Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-qs9v7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-14T18:51:43.290Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Ownership of mines and taxation in Castilian laws, from the middle ages to the early modern period: the decisive influence of the sovereign in the history of mining

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 April 2011

JEANNETTE GRAULAU
JEANNETTE GRAULAU
Affiliation:
The City University of New York, Herbert H. Lehman College, Department of Political Science.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Sovereign ownership of mines and taxation were fundamental principles governing the mining economy of the territories of the Castilian crown during the medieval period. Ownership of mines meant that mineral wealth, discovered or undiscovered, belonged to the crown estate. Only the sovereign could grant mining rights to ‘private’ persons and impose mineral taxation. Particularly during the last three centuries of the Reconquista (thirteenth to fifteenth centuries), these principles were used to unify the situation in those territories falling under the sway of a sovereign with expansionist ambitions. Increasing globalisation of the metal trade in the thirteenth century and the formation of capital markets in Europe firmly put the Castilian crown in competition with other economic agents aiming to win a monopoly in metallic wealth. Castile's mining laws aspired to solve the ensuing tension by attracting merchant capital to the mines, aiming to absorb the comparative advantages of mining capital. In a protracted process, the mineral laws of the sixteenth century were a testimony to the decisive influence of the sovereign in the history of mining.

Mines et taxes selon la législation castillane en vigueur du moyen age à l'époque moderne: l'influence décisive de la propriété royale pour l'histoire minière

Sur les terres du roi de Castille, au Moyen Age, les mines appartenaient à la Couronne, autant que les impôts levés. Ces principes régissaient toute l'économie minière. Posséder les mines signifiait que l'Etat royal avait la richesse minière, quelle soit connue ou encore non découverte. Seul le souverain avait le pouvoir d'attribuer un privilège d'exploitation à des personnes „privées“ puis d'exiger le paiement d'impôts sur l'activité minière. Pendant les trois derniers siècles de la Reconquête (XIIIe-XVe siècles) ces principes servirent d'arguments unificateurs pour justifier la domination d'un souverain à l'expansionnisme ambitieux sur les territoires alors concernés. La globalisation croissante du commerce métallique au cours du XIIIe siècle, alliée, en Europe, à la formation de marchés capitalistes, plaça la Couronne de Castille en compétition avec des agents économiques susceptibles de prendre le monopole de richesses minières. Aboutissement d'un très long processus, la législation minière du XVIe siècle témoigne de l'influence décisive du souverain sur l'histoire minière.

Bergwerksbesitz und besteuerung im kastilischen recht im mittelalter und zu beginn der frühen neuzeit: der entscheidende einfluss der krone in der bergwerksgeschichte

Der Bergbau in den Territorien der kastilischen Krone wurde im Mittelalter durch die grundlegenden Prinzipien der königlichen Vorrechte (Regalien) auf Bergbaubesitz und Besteuerung bestimmt. Nach dem Bergregal gehörten alle Erzvorkommen, ob bereits entdeckt oder nicht, zum Krongut. Nur der König konnte Schürf- und Abbaurechte an „Privatpersonen“ verleihen oder Steuern auf Erze und Mineralien erheben. Besonders in den drei letzten Jahrhunderten der Reconquista (13. bis 15. Jahrhundert) wurden diese Prinzipien dazu benutzt, um in den Territorien, die nun in den Einflussbereich eines expansionistisch ambitionierten Herrscherhauses gerieten, die innere Einheit voranzutreiben. Die zunehmende Globalisierung des Metallhandels im 13. Jahrhundert und die Herausbildung eines europäischen Kapitalmarktes brachten die kastilische Krone in scharfe Konkurrenz zu anderen Akteuren, die auf ein Monopol der Metallvorkommen aus waren. Die kastilischen Bergbaugesetze zielten darauf ab, die daraus erwachsenden Spannungen dadurch zu lösen, dass man Handelskapital in den Bergbau lockte, um so die komparativen Vorteile des Bergbaukapitals einzustreichen. Den Endpunkt dieses langwierigen Prozesses bildeten die Bergbaugesetze des 16. Jahrhunderts, die den entscheidenden Einfluss der Krone auf die Bergbaugeschichte bezeugen.

Type
Research Article
Information
Continuity and Change , Volume 26 , Issue 1 , May 2011 , pp. 13 - 44
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ENDNOTES

1 F. X. Gamboa, Comentarios a las ordenanzas de minas dedicados al catholico rey (Madrid, 1761), Prólogo. Gamboa echoes the dictum of priest José De Acosta, ‘Aʃsi que aunque el mundo nuevo ya no es nuevo viejo’. J. De Acosta, Historia natural y moral de las Indias, ed. 1590 (San Lorenzo, 1589), 6.

2 For a history of the mines of the Spanish Empire, see Joaquín García Icazbalceta, Relaciones geográficas de México y Guatemala 1577–1585, Benson Latin American Collection, General Libraries (University of Texas at Austin); Joaquín García Icazbalceta, Descripción de las minas de Pachuca de 1868, Benson Latin American Collection, General Libraries (University of Texas at Austin); De Acosta, Historia natural y moral; A. De Alcedo, Diccionario geográfico-histórico de las Indias Occidentales ó América (Madrid, 1788); C. B. Dahlgren, Minas históricas de la República Mexicana (México, 1887); E. Guajardo e Hijos, Informe provisional de minas de oro en Sonora, México (Chihuahua, México, 1900–1901). Useful secondary sources include the following: R. Acuña ed., Relaciones geográficas del siglo XVI, 10 vols. (México, D. F., 1980–); Eguía, G. Arduz, ‘Sobre la metalurgia colonial de la plata en Potosí’, Historia y Cultura (Bolivia) 24 (1997), 103–34Google Scholar; J. Burkart, Memoria sobre la explotación de minas en los distritos de Pachuca y Real del Monte (Pachuca, 1989); A. C. Craig and R. C. West, In quest of mineral wealth: aboriginal and colonial mining and metallurgy in Spanish America (Baton Rouge, 1994); M. Jiménez De La Espada, comp., Relaciones geográficas de Indias, 3 vols. Biblioteca de autores españoles (Madrid, 1965); J. R. Páez, Las minas de Zamora cuentas de la Real Hacienda 1561–1565 (Quito, 1957); S. A. Rivera et al., Historia de la minería en el Perú (Lima, 1999); E. Sluiter, The gold and silver of Spanish America (Berkeley, 1998).

3 Treatises on mining laws include the following: G. Escalona y Agüero, Gazophilatium Regium Peruvicum (Madrid, 1675); R. De La Fuente, Legislación de minas del Perú (Lima, 1887); Gamboa, Comentarios a las ordenanzas de minas; S. Sandoval y Guzmán, Pretensiones de la Villa Imperial de Potosí propuestas en el Real Consejo de las Indias (Madrid, 1634), Benson Latin American Collection, General Libraries (University of Texas at Austin). The English translation used here is H. W. Halleck, A collection of mining laws of Spain and Mexico, ed. University of Michigan Reprint Series (San Francisco, 1859).

4 C. S. Osbron, The iron hunter (New York, 1919), 244.

5 I. Blanchard, The international economy in the ‘age of discoveries’, Antwerp and the English merchants' world (Stuttgart, 2009), especially 217–49; Mining, metallurgy and minting in the Middle Ages: vol. 2, Afro-European supremacy, 1125–1225 (African gold production and the first European silver production cycle) (Stuttgart, 2001); ‘Labour productivity and work psychology in the English mining industry, 1400–1600’, Economic History Review 31, 1 (1978), 1–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar; J. Hatcher, English tin production and trade before 1550 (Oxford, 1973).

6 Georgius Agricola, De Re Metallica, trans. H. C. Hoover and L. H. Hoover (New York, 1950); also for mining laws in central Germanic lands, see H. Boyce, The mines of the Upper Harz from 1514–1589 (Chicago, 1920); for modern-day Hungary and Slovakia, see P. Kalus, Die Fugger in der Slowakei (Ausgburg, 1999).

7 M. Lombard, The golden age of Islam (Princeton, 2004); L. P. Harvey, Islamic Spain, 1250–1500, trans. J. Spencer (Chicago, 1992).

8 A. Aiton, S., ‘The first American mining code’, Michigan Law Review 23, 2 (1924), 105–113CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cabrero, J. L. Bermejo, ‘Juntas y Superintendencias de Minas’, Anuario de Historia del Derecho Español (hereafter AHDE) 71, 1 (2001), 75–121Google Scholar; M. D. R. González Domínguez, Las ordenanzas de minería de la Nueva España formadas y propuestas por su Real Tribunal (México, 1996); Hanke, L., ‘Viceroy Francisco de Toledo and the just titles of Spain to the Inca empire’, The Americas 3, 1 (1946), 3–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar; L. Hanke and C. Rodríguez eds., Biblioteca de autores españoles. Los virreyes españoles en América durante el gobierno de la Casa de Austria, México, 5 vols. (Madrid, 1978); L. Hanke and C. Rodríguez eds., Biblioteca de autores españoles. Los virreyes españoles en América durante el gobierno de la Casa de Austria, Perú, 6 vols. (Madrid, 1978–1980); M. F. Lang, El monopolio estatal del mercurio en el México colonial (1550–1710) (México, D. F., 1977); G. Lohmann Villena, Las relaciones de los virreyes del Perú (Madrid, 1959); J. D. Pastor y Rodríguez and M. D. Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos mineros en España (Madrid, 1878); S. Ramírez, La propiedad de las minas, estudio minero-legal (México, 1883); C. Ruigómez Gómez, ‘Las ordenanzas del Nuevo Cuaderno (1584) sobre minería y su vigencia en América’, in D. Ramos Pérez, comp., Castilla y León en América, vol. II (Valladolid, 1991), 181–203; J. Solórzano y Pereyra, Política indiana, Corregido y aumentado por Francisco Ramiro de Valenzuela, 5 vols. (Madrid, 1972); J. Velázquez de León, Notas a las nuevas ordenanzas de minas, puestas para su mejor inteligencia (México, 1875).

9 Cora, A. Álvarez, ‘La naturaleza jurídica de la ley hispanorromana’, AHDE 73 (2003), 497–536Google Scholar; Martínez, J. M. Blázquez, ‘Administración de las minas en época romana, su evolución’, Minería y metalurgia en las antiguas civilizaciones mediterráneas y europeas, vol. II (Madrid, 1989), 119–31Google Scholar; ‘Fuentes literarias griegas y romanas referentes a las explotaciones mineras de la Hispania romana’, in La minería hispana e iberoamericana: contribución a su investigación histórica (León, España, 1970), 117–50; Gamboa, Comentarios a las ordenanzas de minas.

10 H. Kamen, Empire, how Spain became a world power 1492–1763 (New York, 2003).

11 S. Gandarias, Aguirre, ‘Relaciones internacionales de Bizkaia con la Europa Atlántica medieval’, Revista Internacional de los Estudios Vascos, Riev XXXVI, 2 (1991), 339–63Google Scholar; E. Rodríguez, Guinot, ‘Fronteras exteriores e interiores en la creación de un reino medieval: Valencia en el siglo XIII’, Studia Historica 24 (2006), 127–53Google Scholar.

12 Manuel García Pelayo, in J. A. Maravall, Estado moderno y mentalidad social, siglos XV al XVII, 2 vols. (Madrid, 1972), vol. I, 332. J. A. Maravall, Carlos V y el pensamiento político del Renacimiento (Madrid, 1999).

13 For Francisco de Vitoria, the dominio existed in two forms: property and civil power. Both, based upon private property, coexisted in perfect harmony for the well-being of the human community and the life of the Republic. A. García Gallo, ‘La Universidad de Salamanca en la formación del Derecho Indiano’, in III Congreso del Instituto Internacional de Historia del Derecho Indiano (Madrid, 1973).

14 Bertelli, S., ‘«Religio Regis» La propaganda del poder real’, Medievalismo, Boletín de la Sociedad Española de Estudios Medievales 8 (1958), 9–17Google Scholar; M. J. Bosch, Bravo, ‘Derecho privado y derecho público en relación con los yacimientos mineros de Gallaecia’, Revista General de Derecho Romano 11 (2008), 1–28Google Scholar; V. Carro, La teología y los teólogos juristas españoles ante la conquista de América (Madrid, 1944); R. J. Fernández De Morales, Marcos, ‘Alfonso X el Sabio, candidato al Sacro Imperio Romano Germánico, y la proyección europea de las Siete Partidas’, Revista General de Derecho Romano 11 (2008), 1–13Google Scholar; A. García-Gallo, , ‘La ciencia jurídica en la formación del derecho hispano-americano en los siglos XVI al XVIII’, AHDE 44 (1974), 157–200Google Scholar; ‘El Libro de las Leyes de Alfonso el Sabio’, AHDE 21–22 (1951–52), 345–528Google Scholar; Martínez, J. G. Martínez, ‘«Historia del derecho en América Hispana» (Una reflexión hecha en y desde las tierras del Nuevo Mundo)’, Anuario de la Facultad de Derecho XXI (2003), 503–17Google Scholar; I. J. A. Del Río and I. M. De Rodríguez, El ordenamiento de leyes que D. Alfonso XI hizo en las Cortes de Alcalá de Henares (1774), 2009 edn (Illinois, 2009).

15 Edmondson, J. C., ‘Mining in the later Roman empire and beyond: continuity or disruption?’, Journal of Roman Studies 79 (1989), 84–102CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Pastor y Rodríguez and Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos, 13–14.

16 S. Keay, Roman Spain (Berkeley, 1988).

17 R. Castejón Calderón, Los juristas hispano-musulmanes (Desde la conquista hasta la caída del califato de Córdoba años 711 a 1031) (Madrid, 1948); Edmondson, ‘Mining in the later Roman Empire’.

18 I. Blanchard, A. Goodman, J. Newman eds., Industry and finance in early modern history (Stuttgart, 1992); F. Braudel, The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean world in the age of Philip II, vol. I, trans. S. Reynolds (Berkeley, 1992); R. Carande, Carlos V y sus banqueros (Madrid, 1945); P. E. Chevedden, D. J. Kagay and P. G. Padilla, Iberia and the Mediterranean world of the Middle Ages, vol. II (Leiden, 1996); R. Ehrenberg, Capital & finance in the age of the Renaissance, a study of the Fuggers and their connections (New York, 1923); H. Kellenbenz, Precious metals in the age of expansion (Stuttgart, 1981); The rise of the European economy (New York, 1976); L. J. Simon ed., Iberia and the Mediterranean world of the Middle Ages, vol. I (Leiden, 1995).

19 Del Río and De Rodríguez, El ordenamiento de leyes, 462.

20 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 1.

21 Pastor y Rodríguez and Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos; A. Matilla Tascón, Historia de las minas de Almadén, vol. I, Desde la época romana hasta el año 1645 (Madrid, 1958), 12–13.

22 Del Río and De Rodríguez, El ordenamiento de leyes.

23 Ruigómez Gómez, ‘Las ordenanzas’.

24 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 5. The law appeared as Law no. 8 in the Ordenanzas Reales de Castilla promulgated by Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand in 1484. Ruigómez Gómez, ‘Las ordenanzas’, 186–7.

25 Davis, G., ‘The incipient sentiment of nationality in mediæval Castile: the patrimonio real’, Speculum 12, 3 (1937), 351–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar; F. D. Palacios, Z., ‘Mutaciones monetarias y propuesta de reorganización del mercado monetario en el segundo tercio del siglo XV’, Aragón en la Edad Media 19 (2006), 599–616Google Scholar; B. F. Reilly, The contest of Christian and Muslim Spain (London, 1996); M. Martínez, Sánchez, ‘El reino de Aragón y los conflictos mediterráneos a mediados del siglo XIV (1353–1356)’, Aragón en la Edad Media 19 (2006), 485–500Google Scholar; M. E. Schaffer and A. Cortijo Ocaña eds, Medieval and Renaissance Spain and Portugal: studies in honor of Arthur L. F. Askins (London, 2006).

26 F. S. Lajusticia, Rodríguez, ‘Aragoneses con propiedades en el reino de Valencia en época de Jaime I según los Registros de Cancillería’, Aragón en la Edad Media 20 (2008), 677–90Google Scholar.

27 Ferrer i Mallol, M., ‘El endeudamiento de la aljama islámica de Zaragoza a fines del siglo XIV’, Aragón en la Edad Media 19 (2006), 173–80Google Scholar; J. Ray, The Sephardic frontier: the Reconquista and the Jewish community in medieval Iberia (Ithaca, New York, 2006); Sánchez Martínez, ‘El reino de Aragón’.

28 Estow, C., ‘The economic development of the Order of Calatrava, 1158–1366’, Speculum 57, 2 (1982), 267–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar, especially 269.

29 Matilla Tascón, Historia de las minas de Almadén; D. J. Kagay and T. M. Vann, On the social origins of medieval institutions: essays in honor of Joseph F. O'Callaghan (Leiden, 1998); P. Spufford, The merchant in medieval Europe (London, 2002).

30 Spufford, The merchant in medieval Europe; R. S. Lopez, The commercial revolution of the Middle Ages, 950–1350 (Cambridge, 1995).

31 F. Larráyoz, Serrano, ‘Item perrexil, mostarda, lechugas et rauanos. Notas sobre la alimentación de mineros alemanes en Pamplona a finales del siglo XIV (1392)’, Anuario de Estudios Medievales 38, 1 (2008), 235–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 M. C. Herrero, García, ‘Doña Xemçi de Taher y la venta de hierro en Daroca (1311–1314)’, Aragón en la Edad Media XX (2008), 361–71Google Scholar.

33 A. Del Mar, Money and civilization (London, 1886); Bru, Pellicer I., ‘La “quiebra del maravedí de oro” finalizando el reinado de Fernando III (1217–1230/1252)’, Documenta e Instrumenta 6 (2008), 227–48Google Scholar.

34 García Herrero, ‘Doña Xemçi de Taher’.

35 R. D. Fernández, Capitulaciones colombinas (1492–1506) (Michoacán, México, 1987).

36 Fernández, Capitulaciones colombinas, 172.

37 González Domínguez, Las ordenanzas, 22–3.

38 H. G. Nutini, The wages of conquest: the Mexican aristocracy in the context of Western aristocracies (Michigan, 1995), 149.

39 Fernández, Capitulaciones colombinas.

40 Bodian, M., ‘In the cross-currents of the Reformation: Crypto–Jewish martyrs of the Inquisition, 1570–1670’, Past and Present 176 (2002), 66–104CrossRefGoogle Scholar; J. B. Chapa, Texas and Northeastern Mexico, 1630–1690, by Juan Bautista Chapa, introd. W. C. Foster, transl. N. Brierly (Austin, Texas, ed. 1997); A. Toro, La familia Carvajal: estudio histórico sobre los judíos y la Inquisición de la Nueva España en el siglo XVI (México, 1944).

41 González Domínguez, Las ordenanzas, 24–5.

42 Del Río and De Rodríguez, El ordenamiento de leyes.

43 Matilla Tascón, Las minas de Almadén.

44 Azogue refers to mercury or quicksilver. Vermilion or cinnabar is the most common ore of mercury. Matilla Tascón, Historia de las minas de Almadén, 23.

45 Craig and West, In quest of mineral wealth.

46 Solórzano y Pereyra, Política indiana, vol. IV, 216.

47 Pastor y Rodríguez and Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos, 31.

48 Halleck, A collection of mining laws.

49 Pastor y Rodríguez and Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos.

50 Hernán Cortés, Letters from México, trans. A. H. Pagden (New Haven, 1986).

51 H. Keniston, Francisco de los Cobos. Secretary of the Emperor Charles V (Pittsburgh, 1960), 16–49.

52 Pastor y Rodríguez and Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos.

53 P. J. Bakewell, Silver and entrepreneurship in seventeenth-century Potosí: the life and times of Antonio López De Quiroga (New Mexico, 1988); Keniston, Francisco de los Cobos; L. Navarro García, América en el siglo XVIII, los primeros Borbones (Madrid, 1989).

54 The law established that if the mines yielded more than 1½ mark per quintal of lead-silver, but less than 4 marks, the payment owed to the crown was one-fifth part of the silver, without deducting expenses. If the mines yielded more than 4 marks per quintal of lead-silver but less than 6 marks, one-quarter part of the silver had to be paid, without deduction of expenses. For the mines that yielded more than 6 marks per quintal of lead-silver, regardless of quality, half of the silver extracted had to be paid, without deduction of expenses. For gold mines, the 1584 ordinances established that half of the gold extracted had to be paid, without deduction of expenses. Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 71–2. Other taxes were imposed for the silver extracted from the terreros (rubbish) and slag of abandoned mines.

55 The one-tenth applied for a period of 10 years from 22 December 1611. Immediately, a controversy started in Peru and La Plata. The guild of miners claimed that the new tax overruled the one-fifth tax. Miners claimed that the policy of the one-tenth tax had to apply to all mines in operation prior to 22 December 1611. Hanke and Rodríguez, Los virreyes españoles, México; Martínez Martínez, ‘Historia del Derecho en América Hispana’; Sandoval y Guzmán, Pretensiones. Among the most influential groups of miners in Spanish America was the guild of azogueros (mercury producers) of Peru. Legally, they were entitled to a special protection by the crown. In 1572, Philip II established a law favouring miners and azogueros with ‘all the privileges (preeminencias) granted by the Kings, our ancestors, and by us, as having in every respect the force of law; and especially that, for no debts of whatsoever nature they may be, if not due to us, may or shall any execution be issued against the slaves and negroes, the tools, provisions, and other things necessary for the supply, working and provision of the Mines, and the persons who work in them’. Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 141.

56 Halleck, A collection of mining laws.

57 Pastor y Rodríguez and Pastor y Rodríguez, Historia de los impuestos.

58 Halleck, A collection of mining laws.

59 Cañeque, A., ‘Cultura vicerregia y Estado colonial. Una aproximación crítica al estudio de la historia política de la Nueva España’, Historia Mexicana 51, 1 (2001), 5–57Google Scholar; Miranda, J., ‘La población indígena de México en el siglo XVII’, Historia Mexicana 12, 2 (1962), 182–9Google Scholar; R. Patch, W., ‘Imperial politics and local economy in colonial Central America 1670–1770’, Past & Present 143, 2 (1994), 77–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 J. P. Rodríguez, The historical encyclopedia of world slavery (Santa Barbara, 1997), 437. J. A. Cole, The Potosí mita, 1573–1700 (Santa Barbara, 1985); D. J. Robinson, Migration in colonial Spanish America (Cambridge, 1990).

61 G. Lamana, Domination without dominance, Inca-Spanish encounters in early colonial Peru (Durham, NC, 2008).

62 Aiton, ‘The first American mining code’; D. A. Brading and H. E. Cross, ‘Colonial silver mining: Mexico and Peru’, in M. Adas ed., An expanding world: the European impact on world history, 1450–1800 (London, 1996), 227–61; Craig and West, In quest of mineral wealth; González Domínguez, Las ordenanzas; Hanke, ‘Viceroy Francisco de Toledo’; Hanke and Rodríguez, Los virreyes españoles, Perú; Francisco de Toledo, Disposiciones gubernativas para el virreinato del Perú, 2 vols., trans. M. J. Sarabia Viejo, intro. G. Lohmann Villena (Sevilla, 1989); Solórzano y Pereyra, Política indiana, vol. I.

63 C. Álvarez Nogal, Los banqueros de Felipe IV y los metales preciosos americanos (Madrid, 1997); Carande, Carlos V; A. Domínguez Ortíz, Política y hacienda de Felipe IV (Madrid, 1960); Kellenbenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal.

64 J. Cervera Pery, La Casa de Contratación y el Consejo de Indias: las razones de un superministerio (Madrid, 1997); G. De Carlos Boutet, coord., España y América, un océano de negocios: quinto centenario de la Casa de la Contratación, 1503–2003 (Madrid, 2003); F. J. González, Díaz, ‘Las competencias inspectoras y judiciales de la Casa de la Contratación hasta el reinado de Felipe II’, Estudios de Historia Social y Económica de América 14 (1997), 59–74Google Scholar; M. M. Guerrero, León, ‘La Casa de la Contratación: precedentes inmediatos’, Revista de Humanidades (Tecnológico de Monterrey) 15 (2003), 163–86Google Scholar.

65 Kalus, Die Fugger in der Slowakei; P. Kriedte, Feudalismo tardío y capital mercantil (Barcelona, 1994); J. Nef, U., ‘Silver production in central Europe, 1450–1618’, Journal of Political Economy 49, 4 (1941), 575–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 10. The mines of Guadalcanal were discovered in 1555, and immediately were negotiated as part of an asiento with the Fugger. Kellenbenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal.

67 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 11.

68 Kamen, Empire; Kamen, Golden age.

69 E. J. Hamilton, American treasure and the price revolution in Spain (Cambridge, 1934); ‘Imports of American gold and silver into Spain, 1503–1660’, Quarterly Journal of Economics 43 (1929), 436–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Haring, C., ‘American gold and silver production in the first half of the sixteenth century’, Quarterly Journal of Economics 29, 3 (1915), 433–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Montero, A. E., ‘Oro, plata y mercurio, nervios de la monarquía española’, Revista de Historia Económica 19, 3 (2001), 507–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar; R. Pieper, ‘The volume of African and American exports of precious metals and its effects in Europe, 1500–1800’, in H. Pohl ed., The European discovery of the world and its economic effects on pre-industrial society, 1500–1800 (Stuttgart, 1990).

70 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 17–18.

71 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 99.

72 Halleck, A collection of mining laws, 40. Mining, however, naturally resisted accounting requirements. The first pressing problem of accounting was how to account for extracted ores (versus refined ores), particularly in mines where ‘ore recyclers’ slowly penetrated and invaded the sites of processed and discarded ores. This problem haunted the sovereign crown and its inspectors in the mines of Almadén and Idria. The second pressing problem was one of bureaucratic order: how to deal with the book accounts written in a foreign language by foreign merchants when the accounts were handed over for royal inspection? This was the case of Mateo Alemán, inspecting the book accounts of the Fugger for the mines of Almadén. G. Bleiberg, El «Informe Secreto» de Mateo Alemán sobre el trabajo forzoso en las minas de Almadén (London, 1985); Lang, El monopolio; Matilla Tascón, Las minas de Almadén; H. Valentinitsch, ‘Die Versorgung des Bergwerks Idrija (Idria) mit Gefäßen für die Quecksilbergewinnung 1490–1750’, in E. Westermann, ed., Bergbaureviere als Verbrauchszentren im vorindustriellen Europa (Stuttgart, 1977), 21–32.

73 Álvarez Nogal, Los banqueros de Felipe IV.

74 Flynn and Giráldez propose that demand for silver of the Ming dynasty and its stimulus for global trade during the period 1550–1650 absorbed most of the American silver. D. O. Flynn, ‘Comparing the Tokugawa Shogunate with Hapsburg Spain: two silver-based empires in a global setting’, in James D. Tracy ed., The political economy of merchant empires (Cambridge, 1991), 332–59; D. Flynn, O. and Giráldez, A., ‘Born with a “silver spoon”: the origin of world trade in 1571’, Journal of World History 6, 2 (1995), 201–21Google Scholar; D. Flynn, O. and Giráldez, A., ‘China and the Spanish Empire’, Revista de Historia Económica 14, 2 (1996), 309–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

75 Pieper and Lesiak, ‘Redes mercantiles’.

76 P. T. Bakewell, Miners of the Red Mountain: Indian Labor in Potosí, 1545–1650 (Albuquerque, New Mexico, 1984); D. A. Brading and H. E. Cross, ‘Colonial silver mining: Mexico and Peru’, in M. Adas ed., Technology and European overseas enterprise: diffusion, adaptation and adoption (London, 1996), 227–61; S. E. Domínguez, Cruz, ‘Sistemas de trabajo en las minas de Pachuca, siglos XVI-XVIII’, Contribuciones desde Coatepec V, 9 (2005), 33–67Google Scholar; R. Estrada Carrión, Zacualpán, primer Real de Minas: ensayo histórico sobre Zacualpán de Cohuixco y el Real de Minas de Zacualpán (México, 1995); R. Himmerich y Valencia, The encomenderos of New Spain 1521–1555 (Austin, 1991).

77 A good example is the regulation established by the government of Montesclaros in Peru for the transport and deliveries of silver from Arica, Potosí and Oruro to Callao. From this port in Peru, silver travelled to the port of Tierra Firme in Panamá, en route to Seville through the Bahamas channel. Ships had to be in Havana before the end of the summer to avoid the hurricane season. This timetable imposed by nature required tremendous mobilisation of local and regional transportation corridors, enforced by the law. A royal letter (cédula) dated 30 December 1607 imposed the calendar for deliveries of silver. The central nervous system, as Latasa Vassallo puts it, of this transportation timetable was similar to that for the deliveries of mercury from Huancavelica, to the mining towns of Peru. I. González Tascón, D. Romero Muñoz and A. Sáenz Sanz, ‘Los caminos del mercurio de Almadén a Nueva España’, in Actas del II Congreso internacional de caminería hispánica, tomo III (Madrid, 1994), 683–92; P. Latasa Vassallo, ‘El transporte de plata en el Atlántico: conflicto entre los intereses peruanos y metropolitanos’, in J. A. Armillas Vicente ed., VII Congreso internacional de historia de América, la economía marítima de la pesca, navegación y comercio, vol. III (Aragón, 1996), 1567–81.

78 J. L. Cabrero, Bermejo, ‘Juntas y superintendencias de minas’, AHDE 71 (2001), 75–122Google Scholar; Gamboa, Comentarios a las ordenanzas; Halleck, A collection of mining laws; Kellenbenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal.

79 Boyce, The mines of the Upper Harz.

80 Spufford, The merchant in medieval Europe.

81 J. Rodríguez Carracido, Los metalúrgicos españoles en América (Madrid, 1892).

82 Braunstein, P., ‘Innovations in mining and metal production in Europe in the late Middle Ages’, Journal of European Economic History 12, 3 (1983), 573–91Google Scholar; Agricola, De Re Metallica; P. Long, O., ‘The openness of knowledge: an ideal and its context in 16th-century writings on mining and metallurgy’, Technology and Culture 32, 2 (1991), 318–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar; W. B. Parsons, Engineers and engineering in the Renaissance (London, 1939), especially 177–220; V. Vázquez Prada, De, ‘La coyuntura de la minería y de la metalurgia europeas (siglos XIII–XVIII)’, Revista de Historia Económica VI, 2 (1988), 257–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

83 Graulau, J., ‘Finance, industry and globalisation in the early modern period: the example of the metallic business of the House of the Fugger’, Rivista di Studi Politici Internazionali LXXV, 300 (2008), 554–598Google Scholar; Kalus, Die Fugger in der Slowakei; Kellenbenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal.

84 Kellenbenz, Precious metals in the age of expansion; P. Vilar, Historia de España (Barcelona, 1978).

85 Graulau, ‘Finance, industry and globalisation’; Kellenbenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal; Mastilla Tascón, Las minas de Almadén.

86 V. D. Carro, La teología y los teólogos-juristas españoles ante la conquista de América (Salamanca, 1951); J. Rickaby, Of God and his creatures: an annotated translation of the Summa contra gentiles of St. Thomas Aquinas (Maryland, 1950).

87 A. Vauchez, B. Dobson and M. Lapidge eds., Encyclopedia of the Middle Ages (Cambridge, 2000), 845; M. Majo, Cuadrado, ‘Sobre la genesi medieval de l'Estat modern’, Acta Historia et Archaeologica Mediaevalia 10 (1989), 469–79Google Scholar; E. Lewis, Medieval political ideas, 2 vols. (New York, 1974); Maravall, Estado moderno y mentalidad social; W. Stark, Pre-capitalist economic thought: three modern interpretations (New York, 1972).

88 Boyce, The mines of the Upper Harz; Kalus, Die Fugger in der Slovakei; Lewis, A., ‘The closing of the mediaeval frontier, 1250–1350’, Speculum 33, 4 (1958), 475–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar; V. K. M. Müller, Unsere befestigten Städte des Mittelatters (Frankfurt am Main, 1987).

89 Vázquez De Prada, ‘La coyuntura de la minería’.

90 P. Freedman, Images of the medieval peasant (Stanford, 1999).

91 Freedman, Images of the medieval peasant, 272; C. Allmand ed., The New Cambridge Medieval History, vol. II, c.1415–c.1500 (Cambridge, 1998); Fenoaltea, S., ‘The organization of serfdom in Eastern Europe: a comment’, Journal of Economic History 43, 3 (1983), 705–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Millward, R., ‘An economic analysis of the organization of serfdom in Eastern Europe’, Journal of Economic History 42, 3 (1982), 513–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar; S. Reynolds, Fiefs and vassals: the medieval evidence reinterpreted (Oxford, 2001).

92 J. Cardoso, L., ‘The history of economic thought in Spain and Portugal, a brief survey’, History of Political Economy 34 (2002), 137–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar; K. N. Chaudhuri, The trading world of Asia and the English East India Company 1660–1760 (Cambridge, 1978); S. Chaudhury and M. Morineau, Merchants, companies and trade: Europe and Asia in the early modern era (Cambridge, 1999); E. Florescano ed., Ensayos sobre el desarrollo económico de México y América Latina, 1500–1975 (México, 1979); Kamen, Empire; S. Medema and P. Boettke, The role of government in the history of economic thought (Durheim and London, 2005); Pagden, Lords of all the world; J. H. Parry, The Spanish seaborne empire (New York, 1966); The establishment of European hegemony, 1415–1715: trade and exploration in the age of the Renaissance (Berkeley, 1966); Sombart, W., ‘Economic theory and economic history’, Economic History Review 2, 1 (1929), 1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar; I. Wallerstein, The modern world-system: capitalist agriculture and the European world-economy in the sixteenth century (New York, 1974); E. R. Wolf, Europe and the people without history (Berkeley, 1982).

93 Solórzano y Pereyra, Política indiana, vol. III, 285.

94 Carande, Carlos V; Kellebenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal.

95 Carande, Carlos V; Ehrenberg, Capital & finance; Kamen, Philip of Spain; Kellenbenz, Los Fugger en España y Portugal. A useful spatial analysis of relations of trade and credit cities is R. Pieper, ‘Espacios y relaciones económicas en el Imperio de Carlos V’, in A. Otazu ed., Dinero y crédito (Siglos XVI al XIX), Actas del Primer Coloquio internacional de historia económica (Madrid-Villalba-Segovia, 1977), 549–60.

96 Ehrenberg, Capital & finance.

97 Cited in Carande, Carlos V, vol. I, 223.

98 Carande, Carlos V.

99 W. Sombart, The quintessence of capitalism, a study of the history and psychology of the modern business man, trans. M. Epstein (New York, 1967; 1st publ. 1915); M. Welborn, C., ‘An intellectual father of modern business’, Bulletin of the Business Historical Society 13, 2 (1939), 20–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

100 Sombart, The quintessence of capitalism, 29.

101 Flynn and Giráldez, ‘Born with a “silver spoon”’, 201.