Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Tables, Graph, and Figures
- Preface and Acknowledgments
- Introduction: Ordering from the Menu in Central Europe
- 1 Emulation as Embedded Rationalism
- 2 Emulation as Rapid Modernization: Health Care and Consumer Protection
- 3 Emulation Under Pressure: Regional Policy and Agriculture
- 4 The Struggle for Civilian Control of the Military
- 5 Military Professionalization in War and Peace
- 6 Using Theory to Illuminate the Cases
- 7 Synthesis and Sequence: Juxtaposing Theory Traditions
- 8 Extensions and Conclusions
- Appendix: Selected List of Persons Interviewed
- Works Cited
- Index
8 - Extensions and Conclusions
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 06 July 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Tables, Graph, and Figures
- Preface and Acknowledgments
- Introduction: Ordering from the Menu in Central Europe
- 1 Emulation as Embedded Rationalism
- 2 Emulation as Rapid Modernization: Health Care and Consumer Protection
- 3 Emulation Under Pressure: Regional Policy and Agriculture
- 4 The Struggle for Civilian Control of the Military
- 5 Military Professionalization in War and Peace
- 6 Using Theory to Illuminate the Cases
- 7 Synthesis and Sequence: Juxtaposing Theory Traditions
- 8 Extensions and Conclusions
- Appendix: Selected List of Persons Interviewed
- Works Cited
- Index
Summary
The desire to achieve the standards of Western Europe, or in more general terms to modernize society along the lines pioneered by Western civilization, has been the chief motivating force in the history of modern Bulgaria.
(Black 1957: 7)Whether or not this epigraph remains plausible nearly a half century after it was written, it is clear that the postcommunist Czechs and Hungarians are hardly novel in their approximations of Western practices and structures. In a region long characterized by “backwardness,” Western European states have often appeared as models for reform (Janos 2000).
But we have seen that emulation is both hard to do and hard to describe. It is hard to do because elites must do more than simply copy best practices. Rather, they must understand how attractive foreign models actually work, agree with other actors on the desirability of emulating them, and be able to execute their plans (Jacoby 2000). All of these are challenges. It is easy to misperceive how foreign models actually work — to see only their virtues and miss their vices. Actors must overcome political disagreements about the desirability and appropriateness of particular foreign models for their society. And actors must persevere through difficulties in implementing foreign-inspired practices and designs. Unfortunately, the major macrosociological and political science research tradition — that of diffusion — has a markedly difficult time with these complexities since it blends out uncertainty and disagreement in favor of tracking the spread of highly stylized models and generally ignores the implementation phase altogether.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Enlargement of the European Union and NATOOrdering from the Menu in Central Europe, pp. 216 - 242Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2004