Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-swr86 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-22T05:03:32.508Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Conflicting Rules of Recognition: UN Security Council Resolution 1244 or the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 March 2019

Robert Muharremi

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Kosovo's declaration of independence in 2008 and the United Nation's claim that UN Security Council Resolution 1244 (1999) (“Resolution 1244”) remains in effect have resulted in the unique case of two competing legal systems, both of which claim legitimacy and supremacy in Kosovo. While Kosovar authorities claim to exercise exclusive and sovereign authority over Kosovo based on the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, the UN, acting through the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (“UNMIK”), maintains that Resolution 1244 vests administrative authority over Kosovo in the Special Representative of the Secretary-General (“SRSG”). This conflict is best exemplified in a number of judgments rendered by the Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Privatization Agency Related Matters (“Special Chamber”) and the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo. The purpose of this Article is to illustrate the problems that have emerged in the process of the creation of a new legal system in Kosovo and the emergence of a new rule of recognition which is reflected in conflicting judgments of the Special Chamber and the Constitutional Court.

Type
Developments
Information
German Law Journal , Volume 15 , Issue 4 , 01 July 2014 , pp. 719 - 733
Copyright
Copyright © 2014 by German Law Journal GbR 

References

1 See Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Kosovo Trust Agency Related Matters, No. ASC-09-0089 (Feb. 4, 2010); Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Privatization Agency Related Matters, Nos. SCC-08-0227, SCC-08-0226 (Dec.27, 2012); Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, No. KI 25/10 (Mar. 31, 2011).Google Scholar

2 See H.L.A. Hart, The Concept of Law 98 (1961).Google Scholar

3 S.C. Res. 1244, para. 10, U.N. Doc. S/RES/1244 (June 10, 1999).Google Scholar

4 See id. at paras. 11(e), 11(f).Google Scholar

5 See UNMIK Regulation No. 1999/1, amended by UNMIK Regulation No. 2000/54, § 1.Google Scholar

6 See UNMIK Regulation No. 2000/54, § 3.Google Scholar

7 See Coronna, M.E., The Concept of Social Property and the Rights of the Foreign Investor in Yugoslavia, 11 Rev. Socialist L. 227, 230 (1985).Google Scholar

8 See Medjad, Karim, The Fate of the Yugoslav Model: A Case Against Legal Conformity, 52 Am. J. Comp. L. 287, 290 (2004).Google Scholar

9 See Knudsen, Rita Augestad, Privatization in Kosovo: The International Project 1999-2008, Norwegian Inst. Int'l Aff. 29 (2010).Google Scholar

10 See Muharremi, Robert, The Role of the United Nations and the European Union in the Privatization of Kosovo's Socially Owned Enterprises, 14 German L.J. 889, 898 (2013).Google Scholar

11 See UNMIK Regulation No. 2002/12, § 1.Google Scholar

12 See UNMIK Regulation No. 2002/13, § 4.Google Scholar

13 See Muharremi, , supra note 10, at 903, 909.Google Scholar

14 See U.N. Secretary-General, Letter Dated 26 March 26, 2007 Addressed to the President of the Security Council, U.N. Doc. S/2007/168/Add.1 (Mar. 26, 2007) [hereinafter Settlement Proposal].Google Scholar

15 See Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, June 15, 2008, art. 143.Google Scholar

16 See Proposal, Settlement, supra note 14, at Annex VII, art. 2, 4.Google Scholar

17 See Law No. 04/L-034 on the Privatization Agency of Kosovo, art. 1 (2011).Google Scholar

18 See Id. Google Scholar

19 See U.N. Secretary-General, Report of the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo, para. 4, U.N. Doc. S/2008/354 (June 12, 2008).Google Scholar

20 See Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, Case No. KI 25/10, at 20 (Mar. 31, 2011).Google Scholar

21 See id. at 21.Google Scholar

22 See Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Kosovo Trust Agency Related Matters, No. ASC-09-0089, 3 (Feb. 4, 2010).Google Scholar

23 See id. Google Scholar

24 See Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, Case No. KI 25/10, at 53 (Mar. 31, 2011).Google Scholar

25 See Law No. 04/L-033 On the Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Privatization Agency Related Matters, Official Gazette of the Republic of Kosovo No. 20 (Sept. 22, 2011).Google Scholar

26 See id. at art. 2.Google Scholar

27 See id. at art. 3.1.Google Scholar

28 See U.N. Secretary-General, Report on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo, para. 31, U.N. Doc. S/2012/72 (Jan. 31, 2008).Google Scholar

29 See Settlement Proposal, supra note 14, at Annex IX, 2.3.Google Scholar

30 See U.N. Secretary-General, Report on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo, para. 8, U.N. Doc. S/2008/354 (June 12, 2008); see also U.N. Secretary-General, Report on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo, para. 2, U.N. Doc. S/2011/675 (Oct. 31, 2011); U.N. President of the S.C., Statement Dated Nov. 26, 2008, U.N. Doc. S/PRST/2008/44 (Nov. 26, 2008).Google Scholar

31 See U.N. Secretary-General, Report on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo, para. 13, U.N. Doc. S/2009/149 (Mar. 17, 2009).Google Scholar

32 See International Steering Group for Kosovo, Communiqué of the Sixteenth and Final Meeting (Sept. 10, 2012).Google Scholar

33 See Amendments to the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo Regarding the Ending of International Supervision of Independence of Kosovo, Official Gazette of the Republic of Kosovo (Sept. 7, 2012).Google Scholar

34 See Law No. 04/L-148 On the Ratification of the International Agreement between the Republic of Kosovo and the European Union on the European Union Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo, Official Gazette of the Republic of Kosovo No. 25 (Sept. 7, 2012).Google Scholar

35 See id. Google Scholar

36 See U.N. Secretary-General, Report on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo, para. 2, U.N. Doc. S/2013/444 (July 26, 2013).Google Scholar

37 See Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Privatization Agency Related Matters, No. SCC-08-0227 (Dec. 27, 2012).Google Scholar

38 See id. at 1.Google Scholar

39 See id. Google Scholar

40 See id. Google Scholar

41 See id. at 2.Google Scholar

42 See id. at 3.Google Scholar

43 See id. Google Scholar

44 See id. Google Scholar

45 See id. at 4.Google Scholar

46 See id. Google Scholar

47 See id. Google Scholar

48 See Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Kosovo Trust Agency Related Matters, No. ASC-09-0025 (July 24, 2010).Google Scholar

49 Id. at 11.Google Scholar

50 See id. Google Scholar

51 See Id. Google Scholar

52 Id. at 11–12.Google Scholar

53 See Special Chamber of the Supreme Court of Kosovo on Privatization Agency Related Matters, Nos. SCC-08-0227, SCC-08-0226, at 8 (Dec.27, 2012).Google Scholar

54 See id. Google Scholar

55 See id. Google Scholar

56 See id. Google Scholar

57 See id. Google Scholar

58 See id. Google Scholar

59 See id. Google Scholar

60 See id. Google Scholar

61 See id. at 6.Google Scholar

62 See id. Google Scholar

63 See Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, Case No. KI 25/10, para. 20 (Mar. 31, 2011).Google Scholar

64 See id. at para. 24.Google Scholar

65 See id. at para. 53.Google Scholar

66 See id. at paras. 59–60.Google Scholar

67 See Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, June 15, 2008, art. 102.3.Google Scholar

68 See id. at art. 112.1.Google Scholar

69 See id. at art. 116.1.Google Scholar

70 See Settlement Proposal, supra note 14, at annex VII, art. 2.Google Scholar

71 See id. Google Scholar

72 See id. at art. 15.1(a).Google Scholar

73 See id. at art. 15.1(b), 15.1(e).Google Scholar

74 See id. at art. 15.1(g).Google Scholar

75 See Law No. 03/L-067 on the Privatization Agency of Kosovo (2008).Google Scholar

76 See Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, Case No. KI 25/10, at 59 (Mar. 31, 2011).Google Scholar

77 Hart, H.L.A., The Concept of Law 120 (1961).Google Scholar

78 See id. at 98.Google Scholar

79 See id. at 103.Google Scholar

80 See id. at 100.Google Scholar

81 See id. at 101.Google Scholar

82 See id. at 108–09.Google Scholar

83 See id. at 110.Google Scholar

84 See id. at 115–17.Google Scholar

85 See supra note 1.Google Scholar

86 See Hart, , supra note 2, at 120.Google Scholar

87 See Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, No. KI 25/10, 11 (Mar. 31, 2011).Google Scholar