Online ordering is currently unavailable due to technical issues. We apologise for any delays responding to customers while we resolve this. For further updates please visit our website: https://www.cambridge.org/news-and-insights/technical-incident
We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 18 December 2008
How did philanthropy adjust to the transformation of society in the nineteenth century? What was its role in social relations and in relieving poverty? Recent writers studying these issues have suggested the need for detailed studies at local level, and in studying some English towns and cities in the earlier part of the nineteenth century they have come to varying conclusions. Roger Smith's study of Nottingham shows that philanthropy added insignificantly to the amount of relief available through the Poor Law. By contrast Peter Searby's study of Coventry shows that philanthropic funds were quite abundant and after some reforms in the 1830's even applied to the relief of the poor! Professor McCord's articles on the North-East of England in the early nineteenth century seek to establish the more ambitious claim “that nineteenth-century philanthropy provided increasing resources and extended machinery with which to diminish the undesirable effects of that period's social problems”.
1 Smith, R., “The Relief of Poverty outside the Poor Law, 1800–1850: A Study of Nottingham”, in: Midland History. II(1974).Google Scholar
2 Searby, P., “The Relief of the Poor in Coventry, 1830–1863”, in: Historical Journal, XX (1977).Google Scholar
3 McCord, N., “Aspects of the Relief of Poverty in Early 19th-Century Britain”, in: The Long Debate on Poverty (London, 1972)Google Scholar; id., “The Poor Law and Philanthropy”, in: The New Poor Law in the Nineteenth Century, ed. by D. Fraser (London, 1976), quotation from p. 110.
4 Id., “The Poor Law and Philanthropy”. pp. 95, 109.Google Scholar
5 Schumpeter, J. A., History of Economic Analysis (New York, 1954), p. 147Google Scholar. cited in Rimlinger, G. V., “Welfare Policy and Economic Development: A Comparative Histoncal Perspective”, in: Journal of Economic History. XXVI (1966). p. 559.Google Scholar
6 Rees, W.. Cardiff: A History of the City. 2nd ed. (Cardiff, 1969), p. 297Google Scholar; Carter, H.. “Phases of Town Growth in Wales”, in: The Study of Urban History, ed. by Dyos, H. J. (London, 1968)Google Scholar: Report on Endowed Charities, County Borough of Cardiff [Parliamentary Papers, 1897. LXVII] (this reprints the 1837 report); Owen, D., English Philanthropy 1660–1960 (London, 1965), pp. 276, 444, 447–49Google Scholar; Simey, M., Charitable Effort in Liverpool in the Nineteenth Century (Liverpool, 1951)Google Scholar: Meller, H. E., Leisure and the Changing City, 1870–1914 (London, 1976), ch. 2. Despite its slow growth Bristol had severe public-health problems.Google Scholar
7 Davies, J., ‘Glamorgan and the Bute Estate’ (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Wales, 1969)Google Scholar; Evans, N., “‘The First Charity in Wales’: Cardiff Infirmary and South Wales Society, 1837-1914”, in: Welsh History Review, IX (1978–1979); Cardiff and Merthyr Guardian, 31 05 and 10 07 1834; 3 01 and 14 09 1835; 26 03 1836; 9 12 1837Google Scholar; Ch., Morgan, “Education in Cardiff”, in: Cardiff: An Illustrated Handbook, ed. by Ballinger, J. (Cardiff, 1896).Google Scholar
8 This theme is prominent in much recent urban sociology. For a brief introduction see Pahl, R. E., Whose City?, 2nd ed. (Harmondsworth, 1975), ch. 8, esp. pp. 167–71.Google Scholar
9 Moore, R., Pitmen, Preachers and Politics (Cambridge, 1974)Google Scholar, ch. 3; Thompson, E. P., “On History, Sociology and Historical Relevance”, in: British Journal of Sociology, XXVII (1976), pp. 392–93Google Scholar; Daunton, M. J., “Miners' Houses: South Wales and the Great Northern Coalfield, 1880-1914”, in: International Review of Social History. XXV (1980)Google Scholar; Morris, J. and Williams, L. J., The South Wales Coal Industry, 1841-75 (Cardiff, 1958), ch. IX and p. 209Google Scholar; Williams, L. J., “The Coalowners”, in: A People and a Proletariat, ed. by Smith, D. (London, 1980), pp. 106–10.Google Scholar
10 Daunton, M. J., Coal Metropolis: Cardiff 1870–1914 (Leicester, 1977), esp. chs 2,3 and 4.Google Scholar
11 Harrison, B., “Philanthropy and the Victorians”, in: Victorian Studies, IX (1965–1966), p. 351.Google Scholar
12 Bremner, R., American Philanthropy (Chicago, 1960), p. 3.Google Scholar
13 Cardiff Times (hereafter CT), 30 June 1888, gives an account of the opening of Turner House. Ibid., 27 October 1883, deals with the opening of the University College of South Wales and Monmouthshire.
14 CT, 1 March 1861.
15 Davies, D., Christ Magnified, The Life of Mrs. N. Thomas of Cardiff (London, n.d. [c. 1884]), pp. 24–25.Google Scholar
16 CT, 22 October 1859.
17 CT, 4 March 1864; 7 March 1874; Cardiff Sailors' Rest, Annual Report, 1912, p. 8.Google Scholar
18 M. J. Daunton, “Jack Ashore': Seamen in Cardiff Before 1914”, in: Welsh History Review, IX.
19 Cardiff, and Merthyr, Guardian, 27 01 1838Google Scholar; CT, 30 01 1863; 13 03 1864; 13 03 1869Google Scholar; Cardiff Tide Tables and Almanack, 1891, p. 112; 1906, p. 77.Google Scholar
20 CT, 7 03 1874; 11 10 1902; 29 January 1910; Western Mail, 28 January 1910; Royal Hamadryad Seamen's Hospital, Annual Reports, 1872 and 1914; Cardiff Sailors' Rest, Annual Reports, 1910–1914, and letter of explanation bound with these in the Cardiff Public Library.Google Scholar
21 CT, 15 01, 15 02, 1, 8, 15 and 22 March, 9 July and 27 December 1861; 13 March 1863; 5 December 1866; 1st Report of the Cardiff Associate Institute for Improving and Enforcing the Laws for the Protection of Women (Cardiff, 1860)Google Scholar; Cardiff Tide Tables and Almanack, 1882, pp. 76–78; 1883, p. 91; 1895, p. 128; 1896, p. 128; House of Mercy for South Wales and Monmouthshire, Annual Reports, 1863, 1865–1866, 1868, 1870–1872, 1875–77, 1880 and 1890; Llandaff Diocesan Magazine, June 1903.Google Scholar
22 CT, 1 and 22 Octobar 1859; 23 April 1870; Ladies Association for the Care of Friendless Girls (Cardiff, 1883); South Wales Daily News (hereafter SWDN), 8 December 1893; Cardiff and District Ladies Association for the Care of Friendless Girls, 24th Annual Report, 1906Google Scholar; Cardiff Tide Tables and Almanack, 1883, p. 90; 1884, p. 92; Western Mail, 20 April 1891Google Scholar; CT, 4 05 1908; Forward Movement, Women's Branch, Annual Reports of the Social Wing, 1904–1905, 1905–1906, 1909–1910 and 1910–1911.Google Scholar
23 CT, 8 01 1862; 5 October 1866; 20 April and 21 Setember 1867; Cardiff Medical Society, Minutes, 9 March 1876Google Scholar; Daunton, M. J., “Aspects of the Social and Economic Structure of Cardiff, 1870–1914” (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Kent, 1974), pp. 491–94Google Scholar; Cardiff Tide Tables and Almanack, 1894, p. 130; Cardiff and District Citizen's Union, Annual Reports, 1909–1910 and 1918–1919. For the later role of the Citizen's Union, see Evans, N., “The South Wales Race Riots of 1919”, in: Llafur, III (1980–1983), pp. 9–10.Google Scholar
24 CT, 15 03 1861; 7 November 1862; 16 January and 19 December 1863; 22 01, 12 02 and 23 April 1870; 12 May 1883Google Scholar; Cardiff Tide Tables and Almanack, 1892, pp. 115–16; Cardiff YMCA, Annual Reports, 1857, 1894–1896; id., Fourth Anniversary of Lads' Union (Cardiff, 1904)Google Scholar; CT, 11 04 1908; 10 07 1909.Google Scholar
25 CT, 15 10 1858; 8 January, 12 February and 15 October 1859; 30 January 1860; 12 May 1865; 12 October 1883Google Scholar; Allen, S. W., Reminiscences (Cardiff, 1918), pp. 57, 68–71.Google Scholar
26 Cardiff Town Mission, Annual Reports, 1878–1879, 1889 and 1898; CT, 8 January 1859; 4 February 1860; 14 February 1862; 6 March 1863; 6 April 1867; 15 April 1871; Christian Endeavour and its Results: A Short Narrative of the Cardiff Sunday School Canvass Movement (Cardiff, n.d.); Thompson, C. J., The Defects of Sunday Schools and How to Remedy Them (Cardiff, 1889), p. 5.Google Scholar
27 Home Office Papers 129/581, Religious Census, Public Record Office, London; The Religious Census of 1851: A Calendar of the Returns Relating to Wales, ed. by Jones, I. G. and Williams, D. (Cardiff, 1976), I, pp. 137–45Google Scholar; Census of England and Wales, 1851–1911; James, W. F., Seven Years' Pioneer Mission Work in Cardiff, 2nd ed. (London, 1882), p. 8; CT, 10 February and 12 May 1865; 8 September 1882; 20 August and 1 October 1904; Christian Herald, April 1910, Supplement: Spread the Fire Souvenir.Google Scholar
28 CT, 27 March 1863; 1 October 1904; Kent, J., “The Role of Religion in the Cultural Structure of the Late Victorian City”, in: Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, Fifth Series, XXIII (1973).Google Scholar
29 Stedman Jones, G., Outcast London (London, 1971), pp. 251–52.Google Scholar
30 Waite, J., Three Sermons (Cardiff, 1865), p. 19.Google Scholar
31 CT, 18 January 1861; 26 January 1867.
32 Cardiff Infirmary, Annual Report, 1911; Llandaff School for the Deaf and Dumb, Annual Report, 1874; James, , Seven Years' Pioneer Mission Work, op. cit., pp. 42–43; CT, 30 October 1858; 28 March 1862; 3 April 1869; 24 January 1880; Cardiff Infirmary, Annual Reports, 1906–1907.Google Scholar
33 CT, 15 April 1871; 8 September 1883.
34 Cardiff Provident Dispensary, Annual Reports, 1885–1914; Evans, , “‘The First Charity in Wales”’, loc. cit., pp. 324–25; CT, 14 February 1880.Google Scholar
35 CT, 11 January 1861; Harrison, , “Philanthropy and the Victorians”, loc. cit., p. 363Google Scholar; CT, 3 October 1859; 14 February 1862; 6 November 1869: 22 January 1870: 21 January and 1 April 1871; 24 January 1880; Cardiff Infirmary, Patti Charity Concert, 1905 – Programme (Cardiff, 1905): Allen, , Reminiscences, op. cit., pp. 153–54Google Scholar, 161–62; James, , Seven Years' Pioneer Mission Work, p. 29Google Scholar: SWDN. 27 11 1893.Google Scholar
36 Yeo, S., Religion and Voluntary Organisations in Crisis (London, 1976).Google Scholar
37 The term walking city is from Warner, S. B. Jr, Streetcar Suburbs (Cambridge, Mass., 1962)Google Scholar. Hilling, J. B., “The Buildings of Cardiff”, in: Glamorgan Historian, ed. by Williams, S. (Cowbridge, 1969)Google Scholar; Lewis, C. R., “A Stage in the Development of an Industrial Town: A Case Study of Cardiff, 1845-1875”, in: Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series, IV (1979); CT, 30 August 1861; 22 September 1865; 9 December 1893.Google Scholar
38 For more detail on middle-class attitudes to Cardiff see Evans, N., “The Welsh Victorian City: The Middle Class, Civic and National Consciousness in Cardiff, 1850–1914”, in: Welsh History Review, forthcoming.Google Scholar
39 Some of the arguments here owe much to Meller, , Leisure and the Changing City, op. cit.Google Scholar, and Yeo, , Religion and Voluntary Organisations, op. cit.Google Scholar, though, of course. I am responsible for my use of them; CT, 14 February, 8 May, 2 and 9 October 1880; 1 October 1885; and Allen, , Reminiscences, passim, illustrate the growth of middle-class leisure facilitiesGoogle Scholar; Daunton, , “Aspects”. op. cit., p. 491.Google Scholar
40 Here I am influenced by Johnson, R., “Educational Policy and Social Control in Early Victorian England”, in: Past & Present, No 49 (1970)Google Scholar: Hay, J. R., “Employers' Attitudes to Social Policy and the Concept of ‘Social Control’. 1900–1920”, in: The Origins of British Social Policy, ed. by Thane, P. (London, 1978)Google Scholar. G. Stedman Jones has modified his views on “social control”, see “From Historical Sociology to Theoretical History”, in: British Journal of Sociology, XXVIII; id., “Class Expression versus Social Control?”, in: History Workshop. No 4 (1977).Google Scholar
41 Cardiff Strangers' Rest, Annual Report, 1887, p. 24.Google Scholar
42 SWDN, 5 12 1893.Google Scholar
43 Cardiff Strangers' Rest. Annual Report. 1887, p. 3.Google Scholar
44 Hobson, S. to Tom, Jones and others, 25 02 1896, Thomas Jones Papers, Class X, Vol. 2, National Library of Wales, Aberystwyth. I am grateful to Baroness White of Rhymney and Mr Tristan Jones for permission to consult these papers.Google Scholar
45 Parish of Canton St. John, Report and Statement of Accounts, 1906, p. 7.
46 Evans, , ‘“The First Charity in Wales”’, pp. 319, 341–45Google Scholar; Stead, P., Coleg Harlech: The First Fifty Years (Cardiff, 1977), pp. 3–4Google Scholar; Sanderson, M., The Universities and British Industry, 1850–1970 (London, 1972), ch. 5Google Scholar; Cardiff Chamber of Commerce, Annual Report, 1914, p. 26.Google Scholar
47 CT, 7 March 1874; postcard sent from Cardiff, 21 August 1911, showing Cardiff Infirmary, in my possession.
48 Cardiff Seamen's Hospital, Programme, Guide and Souvenir of the Grand Bazaar (Cardiff, 1899).
49 Evans, , “‘The First Charity in Wales’”, p. 341; Cardiff Sailors' Rest, Official Handbook of the Sale of Work, 1899.Google Scholar
50 Stedman Jones, Outcast London, op. cit., ch. 13.
51 CT, 30 January 1886. For its origins see Western Mail, 26 January; SWDN, 25 January, 23 February, 3 and 8 March 1886.
52 CT, 18 March 1871; 3 January and 14 February 1880; Western Mail, 18 November 1886; Cardiff COS, Annual Reports, 1886-1914, passim.
53 Richards, G. Ch., M.A., The Evils of Indiscriminate Charity (Cardiff, 1894), pp. 4–7 (bound with COS Annual Reports, Cardiff Public Library); SWDN, 5 December 1893.Google Scholar
54 Cardiff COS, Annual Reports, passim; Owen, , English Philanthropy, op. cit., pp. 110–12Google Scholar; Hill, Ch., Change and Continuity in Seventeenth-Century England (London, 1979), p. 95.Google Scholar
55 This statement is based on membership and occupational data in Cardiff COS, Annual Report, 1895: Infirmary, Annual Report, 1895; Daniel Owen and Co's Wright's Directory, 1894–1895.
56 Perkin, H., The Origins of Modern English Society, 1780–1880 (London, 1969), ch. VII, has a good discussion of class ideals.Google Scholar
57 Houghton, W. E., The Victorian Frame of Mind (New Haven, 1957), pp. 273–81, 291–97Google Scholar; Chesney, K., The Victorian Underworld (London, 1970), pp. 222–28Google Scholar; Webb, B., My Apprenticeship, with an introd. by MacKenzie, N. (Cambridge, 1979), p. 197.Google Scholar
58 Hobson, S. to Tom, Jones and others, 25 02 1896; J. S. MacKenzie to Tom Jones, 28 February; B. Evans to Tom Jones, 1 March, Thomas Jones Papers, Class X, Vol. 2.Google Scholar
59 University College of South Wales and Monmouthshire Magazine, XIII (1900). There is a copy in the Thomas Jones Papers, ibid.
60 Welsh University Association for the Furtherance of Social Work, Cardiff Branch Annual Reports, 1901-14; CT, 24 June and 15 July 1899; 19 October 1901; 18 October 1902; 11 July 1903. Bull, B. M., The Cardiff University Settlement (Cardiff, 1965)Google Scholar, gives a good account. Glasgow, G., Ronald Burrows, A Memoir (London, 1924), pp. 80–118Google Scholar; Daunton, , “Aspects”, pp. 490–91Google Scholar; Inglis, K., Churches and the Working Classes in Victorian England (London, 1963), pp. 159–60Google Scholar. Settlements in the United States (like Cardiff) tended to be secular, see Davis, A. F., Spearheads for Reform (New York, 1967), pp. 15–16.Google Scholar
61 E.g., CT. 9 October 1863; 15 April and 24 June 1871; 19 July 1884; SWDN, 23 11 1893.Google Scholar
62 SWDN, 29 11 1893.Google Scholar
63 See Genovese, E., Roll, , Jordan, Roll; The World the Slaves Made (New York, 1974)Google Scholar; Stampp, K. M., The Peculiar Institution (New York, 1956).Google Scholar
64 Johnstone, W., The Welsh at Home (Cardiff, 1904), ch. XXXVI, esp. p. 371.Google Scholar
65 Cardiff Infirmary, Annual Reports, 1877, 1888 and 1909.
66 Morrison, A., A Child of the Jago (London, 1971), pp. 104–05.Google Scholar
67 Greenwood, W., Love on the Dole (London, 1933), p. 217; see also p. 144.Google Scholar
68 Cardiff COS, Directory of Charities, 1910: CT. 3 October 1875: 20 August 1881: 5 December 1885.
69 Williams, R., Keywords (London, 1976), p. 46 (sub Charity).Google Scholar
You have
Access
