Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-wxhwt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-13T22:44:40.313Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘What did the Greeks owe the Orient?’ The question we can't stop asking (even though we can't answer it)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 May 2010

Suzanne Marchand
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Reviewing five recent books in German classical and oriental studies, this essay argues that the question of archaic Greece's debts to the Orient remains a particularly lively one in German-speaking Europe. Like their predecessors in previous generations, iconoclastic classicists like Walter Burkert, oriental archaeologists like Ernst Herzfeld (1879–1948) and maverick outsiders like Raoul Schrott have attacked the enraptured view of ‘the Greek miracle’ familiar to those educated in classical Gymnasien. And yet the question of Greek cultural autonomy is still alive, in part because there are too many uncertainties for it to be answered definitively, and in part because it continues to play a role in attempts to define modern European identity.

Keywords

archaic GreeceorientalismSonderwegEuropean identityGerman archaeology in the Near Easthistory of classical scholarship
Type
Review Article
Information
Archaeological Dialogues , Volume 17 , Issue 1 , June 2010 , pp. 117 - 140
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bernabé, A., 2004: Hittites and Greeks. Mythical influences and methodological considerations, in Rollinger, R. and Ulf, C. (eds.), Griechische Archaik. Interne Enwicklungen – externe Impulse, Berlin, 291–310.Google Scholar
Bernal, M., 1987: Black Athena. The Afroasiatic roots of classical civilization, Vol. 1, New Brunswick, NJ.Google Scholar
Bichler, R., 2004: Das chronologische Bild der ‘Archaik’, in Rollinger, R. and Ulf, C. (eds.), Griechische Archaik. Interne Enwicklungen – externe Impulse, Berlin, 27–45.Google Scholar
Bowersock, G.W., 2009: Burckhardt on late antiquity from the Constantin to the Griechische Kulturgeschichte, in Bowersock, G.W., From Gibbon to Auden. Essays on the classical tradition. Oxford, 109–22.Google Scholar
Burkert, W., 1972: Homo necans. Interpretationen altgriechischer Opferriten und Mythen. Berlin.Google Scholar
Burkert, W., 2008: War der große Homer ein Plagiator?, Die Welt Online, 10 March, available at http://www.welt.de/wissenschaft/article1781286/War_der_grosse_Homer_ein_Plagiator.html.Google Scholar
Burkert, W., 2009: Die Griechen und der Orient. Von Homer bis zu den Magiern, 3rd edn, Munich.Google Scholar
Butler, E.M., 1935: The tyranny of Greece over Germany, New York.Google Scholar
Calder, W.M. (ed.), 1990: Eduard Meyer. Leben und Leistung eines Universalhistorikers, Leiden.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Constant, B., 1988: The liberty of the ancients compared with that of the moderns (1816), in Constant, B., Political writings, Cambridge (Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought), 308–28.Google Scholar
Deissmann, A., 1908: Licht vom Osten. Das neue Testament und die neuentdeckten Texte der hellenistisch-römischen Welt, Tübingen.Google Scholar
Dieterich, A., 1903: Eine Mithrasliturgie, Leipzig.Google Scholar
Dräger, P., 2008: Paul Dräger zu Homer, Ilias, übertragen von Raoul Schrott, kommentiert von Peter Mauritsch, Munich, available at www.uni-tuebingen.de/troia/deu/Rezension-Schrott-Homer.pdf.Google Scholar
Dusinberre, E.R.M., 2005: Herzfeld in Persepolis, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 137–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ettinghausen, E.S., 2005: Ernst Herzfeld. Reminiscences and revelations, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 583–615.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goethe, J.W., 1994: Skizze zu einer Schilderung Winckelmanns, Frankfurt am Main.Google Scholar
Gunter, A.C., and Hauser, S.R. (eds), 2005a: Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden.Google Scholar
Gunter, A.C., and Hauser, S.R., 2005b: Ernst Herzfeld and Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 3–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haider, P.W., 2004: Kontakte zwischen Griechen und Ägyptern und ihre Auwirkungen auf die archaisch-griechische Welt, in Rollinger, R. and Ulf, C. (eds.), Griechische Archaik. Interne Enwicklungen – externe Impulse, Berlin, 447–91.Google Scholar
Hauser, S.R, 2005: History, races, and orientalism. Eduard Meyer, the Organization of Oriental Research, and Ernst Herzfeld's intellectual heritage, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 505–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herzfeld, E., 1947: Zoroaster and his world, 2 vols., Princeton.Google Scholar
Hillenbrand, R., 2005: The one that got away. Ernst Herzfeld and the Islamic architecture of Iran, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 405–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Humphreys, S.C., 2004: Classics and colonialism. Towards an erotics of the discipline, in Humphreys, S.C., The strangeness of gods. Historical perspectives on the interpretation of Athenian religion, Oxford, 8–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jaeger, W., 1934: Paideia. Die Formung des griechischen Menschen, Vol. 1, Berlin.Google Scholar
Jensen, P., 1910: Moses, Jesus, Paulus. Drei Varianten des babylonischen Gottmenschen Gilgamesh: Eine Anklage und ein Appell, Frankfurt.Google Scholar
Kawami, T.S., 2005: Ernst Herzfeld, Kuh-e Khwaja, and the study of Parthian art, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 181–214.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kröger, J., 2005: Ernst Herzfeld und Friedrich Sarre, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 45–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kröger, J., 2008: Friedrich Sarre und die islamische Archäologie, in Trümpler, Charlotte (ed.), Das Große Spiel. Archäologie und Politik zur Zeit des Kolonialismus (1860–1940). Cologne, 275–85.Google Scholar
Latacz, J., 2004: Troy and Homer. Towards a solution of an old mystery, Oxford.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Latacz, J., 2007: Altphilologe Latacz kritisiert Raoul Schrotts Arbeiten zu Homer, 31 December, available at www.dradio.de/dkultur/sendungen/interview/717508.Google Scholar
Losemann, V., 1977: Nationalsozialismus und Antike. Studien zur Entwicklung des Faches Alte Geschichte, 1933–1945, Hamburg.Google Scholar
Losemann, V., 2001: ‘Nationalsozialismus und Antike’, in Näf, Beat (ed.), Antike und Altertumswissenschaft in der Zeit von Faschismus und Nationalsozialismus, Mandelbachtal and Cambridge, 2001, 71–88.Google Scholar
Marchand, S., 1996: Down from Olympus. Archaeology and philhellenism in Germany, 1750–1970, Princeton.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marchand, S., 2003: From liberalism to neoromanticism. Albrecht Dieterich, Richard Reitzenstein and the religious turn in fin-de-siècle German classical studies, in Ruehl, Martin and Gildenhard, Ingo (eds.), Out of Arcadia, London (British Institute of Classical Studies Supplement, 79), 129–60.Google Scholar
Marchand, S., 2009: German orientalism in the age of empire. Religion, race and scholarship, New York.Google Scholar
Meier, C., 2005: From Athens to Auschwitz. The uses of history (tr. Schneider, Deborah Lucas), Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
Meier, C., 2008: ‘Wir sind Kinder des Okzidents’, Neue Zürcher Zeitung, 2 February, available at www.nzz.ch/nachrichten/kultur_und_kunst/wir_sind_kinder_des_okzidents.Google Scholar
Meier, C., 2009: Kultur, um der Freiheit willen. Griechische Anfänge – Anfang Europas?, Munich.Google Scholar
Mietke, G, 2005: Ernst Herzfeld und Samuel Guyer in Kilikien. Forschungen zur spätantik-frühbyzantinischen Architektur, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 345–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mousavi, A., 2005: Ernst Herzfeld, politics and antiquities legislation in Iran, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 445–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Narjesus, comment of 29 January 2008, sent to Die Welt Online, available at http://www.welt.de/kultur/article1606772/Die_Ilias_zwischen_Ost_und_West_Teil_3.html.Google Scholar
Raablauf, K.A., 2004: Zwischen Ost und West. Phönizische Einflüsse auf die griechische Polisbildung?, in Rollinger, R. and Ulf, C. (eds.), Griechische Archaik. Interne Enwicklungen – externe Impulse, Berlin, 271–90.Google Scholar
Rollinger, R., 2004: Die Verschriftung von Normen. Einflüsse und Elemente orientalischer Kulturtechnik in den homerischen Epen, dargestellt in Beispiel des Vertragswesens, in Rollinger, R. and Ulf, C. (eds.), Griechische Archaik. Interne Enwicklungen – externe Impulse, Berlin, 369–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rollinger, R., 2008: Schrott wagt den Blick über die Zäune hinweg. Althistoriker Rollinger über die neuen Thesen zu ‘Ilias’, interview on Deutschlandfunk, 5 January, available at http://www.dradio.de/dlf/sendungen/kulturheute/720045.Google Scholar
Rollinger, R. and Ulf, C. (eds.), 2004: Griechische Archaik: Interne Enwicklungen – externe Impulse, Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Root, M.C., 2005: Prismatic prehistory. Ernst Herzfeld on early Iran, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 215–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schipper, B.U. (ed.), 2006: Ägyptologie als Wissenschaft. Adolf Erman (1854–1937) in seiner Zeit, Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schrott, R., 2007: Ilias. Homers Geheimnis ist gelüftet, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 22 December, Z1, available at http://www.faz.net/s/Rub4521147CD87A4D9390DA8578416FA2EC/Doc~E1921659A77D44B2AB44EB3B6F7BBE1F5~ATpl~Ecommon~Scontent.html.Google Scholar
Schrott, R., 2008: Homers Heimat. Der Kampf um Troia und seine realen Hintergründe, Munich.Google Scholar
Skjaervø, P.O, 2005: Ernst Herzfeld and Iranian studies, in Gunter, A.C. and Hauser, S.R. (eds), Ernst Herzfeld and the development of Near Eastern studies, 1900–1950, Leiden, 295–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strachan, H., 2003: The First World War, Vol. 1, To arms, Oxford.Google Scholar
Sünderhauf, E.S., 2004: Griechensehnsucht und Kulturkritik: Die deutsche Rezeption von Winckelmanns Antikenideal, 1840–1945, Berlin.Google Scholar
Tagesspiegel, 2008: Willkommen im Morgenland, Der Tagesspiegel, 9 March, available at http://www.tagesspiegel.de/zeitung/Die-Dritte-Seite-Tuerkei;art705,2491298.Google Scholar
Tignor, R, Adelman, J., Aron, S., Kotkin, S., Marchand, S., Prakash, G. and Tsin, M., 2002: Worlds together, worlds apart. A history of the modern world (1300 to the present), New York.Google Scholar
Wendland, P., 1907: Die hellenistisch-römisch Kultur in ihren Beziehung zu Judentum und Christentum, Tübingen.Google Scholar
Wenk, S. (ed.), 1985: Auf den Spuren der Antike: Theodor Wiegand, ein deutscher Archäologe, Bendorf am Rhein.Google Scholar
Winckler, H., 1889: Untersuchungen zur altorientalischen Geschichte. Leipzig.Google Scholar