No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Nature and History in the Greek Conception of the Cosmos
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 July 2024
Extract
Nature and history are for us two diametrically opposed possibilities of organization, knowledge, interpretation, and evaluation of the reality around us. Since the Renaissance, the world can no longer be thought of as a structured and coherent whole, and its meaning always remains partial. The world bears within it a duality which nothing can surmount: Nature and mind represent the two poles of a reality which Jean Mair described as early as the end of the fifteenth century as non facientia unum. The being of Nature consists henceforth in being an object of representation, of scientific knowledge, and of technical exploitation. The being of man consists in placing himself as subject opposite the world, which is conceived as an object essentially foreign to man, “mute” in what concerns his ultimate destination. Up to that time, man knew himself by referring to an “objective,” undiscussed world; existence could be constantly shaken by the deepest terrors, but it was not problematical : man knew his natural place in a world ordered by a sovereign reason. Now with the destruction of the theophanic universe, it was not only man's place in the world which became problematical but the very idea of the universe; the experience of the living totality of the world was progressively drained of its substance. The new “situation of man in the world” is that of a being savagely freed of everything, profoundly isolated in the midst of an infinitely open world in which the global has less and less meaning and in which it is no longer a question of participating in being but of doing and of having. Rimbaud's remark, “We are not in the world,” began to be true; incapable of finding his support in the universe, placing all his pride in seeking his truth within himself, man then turned to history to ask of it those answers which the former wisdom, the former Weltweisheit, or revelation could no longer give him. In the “ocean of Cartesian doubt” Vico saw history as the only firmum et mansurum to which man could lay claim. As the work of a freedom progressively creating its own content for itself, as a return to itself of the mind lost or “alienated” in matter, history was becoming the only humanly possible way of conceiving the “natural” place of man in the world, the sole encompassing (τɛρι∊χoν) totality still capable of serving as a horizon for his triumphant self-certainty, the only world still conceivable after the suppression of transcendency and the loss of presence. According to Marx’ profound observation, history had the mission, “once the thither side of truth had vanished, to establish the truth of the hither side.” To the “dead” or “hidden” God and to “mute” or inaudible Nature, man opposed this derisory fragment of time which he had succeeded in making his and from which he hoped to derive at once the truth of his being and the norm of his action.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 1959 Fédération Internationale des Sociétés de Philosophie / International Federation of Philosophical Societies (FISP)
References
1. Karl Marx, "Critique de la philosophie hégelienne du droit," in Die Frühschriften, ed. Kröner (I953), pp. 208-9; trans. H. J. Stenning, Selected Essays by Karl Marx (New York: International Publications, I946), p. I3.
2. In the second Meditation, trans. John Veitch (London: Dent, I9I2), p. 85.
3. Heraclitus Frag. 30 (Diels).
4. Plato Menexenus 236e; Sophocles Ajax 1. 293; etc.
5. Cf. Aeschylus Agamemnon I. 356: Nξϕλ, μ∈γλων κóσμων κεὰτρα. Trans. Her bert Weir Smith ("Loeb Classics" [New York: Putnam, I926]), II, 33: "… kindly Night, that has given us great glory for our possession."
6. Cf. Herodotus i. 65; Euripides Suppliant Maidens 245; Plato Laws 846d.
7. Whether a house or a body (Plato Gorgias 504a) or a city (Laws 734a, 74Ia).
8. Cf. the fundamental analyses of Plato in Gorgias 504d.
9. Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics II78b. 8, 22. Trans. H. Rackham ("Loeb Classics" [New York: Putnam, I926]), p. 623.
10. Ibid.
11. Aristotle Metaphysics I072b. I4, I6.
12. Nemea vi. I, I3.
13. Plato Phaedrus 249c.
14. Ibid. 247 c, d.
15. Cf. Plato Republic 433c ff.
16. Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics II77a. I2, II78a. 8.
17. Pindar loc. cit.
18. Aristotle Physics 265a.
19. Republic 500 c.
20. The classical definition of law; cf., e.g., Plato Laws 683b; Aristotle Politics I289B. 25; Nicomachean Ethics in fine.
21. Plato Philebus 26b.
22. Heraclitus Frag. 94.
23. Plato Philebus 26b.
24. Aeschylus Agamemnon 1. I77, trans. Smith, op. cit., II, I9.
25. Ibid. ll. I80-82.
26. Pato Timaeus 90a.
27. ὐηρλμν ϕρòνυμα: Libation Bearers 1. 595, trans. Smith, op. cit., II, 2I9; λμα χáρἰν: Antigone 1. 372.
28. Libation Bearers 11. 306-8.
29. Heraclitus Frag. 4I.
30. Gorgias 502 b. Cf. also Laws 8I7b, c.
31. Aechylus Suppliant Maidens 1. 95, trans. Smith, op. cit., II, II.
32. Frag. 2I3 (Schröder), trans. Lewis Richard Farnell (London: Macmillan & Co., 1930), PP. 347-48.
33. Purgatory xi. 85: "gran disio dell'eccellenza."
34. Isa. 2 : I2-I5.
35. Plato Republic 5I8c, 532c, 526e.
36. Aeschylus Agamemnon 1. II97. (cf. trans. Smith, op. cit., p. I03: "Deeds of sin, ancient in story.")
37. Parmenides 8. I3-I5.
38. Frag. I2, ll. I7 ff., trans. Ivan M. Linforth (Solon the Athenian [Berkeley: University of California Press, I9I9]), pp. I40-4I.
39. Metaphysics I075 a. I9.
40. Politics I292 a.
41. Aristotle Athenian Republic xxviii. 4: παρανιἰκα.
42. Plato Laws 70I c.
43. Aeschylus Eumenides 11. 5I6-24 and 696-99, trans. Smith, op. cit., II, 32I and 339.
44. Ajax 11. 669-77, trans. F. Storr ("Loeb Classics" [New York: Macmillan Co., 193]), II, 59.
45. Aeschylus Eumenides 11. 5 19-20: 2~VAOiPIEL QGO~/DOYELY iJ1ró O"TÉPEL
46. Heraclitus Frag. 1 4.
47. Pato Timaeus god.
48. Republic 500 c, d, trans. Paul Shorey ("Loeb Classics" [Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, I935]), II, 69.
49. Sophist 253 c, trans. Harold North Fowler ("Loeb Classics" [Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, I952]), II, 40I: "Have we unwittingly stumbled upon the science that belongs to free men and perhaps found the philosopher while we were looking for the sophist?"
50. G. W. F. Hegel, Philosophie der Weltgeschichte, ed. Georg Lasson (Leipzig: Meiner, I923), p. 544; trans. (from an earlier edition) J. Sibree (London: Bell, I890), p. 250.
51 Physics I99 a, trans. Philip H. Wicksteed ("Loeb Classics" [Cambridge, Mass.: Har vard University Press, I957]), I, I73.
52. Parts of Animals 639b. I6, 2I, trans. A. L. Peck ("Loeb Classics" [Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, I945]), p. 57.
53. Plato Laws 889 a, trans. B. Jowett (3d ed.; Oxford: Clarendon Press, I892), v, 273.
54. Ibid. 889 c, d.
55. Ibid.
56. Physics 222 b. I6, 26, trans. Wicksteed, op. cit., I, 4I5.
57. Plato Republic 537b.
58. Ibid. 62I c.
59. Aristotle Physics 222b.
60. For Plato cf. Republic 452a; for Hippias cf. Plato Protagoras 337c, d.
61. Republic 592 b, trans. Shorey, op. cit., II, 4I5 ff.
62. The City of God i. 35, trans. John Healey (London: Dent, I93I), I, 42-43.
63. W. Dilthey, Einleitung in die Geisteswissenschaften, trans. Louis Sauzin (Introduc tion a l'étude des sciences humaines [Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, I942], p. 274).
64. Persians 11. 654 ff., 767, 772.
65. I. 32. ϕθ ονερὀν καἰ ταραχωδη ς. Trans. George Rawlinson (New York: Tudor, I94I), p. II.
66. Dilthey, op. cit., pp. 273-74.
67. From the Dedication of his Seven Books against the Pagans, trans I. W. Raymond (New York: Columbia University Press, I936), p. 30: "… the burdens of war, the ravages of disease, the horrors of famine, of terrible earthquakes, extraordinary floods …"
68. Laws 677a.
69. Problems xviii. 3.
70. Meteorology i. 3.
71. "The supreme teaching." Cf. Plato Republic.
72. Timaeus 47 b, c, trans. R. G. Bury ("Loeb Classics" [New York: Putnam, I929]). VII, 107, 109.