Hostname: page-component-7bb8b95d7b-qxsvm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-09-05T06:18:16.171Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Postcolonial partnerships: deep sea research, media coverage and (inter)national narratives on the Galathea Deep Sea Expedition from 1950 to 1952

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 July 2009

KRISTIAN HVIDTFELT NIELSEN
KRISTIAN HVIDTFELT NIELSEN
Affiliation:
Department of Science Studies, Aarhus University, C. F. Møllers Allé, Building 1110, DK-8000Århus C, Denmark. Email: khn@ivs.au.dk.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Danish Galathea Deep Sea Expedition between 1950 and 1952 combined scientific and official objectives with the production of national and international narratives distributed through the daily press and other media. Dispatched by the Danish government on a newly acquired naval ship, the expedition undertook groundbreaking deep sea research while also devoting efforts to showing the flag, public communication of science, and international cooperation. The expedition was conceived after the war as a way in which to rehabilitate Denmark's reputation internationally and to rebuild national pride. To this end, the expedition included an onboard press section reporting the expedition to the Danish public and to an international audience. The press section mediated the favourable, post-war and postcolonial image of Denmark as an internationalist, scientific, modernizing and civilizing nation for which the expedition planners and many others were hoping. The expedition, therefore, was highly relevant to, indeed fed on, the emerging internationalist agenda in Denmark's foreign policy. Bringing out these aspects of the historical context of the expedition, this paper adds important perspectives to our knowledge about the expedition in particular and, more generally, about scientific exploration in the immediate post-war and postcolonial period.

Type
Research Article
Information
The British Journal for the History of Science , Volume 43 , Issue 1 , March 2010 , pp. 75 - 98
Copyright
Copyright © British Society for the History of Science 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 M. Bravo and S. Sörlin, ‘Narrative and practice: an introduction’, in Narrating the Arctic: A Cultural History of Nordic Scientific Practices (ed. M. Bravo and S. Sörlin), Canton, MA, 2002, 3–32.

2 R. MacLeod (ed.), Nature and Empire: Science and the Colonial Enterprise, Osiris (2000), 15; Schiebinger, L., Harrison, M., Cañizares-Esguerra, J., Harris, S. H. and Osborne, M. A., ‘Focus: colonial science’, Isis (2005), 96, 52–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar; N. Reingold and M. Rothenberg (eds.), Scientific Colonialism: A Cross-cultural Comparison, Washington, DC, 1987; D. P. Miller and P. H. Reill (eds.), Visions of Empire: Voyages, Botany and Representations of Nature, Cambridge, 1996.

3 The Koch case is presented in C. J. Ries, ‘Lauge Koch and the mapping of North East Greenland: tradition and modernity in Danish arctic research, 1920–1940’, in Narrating the Arctic: A Cultural History of Nordic Scientific Practices (ed. M. Bravo and S. Sörlin), Canton, MA, 2002, 199–231; and C. J. Ries, Retten, magten og æren: Lauge Koch-sagen – en strid om Grønlands geologiske udforskning, Copenhagen, 2003.

4 K. H. Nielsen, ‘In quest of publicity: the science–media partnership of the Galathea Deep Sea Expedition from 1950 to 1952’, Public Understanding of Science, in press.

5 G. Hecht and W. Anderson (eds.), Special issue on postcolonial technoscience, Social Studies of Science (2002), 32.

6 B. Anderson, ‘Narrating the nation’, Times Literary Supplement, 13 June 1986, 659; and B. Anderson, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, rev. edn, London, 2006.

7 K. Thisted, ‘The power to represent: intertextuality and discourse in Smilla's Sense of Snow’, in Narrating the Arctic: A Cultural History of Nordic Scientific Practices (ed. M. Bravo and S. Sörlin), Canton, MA, 2002, 311–42; and M. Stecher-Hansen, History Revisited: Fact and Fiction in Thorkild Hansen's Documentary Works, Columbia, SC, 1997.

8 Thisted, op. cit. (7).

9 H. C. Andersen, The Complete Stories, London, 2005.

10 Østergaard, U., ‘Peasants and Danes: the Danish national identity and political culture’, Comparative Studies in Society and History (1992), 34, 3–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘Language and national identity in the Danish nation-state in the 19th century’, History of European Ideas (1993), 16, 213–18; and idem, ‘Denmark: A big small state – the peasant roots of Danish modernity’, in National Identity and the Varieties of Capitalism: The Danish Experience (ed. J. L. Campbell, J. A. Hall and O. K. Pedersen), Montreal and Kingston, 2006, 51–98.

11 L. B. Kaspersen, ‘The formation and development of the welfare state’, in National Identity and the Varieties of Capitalism: The Danish Experience (ed. J. L. Campbell, J. A. Hall and O. K. Pedersen), Montreal and Kingston, 2006, 99–132.

12 B. Lidegaard, Defiant Diplomacy: Henrik Kauffmann, Denmark, and the United States in World War II and the Cold War, 1939–1958, New York, 2003.

13 Anton F. Bruun to Vice-Admiral Aage H. Vedel, 5 December 1944, Aa. H. Vedel Papers, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 06499, Box 24.

14 H. Mielche, Monsunens sidste rejse, Copenhagen, 1935; and idem, Let's See if the World Is Round, London, 1938.

15 For essays on creative couples in the sciences see H. M. Pycior, N. G. Slack and P. G. Abir-Am, Creative Couples in the Sciences, New Brunswick, NJ, 1996.

16 On the role of the sea serpent in the expedition narrative see Nielsen, K. H., ‘In search of the sea monster’, Endeavour (2006), 30, 36–40.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

17 S. Nørby, Flådens sænkning 29. august 1943, Odense, 2003.

18 H. Mielche, Galathea lægger ud, Copenhagen, 1951, 18. All Danish quotes have been translated by the present author.

19 R. Spärck, ‘Background and origin of the expedition’, in The Galathea Deep Sea Expedition 1950–1952 (ed. A. F. Bruun, S. Greve, H. Mielche and R. Spärck), London, 1956, 11–17.

20 Deed of Foundation for the Danish Expedition Foundation, May 1948, Danish Expedition Foundation, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10541, Box 1.

21 Mielche, op. cit. (18), 29.

22 Mielche, op. cit. (18), 30–1.

23 H. Mielche and L. B. Hendil, ‘Dansk Ekspeditionsfond’, 1948, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Box 12, quote from p. 2.

24 MacLeod, op. cit. (2); Schiebinger et al., op. cit. (2).

25 Minutes of the Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, 5 April 1950, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 1.

26 Minutes of the Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, 21 May 1948 and 26 October 1948, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 1.

27 R. Spärck, ‘Den danske dybhavsekspeditions videnskabelige baggrund og formål’, 1950, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 1.

28 Spärck, op. cit. (27).

29 Aa. H. Vedel, ‘Søværnets deltagelse i dybhavsekspeditionen og ekspeditionens nationale opgaver’, 1950, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 1.

30 Vedel, op. cit. (29).

31 M. Sterll, ‘Galatheas rejse omkring jorden’, in Natur, Nytte og Ånd 1730–1850. Dansk Naturvidenskabs Historie (ed. H. Kragh), 2 vols., Århus, 2005, ii, 428–37.

32 Spärck, op. cit. (27).

33 Mielche, op. cit. (18), 31–2.

34 H. Mielche and A. F. Bruun, ‘Science and the man in the street: A deepsea expedition round the world’, Danish Foreign Office Journal (1950), 14–18, 17.

35 Mielche and Bruun, op. cit. (34), 17.

36 Tikili., ‘Galathea drog i gaar ud i verden’, Berlingske Tidende, 16 October 1950, 1.

37 H. C. Andersen, ‘Denmark, My Native Land’, 1850, available at http://www.andersen.sdu.dk/rundtom/borge/danmark_e.html, accessed 24 November 2008.

38 H. C. Andersen, Mit livs eventyr, Århus, 1966 (1855).

39 Perhaps expressed most clearly in U. Østergaard, ‘Danish national identity: between multinational heritage and small-state nationalism’, in Denmark's Policy towards Europe after 1945: History, Theory and Options (ed. H. Branner and M. Kelstrup), Odense, 2000, 139–84.

40 H. Mielche, Round the World with Galathea, London, 1954, 4–5.

41 Stecher-Hansen, op. cit. (7).

42 H. Mielche, ‘Galathea besøger Danmarks gamle besiddelser paa Guldkysten’, Illustreret Familie-Journal, 20 February 1951, 4–5, 18. All quotes from 18.

43 H. Mielche, ‘Christiansborg’, Illustreret Familie-Journal, 27 February 1951, 4–5, 22.

44 H. Mielche, ‘Fra negerslaver til kakao’, Illustreret Familie-Journal, 6 March 1951, 4–5, 28–9, 29.

45 Mielche, op. cit. (18), 7.

46 Spärck, op. cit. (27).

47 T. Wolff, ‘Contact with international science’, in The Galathea Deep Sea Expedition 1950–1952 (ed. A. F. Bruun, S. Greve, H. Mielche and R. Spärck), London, 1956, 272–81, 272.

48 Rozwadowski, H., ‘Internationalism, environmental necessity, and national interest: marine science and other sciences’, Minerva (2004), 42, 127–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

49 J. D. Hamblin, Oceanographers and the Cold War: Disciples of Marine Science, Seattle, 2005.

50 Cited in Hamblin, J. D., ‘Visions of international scientific cooperation: the case of oceanic science, 1920–1955’, Minerva (2000), 38, 393–423CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 393.

51 T. B. Olesen and P. Villaume, I blokopdelingens tegn 1945–1972. Dansk udenrigspolitiks historie, Copenhagen, 2006.

52 K. K. N. Midtgaard, Jutlandia-ekspeditionen: Tilblivelse og virke 1950–53, Copenhagen, 2001.

53 A. Georg, ‘Galathea som Danmarks sejlende ambassadør’, Berlingske Tidende, 19 June 1951, 5.

54 Prince Axel to Minister of Foreign Affairs Frantz Hvass, 13 April 1950, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 2; Frantz Hvass to Prince Axel, 15 April 1950, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 2.

55 Trade Office of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark, ‘Notat til Komiteen for den Danske dybhavsekspedition’, 29 October 1949, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 2.

56 A. F. Bruun, ‘Verdrørende notat fra Udenrigsministeriets Handelskontor’, 22 November 1949, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 6.

57 The Royal Danish Embassy of India, ‘Report on the visit of H.M.S. Galathea to Calcutta’, 4 May 1951, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 6.

58 S. Greve, ‘Skibet og togtet’, in Galatheas jordomsejling 1950–52. Den danske dybhavsekspeditions virke og resultater skildret af deltagerne (ed. A. F. Bruun, S. Greve, H. Mielche and R. Spärck), Copenhagen, 1953, 11–38.

59 L. Tillitse to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark, 7 May 1951, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 6.

60 Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark to the Committee for the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, 29 May 1951, Committee of the Danish Deep Sea Expedition, the Danish National Archives, Copenhagen, No. 10289, Box 6.

61 top-, ‘Minister Tillitse burde have hjælp’, Berlingske Aftenavis, 22 May 1951, 3.

62 Pettersson, H., ‘The Swedish Deep-Sea Expedition, 1947–48’, Deep-Sea Research (1953), 1, 17–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

63 Carruthers, N. and Lawford, A. L., ‘The deepest oceanic sounding’, Nature (1952), 169, 601–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 603.

64 ZoBell, C., ‘Bacterial life at the bottom of the Philippine Trench’, Science (1952), 115, 507–8CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

65 Bruun, A. F., ‘The Philippine Trench and its bottom fauna’, Nature (1951), 168, 693CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66 Bruun, A. F., ‘The abyssal fauna: its ecology, distribution and origin’, Nature (1956), 177, 1105–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 Nielsen, op. cit. (4).

68 H. Mielche, ‘Films, press, and radio on the expedition’, in The Galathea Deep Sea Expedition 1950–1952 (ed. A. F. Bruun, S. Greve, H. Mielche and R. Spärck), London, 1956, 282–93, 282.

69 The Danish Expedition Foundation, ‘Galathea 3’, available at http://www.galathea3.dk/uk, accessed 14 November 2008.

70 Nielsen, K. H., ‘Enacting the social relations of science: historical (anti-)boundary-work of Danish science journalist Børge Michelsen’, Public Understanding of Science (2008), 17, 171–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

71 H. Knudsen, ‘Politik, penge og forskningsvilkår’, in Viden uden grænser. Dansk Naturvidenskabs Historie 1920–70 (ed. H. Nielsen and K. H. Nielsen), Århus, 2006, 323–46.

72 N. Thomsen, O. Hyldtoft, J. P. Christensen, H. C. Johansen, C. Nilsson and P. Boje, Dansk industri efter 1870. Industriens vækst og vilkår, 6 vols., Odense, 1988–97; and S. A. Hansen, Early Industrialisation in Denmark, Copenhagen, 1970.

73 T. Wolff, ‘Contact with international science’, in The Galathea Deep Sea Expedition 1950–1952 (ed. A. F. Bruun, S. Greve, H. Mielche and R. Spärck), London, 1956, 272–81, 272.

74 Hamblin, op. cit. (49); Rozwadowski, op. cit. (48).

75 Hubbs, C. L., ‘Death notice: Anton Fredrik Bruun’, Copeia (1962), 2, 481–2Google Scholar.

76 Baba, K., ‘Deep-sea chirostylid and galatheid crustaceans (decapoda, anomura) from the Indo-Pacific, with a list of species’, Galathea Report: Scientific Results of The Danish Deep-Sea Expedition Round the World 1950–52 (2005), 20, 1–317.Google Scholar

77 Anon., ‘30.000 københavnerne modtog Galathea’, Politiken, 30 June 1952, 1.

78 Tikili., ‘Straalende velkomst til “Galathea”’, Berlingske Tidende, 30 June 1952, 1.