Six - Rethinking children’s rights
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 March 2022
Summary
The most recent phase of childhood – let us call it the age of the child citizen – is one in which the principle that children are capable of living within civil societies, and that they are honorary citizens, serves as both a rallying point for many organisations, networks and groups, and as the focus of conduct and policymaking in the fields of government, law and civil society. Although the emancipation of children as full citizens is bitterly contested – there is plenty of resistance from government administrators, paediatricians, social workers, nurses, day care centre employees, school teachers and child therapists – there are also many indications that the release of children from bondage, into civil society and its political and legal entitlements, is now under way. The old dogmas of quarantine and welfare regulation are crumbling; it is as if civil societies and governments have decided that they cannot live with the incivility that they formerly inflicted on children. The consequence is not only that the dualism between children and civil society becomes blurred in many people's minds; the power-ridden division between child and adult becomes questionable, and is publicly questioned, with politically unsettling effects. (John Keane, 2008: 16)
Professor Keane is widely regarded as one of the foremost authorities writing about civil society in the world. His argument that it is time to consider the emancipation of children from ‘age-patriarchy’ – involving an imbalance of power, control and resources between adults and children – therefore takes on a powerful resonance. John Keane’s argument also finds support among scholars working in the field of childhood studies. Chris Jenks (2005: 37) asserts that childhood is defined in terms of its ‘contingency’ (ie, power relationships between adult–child, parent–child, teacher–child and so on). David Buckingham (2000: 4) observes ‘the sacred garden of childhood has increasingly been violated; and yet children themselves seem ever more reluctant to remain confined within it’. John Holt (1974: 27), in a sardonic comment on the garden metaphor that represents childhood as Eden, comments: ‘some children experience childhood in just that way. I do not want to destroy their garden or kick them out of it. If they like it, by all means let them stay in it. But, I believe most young people, at earlier and earlier ages, begin to experience childhood not as a garden but as a prison’.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Dark Secrets of ChildhoodMedia Power, Child Abuse and Public Scandals, pp. 185 - 206Publisher: Bristol University PressPrint publication year: 2015