Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-m9kch Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-03T11:45:26.321Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Observations on the Electric Lance and the Welfare of Whales: A Critical Appraisal

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 January 2023

D K Blackmore ,
P Madie  and
G R G Barnes
D K Blackmore
Affiliation:
The New Zealand Foundation for the Study of the Welfare of Whales, 371 Albert St, Palmerston North, New Zealand
P Madie*
Affiliation:
Cetacean Investigation Centre, Faculty of Veterinary Science, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand
G R G Barnes
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand
*
† Contact for correspondence and requests for reprints.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Japanese whalers use the electric lance as a secondary method of killing minke whales (Balaenoptera acutorostrata). The lances are dropped into the body, and currents varying between 2.2 and 14. OA, with a mean of 6.8A, are applied.

When currents of 5A were applied to the carcasses of dead whales, varying in size from 1.8 to 15.7m in length, no current densities induced in the target organs were sufficient to cause either insensibility (10mA cm−2 in the brain), or to cause ventricular fibrillation (0.5mA cm−2 in the heart), except in a few cases where electrodes were specifically placed to span the heart. When electrodes were placed in positions normally used in whaling operations, no current densities were produced which would have been sufficient to cause brain and cardiac dysfunction.

Further investigations on changes in current density with time post mortem after application of a controlled current of 5A showed, during a 60 hour period, a fourfold increase in the current density in the heart, and more than a twofold increase in the brain. Thus contrary to previous criticisms, if these studies had been carried out on live animals, all current densities would have been below threshold values.

There are no records of signs of epileptic form seizure, which are associated with an effective electrical stun, in whales subjected to the electric lance.

It is concluded that the electric lance as used in whaling operations is ineffective and likely to cause extra pain and suffering to an already distressed animal.

Keywords

animal welfarebehaviourbrainconductivitycurrent densityelectric lanceheartinsensibilitypainventricular fibrillationwhales
Type
Research Article
Information
Animal Welfare , Volume 6 , Issue 1 , February 1997 , pp. 43 - 51
Copyright
© 1997 Universities Federation for Animal Welfare

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Anon 1994 Code of Recommendations and Minimum Standards for the Welfare of Animals at the Time of Slaughter at Licensed and Approved Premises. Animal Welfare Advisory Committee. Ministry of Agriculture: Wellington, New ZealandGoogle Scholar
Anon 1995 Report of the workshop on whale killing methods. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/47/18Google Scholar
Barnes, G R G, Madie, P and Blackmore, D K 1995 Further investigations relevant to the use of the electric lance in whaling. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/47/HK2Google Scholar
Barnes, G R G, Madie, P and Blackmore, D K 1996 An assessment of the humane aspects of electric lancing of whales by measurement of current densities in the brain and heart of dead animals. Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing 34: 1–11CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Blackmore, D K and Delany, M W 1988 Slaughter of Stock: A Practical Review and Guide. Publication No 118, Veterinary Continuing Education, Massey University: Palmerston North, New ZealandGoogle Scholar
Blackmore, D K, Nutman, A, Barnes, G R G, Madie, P, Davies, A S, Bowling, M C, Donoghue, M and Kirk, E J 1994 Preliminary investigations of techniques for killing whales. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/46/HK4Google Scholar
Bryden, M M 1989 Adaptation to the aquatic environment. In: Harrison R H and Bryden M M (eds) Whales, Dolphins and Porpoises pp 112. Weldon Owen Pty Ltd: Sydney, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
Government of Japan 1993 Study of the humane killing of whales conducted in the Antarctic in the 1992/93 season in conjunction with the national research program. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/45/HK8Google Scholar
Government of Japan 1995 Report on killing method for the 1994/1995 Antarctic minke whale research operations. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/47/WK11Google Scholar
Hayashi, Y 1980 Report on method of catching minke whales. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/SC/32/024Google Scholar
Hayashi, Y 1995 Quoted in discussion of IWC/47/WK2. In: Report of the workshop on whale killing methods ρ 7. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/47/18Google Scholar
Kestin, S C 1995 Welfare aspects of the commercial slaughter of whales. Animal Welfare 4: 11–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McLachlan, H 1995 The use of electricity to kill whales: humane considerations. Animal Welfare 4: 125–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mitchell, E 1986 Aspects of pre-world war II German electrical whaling. In: Mitchell, E D, Reeves, R R and Evely, A (eds) Bibliography of Whale Killing Techniques pp 115–129. International Whaling Commission: Cambridge, UKGoogle Scholar
Øen, E O 1992 The Norwegian hunt of minke whales: hunting trials using 20mm high-velocity projectiles in 1982. Proceedings of the International Whaling Commission. IWC/44/HKW3Google Scholar
Reilly, J P 1994 Scales of reaction to electric shock: thresholds and biophysical mechanisms. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 720: 21–37CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Swatland, H J 1980 Postmortem changes in electrical capacitance and resistivity of pork. Journal of Animal Science 51: 1108–1112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zheng, E, Shao, S and Webster, J G 1984 Impedance of skeletal muscle from 1Hz to 1MHz. Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 31: 477–481CrossRefGoogle Scholar