1. Hopkins, Charles Howard, The Rise of the Social Gospel in American Protestantism, 1865–1915 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1940), pp. 302–317.Google Scholar

2. Hutchinson, John Alexander, We Are Not Divided: A Critical and Historical Study of the Federal Council of the Churches of Christ in America (New York: Round Table Press, 1941), p. 25.Google ScholarPubMed

3. See, for example, Macfarland, Charles Steadman, Christian Unity in the Making: The First Twenty-five Years of the Federal Council of the Churches of Christ in America (New York: Federal Council of Churches, 1948), pp. 24, 27Google Scholar; Smith, H. Shelton, Handy, Robert T. and Loetscher, Lefferts A., American Christianity: An Historical Interpretation with Representative Documents, 2 vols. (New York: Scribner's, 1960–1963) 2:394Google Scholar: Mead, Sidney Earl, The Lively Experiment: The Shaping of Christianity in America (New York: Harper and Row, 1963), p. 182Google Scholar; Ahlstrom, Sydney E., A Religious History of the American People (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1972), pp. 802–804Google Scholar; Cavert, Samuel McCrea, The American Churches in the Ecumenical Movements, 1900–1968 (New York: Association Press, 1968), pp. 29–31.Google Scholar Macfarland and Cavert were secretaries of the Federal Council.

4. Sanford, Elias Benjamin, The Origin and History of the Federal Council of the Churches of Christ in America (Hartford, Connecticut: S. S. Scranton, 1916), p. iv.Google Scholar

5. Minutes of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the United States (hereafter PCUS) 5 (Wilmington, North Carolina: Jackson and Bell, 1881): 353, 356, 391–392; 5Google Scholar (Wilmington, North Carolina: Jackson and Bell, 1882): 523, 526, 530–531, 541, 542, 552–553; 6 (Wilmington, North Carolina: Jackson and Bell, 1883): 19, 20–23, 49–50, 54, 57–58; 6 (Wilmington, North Carolina: Jackson and Bell, 1884): 219–221, 243, 248, 249, 251; Minutes of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America (hereafter PCUSA, n. s., 7 (New York: Presbyterian Board of Publication, 1882): 50–66, 83–84, 102–103Google Scholar; n. a., 7 (New York: Presbyterian Board of Publication, 1883): 569, 576, 591, 596, 630, 636, 646, 687; n. s., 8 (Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication, 1884): 27, 67–70, 101.

6. Kirkpatrick, Dow, “Early Efforts at Reunion,” in The History of American Methodism, ed. Bucke, Emory Stevens et al., 3 vols. (Nashville, Tennessee: Abingdoa Press, 1964). 2:689–694.Google Scholar

7. PCUSA, u.s., 9 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1886): 25–26, 57–58; n.s., 10 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1887): 26, 35, 57, 116–117, 128; n. s., 11 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1888): 85, 923–102; n. s., 12 Philadelphia: By the Sttaed Clerk, 1889): 64, 68–74, 79–80; PCUS 7 (Columbia, South Carolina: Presbyterian Publishing House, 1886): 20, 22; 7 (Columbia, South Carolina: Presbyterian Publishing House, 1887): 188, 191–192, 193–195, 200–201, 203, 205–206, 207–210, 211, 216–219, 220, 224; 7 (Richmond, Virginia: Presbyterian Committee of Publication, 1888): 420–423, 431–432, 456–463; 7 (Richmond, Virginia: Presbyterian Committee of Publication, 1889): 570–573, 576, 577, 582, 594–598; “The Prospects of Presbyterian Union,” Independent 40 (1888): 362;Google Scholar Charles Augustus Briggs, “Union of Northern and Southern Presbyterians,” ibid., p. 316; Briggs, Charles Augustus. “A Plea for an American Alliance,” Presbyterian Review 9 (1888) 306–309.Google Scholar

8. Journal of the Proceedings of the Bishops, Clergy, and Laity of the Protestant Episcopal Church… Assembled in a General Convention, Held in Chicago, from October 6 to October 28… 1886 (hereafter PEC with year) (n.p.: Printed for the Convention, 1887), pp. 79–80, 199–200, 212, 256–257, 302, 800–844; “The General Convention,” Churchman 54 (1886): 497–498, 539–540Google Scholar; “Reports on Church Unity,” ibid., pp. 560–562; “ A Memorial on the Reunion of Christians,” ibid., pp. 225, 229 et passim.

9. Minutes of the Nationah Council of the Congregational Churches … in Chicago, Ill., October 3–20,1886 (hereafter NCCC with year) (Boston: Congregational Publishing Society, 1887), pp. 16,Google Scholar 17, 21, 22, 33–35, 36, 349–350, 356–358.

10. George Park Fisher to William E. Dodge Jr., December 3, 1887, in NCCC, 1889, (Boston: Congregational Publishing Society, 1889), pp. 251–252; Evangelical Alliance for the United States. I. Action of the United States Evangelical Alliance on the Death of its President, Hon. William E. Dodge, Document 16 (New York, 1883), pp. 6–7Google Scholar; Coxe, Arthur Cleveland, “A Christian Alliance, the Demand of Our Times,” Independent 36 (1884): 193–194Google Scholar; “Evangelical Alliance: A Notable Reunion,” New York Observer 64 (1886): 114Google Scholar; National Perils and Opportunities: The Discussions of the General Christian Conference Held in Washington, D. C., December 7th, 8th, and 9th, 1887, under the Auspices of the Evangelical Alliance for the United States (New York: Baker and Taylor, 1887), pp. 303Google Scholar et passim; Ward, Julius Hammond, “The Evangelical Alliance in Boston,” Churchman 60 (1889): 771.Google Scholar

11. Evangelical Alliance for the U. S., Eighth Annual Report… 1875, Document 11 (New York, 1875), pp. 7–11,Google ScholarTenth and Eleventh Annual Reports… 1877 and 1878, Document 13 (New York, 1879), pp. 3–5,Google Scholar and Twelfth Annual Report … 1879, Document 15 (New York, 1879), pp. 5–7Google Scholar; Discussions of the Interdenominational Congress in the lnterest of City Evangelization, Held in Cincinnati, December 7–11, 1885 (Cincinnati: The Congress, 1886)Google Scholar; American Congress of Churches, Proceedings of the Hartford Meeting, 1885 (Hartford, Connecticut: Case, Lockwood, and Brainerd, Co., 1885)Google Scholar and Proceedings of the Cleveland Meeting, May, 1886 (Hartford, Connecticut: Case, Lockwood and Brainerd Co., 1886).Google Scholar See also National Perils and Opportunities; National Needs and Remedies: The Discussions of the General Christian Conference Held in Boston, Massachusetts, December 4th, 5th, and 6th, 1889, under the Auspices of the Evangelical Alliance for the United States (New York: Baker and Taylor, 1890)Google Scholar; and Christianity Practically Applied: The Discussions of the International Christian Conference Held in Chicago, October 6–14, 1893, in Connection with the World's Congress Auxiliary of the World's Columbian Exposition and under the Auspices and Direction of the Evangelical Alliance for the United States, 2 vols. (New York: Baker and Taylor, 1894).Google Scholar

12. “First Response to the Bishop's [sic] Declaration on Unity,” Churchman 54 (1886): 629;Google Scholar“The First Response to the Bishops,” Independent 38 (1886): 1346; PEC 1895 (n.p.: Printed for the Convention, 1896), pp. 613–627.Google Scholar

13. Briggs, Charles Augustus, ed., “Letters on the Relations between the Presbyterians and Episcopalians in England by Benedict Pietet, 1708,” Presbyterian Review 8 (1887): 132–133Google Scholar; Charles Augustus Briggs, “The Work of John Durie in Behalf of Christian Union in the Seventeenth Century,” ibid., pp. 297–309; Charles Augustus Briggs, “The Barriers to Christian Union,” ibid., pp. 441–471. See also Briggs, Charles Augustus, “Terms of Christian Union,” Christian Union 35 (05 12, 1887): 8–9.Google Scholar

14. Shields, Charles Woodruff, “The United Churches of the United States: Their Existing Agreements in Doctrine, Polity, and Worship,” Century 31 (1885): 74–84,Google Scholar and “The United Churches of the United States, No. II: A Review of the Century Letters on Christian Unity,” Century 35 (1887): 254–264.Google Scholar See also “Unity and the Prayerbook,” New York Observer 64 (1886): 2,Google Scholar and Sloan, William Milligan, “Charles Woodruff Shields:A Biographical Sketch,” in Shields, C. W., Philosophia Ultima, or Science of the Sciences, 3 vols. (New York: Scribner's, 1888–1905), 3: viii–lxx.Google Scholar

15. PCUSA, n.s., 10 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1887): 62, 82, 157–158; “The Beginning of a Great Movement,” Christian Union 35 (05 12, 1887): 3Google Scholar; “Christian Unity,” Church Union 15 (06 15, 1887): 6.Google Scholar

16. Acts and Proceedings of the … General Synod of the Reformed Church in America, Convened at Catskill, New York, June 1887, 16 (New York: Board of Publication of the Reformed Church in America, 1887): 363–365, 368–369Google Scholar; Briggs, , “A Plea for an American Alliance,” pp. 306–309.Google Scholar

17. PCUSA, n. s., 13 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1890): 103–104; n. s., 14 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1891): 162–166; n. s., 15 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1892): 91–96; “Comity,” Home Missionary 65 (1893): 470Google Scholar; “Interdenominational Comity,” ibid., pp. 562–563.

18. Interdenominational Conference of Foreign Missionary Boards and Societies in the United States and Canada, Held in the Presbyterian Mission House, January 12, 1893 (New York: E. O. Jenkins' Son's Printing House, 1893), p. iii.Google Scholar

19. Newton, William Wilberforce, “Beginning at Jerusalem,” Christian Union 17, (1883): 268,Google Scholar See also [William Augustus Muhlenberg] Hints on Catholic Union by a Presbyter (New York, 1835),Google Scholar rpt. in Evangelical Catholic Papers: A Collection of Essays, Letters, and Tractates from Writings of Rev. William Augustus Muhlenberg, D.D., during the Last Forty Years, ed. Anne Ayres, 1st ser. (Suffolk Co., New York: St. Johnland Press, 1875), pp. 27–32,Google Scholar and Newton, William Wilberforce, Dr. Muhlenberg (Boston: Houghton, Mifflin, 1890), pp. viii, 123ff., 149.Google Scholar

20. Newton, William Wilberforce, The Vine Out of Egypt (New York: Thomas Whittaker, 1887), pp. 128–129.Google Scholar

21. Davidson, Randall Thomas, ed., The Six Lambeth Conferences, 1867–1920 (London: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, 1929), pp. 122, 156–161Google Scholar; Jewell, Frederick S., “Church Unity and the Convention,” Church Eclectic 21 (1892): 24–25.Google Scholar

22. “Chureh Reunion,” Church Review 59 (10 1890): iii–iv, 11–221.Google Scholar See “The Historic Episcopate as a Basis of Reunion,” Church Review 57 (04 1890): 11–144.Google Scholar

23. McCosh, James, “Federation of Churches to Secure that the Gospel Be Preached to Every Creature,” Christian Union 41 (1890): 180–190Google Scholar; McCosh, James, “Federation of Evangelical Churches,” Church Review, 57 (04 1890): 132–134Google Scholar; McCosh, James, “Federation of Churches,” Homiletic Review 21 (1891): 398.Google Scholar See also “Federation of Churches for Evangelistic Work,” Independent 42 (1890): 778–779.Google Scholar

24. Acts and Proceedings of the … General Synod of the Reformed Church in America, Convened at Asbury Park, N. J., June, 1890 17 (New York: Board of Publication of the Reformed Church in America, 1890): 124–134Google Scholar; … Convened at Asbury Park, N. J., June, 1891 (New York: Board of Publication of the Reformed Church in America, 1891): 343–359Google Scholar; … Convened at Asbury Park, N. J., June, 1892, 17 (New York: Board of Publication of the Reformed Church in America, 1892): 577–586;Google Scholar… Convened at Asbury Park, N. J., June 1893, 17 (New York: Board of Plublication of the Reformed Church in America, 1893) 816–823Google Scholar; Acts and Proceedings of the General Synod of the Reformed Church in the United States at Lebanon, Pa., May, 1890 (Dayton, Ohio: Reformed Publishing Company 1890), pp. 36–40Google Scholar; … Convened in Special Session at Philadelphia, Pa., June 4–6, 1891 (Dayton, Ohio: Reformed Publishing Company, 1891),Google Scholar passim; … at Reading, Pa., May 24 to June 1, 1893 (Dayton, Ohio: Reformed Publishing Company, 1893), pp. 28, 33, 42–45Google Scholar; Harmelink, Herman, III, Ecumenism and the Reformed Church (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1968), pp. 32–54.Google Scholar

25. PCUSA, n.s., 14 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1891): 206–207; n. s. 15 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1892): 38–41; n. s., 17 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk 1894): 164–166; n. s., 19 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1896): 47, 180–182; Report of the Special Committee on Church Unity [PCUSA] (n. p., 1893), pp. 12–14.Google Scholar

26. NCCC, 1892 (Boston: Congregational Sunday School and Publishing Society, 1893), pp. 39–40, 109–113.

27. Journal of the … General Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, Held in Memphis, Tennessee, May 3–21, 1894 (Nashville, Tennessee: Publishing House, Methodist Episcopal Church, South, 1894), pp. 117, 118, 128, 162, 177, 217–219Google Scholar; … in Baltimore, Maryland, May 5–23, 1898 (Nashville, Tennessee: Publishing House, Methodist Episcopal Church, South, 1898), pp. 72, 85, 171–172, 237–247Google Scholar;… in Dallas, Texas, May 7–26, 1902 (Nashville, Tennessee: Publishing House, Methodist Episcopal Church, South, 1902), pp. 70, 81, 161–62, 171,Google Scholar … in Asheville, N. C., May 4–21, 1910 (Nashville, Tennessee: Publishing House, Methodist Episcopal Church, South, 1910), p. 264Google Scholar; Journal of the … General Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church, Held in Cleveland, Ohio, May 1–28, 1896 (New York: Eaton and Mains, 1896), p. 178Google Scholar; … in Chicago, Illinois, May 2–29, 1900 (New York: Eaton and Mains, 1900), pp. 323, 329, 367–370, 469–470Google Scholar; … in Baltimore, Maryland, May 6-June 1, 1908 (New York: Eaton and Mains, 1908), pp. 417–418, 621–625. 919–928Google Scholar: Moser, Frederick E.. “The Story of Unification,” in Bueke et al., eds.. History of American Methodism, 3: 412–414.Google Scholar

28. Proceedings of the Southern Baptist Convention … Held at Dallas. Texas, May 11–15, 1894 (Atlanta, Georgia: Franklin Printing and Publishing Co., 1894). pp. 15–16Google Scholar; … at Washington, D. C., 05 10–14. 1895 (Atlanta. Georgia: Franklin Printing and Publishing Co., 1895), pp. 14–16Google Scholar; Baker, Robert Andrew. Relations between Northern and Southern Baptists (Fort Worth, Texas: Seminary Hill Press, 1948). pp. 184–202Google Scholar; Barnes, William Wright, The Southern Baptist Convention, 1845–1953 (Nashville, Tennessee: Broadman Press, 1954), pp. 80, 263–268.Google Scholar

29. Proceedings of the … Convention of the General Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Session at Canton, Ohio, May 24-June 1. 1893 (Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1893), p. 50Google Scholar: at Hagerstown. Md., 06 5–13, 1895 (Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1895), pp. 56, 77–79Google Scholar; Minutes of the … Convention of the General Council of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Held in Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, Ft. Wayne, Indiana, October 5th to October 10th. 1893 (Lancaster. Ohio: Eagle Job Printing House, 1893), pp. 11–13, 88–89Google Scholar; … in St. John's Church, Erie, Pa., October 14–20, 1897 (Philadelphia: General Council Publication Board, 1897). pp. 9–10, 62–63, 129–130Google Scholar; Minutes of the … Convention of the United Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in the South, Held in Christ Church, Staunton. Virginia, September 18–21, 1895 (Asheville, North Carolina: Southern Lutheran Printing Co., 1895), pp. 56–59Google Scholar; … in Luther Chapel Church, Newbury, S. C., May 11–16, 1898 (New Market, Virginia: Henkel and Co.'s Steam Printing House, 1898), pp. 48–49Google Scholar; The First General Conference of Lutherans in America, Held in Philadelphia, December 27–29, 1898 (Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Board and General Council Publication Board, 1899), p. 16.Google Scholar

30. de Witt Hyde, William, “Religious Cooperation in Maine,” Review of Reviews [New York] 5 (1892): 51–52Google Scholar; de Witt Hyde, William, “Christian Cooperakion in Church Extension,” in Christianity Practically Applied, 1:261–272Google Scholar; de Witt Hyde, William, “Church Union a Necessity: The Maine Experiment,” Forum 14 (1893): 154–162Google Scholar; The Interdenominational Commission of Maine (Portland, Maine, 1894),Google Scholar pamphlet in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York.

31. McCosh, James, “The Federation of Churches,” in Christianity Practically Applied, 1: 230–233Google Scholar; Barrows, John Henry, ed., The World's Parliament of Religions, 2 vols. (Chicago: Parliament Publishing Co., 1893), 2: 1179–1220Google Scholar et passim; Feldman, Egal, “American Ecumenism: Chicago's World's Parliament of Religions of 1893,” Journal of Church and State 9 (1967): 180–199.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

32. McCosh, James, O Whither? Tell Me Where (New York: Scribner's, 1889), pp. 43–44Google Scholar; McCosh, , “Federation of Churches to Secure that the Gospel Be Preached to Every Creature,” p. 190Google Scholar. See Briggs, Charles Augustus, “The Barriers to Christian Union,” Presbyterian Review 8 (1887): 435–436, 410–471Google Scholar and Whither? A Theological Question for the Times (New York: Scribner's, 1889), pp. 237, 244, 261–265.Google Scholar

33. PCUSA, n. s., 17 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1894): 25–29; PEC 1895 (n.p.: Printed for the Convention, 1895): 608–627: The Correspondence between the Committee on Church Unity of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. and the Commission on Christian Unity of the Protestant Episcopal Church in the U. S. (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1896).Google Scholar

34. PCUSA, n. s., 17 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1896): 22, 143–144, 206–209.

35. Ibid., pp. 22, 25, 164–166; n. s., 18 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1895): 25, 27; n. s., 19 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1896): 47, 105, 180–183.

36. Ibid., pp. 66–69: n. s., 20 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1897): 156–157.

37. Strong, Josiah, “Practical Cooperation in Christian Work,” Review of Reviews [New York] 6 (1892): 301.Google Scholar See also Strong, Josiah, The New Era, or the Coming Kingdom (New York: Baker and Taylor, 1893), pp. 312–314.Google Scholar

38. Evangelical Alliance, U. S., Manuscript Minutes, 5 vols., 4: 107–108, 126, 149, 176, 213,223, 255, 278, 301, in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York; Strong, Josiah, “Local Alliances,’ American Journal of Sociology 1 (1895): 170–181.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

39. Josiah Strong to Robert M. Patterson, September 16, 1893, in Evangelical Alliance, U.S., Letters, 6 pressbook vols. 3:159, 287–288, in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York.

40. Sanford, pp. 34–57; Abell, Aaron Ignatius, The Urban Impact on American Protestantism, 1865–1900 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1943), pp. 161–163Google Scholar; The Open or Institutional Church League: Preliminary Conference Held in the Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church, March 27, 1894 (Boston, 1894).Google Scholar

41. Berry, Charles A., “Federation of the Churches and Arbitration in America,” Homiletic Review 26 (1899): 133–138Google Scholar; “Federation of the Churches,” Homiletic Review 25 (1898): 96–97Google Scholar; Jordon, Edward Kenneth Henry, Free Church Council: History of the Free Church Council Movement, 1896–1941 (London: Lutterworth Press, 1956), pp. 36–76.Google Scholar

42. Sanford, pp. 85, 103–111, 432–436; A Brief Statement of the Need, Purpose, and Work of a National Federation of Churches and Christian Workers in the United States, with a Sketch of the Work of the Federation of Churches and Christian Workers in New York City (New York, 1898), pp. 2Google Scholar et passim, pamphlet in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York.

43. Sanford, pp. 110–111, 116–117; “The Federation,” Outlook 61 (1899): 565;Google Scholar“Conference in the Interest of Federative Action among Churches and Christian Workers in the United States, Held in Philadelphia, February 5, 6, 1901,” in Federation Chronicle:Published in the Interests of the Work of the National Federation of Churches and Christian Workers (New York, 1901), pp. 1–2.Google Scholar

44. Sanford, pp. 112–145; Federation Chronicle, pp. 2–12.

45. Sanford, pp. 305–306; Church Federation: First Annual Report of the Executive Committee of the Federal Council (New York, 1909), p. 14;Google Scholar … Third Annual Report… (New York, 1911), pp. 8Google Scholar et passim.

46. Elias Benjamin Sanford to Charles Steadman Macfarland, May 14, 1916, and to Samuel McCrea Cavert, August 16, 1922, in Sanford Special Correspondence File, Archives of the National Council of Churches; Macfarland, Charles Steadman, Across the Years (New York: Macmillan, 1936), pp. 86–96Google Scholar; Macfarland, Charles Steadman, The Churches of the Federal Council: Their History, Organization, and Distinctive Characteristics and a Statement of the Federal Council (New York: Fleming H. Revell, 1916), p. 246.Google Scholar

47. de Land Leete, Frederick, Christian Brotherhoods (Cincinnati, Ohio: Jennings and Graham, 1912), pp. 291–296.Google Scholar

48. Elias Benjamin Sanford to Charles Steadman Macfarland, June 30, 1922, and to Samuel MeCrea Cavert, February 28, 1923, in Sanford Special Correspondence File, Archives of the National Council of Churches.

49. NCCC 1895 (Boston: Congregational Sunday School and Publishing Society, 1896), pp. 20–21, 34–37, 282–308; NCCC 1898 (Boston: Congregational Sunday School and Publishing Society, 1898), p. 36.

50. NCCC, 1904 (Boston: Office of the Secretary of the National Council, 1904), pp. 468 474, 546–548; 1907 (Boston: Office of the secretary of the Nationa1 Council, 1907), pp. 284–291; Atkins, Gaius Glenn and Flagley, Frederick Louis, History of American Congregationalism (Boston: Pilgrim Press, 1942), pp. 353–354Google Scholar; Drury, Augustus Waldo, History of the Church of the United Brethren in Christ (Dayton, Ohio: Otterbein Press, 1924), pp. 528–532.Google Scholar

51. In Bradford, Amory H., ed., The Question of Unity: Many Voices Concerning the Reunion of Christendom (New York: Christian Literature Co., 1894), p. 34.Google Scholar

52. Dorn, Jacob Henry, Washington Gladden: Prophet of the Social Gospel (Columbus, Ohio: Ohio State University Press, 1968), p. 355.Google Scholar

53. Sanford, pp. 119–121.

54. Ibid., p. 174; NCCC 1901 (Boston: By the Publishing Committee of the National Council, 1901), pp. 35–36, 149–151; Amory H. Bradford. William Hayes Ward, and Washington Choate to Nacy M. Waters, March 3, 1902, in Archives of the National Council of Churches.

55. Sanford. pp. 179, 198–200. See “Church Union and Church Federation,” Independent 55 (1903): 2701–2702,Google Scholar and James Harvey Garrison to Elias Benjamin Sanford, January 21, 1903, in Sanford Special Correspondence File, Archives of the National Council of Churches.

56. Loetscher, Lefferts Augustine, The Broadening Church: A Study of Theological Issues in the Presbyterian Church since 1869 (Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1954), pp. 64, 66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

57. PCUSA, n. s., 2 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1902): 125; n. s., 3 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1903): 134–140; n. s., 4 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk,1904): 75, 235; PEC 1901 (n. p.: Printed for the Convention, 1902), pp. 192, 295–296, 301, 308; PEC 1904 (New York: Printed for the Convention, 1905), pp. 21–22: PEC 1907 (New York: Printed for the Convention, 1907), pp. 22, 291, 514–517; “Church Union and Church Federation,” p. 2701.

58. PCUSA, n. s., 3 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1903): 91, 147, 169; Loetscher, pp. 83–89.

59. Sanford, p. 210.

60. PCUSA, n. s., 4 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1904): 21, 57, 76, 104–105, 119–140, 152 157; n. s., 5 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1905): 68, 77–78, 81, 86, 109, 110–117, 182; n. s., 6 (Philadelphia: By the Stated Clerk, 1906): 15, 16, 52, 123–151, 173, 210–211, 233; PCUS 1907 (Richmond, Virginia: Presbyterian Committee of Publication, 1907), pp. 43–47, 55–58; Handy, Robert Theodore, We Witness Together: The Story of Cooperative Home Missions (New York: Friendship Press, 1956), p. 24.Google Scholar

61. Church Federation: Interchurch Conference on Federation, New York, November 15–21, 1905, ed. Elias Benjamin Sanford (New York: Fleming H. Revell, 1906), pp. 43, 637–667Google Scholar; Sanford, pp. 196–197; PEC 1904:60.

62. Sanford, p. 210.

63. Church Federation, pp. 75–101. See also Report of the First Meeting of the Federal Council, Philadelphia, 1908 (New York: Fleming H. Revell, 1909), p. 77.Google Scholar

64. Ward, William Hayes, “A Federal Congress of Churches,” Independent 59 (1905): 1135–1141.Google Scholar