Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-767nl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T03:00:08.317Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

WHO FIGHTS

Substitution, Commutation, and “Green Card Troops”1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 January 2008

Cara Wong
Cara Wong*
Affiliation:
Department of Political Science, University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana
*
Professor Cara Wong, Department of Political Science, University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana. E-mail: carawong@uiuc.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In discussions of political obligation, it is commonly assumed that duties follow from citizenship. However, the performance of a duty by aliens can lead to citizenship status in at least one critical case: service by noncitizen soldiers. While politicians and pundits recently have called citizenship a just reward for bearing arms and these “green card troops” another example of immigrant entrepreneurship in the United States, there is a good deal of ideological ambivalence about the policy. A clear discussion of its merits is crucial, particularly because in upending the traditionally accepted relationship between obligation and membership in a community, it gives new meaning to citizenship; it also forces a choice between our egalitarian and civic republican values. In this essay, I provide a theoretical framework for evaluating the policy normatively, as well as a political analysis of why—regardless of one's normative stance—the practice of granting citizenship for military service is likely to continue into the future.

Keywords

CitizenshipObligationMilitary ServiceCommutationSubstitution
Type
STATE OF THE ART
Information
Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race , Volume 4 , Issue 1 , Spring 2007 , pp. 167 - 188
Copyright
Copyright © W.E.B. Du Bois Institute for African and African American Research 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Anderson, Stuart (1996). In Defense of a Nation: The Military Contributions of Immigrants. Washington, DC: Empower America and the American Immigration Law Foundation.Google Scholar
Arabian, Jane (n.d.). Information Paper: Enlistment and Commissioning Standards for Immigrants. OUSD (P and R)/Accession Policy Directorate.Google Scholar
Aylsworth, Leon E. (1931). The Passing of Alien Suffrage. American Political Science Review, 25(1): 114–116.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barker, Laura and Batalova, Jeanne (2007). The Foreign Born in the Armed Services. Migration Information Source. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute. ⟨http://www.migrationinformation.org/usfocus/display.cfm?ID=5727⟩ (accessed March 20, 2007).Google Scholar
BBC News (2007). Migrants Should Volunteer—Brown. February 27. ⟨http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/uk_politics/6399457.stm⟩ (accessed March 15, 2007).Google Scholar
Benhabib, Seyla (2002). Political Theory and Political Membership in a Changing World. In Katznelson, Ira and Milner, Helen V. (Eds.), Political Science: The State of the Discipline, pp. 404–432. New York: W. W. Norton and Company.Google Scholar
Berns, Walter (2001). Making Patriots. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boot, Max and O'Hanlon, Michael (2006). A Military Path to Citizenship. Washington Post, October 19, A29.Google Scholar
Branch-Brioso, Karen (2003). Open Door Policy. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, April 28, A7.Google Scholar
Buckley, Gail (2001). American Patriots: The Story of Blacks in the Military from the Revolution to Desert Storm. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Burk, James (2001). The Military Obligation of Citizens Since Vietnam. Parameters, 31(2): 48–60.Google Scholar
Caldera, LouisArmy, Secretary of the (2001). Army Announces New Advertising Campaign, News Transcript, January 10. Washington, DC: Federal News Service. ⟨http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=866⟩ (accessed March 20, 2007).Google Scholar
Carens, Joseph H. (1987). Aliens and Citizens: The Case for Open Borders. Review of Politics, 49(2): 251–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chambers, John Whiteclay II (1987). To Raise an Army: The Draft Comes to Modern America. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Chen, David W. and Sengupta, Somini (2001). A Nation Challenged: The Recruits; Not Yet Citizens but Eager to Fight for the U.S. New York Times, October 26, A1.Google Scholar
Connell, Rich and Zamichow, Nora (2003). Fighting for their Citizenship. Los Angeles Times, April 1, A1.Google Scholar
Cress, Lawrence (1982). Citizens in Arms: The Army and Militia in American Society, to the War of 1812. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Department of the Army (2002). Section 578.4 Medal of Honor. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 32, Volume 2, July 1. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Department of Defense (DOD) (2003). News Briefing: Secretary Rumsfeld and General Myers. January 7. ⟨http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=1226⟩ (accessed August 27, 2007).Google Scholar
Derbyshire, John (2002). Dual Citizen. National Review Online, April 23. ⟨http://www.nationalreview.com/derbyshire/derbyshire042302.asp⟩ (accessed March 20, 2007).Google Scholar
Earnhart, Hugh G. (1998). Commutation: Democratic or Undemocratic. In Karsten,, Peter (Ed.), Recruiting, Drafting, and Enlisting, pp. 226–237. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Fitzhugh, William W. Jr. and Hyde, Charles Cheney (1942). The Drafting of Neutral Aliens by the United States. American Journal of International Law, 36(3): 369–382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldstein, Amy and Moreno, Sylvia (2003). For Immigrants, a Special Sacrifice. Washington Post, April 7, A17.Google Scholar
Goring, Darlene C. (2000). In Service to America: Naturalization of Undocumented Alien Veterans. Seton Hall Law Review, 31: 402–478.Google Scholar
Hakim, Danny (2003). In their Hummers, Right Beside Uncle Sam. New York Times, April 5, C1.Google Scholar
Hayduk, Ronald (2002). Noncitizen Voting Rights: Shifts in Immigrant Political Status During the Progressive Era. Boston, MA: Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, August 29–September 1.Google Scholar
Helman, Sara (1997). Militarism and the Construction of Community. Journal of Political and Military Sociology, 25(2): 305–332.Google Scholar
Holsti, Ole R. (2001). Of Chasms and Convergences: Attitudes and Beliefs of Civilians and Military Elites at the Start of New Millenium. In Feaver, Peter D. and Kohn, Richard H. (Eds.), Soldiers and Civilians: The Civil-Military Gap and American National Security, pp. 15–100. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Honig, Bonnie (2001). Democracy and the Foreigner. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ibarguen, Diego (2003). Bush Sees 2 Marines Wounded in Iraq become U.S. Citizens. Knight Ridder Washington Bureau, April 12.Google Scholar
INS Reporter (1977–1978). Naturalizations Since 1907. 26(3): 41–46.Google Scholar
Jacobs, James B. and Hayes, Leslie Anne (1981). Aliens in the U.S. Armed Forces: A Historico-Legal Analysis. Armed Forces and Society, 7(2): 187–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Janowitz, Morris (1975). The All-Volunteer Military as a “Sociopolitical” Problem. Social Problems, 22(3): 432–449.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Joppke, Christian (2001). The Evolution of Alien Right in the United States, Germany, and the European Union. In Aleinikoff, T. Alexander and Klusmeyer, Douglas (Eds.), Citizenship Today: Global Perspectives and Practices, pp. 36–62. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.Google Scholar
Karsten, Peter (2001). The US Citizen-Soldier's Past, Present, and Likely Future. Parameters, 31(2): 61–73.Google Scholar
Kerber, Linda K. (1997). The Meanings of Citizenship. Journal of American History, 84(3): 833–854.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kestnbaum, Meyer (2000). Citizenship and Compulsory Military Service: The Revolutionary Origins of Conscription in the United States. Armed Forces and Society, 27(1): 7–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kettner, James H. (1978). The Development of American Citizenship, 1608–1870. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
King, Michael (2003). Draft Talk Evokes Worries, Memories. Post-Crescent, March 5.Google Scholar
Krikorian, Mark (2003). Green-Card Soldiers. National Review Online, April 22. ⟨http://www.nationalreview.com/nr_comment/nr_comment042203.asp⟩ (accessed March 20, 2007).Google Scholar
Lane, Robert E. (1965). The Tense Citizen and the Casual Patriot: Role Confusion in American Politics. Journal of Politics, 27(4): 735–760.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
LeMay, Michael and Barkan, Elliott Robert (1999). U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Laws and Issues: A Documentary History. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Levi, Margaret (1997). Consent, Dissent, and Patriotism. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McLean, Scott (1999). Land That I Love: Feelings Toward Country at Century's End. Public Perspective, 10(3): 21–25.Google Scholar
Moniz, Dave (1999). Noncitizen Soldiers in US Ranks. Christian Science Monitor. January 6, p. 1.Google Scholar
Moskos, Charles C. (1988). A Call to Civic Service. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Moskos, Charles C. and Butler, John Sibley (1996). All That We Can Be: Black Leadership and Racial Integration the Army Way. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Muller, Eric (2001). Free to Die for Their Country. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Nalty, Bernard C. (1986). Strength for the Fight: A History of Black Americans in the Military. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Navarrette, Ruben (2003). Heroism Should be Worth Citizenship. Dallas Morning News, April 11.Google Scholar
O'Neil, Lynn G. and Senturk, Omer S. (2004). Noncitizens in the U.S. Military. Master's Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA.Google Scholar
Padilla, Peter A. and Laner, Mary Riege (2002). Trends in Military Influences on Army Recruitment Themes: 1954–1990. Journal of Political and Military Sociology, 30(1): 113–133.Google Scholar
Putnam, Robert D. (2001). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Raskin, Jamin B. (1993). Legal Aliens, Local Citizens. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 141(4): 1391–1470.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
San Diego Union-Tribune (2003). Defenders Deserve Citizenship. April 15.Google Scholar
Schildkraut, Deborah J. (2005). Press One for English. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Schneiderman v. United States (1943). 320 U.S. 118.Google Scholar
Schuck, Peter H. (1998). The Re-Evaluation of American Citizenship. In Joppke, Christian (Ed.), Challenge to the Nation-State: Immigration in Western Europe and the United States, pp. 191–231. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schuck, Peter H. and Smith, Rogers M. (1985). Citizenship Without Consent. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Schweizer, Peter (2003). All They Can Be, Except American. New York Times, February 18, A23.Google Scholar
Segal, David R., Bachman, Jerald G., Freedman-Doan, Peter, and O'Malley, Patrick M. (1999). Propensity to Serve in the U.S. Military. Armed Forces and Society, 25(3): 407–428.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shklar, Judith N. (1991). American Citizenship. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Shklar, Judith N. (1998). Obligation, Loyalty, Exile. In Political Thought and Political Thinkers, pp. 38–55. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Soldier's Guide to Citizenship Application (2001). ⟨http://www.riley.army.mil/view/document.asp?ID=701-2003-04-15-57289-91⟩ (accessed March 20, 2007).Google Scholar
Solomon, John (1999). Military Draft Entangles Needy Young Men's Lives. USA Today, December 15, 31A.Google Scholar
Takao Ozawa v. United States (1922). 260 U.S. 178.Google Scholar
Traub, James (2003). The Way We Live Now: All Go Down Together. New York Times Magazine, March 2, pp. 21–22.Google Scholar
Tuan Anh Nguyen v. INS (2001). 533 U.S. 53.Google Scholar
U.S. Congress, House (1918). Congressman Rogers of Massachusetts Speaking for the Naturalization of Aliens in Military Service, Sixth-fifth Congress, second session, May 3, p. 6014. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
U.S. Congress, Senate (1949). Senator Lodge of Massachusetts Speaking for the Enlistment of Aliens in Regular Army, Eighty-first Congress, first session, January 10, p. 110. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
U.S. v. Bhagat Singh Thind (1923). 261 U.S. 204.Google Scholar
Vagts, Alfred (1946). The Foreigner as Soldier in the Second World War, I. Journal of Politics, 8(2): 174–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walzer, Michael (1970). Obligations: Essays on Disobedience, War, and Citizenship. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Walzer, Michael (1996). What It Means to Be an American. New York: Marsilio.Google Scholar
Walzer, Michael (1998). Membership. In Jacobson, David (Ed.), The Immigration Reader, pp. 341–364. New York: Blackwell Publishers.Google Scholar
Wong, Cara and Cho, Grace E. (2006). Jus Meritum: Citizenship for Service. In Lee, Taeku, Ramakrishnan, Karthick, and Ramirez, Ricardo (Eds.), Transforming Politics, Transforming America. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press.Google Scholar