'At a moment when ‘Send Them Back’ has reemerged as a nativist rallying cry, Becoming Free, Becoming Black is a brilliantly lucid guide to the deep history of how race and ethnic origin came to be potent ciphers for civic belonging. … De la Fuente and Gross show that brutality lay not merely in the imposition of slavery, but in the creation of racial regimes ranking black bodies even once freed from bondage. If enslavement is construed as an external political constraint, the project of freedom becomes focused on unshackling bodies from those confines. But if white means free and black means slave, then political status is embodied, innate and inescapable. … To this day, the legacy of free-but-not-full-citizen delimits quietly powerful hierarchies in our varying capacities to travel, vote, mix socially, run a business, hold public office, and intermarry. This indispensable book shows how knowing the past might aid us to intelligently reform our future.'
Patricia J. Williams - Columnist, The Nation Magazine
'In this incisive and spell-binding study, Alejandro de la Fuente and Ariela Gross meticulously investigate the archives of the ‘legal regimes of slavery and race’ in the culturally disparate locations of Cuba, Louisiana, and Virginia, thus exposing the differences and similarities between Spanish, French, and English approaches to manumission and interracial relationships. In addition, the authors brilliantly focus on the bottom up efforts of the enslaved to gain freedom, thus exposing how these ‘unpredictable twists and turns’ established the meaning of blackness in law. Not only an important legal analysis, Becoming Free, Becoming Black tells many fascinating stories of heroic efforts to attain freedom through legal regimes.'
Henry Louis Gates, Jr - Alphonse Fletcher University Professor, Harvard University
'Becoming Free, Becoming Black is a brilliant study of the making of race in the New World. Deeply researched, insightful, and smoothly written, this book is a major contribution to the scholarly literature on slavery and the way it shaped, and was shaped by, attitudes about people of African descent.'
Annette Gordon-Reed - Charles Warren Professor of American Legal History, Harvard University, and author of The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family
'In Cuba of 1860, many persons of color who purchased their freedom lived alongside slaves; while In Louisiana and Virginia free people of color had almost disappeared, and to be black was to be enslaved. The difference was in the law and custom regulating freedom - law made by many hands, including those of slaves themselves. This book, based on meticulous archival research and brilliantly reasoned and written, is comparative legal history at its finest.'
Robert W. Gordon - Stanford University
'To what can we attribute the distinct racial ideologies that emerged in different slaveholding societies in the Americas? In this rich and innovative comparative study, Ariela Gross and Alejandro de la Fuente emphasize the role of the emergence of communities of free persons of African descent, and their evolution over time. Although elites in all three societies sought to attach sharp social distinctions to color, the authors find that ‘the association between blackness and enslavement, whiteness and freedom, remained less strict and precise in Cuba than in Virginia and Louisiana.’ As slavery itself was abolished, these prior differences laid the groundwork for divergent experiences of access to the rights of citizenship. This is a provocative and important book.'
Rebecca J. Scott - Charles Gibson Distinguished University Professor of History and Professor of Law, University of Michigan
'Becoming Free, Becoming Black provides crucial insights into the ways that conceptions of race and power varied across the Americas in the era when slavery was at its most widespread. It is a valuable window on the ways that the system maintained itself, and on the resistance that, although often unsuccessful, showed the persistence of the will to resist under even the most horrendous conditions.'
John Foster
Source: Souciant Magazine
‘… this book contributes greatly to a comparative understanding of the African diaspora and the complexities of both colonial experiences and post-emancipation societies.’
G. de Laforcade
Source: Choice
‘Becoming Free, Becoming Black is a beautifully written manuscript based on both archival research and extensive bibliographic discussion.’
Keila Grinberg
Source: Hispanic American Historical Review
‘De la Fuente and Gross have provided a useful handbook for historians of all three regions who seek to understand the law's effect on regimes of racial exploitation – and the worlds that people of color constructed through and under it.’
Robert Colby
Source: Journal of Southern History
'… set to become a classic study of law in the Americas in the age of enslavement and emancipation… This comparative history sets out to change our understanding of the law by successfully taking on a formidable task - to account for the role of the law in the trajectory of racial ideologies across the two Americas.'
Adriana Chira
Source: ReVista
‘… Becoming Free, Becoming Black is a major work of historiographical synthesis and a rigorous work of original historical investigation.’
Sue Peabody
Source: Journal of Interdisciplinary History
‘Becoming Free, Becoming Black certainly stands as required reading for scholars of history of law and the social history of slavery in the Americas. The solid research in primary sources, combined with an original argument, among other qualities, make the book a reference of excellence on the historiographical debate on racism and law - both past and present.’
Bruno Lima
Source: Rechtsgeschichte - Legal History
‘Becoming Free, Becoming Black is not only the best synthesis of the complex developments of juridical structures in the slave societies of the Atlantic world. It is a generous study which, chapter after chapter, opens up questions that will be debated for a long time to come.’
Jean Hébrard
Source: New West Indian Guide
