Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Contents
- List of tables and figures
- Glossary
- Notes on author
- Acknowledgements
- Foreword
- Introduction: Beyond Benefits Street – exploring experiences and narratives of welfare reform
- one Social citizenship from above
- two The emergence of a framing consensus on ‘welfare’
- three The everyday realities of out-of-work benefits receipt
- four Is welfare-to-work working? Relationships with work over time
- five Ending welfare dependency? Experiencing welfare reform
- six Scroungerphobia: living with the stigma of benefits
- seven Diverse trajectories between 2011 and 2016
- Conclusion: social insecurity and ‘welfare’
- References
- Index
Conclusion: social insecurity and ‘welfare’
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 April 2022
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Contents
- List of tables and figures
- Glossary
- Notes on author
- Acknowledgements
- Foreword
- Introduction: Beyond Benefits Street – exploring experiences and narratives of welfare reform
- one Social citizenship from above
- two The emergence of a framing consensus on ‘welfare’
- three The everyday realities of out-of-work benefits receipt
- four Is welfare-to-work working? Relationships with work over time
- five Ending welfare dependency? Experiencing welfare reform
- six Scroungerphobia: living with the stigma of benefits
- seven Diverse trajectories between 2011 and 2016
- Conclusion: social insecurity and ‘welfare’
- References
- Index
Summary
‘This government is all about security … Security is also what drives the social reform that I want this government to undertake in my second term. Individuals and families who are in poverty crave security – for them, it's the most important value of all. … So for people in Britain who are struggling today, our mission as a government is to look every parent and child in the eye, and say ‘Your dreams are our dreams. We’ll support you with everything we’ve got.’ (Cameron, 2016)
In his successful 2015 General Election campaign and subsequent keynote speeches, then-Prime Minister David Cameron repeatedly returned to the idea of ‘security’ as a leitmotif for the reformed society he and his government were seeking to create. He believed – rightly – that the idea of security resonates with the population (Orton, 2015) and speaks to the anxieties of so many that life is all too often insecure and uncertain.
Whether and how far the reforms instigated under Cameron's leadership between 2010 and 2016 increased security is, of course, highly questionable – particularly for those directly affected by successive waves of welfare reform. As the research reported in this book have illustrated, the material impact of reforms have pushed many people further into poverty and undermined physical and mental wellbeing, while a constant backdrop of change has left individuals living with chronic and destabilising insecurity and fears about an uncertain future. Classic liberal citizenship theorist T. H. Marshall argued that the social rights of citizenship should provide at least a ‘modicum of economic welfare and security’ (1950, emphasis added). Now more than ever it is important to interrogate whether this is provided to those at the sharp end of welfare reform.
In this concluding chapter, the key findings from this research are summarised, focusing particular on the disjuncture between citizenship as it is conceptualised from above and citizenship as it is lived and experienced from below. This is particularly evident in competing notions and experiences of (in)security and benefits receipt. The political and theoretical implications of this are then discussed before a brief consideration of areas that would benefit from further research.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- For Whose Benefit?The Everyday Realities of Welfare Reform, pp. 195 - 220Publisher: Bristol University PressPrint publication year: 2017