Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Contents
- Acknowledgments
- About the Cover
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction
- Prologue: The Prehistory of Power: Souls Spirits, Deities
- Part One Kings and Emperors
- 1 Divine Kingship in Mesopotamia
- 2 Pharaohs among the Indestructibles
- 3 Kingship among the Hebrews
- 4 The Deification of Roman Emperors
- 5 The Deva-Rajas in India and Southeast Asia
- 6 The Chinese Mandate from Heaven
- 7 The Japanese Imperial Cult
- Part Two Empires before the Common Era
- 8 The Legendary Empire of the Sumerians
- 9 Legendary Empires of Preclassical Greece
- 10 Patriarchs, Exodus, and the Epic of Israel
- 11 Legendary Empires of Ancient India
- 12 The Legendary Founding of Rome
- Part Three Founders
- 13 Moses: The Israelite Lawgiver
- 14 Buddha and Legends of Previous Buddhas
- 15 The Savior Narratives
- 16 Muhammad, the Qur’an, and Islam
- 17 The Virgin Mary through the Centuries
- 18 Tonantzin and Our Lady of Guadalupe
- Part Four Empires of the Common Era
- 19 Narrative Inventions of the Holy Roman Empire
- 20 The Epic of Kings, Alexander the Great, and the Malacca Sultinate
- 21 The Franks, Charlemagne, and the Chansons de Geste
- 22 The Legendary Kingdom of King Arthur
- 23 Ethiopian Kings and the Ark of the Covenant
- 24 Narratives of the Virgin Queen
- Part Five Ideologies
- 25 Discovery: The European Narrative of Power
- 26 Epics of the Portuguese Seaborne Empire
- 27 Dekanawida and the Iroquois League
- 28 The New England Canaan of the Puritans
- 29 The Marxist Classless Society
- 30 Adolph Hitler: Narratives of Aryans and Jews
- Epilogue: A Clash of Narratives
- Bibliography
- Index
- About the Author
13 - Moses: The Israelite Lawgiver
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 15 December 2020
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Contents
- Acknowledgments
- About the Cover
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction
- Prologue: The Prehistory of Power: Souls Spirits, Deities
- Part One Kings and Emperors
- 1 Divine Kingship in Mesopotamia
- 2 Pharaohs among the Indestructibles
- 3 Kingship among the Hebrews
- 4 The Deification of Roman Emperors
- 5 The Deva-Rajas in India and Southeast Asia
- 6 The Chinese Mandate from Heaven
- 7 The Japanese Imperial Cult
- Part Two Empires before the Common Era
- 8 The Legendary Empire of the Sumerians
- 9 Legendary Empires of Preclassical Greece
- 10 Patriarchs, Exodus, and the Epic of Israel
- 11 Legendary Empires of Ancient India
- 12 The Legendary Founding of Rome
- Part Three Founders
- 13 Moses: The Israelite Lawgiver
- 14 Buddha and Legends of Previous Buddhas
- 15 The Savior Narratives
- 16 Muhammad, the Qur’an, and Islam
- 17 The Virgin Mary through the Centuries
- 18 Tonantzin and Our Lady of Guadalupe
- Part Four Empires of the Common Era
- 19 Narrative Inventions of the Holy Roman Empire
- 20 The Epic of Kings, Alexander the Great, and the Malacca Sultinate
- 21 The Franks, Charlemagne, and the Chansons de Geste
- 22 The Legendary Kingdom of King Arthur
- 23 Ethiopian Kings and the Ark of the Covenant
- 24 Narratives of the Virgin Queen
- Part Five Ideologies
- 25 Discovery: The European Narrative of Power
- 26 Epics of the Portuguese Seaborne Empire
- 27 Dekanawida and the Iroquois League
- 28 The New England Canaan of the Puritans
- 29 The Marxist Classless Society
- 30 Adolph Hitler: Narratives of Aryans and Jews
- Epilogue: A Clash of Narratives
- Bibliography
- Index
- About the Author
Summary
The life of Moses as presented in Jewish tradition from four books of the Pentateuch (Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy) includes the following: a narrow escape from death while an infant, a privileged childhood in the royal household of the Egyptian Pharaoh, a revelation from Yahweh, command over the enslaved Israelites, a successful defeat of the Pharaoh, an escape with his people to the Sinai Peninsula, reception of the Ten Commandments and the entire Israelite law code from Yahweh, and continuance as the military leader until the Israelites are within sight of the Promised Land of Canaan. This is the kind of biography, though abbreviated, that one finds in standard Bible dictionaries (Berlin 1985, 655–59; Myers 1987, 731–32) along with the widely held but problematic tradition that Moses authored the entire Pentateuch. Both the “biography” and “authorship” assumptions require commonsense examination. Elsewhere in these dictionaries, one can find discussion of the Documentary Hypothesis (Greenstein 1985, 985–86; Myers 1987, 156–57), still widely unknown to most readers. Though it was put forward more than 140 years ago and considerably adjusted since then, it provides perspectives for understanding the Moses narrative.
Corroborating evidence for Moses and the Exodus does not exist outside the Bible, but internal cultural allusions suggest the middle of the New Kingdom of Egypt (1550–1085 BCE) as the likely era of these events. More than a hundred calculations were made between the fourth and seventeenth centuries based on biblical genealogies to provide a chronology for events with little variation for the kingships of David and Solomon and the centuries immediately preceding it. Bishop James Ussher's calculations that were generally accepted until the late nineteenth century dated the reception of the Ten Commandments on Mount Sinai at 1491 BCE. More soundly based periodization (Mazar 1990, 232–39) places Moses and the Exodus a little later, within the Late Bronze Age IIA-B (1400–1200 BCE). Hebrew and Old Testament scholar John Bright (1972) placed the Exodus within this era at 1280; the New Jerusalem Bible places it at 1250. All such dates not only assume but inadvertently imply that the Bible is a historical book.
During the Enlightenment, Thomas Paine (1737–1809) noted the impossibility of Moses as author of the Pentateuch, showing rather decisively that it was composed much later.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Invented History, Fabricated PowerThe Narratives Shaping Civilization and Culture, pp. 151 - 158Publisher: Anthem PressPrint publication year: 2020