No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
The Return to Diversity in Eastern Europe
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 September 2008
Extract
The events of 1989, the annus mirabilis, have led to a great demand for new research and a re-thinking of the history of Eastern Europe. Those sources which were kept from us for years are now available, at least in part. As part of this process political scientists and historians of Eastern Europe are now concerned to fill in the gaps in our knowledge and provide the answers to urgent questions. A consequence of this situation has been a veritable flood of publications, of which eight have been chosen for review here. With two exceptions these studies have deepened our understanding of the issues involved. There are clear differences between the historians on the one hand and the political scientists on the other in terms of their starting-point and the questions they ask. Whereas the historians deal descriptively with the origins, trends and structures of the last centuries and place the revolutions of 1989/90 in their historical context, the political scientists proceed analytically and place greater emphasis on social, ethnic and economic factors. This dichotomy is demonstrated in the different problematics of the books under review.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1993
References
Busek, Erhard and Stourzh, Gerald, eds, Nationale Vielfalt und Gemeinsames Erbe in Mitteleuropa (Munich: Oldesbourg, 1990).Google Scholar
Graubard, Stephen R., ed., Eastern Europe … Central Europe … Europe (Boulder: Westview Press, 1991).Google Scholar
Hill, Ronald J. and Zielonka, Jan, eds, Restructuring Eastern Europe. Towards a New European Order (Aldershot: Edgar Elgar, 1990).Google Scholar
Kaminski, Bartolomiej, The Collapse of State Socialism. The Case of Poland (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1991).Google Scholar
Krejči, Jaroslav. Czechoslovakia at the Crossroads of European History (London/New York: Tauris, 1990).Google Scholar
Roskin, Michael G., The Rebirth of Eastern Europe (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1991).Google Scholar
Rothschild, Joseph, Return to Diversity. A Political History of East Central Europe since World War II (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989).Google Scholar
Skilling, H.Gordon ed., Czechoslovakia 1918–1988. Seventy Years from Independence (London: Macmillan, 1991).Google Scholar
1 On this see Werner Conze, ‘Ostmitteleuropa’. Von der Spätantike bis zum 18. Jahrhundert. Edited and with a postscript by Klaus Zernack (Munich, 1992).
2 Schlögel, Karl, Die Mitte liegt ostwärts. Die Deutschen, der verlorene Osten und Mitteleuropa (Berlin, 1986).Google Scholar Probably the best-known exponents and advocates of a Central European Renaissance are Vaclav Havel and György Konrad. From the mass of literature I recommend the following: Busek, E. and Wilfinger, G. eds, Aufbruch nach Mitteleuropa (Vienna, 1986);Google ScholarKonrad, György, Antipolitik. Mitteleuropäische Meditationen (Frankfurt a/M, 1985).Google Scholar A good survey of this topic can be found in Jaworski, Rudolf, ‘Die aktuelle Mitteleuropadiskussion in historischer Perspektive’, Historische Zeitschrift, Vol. 247 (1988), 529–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
3 Judt, Tony, ‘The Rediscovery of Central Europe’, in Graubard, Europe, 24.Google Scholar
4 Ibid., 26.
5 Timothy Garton Ash, ‘Mitteleuropa’, in ibid., 1–21.
6 See note 2.
7 Roskin, Rebirth, 7–8.
8 Schöpflin, George, ‘The Political Traditions of Eastern Europe’, in Graubard, Europe, 65.Google Scholar
9 See title 1.
10 Judt, ‘Rediscovery’, 43.
11 Hanák, Péter, ‘Der Garten und die Werkstatt. Wien und Budapest des fin de siècle im kulturgeschichtlichen Vergleich’, in Busek, and Stourzh, , Nationale Vielfait, 101–16.Google Scholar
12 Mirjana Gross, ‘Modernisierung und Rückständigkeit in Kroatien in der zweiten Hälfte des 19. Jahrhunderts’, in ibid., 93–100.
13 Wolfgang Häusler, ‘Das Judentum in der Habsburgermonarchie im Zeitalter von Toleranz, Emanzipation und Antisemitismus’ in ibid., 61–79.
14 Quoted by Kovtun, George, ‘T. G. Masaryk: The Problem of a Small Nation’, in Skilling, Czechoslovakia, 26.Google Scholar
15 Ibid., 26ff.
16 Ibid., 38–9.
17 Ullmann, Walter, ‘Beneš between East and West’, in Skilling, Czechoslovakia, 55–61.Google Scholar
18 Skilling H. Gordon ‘Lions or Foxes: Heroes or Lackeys?’, in ibid., 3–22. Although Skilling does not mention Jakob Burckhardt's Weltgeschichtliche Betrachtungen, his dichotomy is very reminiscent of the distinction between historical greatness (‘that which we are not’) and the great ‘ruiners’; with the difference, however, that all the persons in question who do not get the accolade ‘lion’ were not ‘ruiners’ but intriguing, devoted lackeys, who were not in a position to push through the reforms they themselves thought necessary against the Soviet rulers (see p. 20).
19 Ibid., 15.
20 Ibid.
21 Rothschild, Return, 10ff.; Jaworwski does not share this view, see note 2.
22 Roskin, , Rebirth, 36.Google Scholar
23 Ibid., 35.
24 Krejči, Czechoslovakia, 168.
25 Rothschild, , Return, 8.Google Scholar
26 Ibid., 10.
27 Ibid., 74.
28 Ibid., 77.
29 Ibid., 78.
30 Ibid., 122–3.
31 See Krejči, Czechoslovakia, Kaminski, Collapse, and Skilling, Czechoslovakia. Krejči reviews the longest period of time, dealing with over 1100 years of Czech and Slovak history, beginning with Christianisation in the ninth century, through the religious wars of the fifteenth, sixteenth and seventeenth centuries to the recreation of national consciousness, which culminated in independence, but was then thrown between communism and national socialism before the ‘rebirth’ and ‘gentle revolution’ of the 1980s.
32 Krejči, , Czechoslovakia, 171.Google Scholar
33 Ibid., 175.
34 Ibid., 179.
35 An incidental remark: the conference from which this volume came luckily fell on precisely those days, namely 28 and 30 October, when the new Czech Republic came into existence.
36 Barnard, Frederick M., ‘Political culture: Continuity and Discontinuity’, in Skilling, Czechoslovakia, 133–53.Google Scholar
37 Kaminski, , Collapse, 133.Google Scholar
38 Ibid., 161.
39 Walker, Rachel, ‘The Relevance of Ideology’, in Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 76–93.Google Scholar
40 Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 5–6.Google Scholar
41 Kaminski, , Collapse, 5–6.Google Scholar
42 Walker, ‘Relevance’, 76.
43 Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 10.Google Scholar
44 Judt, ‘Rediscovery’, 30 and 35.
45 Kaminski, , Collapse, 43.Google Scholar
46 Ibid., 112–13.
47 Hill, Ronald J., ‘The Institutionalization of Reform’, in Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 21.Google Scholar
48 Ibid., 26–9.
49 Ibid., 30–1.
50 Zielonka, Jan, ‘The Assertion of Democratic Movements’, in Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 43–58.Google Scholar
51 Zielonka, ‘Assertion’, 44.
52 Jacek Kuron, ‘Instead of Revolution’, Eastern European Reporter (Spring–Summer 1989); quoted in Zielonka, ‘Assertion’, 45.
53 Havel, Vaclav in Radio Free Europe Research, Vol. 2 (Aug. 1989), quoted in Zielonka, ‘Assertion’, 45.Google Scholar
54 Ibid., 45–6 and 50.
55 Ibid., 48.
56 Ibid., 51.
57 Hill, ‘Institutionalization’, 33–4 and 36–7.
58 Zielonka sees this as the greatest challenge for the democrats in 1890s. See ‘Assertion’, 53.
59 An exemplary study of this problem is Jozef Skala and Christoph Kunkel, ‘Auf dem Weg zu einem konsolidierten Parteiensystem? Die Parteienentwicklung in der Tsechoslovakie nach der Revolution von 1989’, in Beyme, Klaus von, ed., Demokratisierung und Parteiensysteme in Osteuropa. Geschichte und Gesellschaft, Vol. 18 (1992), 292–310.Google Scholar
60 Pomian, Krzystof, ‘Religion and Politics in a Time of Glasnost’, in Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 113–28.Google Scholar
61 Kristian Gerner and Kerstin Nyström, ‘Nationalist Challenges to State Integrity’, in ibid., 129–46.
62 Baehr Peter R., ‘Human Rights: A Change in Performance’, in ibid., 185–202.
63 Pomian, ‘Religion’, 115ff.
64 Gerner and Nyström, ‘Challenges’, 131.
65 Rothschild, , Return, 223.Google Scholar
66 Baehr, , ‘Human Rights’, 188ff. and 192ff.Google Scholar
67 Ibid., 198.
68 Garton Ash, ‘Mitteleuropa’, 7 and 11.
69 Jahn, Egbert, ‘The Future of Europe, Eastern Europe and Central Europe’, in Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 201–18.Google Scholar One problem with this essay is that it is not up-to-date, though the author cannot be blamed for this, given the speed with which things are changing in Eastern Europe.
70 Ibid., 216.
71 Godfried, van Benthem van den Bergh, ‘The Changing Meaning of Security in Europe’, in Hill, and Zielonka, , Restructuring, 147.Google Scholar
72 Ibid., 162.
73 Ibid., 166.
74 Rupnik, Jacques, ‘Central Europe or Mitteleuropa?’, in Graubard, Europe, 233–65.Google Scholar
76 Rupnik, , ‘Central Europe’, 259.Google Scholar
77 Ibid., 265.