Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-fv566 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-21T12:03:00.377Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Beginning of Labor's End? Britain's “Winter of Discontent” and Working-Class Women's Activism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 April 2009

Tara Martin
Tara Martin
Affiliation:
University of Manchester
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In the midst of the freezing winter of 1978 and 1979, strikes erupted across Britain. In what became infamously known as the “Winter of Discontent,” workers struck against the Labour Government's attempts to curtail wage increases. The defeat of this “incomes policy” and Labour's subsequent electoral defeat ushered in an era of unprecedented political, economic, and social change for Britain. Conservative victory, under the leadership of Margaret Thatcher, not only seemed to signal the dissolution of “traditional” working-class ties to the Labour Party, it also suggested that British working-class politics might finally be on its last leg. Furthermore, a potent social myth developed around the Winter of Discontent, one where “bloody-minded” workers brought down a sympathetic government and “invited” the ravages of Thatcherism upon the British labor movement.

Absent from these various narratives are the experiences of rank-and-file activists, in particular, the growing number of female trade unionists active in these strikes. This article examines the experiences of a group of women trade unionists from the National Union of Public Employees (NUPE) who participated in the strikes of the Winter of Discontent. Based on oral histories and corresponding archival material, it argues that the Winter of Discontent provided a crucial “rite of passage” for these women, one which exposed them to an unprecedented level of involvement in grassroots labor activism and leadership. Thereafter, these working-class women began to make significant inroads into NUPE and the Labour Party, which helped to make working women's issues more central to the British labor movement for decades to come. Therefore, rather than being the death knell of British working-class politics, this study of women involved in the Winter of Discontent strikes reveals that while one form of working-class politics was in decline, a reconfigured one was in the process of being born.

Type
Rethinking the Left in Victory and Defeat
Information
International Labor and Working-Class History , Volume 75 , Issue 1 , Spring 2009 , pp. 49 - 67
Copyright
Copyright © International Labor and Working-Class History, Inc. 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

1. By 1979, trade union membership was at its highest in British history with 13,447,000 members, or 55.4 percent of the overall workforce. Wrigley, Chris, “Women in the Labour Market,” in British Trade Unions and Industrial Politics: The High Tide of Trade Unionism, 1964–1979, eds., McIlroy, John, Fishman, Nina, and Campbell, Alan, (Aldershot, 1999), 120Google Scholar.

2. Sun editor Larry Lamb is given credit for coining the strikes of 1978–1979 the “Winter of Discontent” in an editorial on May 3, 1979. See Tony Benn: Conflicts of Interest, Diaries 1977–80 (London, 1990), 407; and Denham, Andrew and Garnett, MarkKeith Joseph (Chesham, 2001), 327Google Scholar. For an overall analysis of the media portrayal of the Winter of Discontent see Hay, Colin, “Narrating Crisis: The Discursive Construction of the ‘Winter of Discontent,’ ” Sociology 30 (May 1996), 253–277CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3. “Postbag,” Manchester Evening News, January 15, 1979.

4. Political advisor to Prime Minister Callaghan attributes this observation of a “sea-change” in public opinion in the run-up to the General Election of 1979 in Donoghue, Bernard, Prime Minister: The Conduct of Policy under Harold Wilson and James Callaghan (London, 1987), 191>Google Scholar. Margaret Thatcher makes a similar observation in retrospect. Thatcher, Margaret, The Path to Power (London, 1995), 435Google Scholar.

5. Thatcher, The Path to Power, 435.

6. Eley, Geoff, Forging Democracy: The History of the Left in Europe, 1850–2000 (Oxford, 2002), 391Google Scholar.

7. Sked, Alan, “The Political Parties,” in Britain Since 1945, ed., Hollowell, Jonathan (Oxford, 2003), 48Google Scholar.

8. For more detailed political and economic roots of the Winter of Discontent, see Taylor, Robert, The Trade Union Question in British Politics: Government and Unions since 1945 (Oxford, 1993)Google Scholar; and Ludlam, Steve, “ ‘Old’ Labour and the Winter of Discontent,” Politics Review February 2000, 30–33Google Scholar.

9. “After Ford, the Deluge?” The Economist, November 4, 1978, 10.

10. Coates, Ken and Topham, Tony, Trade Unions and Politics (Oxford, 1986), 198Google Scholar.

11. Scottish Daily Express, May 3, 1979.

12. “Ministers Battle to Avert Winter of Discontent,” The Guardian, August, 27, 2007, 8.

13. See Castle, Barbara, Fighting All the Way (London, 1993)Google Scholar; Tomlinson, Jim, “Economic Policy,” in New Labour, Old Labour: The Wilson and Callaghan Governments, 1974–79, 55–69Google Scholar; Interviews with Mike Donovan, Stuart Hill, Lord Sawyer, etc.

14. Interview with Andy Gil, May 19, 2006.

15. See Callaghan, James, Time and Change (London, 1987)Google Scholar; Healey, Dennis, The Time of My Life (London, 1989)Google Scholar, etc.

16. Interview with Tom McNally, November 2006.

17. See Beer, Samuel, Britain Against Itself: The Political Contradictions of Collectivism (New York; London, 1982)Google Scholar; Morgan, K.O., The People's Peace: British History, 1945–1989 (Oxford, 1990)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Taylor, Robert, The Trade Union Question in British Politics: Government and Unions Since 1945 (Oxford, 1993)Google Scholar.

18. Panitch, Leo, Leys, Colin, and Coates, David, The End of Parliamentary Socialism: From New Left to New Labour (London, 1997)Google Scholar; Coates, Ken, “What Went Wrong?” in What Went Wrong?: Explaining the Fall of the Labour Government, ed., Coates, Ken, (Nottingham, 1979), 7–33Google Scholar; S. Ludlam, “Labourism and the disintegration of the postwar consensus: disunited trade union economic policy responses to public expenditure cuts, 1974–79,” (PhD thesis, University of Sheffield, 1991).

19. Eric Hobsbawm, “The Forward March of Labour Halted?” (1978), 9–28 and “The Debate on ‘The Forward March of Labour Halted?’” (1981), 29–41 in Politics for a Rational Left (London, 1989); Seabrook, Jeremy in What Went Wrong?: Working People and the Ideals of the Labour Movement (London, 1978)Google Scholar; Beer, Samuel, Britain Against Itself: The Political Contradictions of Collectivism (London, 1982)Google Scholar.

20. One notable exception is Cunnison, Sheila and Stageman, Jane, Feminising the Unions: Challenging the Culture of Masculinity (Aldershot, 1995)Google Scholar. Cunnison and Stageman are sociologists who documented the involvement of women in several British trade unions in the 1970s and the 1980s. The authors note that the Winter of Discontent was a pivotal moment in generating “gender-consciousness” among female trade unionists. Where my work departs from theirs is that my work focuses solely on female manual workers in NUPE and seeks to place their experiences in a larger historical narrative of the rise and fall of the British labor movement, whereas theirs advances our understanding of the sociology of trade unions.

21. Cronin, James, Labour and Society in Britain 1918–1979 (London, 1984), 148Google Scholar.

22. Solomos, John, Race and Racism in Britain, 2nd edition (London: 1993), 54CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23. Ramdin, Ron, The Making of the Black Working Class in Britain (Aldershot, 1987), 310–311Google Scholar.

24. Hudson, Ray and Williams, AllanDivided Britain, 2nd Edition. (Chinchester and New York, 1995), 136Google Scholar.

25. Cronin, , Labour and Society (London, 1984), 194Google Scholar.

26. Ibid., 195.

27. Boston, Sarah, Women Workers and Trade Unions (London, 1987), 286Google Scholar.

28. Karen Stone, “Motherhood and Waged Work…” 35.

29. “Why Mothers go out to work,” Manchester Evening News (October 16, 1974), 12.

30. David Vincent argues that in postwar Britain, “. . . given the absence of the minimum wage, and the presence of such obstacles as the wage stop, which particularly affected large families of low earners, the wife's labour was in fact the only absolute guarantee of basic subsistence.” Vincent, David, Poor Citizens: The State and the Poor in Twentieth-Century Britain (London, 1991), 144–145Google Scholar). For the increasingly important role of women's wages in the 1970s in the United States, see Bailey, Beth, “She ‘Can Bring Home the Bacon,’: Negotiating Gender in Seventies America,” America in the Seventies, eds., Bailey, Beth and Farber, David (Lawrence, Kansas, 2004), 107–128Google Scholar.

31. Cronin, James, New Labour's Pasts: The Labour Party and Its Discontents (Harlow, 2004), 24Google Scholar.

32. See Ramdin, The Making of the Black Working Class in Britain; Fryer, P., Staying Power: The History of Black People in Britain (London, 1984)Google Scholar; Tabili, Laura, “We Ask for British Justice”: Workers and Racial Difference in Late Imperial Britain (Ithaca, 1994)Google Scholar.

33. Boston, Women Workers and Trade Unions, 247.

34. Purcell, Kate, “Militancy and Acquiescence among Women Workers,” in Women and the Public Sphere: A Critique of Sociology and Politics, eds., Siltanen, Janet and Stanworth, Michelle (London, 1984), 55Google Scholar.

35. Wrigley, Chris, “Women in the Labour Market,” in British Trade Unions and Industrial Politics: The High Tide of Trade Unionism, 1964–1979, eds., McIlroy, John, Fishman, Nina, and Campbell, Alan (Aldershot, 1999), 44Google Scholar.

36. Boston, Women Workers and Trade Unions, 324. See also Ramdin, The Making of the Black Working Class, 337.

37. Beale, Jenny, Getting It Together: Women as Trade Unionists (London, 1982), 7–11Google Scholar.

38. Rowbotham, Sheila, The Past is Before Us: Feminism in Actions Since the 1960s (London, 1989), 182Google Scholar.

39. Sheila Rowbotham, “Cleaners in Britain from the 1970s,” unpublished article.

40. Beale, Getting It Together: Women as Trade Unionists, 14–15. See also, Boston, Women Workers and the Trade Unions.

41. For histories of the left/right conflict in British trade unions and Labour Party, see Minkin, Lewis, The Contentious Alliance: Trade Unions and the Labour Party (Edinburgh, 1991)Google Scholar. Wainwright, Hillary, A Tale of Two Parties (London, 1987)Google Scholar; Hayter, Dianne, Fightback! Labour's Traditional Right in the 1970s and 1980s (Manchester, 2005)Google Scholar; Panitch, Leo and Leys, Colin, The End of Parliamentary Socialism: From New Left to New Labour (London, 1997)Google Scholar. For the debate surrounding free collective bargaining, see Steve Ludlam, “Labourism and the Disintegration of the Postwar Consensus: Disunited Trade Union Economic Policy Responses to Public Expenditure Cuts, 1974–1979.” (PhD diss., University of Sheffield, 1990).

42. Interview with Bob Fryer, June 2006. Also see, Interview with Godfrey Eastwood, August, 2007.

43. Wrigley, “Women in the Labour Market,” 60.

44. Ibid., 65.

45. Rodney Bickerstaffe Papers, MSS.389/6/B/Box 16 NUPE Re-Organisation-Warwick University Research Study, Bob Fryer, Andy Fairclough, Tom Manson, Brenda Waller, NUPE Research Project Department of Sociology, Statistical Appendix II: Union Stewards, Survey taken between May and June 1974. Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK.

46. Rodney Bickerstaffe Papers, MSS.389/6/B/Box 5 Organisation and Change in the National Union of Public Employees, Bob Fryer, Andy Fairclough, Tom Manson, Brenda Waller, NUPE Research Project Department of Sociology, Statistical Appendix II: Union Stewards, August 1974. Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK, 38.

47. Wrigley, “Women in the Labour Market,” 60.

48. Interview with Celia Newman, Lorraine Donovan, and Mike Donovan, October 2006.

49. Interview with Anne Gardiner and Stuart Hill, November 2006.

50. The Guardian, January 9, 1979.

51. Daily Express, September 18, 1978.

52. “Nurses Join Walkout as Unions Step Up Pay Battle: Strikers Paralyse Six City Hospitals,” Manchester Evening News, January 29, 1979.

53. “ ‘We Know that We are Hitting our Relatives, Friends, and Neighbors:’ Hospital Strikers With Red Faces,” The Guardian, February 3, 1979.

54. Northern Echo, January 22, 1979, “North-East Wakes up to Misery Monday,” Manchester Evening News, January 22, 1979, The Guardian, January 30, 1979, “Government promised ‘hammering’ on pay.”

55. Women's Voice, February 1979.

56. Interview with Brenda Tredwell, February 2007.

57. Interview with Celia Newman, Lorraine Donovan, and Mike Donovan, October 2006.

58. Ibid.

59. Ibid.

60. Interview with Betty Hughes, Joe Hughes, and Stuart Hill, November 2006.

61. Interview with Betty and Joe Hughes, March 2007.

62. Interview with Anne Gardiner and Stuart Hill, November 2006.

63. Interview with Brian Whattam, November 2006.

64. Interview with Anne Gardiner and Stuart Hill, March 2007.

65. Interview with Celia Newman, Lorraine Donovan, and Mike Donovan, October 2006.

66. Neale, Jonathan, Memoirs of a Callous Picket (London, 1983), 62Google Scholar.

67. Interview with Linda Perks, September 3, 2007.

68. Survey of Branch District Committees 1st Report, 1981, Rodney Bickerstaffe Papers, MSS 389 Box 5. Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK.

69. Boston, 332.

70. Fryer, Bob and Williams, Steve, A Century of Service: An Illustrated History of the National Union of Public Employees, 1889–1993 (London, 1993), 130Google Scholar.

71. Interview with Anne Gardiner and Stuart Hill, March 2007.

72. Interview with Celia Newman, Lorraine Donovan, and Mike Donovan, October 2006.

73. Ramdin, Ron, Reimaging Britain: 500 Years of Black and Asian History (London, 1999), 227–228Google Scholar.

74. Ramdin, The Making of the Black Working Class in Britain, 318.

75. Paul, Jane, Where There's Muck There's Money: A Report on Cleaning in London (Greater London Council, 1986), 67Google Scholar.

76. Interview with Mike Donovan and Patt Corr, April 2006.

77. Interview with Anne Gardiner and Stuart Hill, November 2006.

78. Fryer, Bob and Williams, Steve, A Century of Service: An Illustrated History of the National Union of Public Employees, 1889–1993 (London, 1993), 130Google Scholar.

79. June Abdoolrohmun Papers, MSS 389 Box 29, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK.

80. Interview with Tom Sawyer, September 3, 2007. Geoff Eley notes that in the 1980s, “NUPE prioritized the minimum wage, for which industrial militants had little time, and stressed equal pay, anti-discrimination, childcare provision, and other issues for women at work . . . as well as women's public representation.” Forging Democracy, 393.

81. Interview with Linda Perks, September 3, 2007.

82. Interview with Betty Hughes, March 2007.

83. “Save the GLC,” Jobs for a Change, February 1984, No. 6.

84. Boston, Women Workers, 328–329.

85. Pearson, Philip, Twilight Robbery: Low-Paid Workers in Britain Today (London, 1985), 101Google Scholar.

86. Labour Party Conference Report. Quoted in Jeroald Waltman, Contemporary Wage Policy in Britain and the United States (New York, forthcoming), Chapter 3.

87. Labour Party Manifesto, 1987. Quoted in Waltman, Contemporary Wage Policy in Britain and the United States (New York, forthcoming), Chapter 3.

88. Labour Party Manifesto, 1987. Quoted in Waltman, Contemporary Wage Policy in Britain and the United States (New York, forthcoming), Chapter 3.

89. Sally Mercer and Richard Notely, Trade Union Membership 2007 Department of Business Enterprise & Regulatory Reform (London: A National Statistics Publication) 4. http://www.berr.gov.uk/whatwedo/employment/research-evaluation/trade-union-statisitcs/index.html

90. Ibid., 8.

91. Trades Union Congress, Report of Congress, 2006 and Certification Officer, Annual Report quoted in Daniels, Gary and McIlroy, John, “An Anatomy of British Trade Unionism Since 1997: Organization, Structure, and Factionalism,” Trade Unions in a Neoliberal World. Eds. Daniels, Gary and McIlroy, John (London, 2009), 130Google Scholar.

92. Interview with Linda Perks, September 4, 2007.

93. Cobble, Dorothy Sue, “Kissing the Old Class Politics Goodbye,” International Labor and Working Class History 67 (2005), 55–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.