No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
A Priest, a Ranch, and los Muchachos: A Study of Race and Clerical Abuse from New Mexico
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 May 2024
Abstract
Father Ed Donelan came to New Mexico from Massachusetts. The priest worked as a chaplain at a facility for “juvenile delinquents,” and later ran a home for boys he called the Hacienda de los Muchachos. Donelan sexually abused youth at both facilities. This essay considers how Donelan leveraged New Mexico’s juvenile justice and habilitation systems, and racial inequities baked into them, to abuse young people. Within those systems, a Catholic culture of clericalism granted Donelan unlimited access to youth, and enabled him to move unchecked between spiritual and quasi-parental forms of authority. Donelan’s story shows that clericalism is not a one-size-fits-all problem; it manifests differently in relation to different communities. Here clericalism intersects with place-based power structures of race and colonialism to damage in locally specific ways. Donelan’s case demonstrates that scholars who study clerical sexual abuse need to pay attention not only to priests, but also to church and state institutions that rendered certain populations of children especially vulnerable to their bad actions.
- Type
- Editorial Essay
- Information
- Copyright
- © College Theology Society 2024
References
1 “US Bankruptcy Court Approves $121M Clergy Abuse Settlement,” US News & World Report, December 29 , 2022, https://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2022-12-29/us-bankruptcy-court-approves-121m-clergy-abuse-settlement.Google Scholar
2 “Archdiocese of Santa Fe List of Priests, Deacons, Religious, and Seminarians Credibly Accused of Sexual Abuse of Minors,” Archdiocese of Santa Fe, last modified March 28, 2023, https://files.ecatholic.com/17613/documents/2023/4/230328_List%20of%20Priests%20Accused%20of%20Sexual%20Abuse-6.pdf?t=1681251589000.
3 The Archdiocese of Boston list includes the names of 132 men. The website BishopAccountability.org, which employs a standard of publicly accused (versus credibly accused) lists 302 men accused of abuse within the Boston archdiocese. Although both numbers are higher than Santa Fe’s tally, the Catholic population of Boston was nearly seven times that of Santa Fe during the 1960s, seventies, and eighties (“Categories of Archdiocesan Clergy Accused of Sexual Abuse of a Child,” Protection, Prevention, & Healing: Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston, https://commitment.bostoncatholic.org/categories-of-archdiocesan-clergy-accused-of-sexual-abuse-of-a-child; “Archdiocese of Boston, MA,” BishopAcccountablity.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/dioceses/usa-ma-boston/; “Archdiocese of Santa Fe” and “Archdiocese of Boston,” Catholic-Hierarchy.org, https://www.catholic-hierarchy.org/.
4 As of 2016, 62 percent of Catholics in the Archdiocese of Santa Fe were Hispanic, 25 percent were Native, and 16 percent were Anglo or white (“Key Demographic, Social, and Religious Statistics for the Archdiocese of Santa Fe,” V Encuentro, https://vencuentro.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/1318-Santa-Fe-EN.pdf).
5 “Archdiocese of Santa Fe List of Priests, Deacons, Religious, and Seminarians Credibly Accused of Sexual Abuse of Minors.”
6 This pattern holds true in places such as the Diocese of Gallup (New Mexico and Arizona) and the Diocese of Fairbanks (Alaska). Jack Downey and I have demonstrated how Catholic priests accused of abuse clustered at Native-serving missions (See Jack Downy and Kathleen Holscher, Desolate Country: Mapping Catholic Sex Abuse in Native America, data as of February 10, 2021, https://www.desolatecountry.com/).
7 Margolick, David, “Sex Abuse Cases Threaten to Bankrupt an Archdiocese,” The New York Times, December 22 , 1993, https://www.nytimes.com/1993/12/22/us/sex-abuse-cases-threaten-to-bankrupt-an-archdiocese.html.Google Scholar
8 “Retreat for Renewal: The What and Why of Via Coeli Monastery” (n.p., n.d.), BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents/single/paraclete/servants-2497-2498.pdf. For additional documents related to Via Coeli, see “Servants of the Paraclete,” BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/treatment/Servants/. BishopAccountability.org is also a physical archive, located in Waltham, Massachusetts.
9 Susanne Burks, “Abuse Suits Name State,” Albuquerque Journal, March 1, 1995.
10 Gilmore, Ruth Wilson, Golden Gulag: Prisons, Surplus, Crisis, and Opposition in Globalizing California (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2007), .Google Scholar
11 See Gonzales, Phillip, “Struggle for Survival: The Hispanic Land Grants of New Mexico, 1848–2001,” Agricultural History 77, no. 2 (Spring 2003): 293–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
12 See Holscher, Kathleen, Religious Lessons: Catholic Sisters and the Captive Schools Crisis in New Mexico (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012), 41–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
13 Sr. M. Lucia Van der Eerden, SCMM, “Maternity Care in a Spanish-American Community in New Mexico” (PhD diss., Catholic University of America, 1948), vii–viii.
14 “1960 Census: Subject Reports, Persons of Spanish Surname: Social and Economic Data for White Persons of Spanish Surname in Five Southwestern States,” United States Census Bureau, modified October 8, 2021, https://www.census.gov/library/publications/1965/dec/population-pc-2-1b.html, 37. For the 1960 US poverty threshold, see Fisher, Gordon M., “The Development and History of the Poverty Thresholds,” Social Security Bulletin 55, no. 4 (1992), https://www.ssa.gov/history/fisheronpoverty.html.Google ScholarPubMed On New Mexico’s economic transformation and its effects on Hispano communities, see Deutsch, Sarah, No Separate Refuge: Culture, Class, and Gender on an Anglo-Hispanic Frontier in the American Southwest, 1880–1940 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1987).Google Scholar
15 Elsewhere in the United States attention has rightly been given to incarceration as a “system of racialized social control” especially in regard to Black men; see Alexander, Michelle, The New Jim Crow (New York: New Press, 2012).Google Scholar In New Mexico this extends to Hispanic men; approximately 60 percent of the state’s incarcerated population is Hispanic, compared to roughly 15 percent of its residents (“New Mexico Profile,” Prison Policy Initiative, https://www.prisonpolicy.org/profiles/NM.html).
16 While the vast majority of Catholic personnel who worked in this capacity did not sexually abuse, one can re-create this Catholic history of work with at-risk youth through archival material related to sexual abusers. See, for example, Paul Shanley from the Archdiocese of Boston, who ministered to “alienated youth,” or Viatorian priest John J. Burke, who worked at a jail and abused a teenager released from custody into his care, or the Jesuit John Morse, who abused youth in his capacity of foster parent at St. Mary’s Mission School on the Colville Reservation at “Comprehensive Selection of Shanley Documents,” BishopAccountaiblity.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/docs/boston/shanley/doclist.htm; Office of the Illinois Attorney General, “Report on Catholic Clergy Child Sex Abuse in Illinois 2023,” BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/reports-2023-05-23-IL-AG-Report.pdf#page=339, 339; Mehaffey, K. C., “Former Omak Mission Children Sue State over St. Mary’s Sex Abuse Case,” The Wenatchee World, November 23 , 2011, https://www.wenatcheeworld.com/news/local/former-omak-mission-children-sue-state-over-st-mary-s-sex-abuse-case/article_ddcec7cd-9ce7-5cde-bd1b-7a7a9f0c385f.html.Google Scholar
17 Edward Donelan to Edwin Byrne, May 1, 1949, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5539.
18 Edward Donelan to Edwin Byrne, April 30, 1955, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5510.
19 Pasternack, Robert, Portillos, Robert, and Hoff, Henry, “Providing an Appropriate Education to Adjudicated and Incarcerated Juvenile Delinquents,” Journal of Correctional Education, 39, no. 4 (December 1988): .Google Scholar
20 The demographics of this incarcerated population deviated from state census numbers, which recorded 40 percent of the state’s population as Hispanic, and just over half as non-Hispanic white (i.e., Anglo). State of New Mexico Department of Corrections, New Mexico Boys’ School 1968–1969 Statistical Report (n.p., n.d.), 25, 19; “Chapter C: General Social and Economic Characteristics New Mexico,” United States Census Bureau, https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/1970/population-volume-1/1970a_nm-02.pdf, 33–105.
21 “Chapter C: General Social and Economic Characteristics New Mexico,” 29–31.
22 Edwin Byrne to Edward Donelan, June 23, 1958, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5565.
23 Edward Donelan, “La Hacienda de los Muchachos,” March 14, 1965, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5577-5584.
24 Edward Donelan to Edwin Byrne, March 28, 1961, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5558-5559.
25 Donelan, “La Hacienda de los Muchachos.”
26 Edward Donelan, “Hacienda de los Muchachos,” n.d., BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5597-5603.
27 Eileen Stanton, “Throw-Away Boys: Who Salvages Them?,” BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5414-5420, 4.
28 Robert Sanchez to Edward Donelan, March 15, 1976, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-4402; M. E. L. Olson and Janet E. Bryan, “Report on the Hacienda de los Muchachos,” March 12, 1976, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-4409-4413.
29 Eaton, Scott, “Approval Withdrawn, Complaint Issued,” Raton Range, April 29 , 1976, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-4404-4405.Google Scholar
30 Donelan, “La Hacienda de los Muchachos.”
31 Donelan, “La Hacienda de los Muchachos.”
32 James P. Davis to Howard C. Leach, March 22, 1971, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-4400-4401.
33 Gutiérrez, Ramón, When Jesus Came, the Corn Mothers Went Away: Marriage, Sexuality, and Power in New Mexico, 1500–1846 (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1991), .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
34 On boarding school initiatives to reconfigure Native kinship, see Rifkin, Mark, When Did Indians Become Straight?: Kinship, the History of Sexuality, and Native Sovereignty (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
35 Priests accused of abuse while acting in the capacity of a foster parent include Fr. Samuel Lupico of the Archdiocese of Boston, Deacon Donald Patrick Dickson of the Archdiocese of New York, Fr. Dennis Muehe of the Archdiocese of Seattle, Fr. Steven Girard of the Archdiocese of Baltimore, Fr. Hubert Mann of the Diocese of Manchester, Fr. Edward Olszewski of the Archdiocese of Detroit, Fr. Francis Hoefgen of the Diocese of Saint Cloud, Fr. Terrence Healy of the Diocese of Marquette, Fr. Barry Ashwell of the Archdiocese of Seattle, and Fr. John Morse of the Society of Jesus. For records related to these men, see BishopAccountability.org.
36 Edward Donelan to Edwin Byrne, July 12, 1961, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5541-5542.
37 Edward Donelan to James P. Davis, December 24, 1969, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5593.
38 Stanton, “Throw-Away Boys.”
39 Edward Donelan to “Friend and Benefactor,” n.d. (c. 1973), BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5612-5613.
40 “Guidelines for Visiting Boys at the Hacienda de los Muchachos,” n.d., BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5425-5426.
41 Eaton, “Approval Withdrawn, Complaint Issued.”
42 Olson and Bryan, “Report on the Hacienda de los Muchachos.”
43 Archbishop Robert Sanchez later faced his own accusations of sexual relations with young women, some of them minors; see “Fr. Robert F. Sanchez,” BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/sanchez-robert-f-1959/.
44 Pierre Nichols to Robert Sanchez, February 20, 1976, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5636-5647.
45 Pierre Nichols to Robert Sanchez, February 20, 1976.
46 Pierre Nichols to Robert Sanchez, February 20, 1976.
47 Edward Donelan to “Friend and Benefactor,” September 1976, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5726-5728.
48 Michael Sheehan to Doug Raun, February 14, 1994, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5686.
49 Charles and Crucita Todd to Robert Sanchez, April 13, 1976, BishopAccountability.org, https://www.bishop-accountability.org/documents-BA-Servants-of-the-Paraclete-5616-5619.
50 Charles and Crucita Todd to Robert Sanchez, April 13, 1976.
51 “Pope Francis: Letter to the People of God,” Vatican News, August 20 , 2018, https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2018-08/pope-francis-letter-people-of-god-sexual-abuse.html.Google Scholar