyathip, ‘Tracing Hồ Chí Minh’s sojourn in Siam’, Southeast Asian Studies, vol. 2, no. 3, 2013, pp. Google Scholar; Gunn, Geoffrey, ‘Under British law: Ho Chi Minh in Hong Kong (1931–33)’, The Asia-Pacific Journal, vol. 20, no. 13, 2022, p. Google Scholar. See also Aiyar, Sana, ‘Anticolonial homelands across the Indian ocean: The politics of the Indian diaspora in Kenya, c. 1930–1950’, The American Historical Review, vol. 116, no. 4, 2011, pp. 987–1013CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
8 See, for instance, Kong, Vivian, ‘Exclusivity and cosmopolitanism: Multi-ethnic civil society in interwar Hong Kong’, The Historical Journal, vol. 63, no. 5, 2020, pp. 1281–1302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
9 Wu Lun Ni Xia 吳倫霓霞, ‘Xianggang fanQing geming xuanchuan baokan ji qiyu Nanyang de lianxi 香港反清革命宣傳報刊及其與南洋的聯繫’, The Journal of the Institute of Chinese Studies of The Chinese University of Hong Kong 香港中文大學中國文化研究所學報, vol. 19, 1988, pp. 407–421; Chan, Catherine S., ‘An alternative Macanese public sphere: Discussing Portuguese Macau’s problems in British Hong Kong’, The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, vol. 51, no. 2, 2023, pp. 244–264CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10 Gunn, G., Ho Chi Minh in Hong Kong: Anticolonial networks, extradition and the rule of law (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021), pp. .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
11 Jarvis, Helen, ‘Tan Malaka: Revolutionary or renegade?’, Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars, vol. 19, no. 1, 1987, pp. 50–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
12 Matthiessen, S., Japanese pan-Asianism and the Philippines from the late nineteenth century to the end of World War II: Going to the Philippines is like coming home? (Leiden: Brill, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Aboitiz, N. C., ‘Philippine Asianist thought and pan-Asianist action at the turn of the twentieth century’, in The anticolonial transnational: Imaginaries, mobilities, and networks in the struggle against empire, (eds) Manela, E. and Streets-Salter, H. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023), pp. 19–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Aboitiz, N. C., Asian place, Filipino nation: A global intellectual history of the Philippine revolution, 1887–1912 (Columbia: Columbia University Press, 2020).Google Scholar
13 Suh, Chris, The allure of empire: American encounters with Asians in the age of transpacific expansion and exclusion (New York: Oxford University Press, 2023).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
14 The Ilustrados comprised educated Filipinos seeking to reform their country in the late nineteenth century under Rizal’s La Liga Filipina. Katipunan, on the other hand, was founded in 1892 by Andrés Bonifacio as an anti-colonial union between urban clerks and artisans.
15 The exile of Aguinaldo and his supporters to Hong Kong was a part of the truce.
16 William W. Smythe to Edward Chichester, ‘State of Cebu’, 18 June 1898, Manila, The National Archives (TNA), ADM 125/143, pp. 174–176.
17 R. B. Mojares, Vicente Sotto: The maverick senator (Cebu: Cebuano Studies Center, 1992), p. 15.
18 Cruz-Lucero, Rosario, ‘The “nation” in Vicente Sotto’s literary imagination: A study of thirteen Cebuano stories’, Philippine Quarterly of Culture and Society, vol. 31, no. 4, 2003, pp. 294–295.Google Scholar
19 Philippine Supreme Court, ‘The United States v. Vicente Sotto’, 20 November 1907, Chan Robles Virtual Law Library, available at https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907novemberdecisions.php?id=632, [accessed 11 April 2024].
20 ‘Local news’, South China Morning Post, 25 November 1908.
21 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 48.
22 Mojares, Resil B., ‘Vicente Sotto and the rise of realism in Cebuano literature’, Philippine Quarterly, vol. 4, no. 2, 1976, p. .Google Scholar
23 Nothing is known of the readership and circulation of The Philippine Republic.
24 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 55.
25 Schumacher, John N., ‘The Cavite mutiny: An essay on the published sources’, Philippine Studies, vol. 20, no. 4, 1972, pp. .Google Scholar
26 Ronald Kenneth Bell, ‘The Filipino junta in Hong Kong, 1893–1903: History of a revolutionary organization’, MA thesis, University of San Diego, 1974, pp. 50–54.
27 For Ponce’s entanglements with Japan and pan-Asianism, see Aboitiz, Asian place, pp. 112–147.
28 Setsuho, Ikehata, ‘La participación de Japón en la revolución Filipina de 1896’, Revista Española del Pacífico, vol. V, no. 5, 1995, p. .Google Scholar
29 Goodman, Grant K., ‘Artemio Ricarte and Japan’, Journal of Southeast Asian History, vol. 7, no. 2, 1966, pp. 48–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
30 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 52.
31 La Liga Filipina was a secret organization founded by José Rizal in 1892 to support the idea of a Filipino reform moment.
32 For Ponce’s pan-Asianism, see Cuunjieng Aboitiz, Nicole, ‘Fantasy, affect, and pan-Asianism: Mariano Ponce, the First Philippine Republic’s foreign emissary, 1898–1912’, Philippine Studies: Historical and Ethnographic Viewpoints, vol. 67, no. 3/4, 2019, pp. 489–520.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
33 Goodman, Grant K., ‘The problem of Philippine independence and Japan: The first three decades of American colonial rule’, Southeast Asia An International Quarterly, vol. 1, no. 3, 1971, p. .Google Scholar
34 Jose, Ricardo T., ‘Exile as protest: Artemio Ricarte’, Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, vol. 8, no. 1–2, 1999, p. .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
35 Goodman, ‘Artemio Ricarte and Japan’, pp. 48, 51.
36 Matthiessen, Japanese pan-Asianism, p. 186.
37 Vicente Sotto, ‘Why we want to be independent’, South China Morning Post, 17 December 1912; Matthiessen, Japanese pan-Asianism, p. 186.
38 A Chinese, ‘Chinese superior to Filipinos’, South China Morning Post, 27 January 1913; Another Chinese, ‘Filipino civilization’, South China Morning Post, 28 January 1913; Vicente Sotto, ‘Filipinos superior to all Orientals’, South China Morning Post, 28 January 1913.
39 Vicente Sotto, ‘Injustice to the Filipinos’, South China Morning Post, 5 December 1913.
40 Vicente Sotto, ‘Democrats and the Philippines’, South China Morning Post, 18 November 1912.
41 Vicente Sotto, ‘Refuting the “San Francisco Chronicle”’, South China Morning Post, 8 February 1913.
42 Vicente Sotto, ‘Wilson and the Philippines’, South China Morning Post, 27 February 1913.
43 Cited in Aboitiz, Asian place, p. 112.
44 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, pp. 61, 55, 58.
45 For the cartoon, see Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 20.
46 For works on the Philippine revolution and Japan, see, for instance, Aboitiz, ‘Fantasy, affect, and pan-Asianism’; Goodman, Grant K., ‘Japanese pan-Asianism in the Philippines: The Hirippin Dai Ajia Kyokai’, Studies on Asia, vol. 1, no. 7, 1966, pp. 133–143.Google Scholar
47 Bell, ‘The Filipino junta’; Epistola, S. V., Hong Kong junta (Quezon City: University, 1996).Google Scholar
48 Laura Díaz Esteve, ‘Aguinaldo’s British men: Defending the Philippine revolution through the Hong Kong and Singapore press, 1896–1902’, PhD thesis, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, 2022.
49 ‘Hostile operations of Filipino junta’, 25 November 1900, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/301, pp. 525–528.
50 ‘Filipino junta kept alive’, New York Times, 28 October 1903.
51 Lowe, L., The intimacies of four continents (Durham: Duke University Press, 2015), p. .Google Scholar
52 May to Foreign Office, 16 June 1904, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/323, pp. 111–112.
53 Foreign Office to May, 22 August 1904, London, TNA, CO129/326, pp. 424–426.
54 Goodman, ‘General Artemio Ricarte’, p. 49.
55 The colonial authorities were referencing a stipulation from the 1870 Extradition Act which prevented the British authorities from surrendering fugitives if their offence was of a political character.
56 The Hongkong law reports. Vol. VII, 1912 (Hong Kong, 1960), p. 146.
57 ‘Extradition proceedings: consul-general Anderson’s evidence’, South China Morning Post, 2 April 1912; ‘The Philippine Republic: Sotto’s views on the extradition case’, South China Morning Post, 6 May 1912.
58 The Hongkong law reports, p. 146.
59 The refusal to use the terms ‘colony’ or ‘dependency’ was rooted in the divergence between imperialism and the republican spirit. For an example of how the Democrats hammered the Republicans for seizing the Philippines, see ‘Hill and Coler speak, Philippine policy of the government denounced again’, New York Times, 14 October 1900. For a detailed study of how and why the Americans denied claims that its overseas territories were ‘colonies’, see Immerwahr, D., How to hide an empire: A history of the greater United States (New York: Farrar Straus and Giroux, 2019).Google Scholar
60 Severn to Harcourt, 1 May 1912, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/390, pp. 6–9; ‘Philippine journalist discharged’, South China Morning Post, 22 April 1912.
61 The Hongkong law reports, pp. 146, 139.
62 Attorney general to colonial secretary, 27 April 1912, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/390, pp. 6–9.
63 Foreign Office to secretary of state, 20 June 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/395, pp. 376–379.
64 ‘Local news’, South China Morning Post, 29 November 1912.
65 Sotto, ‘Democrats and the Philippines’.
66 ‘Vicente Sotto’, The China Mail, 30 November 1912.
67 ‘Sotto discharged, case concluded’, South China Morning Post, 7 December 1912.
68 ‘Local news’, South China Morning Post, 10 December 1912.
69 May to Harcourt, 22 January 1913, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/399, pp. 236–239.
70 Foreign Office to secretary of state, 27 March 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/405, pp. 323–324.
71 Home Office to secretary of state, 7 April 1913, TNA, CO 129/406, pp. 451–452.
72 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 59.
73 ‘The Sotto case, opening of an interesting case’, South China Morning Post, 12 June 1913; ‘The Sotto case, secretary Welch’s cross-examination’, South China Morning Post, 26 June 1913; ‘The Sotto case, Mr. Brutton continues defence’, South China Morning Post, 8 July 1913; ‘Local news’, South China Morning Post, 21 June 1913.
74 ‘The Sotto case, Mr. Brutton continues’, South China Morning Post, 24 July 1913.
75 ‘The Sotto case: A German allegory’, South China Morning Post, 11 July 1913.
76 ‘Sotto discharged’, South China Morning Post, 18 August 1913.
77 Anderson to colonial secretary, 26 August 1913, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/403, pp. 307–310.
78 Bucknill to colonial secretary, 30 August 1913, Hong Kong, TNA, CO 129/403, pp. 302–306.
79 Home Office to secretary of state, 14 October 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/406, p. 473; Page to Grey, 1 September 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/406, pp. 220–221.
80 Home Office to secretary of state, 14 October 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/406, pp. 474–476.
81 Page to Grey, 4 November 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/406, pp. 355–356.
82 Foreign Office to secretary of state, 12 November 1913, London, TNA, CO 129/406, pp. 357–359.
83 ‘Hongkong Filipinos and governor Harrison’, South China Morning Post, 9 October 1913.
84 ‘On the 30th instant’, South China Morning Post, 12 September 1913.
85 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 61–62.
86 Cited in ‘Vice-governor and Mr. Sotto’, South China Morning Post, 31 January 1914.
87 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 62.
88 ‘Local news’, South China Morning Post, 30 April 1914.
89 ‘Vicente Sotto arrested’, The Hongkong Telegraph, 30 October 1914.
90 ‘Vicente Sotto’, The China Mail, 20 November 1914.
91 Vicente Sotto, ‘The Sotto case’, South China Morning Post, 8 July 1912.
92 Vicente Sotto, ‘Mr Welch’s statement refuted’, South China Morning Post, 7 December 1912.
93 Mojares, Vicente Sotto, p. 60.
94 Clarence Paul Oaminal, ‘Pascuala Yap Sotto, Sotto clan matriarch’, The Freeman (Cebu), 8 September 2015.
95 ‘Vicente Sotto, former Hongkong editor accused of libel’, South China Morning Post, 18 April 1917.
96 Goodman, ‘Artemio Ricarte and Japan’, pp. 50–55.
97 Jung, M. H., Menace to empire: Anticolonial solidarities and the Transpacific origins of the US security state (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2023).Google Scholar
98 Sotto, ‘The Sotto case’.