5 - The “world” of Fair View
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 September 2009
Summary
The first time I hear about it is during a class meeting one mid-October morning. Monica Segal's fourth graders are writing to the state Commissioner of Education to voice their criticisms of the Connecticut Mastery Test. During the meeting, the teacher reminds her students that, after they drafted the letter, she showed it to the principal, Anita Byrne, “to make sure that it was OK with her for us to send it.” Byrne, she announces, thought it was a good idea, one that “might generate some press.” That afternoon the class revises the letter, which, in its final form, reads:
Hi! We are students at Fair View Elementary School in Fair View. Last week we finished taking the Fourth Grade Connecticut State Mastery Test. When we spend a lot of time on something in class we always write down our thoughts. We would like to share our thoughts about the test with you. We classified what we had to say in 3 sections: general thoughts, thoughts on directions, and suggestions.
General thoughts
The writing I had to rush a little because it was 45 minutes, not a long time.
Confusing to have two answer sheets on the same page.
The anser [answer] boklet [booklet] was difakot [difficult] to read.
I don't know why they did math twice instead of combinding [combining] it.
When the writing part came up and only 45 minutes it kind of got on my nerves and then I wrote fast enough to finish in twenty minutes.
I think that the listening comprehension is very annoying when the man says one minute left. I think it is distracting and if your [you're] trying to think it takes up your time and gets you off the topic.
First you have abcd and then abcde it was confusing because when I wanted d I would accidently [accidentally] fill in e.
Thoughts on directions
Make the directions clearer.
The directions were very confusing. For example: Questions 10, 11 in box 10 on page 14. And then there would be boxes 10 and 11 on page 12.
I thought the directions on written communication were confusing becaus [because] the question was on one page and the passage was on another.
Confusing directions.
Suggestions
Each test should start on a different page.
The 45 minute test for writing should be longer because we write so fast, sometimes we don't even know what we're writing about.
Is there any way to fix the Connecticut State Mastery Test so it makes more sense? We would like to know what you think. Thank you. Sincerely,
The letter is signed by Monica Segal and each of her students.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- De-Facing Power , pp. 111 - 160Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2000