Introduction
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012
Summary
This volume collects a baker's dozen of my papers in the history of aesthetics. One was published in 1986 and one in 1993, but the rest have all been published or written since 1996. Three have not yet been published elsewhere.
Plato effectively began Western philosophy with an attack on Greek assumptions about the cognitive and practical value of the creation and experience of art, so aesthetics has been both a part of and under attack by philosophy since the outset. In the Republic, Plato questioned the claims of poets and their adherents to any important expertise, and cast doubt on the cognitive value of imitations or representations in general by characterizing them as mere copies of ordinary objects that are themselves mere copies of the genuine realities – the Forms. In the Ion and Phaedrus, he more archly cast doubt on any claims to knowledge that might be made by artists by suggesting that artistic success depends upon divine inspiration, and is therefore incomprehensible to mere mortals. In the Republic, he also questioned the practical value of art not only by questioning the cognitive claims on which its practical value might be thought to depend, but also by arguing that the expression of emotion in either the experience or especially the performance of art would be counterproductive for the education of his ideal guardians, who are to learn above all to use their reason to control their emotions, and by extension the emotions of those they are to govern.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Values of BeautyHistorical Essays in Aesthetics, pp. ix - xviiiPublisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2005