Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-wzw2p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-07T20:36:36.877Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Religion and Revolution in Peru: 1920-1945

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2015

Jeffrey L. Klaiber S.J.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The interim years between the two world wars in Peru witnessed a proliferation of original ideas among Peruvian leftists on the relationship between religion and revolutionary change as a result of their efforts to re-examine national realities and bring about a radical change in Peruvian society. Young social thinkers and protesters such as José Carlos Mariátegui, Víctor Raúl Haya de la Torre, Luís Valcárcel and others felt that the new Peru must incorporate and synthesize the best elements of Peru's past and present with the best ideas emanating from revolutionary Russia and Mexico. In their quest to construct a program of action for a revolutionary Peru, the generation of the twenties and thirties realized the necessity of going beyond the literary liberalism of the grand master of Peruvian anti-clericalism, Manual González Prada. They endeavored to propose a new, positive program which would neither discard nor neglect such an integral part of national life as the Roman Catholicism of the majority of Peruvians. Even more, they consciously explored ways by which the popular Catholicism of the Peruvian lower classes might be converted into a source of energy for the coming revolution.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Americas , Volume 31 , Issue 3 , January 1975 , pp. 289 - 312
Copyright
Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 1975

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 A fuller discussion of González Prada’s anti-clericalism may be found in Basadre, Jorge, Historia de la República del Perú (5th ed.; Lima: Ediciones Historia, 1964), 10, 4391–4399.Google Scholar Also, for a study of González Prada’s impact on succeeding generations, see the article by McNicolls, Robert, “The Intellectual Origins of Aprismo,” Hispanic American Historical Review, 23, (August, 1943), 424–440.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Prada, Manuel González, Páginas Libres (Lima: Fondo de Cultura Popular, 1966), 1, 100.Google Scholar

3 Prada, González, Horas de Lucha (Lima: Ediciones “Futuro,” 1964), p. 59.Google Scholar

4 The union movement alone continued to raise the banner of González Prada’s anticlericalism, with little change of perspective. See, for example, the principal organ of the textile workers in Peru, El Obrero Textil, published in Lima since 1919. For a complete list of anti-clerical newspapers and reviews in Peru, see Basadre, IX, 4831–4833.

5 A survey of the important names and intellectual currents of the Indigenista movement may be found in Basadre, X, 4531–4536.

6 de Turner, Clorinda Matto, Aves Sin Nido (Buenos Aires: Ediciones Solar, 1968), pp. 46, 57, 65–66.Google Scholar Only four years previous to Aves Sin Nido, Juan Torres Lara, writing under the pseudonym of Itolararres, José T., dedicated an entire book to the “Trinity of injustice,” La Trinidad del Indio o Costumbres del Interior (Lima, 1885).Google Scholar Itolarrares saw the priest as the “Greatest vulture”of the trinity.

7 Aguilar, Luis, Cuestiones Indígenas (Cuzco, 1921), pp. 15–16.Google Scholar

8 Garro, J. Eugenio, “La Iglesia y el Estado,” Amauta, November-December, 1928, pp. 31–36.Google Scholar

9 Valcárcel, Luis E., Tempestad en los Andes (Lima: Populibros Peruanos, 1927), p. 83.Google Scholar

10 Alegría, Circo, La Serpiente de Oro (Lima: Editorial Universo, 1967), pp. 94–107.Google Scholar

11 For a humorous satire on the Spanish missionary in Peru dating from this period, see Albújar’s, Enrique López short story, “La Mula de Taita Ramún,” in Cuentos Andinos (6th ed.; Lima: Editorial Juan Mejía Baca, 1971), pp. 117–139.Google Scholar

12 Romero, Emilio, “El Cuzco Católico,” La Sierra, January, 1927, pp. 27–30.Google Scholar La Sierra was the main voice of the indigenista movement in Cuzco. Mariátegui cites Romero’s ideas in his Siete Ensayos de la Realidad Pernana (llth ed.; Lima: Editorial Amauta, 1967), p. 149.

13 García, José Uriel, El Nuevo Indio (2nd. ed.; Cuzco: H.Y. Rozas, 1937), pp. 158–159.Google Scholar

14 Ibid., pp. 113–115.

15 Valcárcel, Luis, Mirador Indio (Lima: 1937), p. 37.Google Scholar An example of a romantic presentation of the nobility of the Inca religion from this same period is the historical novel by Aguirre, Augusto, El Pueblo del Sol (Lima: Imprenta Torres Aguirre, 1927).Google Scholar

16 Mostajo, Francisco, La Sierra, May, 1927, pp. 35–39.Google Scholar

17 Valcárcel, , Tempestad en los Andes, p. 132.Google Scholar Valcárcel lauded the work of the Ad-ventists again in la Sierra, August, 1927, pp. 1–3. For another comparison between the Protestant missionary with the Catholic priest, highly favorable to the former, see La Sierra, April-May, 1928, pp. 15–16.

18 de Zulen, Dora Mayer, El Desarrollo de las Ideas Avanzadas en el Perú (Callao, 1934), pp. 10–11.Google Scholar

19 Falcón, César, “Los Buenos Hijos de Dios,” in Cuentos Revolucionarios del Perú, ed. by Molina, Alfonso (Lima: Ediciones América Latina, 1967), pp. 41–67.Google Scholar

20 Reyna, Ernesto, El Amauta Atusparia (Lima, 1929), p. 52.Google Scholar

21 Ibid., pp. 68–69.

22 Pozo, Hildebrando Castro, Nuestra Comunidad Indígena (Lima, 1924), pp. 57, 260–261.Google Scholar

23 Brief accounts of the life of Mariátegui by two close contemporaries are Wiesse’s, María José Carlos Mariátegui (Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1971)Google Scholar and Bazán’s, Armando Mariátegui y su Tiempo (Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1969).Google Scholar Other informative insights into the early formation of Mariátegui may be found in Jorge Basadre’s prolog to the English translation of the Siete Ensayos: Seven Interpretative Essays on Peruvian Reality, trans, by Urquidi, Marjory (Austin: Univ. of Texas Press, 1971), pp. ix-xxxiv.Google Scholar For an overall survey of Mariátegui's thought in relation to his contemporaries, see Chang-Rodríguez, Eugenio, La Literatura Política de González Prada, Mariátegui y Haya de la Torre (Mexico: Ediciones de Andrea, 1957).Google Scholar The most comprehensive bibliography of Mariátegui’s writings is Rouillon’s, Guillermo Biobibliografía de José Carlos Mariátegui (Lima: Univ. of San Marcos Press, 1963).Google Scholar

24 El Mercurio Peruano, XX, 1930–31, p. 206.

25 El Amigo del Clero, June, 1933, p. 124.

26 María Wiesse, pp. 16–17.

27 Colónida, March, 1916, pp. 26–27. Mariátegui said that the psalms were to be part of a book he was composing, Tristeza, which never appeared.

28 “La Procesión Tradicional,” El Tiempo, April 12,1917, p. 4.

29 Mariátegui, , Defensa del Marxismo (3rd ed.; Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1967), pp. 56–58.Google Scholar Mariátegui only composed two books himself, Siete Ensayos and La Escena Contemporánea (1925). All other works bearing his name are part of the collection of his writings published posthumously by his family.

30 Mariátegui, , Amauta, September, 1926, pp. 3–4.Google Scholar For a further study of the multiple sources of Mariátegui’s Marxism, see Paris, Robert, “El Marxismo de Mariátegui,” Aportes, 17 (July, 1970), 7–30.Google Scholar

31 Mariátegui, , Siete Ensayos, p. 141.Google Scholar Referring to the religious crisis in Mexico, Mariáttegui warned that anti-clerical liberalism should not be confused with socialism, nor should “religion”be confused with the word, “Church.” Socialism, declared Mariátegui, , is also a religion. Temas de Nuestra América (Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1970), pp. 45–46.Google Scholar

32 Mariátegui, , El Alma Matinal (3rd ed.; Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1964), p. 18.Google Scholar On another occasion Mariátegui criticized the purely lay school for its lack of “spiritual values.”It could never satisfy, affirmed Mariátegui, , the “necessity for the Absolute”which exists in the depth of all human anxiety. Temas de Educación (Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1971), p. 21.Google Scholar

33 Mariátegui, , Los Siete Ensayos, p. 228.Google Scholar

34 Mariátegui, , Amauta, October, 1926, p. 47.Google Scholar The article by Haya de la Torre, who discussed the political inspiration behind Don Quijote, appeared in Amauta, December, 1926, pp. 3–7.

35 Mariátegui’s reflections on the role of religion in the Inca empire and in Spanish Peru are systematically presented in his essay, “El Factor Religioso,” Siete Ensayos, pp. 140–167.

36 Ibid., p. 151.

37 Mariátegui’s, ideas on myth are found in El Alma Matinal, pp. 18–27.Google Scholar

38 Ibid., p. 123.

39 Prologue to Valcárcel, Luis, Tempestad en los Andes, p. 10.Google Scholar

40 Mariátegui made these observations in 1925 in La Escena Contemporánea (3rd ed.; Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1964), pp. 193–199. Mariátegui discusses the question of ethics more at length in Defensa del Marxismo, pp. 47–54.

41 Cristóbal-Sebastián, Antonio San, C.M.F., Economía, Educación y Marxismo en Mariátegui (Lima: Ediciones Studium. 1960),p. 74.Google Scholar

42 Bondy, Augusto Salazar, Historia de las Ideas en el Perú Contemporáneo (2nd ed.; Lima: Editores Moncloa, 1967), 2, 311–337.Google Scholar

43 Melis, Antonio, Dessau, Adalbert, and Kossok, Manfred, Mariátegui: Tres Estudios (Lima: Empresa Amauta, 1971), pp. 81–89.Google Scholar

44 Basadre, IX, 4202.

45 The standard study of the Apriste movement is Kantor’s, Harry The Ideology and Program of the Peruvian Aprista Movement (Berkeley: The Univ. of California Press, 1953).Google Scholar Since then many other books and articles on the Apra (Alianza Popular Revolucionaria Americana) have appeared. For a recent appraisal of both the Apra and the abundant literature written about it, favorably and unfavorably, see the article by Clinton, Richard Lee, “Apra: An Appraisal,” Journal of Inter-American Studies and World Affairs, 12, No. 2 (April, 1970), 280 297.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

46 Mayer de Zulen, pp. 14–18.

47 de la Torre, Víctor Raúl Haya, Política Aprista (2nd ed.; Lima: Editorial Amauta, 19 P. 11.Google Scholar

48 El Amigo del Clero presented Haya de la Torre as an incessant fighter against Catholic Action ever since his participation in the events of May 23, 1923. July, 1933, p. 4. On the other end of the political spectrum, Eudocio Ravines, co-founder of the Communist Party in Peru saw May 23, 1923 as Apra’s debut as an “anti-clerical and anti-Catholic movement.” Partido Communista del Perú, August 26, 1931, p. 2. For an Aprista’s account of the affair, see Seoane, Manuel, La Revolución Que el Perú Necesita (Arequipa, 1965), pp. 99–103.Google Scholar

48 El Amigo del Clero, November, 1931, pp. 226–255.

50 “Una Apostilla a la Conferencia del Señor Víctor Raúl Haya de la Torre,” El Heraldo, Puno, November 5,1931, pp. 3–5.

51 La Tribuna, August 12, 1931, p. 1. For examples of anticlerical barbs, see the edition of May 23, 1931, p. 9.

52 El Deber, Arequipa, October 31,1931, p. 3.

53 El Pueblo, Arequipa, October 8,1931, p. 3.

54 Sánchez, Luis Alberto, Aprismo y Religion (Lima: Editorial Atahualpa, 1933).Google Scholar Ruben Vargas, S.J., ¿Aprista o Católico? (Lima: Editorial Alfama, 1934).Google Scholar A summary of Sánchez’ ideas is given in Kantor, p. 94.

55 Catolicismo y Aprismo (Lima: Imprenta Minerva, 1934), p. 2. Other Aprista leaders also spoke out on the religious issue. See, for example, the statements of Carlos Manuel Cox on the Church in La Tribuna, August 15, 1931, p. 2; those by Seoane, Manuel in Nuestros Fines (Buenos Aires, 1932), pp. 47–48 Google Scholar; and Muñiz, Pedro, Lo Que es el Aprismo (Bogotá: Editorial Cromos, 1932), pp. 88–89.Google Scholar

56 La Tribuna, August 9,1944, p. 1.

57 Kantor, pp. 60–68. See, also, Hilliker, Grant, The Politics of Reform in Peru (Baltimore: The John Hopkins Press, 1971), pp. 103–111.Google Scholar

58 Haya de la Torre, p. 108.

59 Ibid., p. 192.

60 Mariátegui, Ideología y Política, p. 91.

61 MacKay, John, The Other Spanish Christ (London: Student Christian Movement Press, 1932), p. 194.Google Scholar

62 Sánchez, Luis Alberto, Haya de la Torre y el Apra (Santiago de Chile: Editorial del Pacífico, 1954), p. 123.Google Scholar

63 Antorcha, Lima, December 24, 1933, p. 5.

64 de la Torre, Haya, Discurso del Jefe del Partido del Pueblo (Lima, 1945), p. 5.Google Scholar For other references of Haya de la Torre to the religious question, see Antorcha, November 13, 1933, p. 4.

65 Sánchez, , Aprismo y Religión, p. 31.Google Scholar

66 National Secretariate de Propaganda (Partido Aprista), “A la Juventud Aprista,”(Lima, 1941 ). Archives, National Library, Lima.

67 Nor-Perú, July 7,1945, p. 5.

68 Peruano, Partido Aprista, Cartilla Aprista (Ecuador, n.d.). National Library, Lima.Google Scholar

69 Delmar, Serafín (Bolaños, Reynaldo), Sol: Están Destruyendo a tus Hijos (Buenos Aires: Editorial Americalee, 1941), pp. 55–61.Google Scholar

70 Delmar, , El Año Trágico (Lima: Editorial Atahualpa, 1933), p. 15.Google Scholar

71 Hoyo, Arturo del, “Ciro Alegria,” in Ciro Alegría: Novelas Completas (Madrid: Ediciones Aguilar, 1959), pp. xi-xix. Google Scholar

72 Alegría, Ciro, Ibid., p. 370.Google Scholar

73 Ibid., pp. 464–465.

74 Ibid., p. 586.

75 Ibid., p. 385.

76 Ibid., p. 930.

77 Bustamante, José Luis y Rivero, , Tres Años de Lucha por la Democracia en el Perú. (Buenos Aires, 1949), p. 18.Google Scholar

78 Astiz, Carlos, Pressure Groups and Power Elites in Peruvian Politics (Ithaca, New York: Univ. of Cornell Press, 1969), pp. 178–180.Google Scholar

79 For a discussion of the importance of the image of the suffering Christ in Latin America, see the article by Richardson, Miles, Pardo, Marta Eugenia and Bode, Barbara, “The Image of Christ in Spanish America as a Model for Suffering,” Journal of Inter-American Studies and World Affairs, 8, No. 2 (April, 1971), 246–257.CrossRefGoogle Scholar