Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-n9wrp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-20T20:20:16.389Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From Etelāʿāti to Eslāhtalabi: Saʿid Hajjarian, Political Theology and the Politics of Reform in Post-Revolutionary Iran

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

Eskandar Sadeghi-Boroujerdi
Eskandar Sadeghi-Boroujerdi*
Affiliation:
Oxford University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article examines the importance of the political thought and praxis of politico, ‘reformist’ strategist and intellectual, Saʿid Hajjarian, and his rethinking of the post-revolutionary Iranian state’s sources and bases of legitimacy in the 1990s and 2000s. It also provides an exposition and assessment of a number of his recommendations for the realisation of ‘political development’ (towseʿeh-ye siyāsi) in the post-revolutionary order and their contribution to the discourse of eslāhāt during the presidency of Hojjat al-Islam Mohammad Khatami (1997–2005). Moreover, it attempts to situate Hajjarian within a broader spectrum of reformist political opinion and its proponents within the Islamic Republic of Iran’s political class.

Keywords

Saʿid HajjarianPolitical TheologyPost-revolutionary IranReformMohammad Khatami Administration1997–2005
Type
Articles
Information
Iranian Studies , Volume 47 , Issue 6 , November 2014 , pp. 987 - 1009
Copyright
Copyright © 2014 The International Society for Iranian Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The author would like to express his deepest gratitude toward Homa Katouzian, Ali Ansari, Nasser Mohajer, Siavush-Randjbar-Daemi, and Faisal Devji for their comments on previous drafts of this piece of research.

References

Ansari, Ali M. Iran, Islam and Democracy: The Politics of Managing Change. 2nd ed. London: Chatham House, Royal Institute of International Affairs, 2006.Google Scholar
Aqajari, Hashem, Khojasteh-Rahimi, Reza, and Bala'i, Amir Hossein. “Sharh-e zendegi-ye yek enqelābi-ye nāārām: goftogu bā Hāshem Āqājari.” Andisheh-ye puyā 2, no. 11 (Mehr-Ābān 1392 [October–November 2013]).Google Scholar
Arjomand, Said Amir. After Khomeini: Iran Under His Successors. Kindle ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009.Google Scholar
Armin, Mohsen. “Negāhi kutāh beh barkhi az teif bandi-hā-ye jadid-e fekri-siyāsi-ye jāme'eh.” 'Asr-e mā (7 Dei 1373 [December 28, 1994] through to 10 Khordad 1374 [May 31, 1995]).Google Scholar
Armin, Mohsen. “Nezārat-e estesvābi va moshārekat-e siyāsi.” In Islam, ejmā', siyāsat. Tehran: Zekr, 1380 [2001].Google Scholar
Baqi, Emadeddin. “Hadaf-e tarāhān-e terur barchidan-e dowlat-e Khātami va hazf-e jebheh-ye Dovvom-e Khordād bud [Āftāb-e emruz, 16 Farvardin 1379 (04/04/2000)].” In Barāye tārikh: goftogu ba Sa'id Hajjāriān. Tehran: Nashr-e ney, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Bashiriyeh, Hossein. “Moshārekat-e siyāsi, reqābat-e siyāsi va towse'eh-ye siyāsi.” In 'Aql dar siyāsat. Tehran: Negāh-e mo'āser, 1382 [2003].Google Scholar
Bashiriyeh, Hossein, and Sadeghi-Boroujerdi, Eskandar. “Interview with Professor Hossein Bashiriyeh.” June 1, 2013.Google Scholar
Bottomore, Tom. Elites and Society. Kindle; 2nd ed. London: Routledge, 1993.Google Scholar
Buchta, Wilfried. Who Rules Iran? The Structure of Power in the Islamic Republic. Washington, DC: Washington Institute for Near East Policy and the Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, 2000.Google Scholar
Chehabi, H. E. Iranian Politics and Religious Modernism: The Liberation Movement of Iran under the Shah and Khomeini. London: I. B. Tauris, 1990.Google Scholar
Chehabi, H. E., and Linz, Juan J.. “A Theory of Sultanism 1: A Type of Nondemocratic Rule.” In Sultanistic Regimes, edited by Linz, Juan J. and Chehabi, H. E.. Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1998.Google Scholar
Forti, Marina. “Arg-e Jadid: A California Oasis in the Iranian Desert.” Chap. 2 In Evil Paradises: Dreamworlds of Neoliberalism, edited by Davis, Mike and Monk, David Bertrand. New York: The New Press, 2007.Google Scholar
Ganji, Akbar. “The Latter-Day Sultan: Power and Politics in Iran.” Foreign Affairs 87, no. 6 (2008).Google Scholar
Ganji, Akbar. “Rowshanfekrān va goftemān-e 'ālijenāb [Originally published in 'Asr-e āzādegān, no. 92, 9 Bahman 1378 (29/01/2000)].” In Hāshemi-Rafsanjāni va Dovvom-e Khordād. Tehran: Rowzaneh, 1380 [2001].Google Scholar
Ganji, Akbar, et al. “Matn-e sokhanrāni-hā-ye ruz-e avval.” In Konforāns-e Berlin; khedmat yā khiyānat, edited by 'Ali Zakaria'i, Mohammad. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Hairi-Yazdi, Mehdi, and Sedghi, Zia. “Mehdi Hairi-Yazdi.” Iranian Oral History Collection, Harvard University, January 28, February 4, 1989 and April 29, 1992.Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Bohrān-e dowgānegi dar qodrat.” In 'Obur az Khātami, edited by Sotudeh, Amir Reza. Tehran: Zekr, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Dovvom-e Khordād: omid-hā va bim-hā: payām-hā va cheshm-andāz-hā.” Rāh-e now, no. 5 (2 Khordād 1377 [May 23, 1998]).Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Falsafeh-ye entekhābāt [Originally published in 'Asr-e mā, no. 90, 1376/12/06 (25/02/1998)].” In Jomhuriyat; afsun zodā'i az qodrat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1389 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Farāyand-e 'orfi shodan-e feqh-e Shi'eh [Originally published in Kiyān, no. 24, Farvardin-Ordibehesht 1374 (April–May 1995)].” In Az shāhed-e qodsi tā shāhed-e bāzāri: 'orfi shodan-e din dar sepehr-e siyāsat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1380 [2001].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Imām Khomeini, faqih-ye dowrān-e gozār: az feqh-e javāheri tā feqh al-maslahat [Originally published in Kiyān, no. 46, Farvardin-Ordibehesht 1378 (March–April 1999)].” In 'Orfi shodan-e din dar sepehr-e siyāsat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1380 [2001].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. ”Mashruteh-talabi.” In Eslāhāt dar barābar-e eslāhāt: goftogu'i-ye enteqādi. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1382 [2003].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Mesbāh-Yazdi dar kākh-e zojāji [Originally published in 'Asr-e mā, no. 101, 21/05/1377 (12/08/1998)].” In Jomhuriyat; afsun zodā'i az qodrat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Nahveh-ye bāz towlid-e saltanat dar andisheh-ye khelāfat va velāyat [First published in 'Asr-e mā, no. 95, 30/02/1377 (20/05/1998)].” In Jomhuriyat; afsun zodā'i az qodrat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Naqdi bar nazariyeh-ye “Farbehtar az idi'olozhi” [Originally published in Kiyān, no. 15, Mehr-Ābān 1372 (September–October 1993)].” In Az Shāhed-e qodsi tā shāhed-e bāzāri: 'orfi shodan-e din dar sepehr-e siyāsat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1380 [2001].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Pāsdāri az qānun-e āsāsi, rāhi barāye nowsāzi-ye siyāsi [Originally published in 'Asr-e mā, no. 85, 1376/9/26 (17/12/1997)].” In Jomhuriyat; afsun zodā'i az qodrat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Sākht-e eqtedār-e soltāni, āsibpazir-hā va badil-hā.” Etelā'āt-e siyāsi-eqtesādi, no. 2 (1374 [1995]).Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Sharhi bar marāmnāmeh-ye jebheh-ye moshārekat-e Irān-e eslāmi.” Moshārekat, no. 27 (18 Shahrivar 1378 [September 9, 1999]).Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “Tallaqi-ye ākādemik az towse'eh-ye siyāsi.” Rāhbord, no. 1 (Bahār 1371 [Spring 1992]): 38–48.Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid. “‘Velāyat-e motlaqeh-ye faqih’ va ‘qānun-e āsāsi’ (1) [Originally published in 'Asr-e mā, no. 61, 1375/11/19 (07/02/1997)].” In Jomhuriyat; afsun zodā'i az qodrat. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1389 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid, and Baqi, Emadeddin. “Goftogu bā Saʿid Hajjāriān.” In Barāye tārikh: goftogu bā Sa'id Hajjāriān. Tehran: Nashr-e ney, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Saʿid, and Ehsani, Kaveh. “‘Existing Political Vessels Cannot Contain the Reform Movement’: A Conversation with Sa'id Hajjarian.” Middle East Report, no. 212 (Autumn 1999).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hajjarian, Sa'id, and Khojasteh-Rahimi, Reza. “Eslāhātchi, cheriki nemishavad: sharh-e yek zendegi-ye siyāsi-fekri.” Andisheh-ye puyā (Tir-Mordād 1391 [July–August 2012]).Google Scholar
Hajjarian, Sa'id, and Salimi, Hossein. “Suteh delān gerd-e ham āmadand: goftogu bā Sa'id Hajjāriān.” In Kālbodshekāfi-ye zehniyat-e eslāhgarāyān, edited by Salimi, Hossein. Tehran: Gām-e now, 1384 [2005].Google Scholar
Kadivar, Mohsen. “Mosāhebeh bā ruznāmeh-ye Khordād.” In Bahā-ye āzādi: defā'iyat-e Mohsen Kadivar dar dādgāh-e vizheh-ye rowhāniyat, edited by Kadivar, Zahra Rudi. Tehran: Nashr-e ney, 1378 [1999].Google Scholar
Kahn, Paul W. Political Theology: Four New Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty. New York: Columbia University Press, 2011.Google Scholar
Karubi, Mehdi. “Matn-e kāmel-e nāmeh-ye Mehdi Karubi beh rahbar-e jomhuri-ye eslāmi.” BBC Persian. Accessed January 2, 2013. http://www.bbc.co.uk/persian/iran/story/2005/06/050619_karoubi-objection.shtmlGoogle Scholar
Khatami, Mohammad. “Din va siyāsat (29/10/1376 [19/1/1998]).” In Islām, rowhāniyat va enqelāb-e eslāmi. Tehran: Tarh-e now, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Khatami, Mohammad. “Rowhāniyat, bayad-hā va nabayad-hā (1/7/1376 [23/9/1997]).” In Islām, rowhāniyat va enqelāb-e eslāmi. Tehran Tarh-e now, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Khatami, Mohammad-Reza, and Salimi, Hossein. “Tasavor-e piruzi nemikardim: goftogu bā Mohammad-Rezā Khātami.” In Kālbodshekāfi-ye zehniyat-e eslāhgarāyān. Tehran: Gām-e now, 1384 [2005].Google Scholar
Khomeini, Ruhollah. Sahifeh-ye Imām. 21 vols. Vol. 20, Tehran: Mo'asseseh-ye tanzim va nashr-e āsār-e Imām Khomeini, 1378 [1999].Google Scholar
Matsunaga, Yasuyuki. “The Secularization of a Faqih-Headed Revolutionary Islamic State of Iran: Its Mechanisms, Processes, and Prospects.” Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East 29, no. 3 (2009). doi: 10.1215/1089201X-2009-032CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mehrpur, Hossein. Ra'is-e jomhur va ma'suliyat-e ejrā'i-ye qānun-e āsāsi. 2 vols. Vol. 1. Tehran: Etelā'āt, 2001.Google Scholar
Mesbah-Yazdi, Mohammad-Taqi. “Hokumat va mashru'iyat.” Ketāb-e naqd 2, no. 7 (1377 [1998]): 42–77.Google Scholar
“Mo'arefi-ye markaz-e tahqiqāt-e esterātezhik.” Rāhbord, no. 3 (Bahār 1373 [Spring 1994]): 228–232.Google Scholar
Modarressi Tabataba'i, Hossein. An Introduction to Shiʿi Law: A Bibliographical Study. London: Ithaca Press, 1984.Google Scholar
Modonesi, Massimo. Subalternity, Antagonism, Autonomy: Constructing the Political Subject. Translated by Garrido, Adriana V. Rendon and Roberts, Philip. Kindle ed. London: Pluto Press, 2014.Google Scholar
Nateq-Nuri, Ali-Akbar, and Mirdar, Morteza. Khāterat-e Hojjat al-Islam 'Ali-Akbar Nāteq-Nuri. Vol. 2. Tehran: Markaz-e asnād-e enqelāb-e eslāmi, Autumn 1384 [2005].Google Scholar
Piscatori, James P. “Religion and Realpolitik: Islamic Responses to the Gulf War.” In Islamic Fundamentalism and the Gulf Crisis, edited by James, P. Piscatori: American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 1991.Google Scholar
Ravanbakhsh, Mohammad Hossein, and Madadi-Ta'emeh, Ahmad. Andisheh va aqāyān-e khoshunat. Tehran: Mo'alefān, 1379 [2000].Google Scholar
Sahabi, 'Ezatollah. Nim-e qarn-e khātereh va tajrobeh: khāterāt-e mohandes 'Ezatollāh Sahābi; sāl-hā-ye 1357 ta 1379. Paris: Khāvarān, 2013.Google Scholar
San'ati, Reza. Goftemān-e Mesbāh: gozāreshi az zendegāni va mavāze'-e 'elmi-siyāsi-ye Ayatollāh Mesbāh-Yazdi. Tehran: Markaz-e asnād-e enqelāb-e eslāmi, 1387 [2008].Google Scholar
Shadlu, 'Abbas. “Hezb-e jebheh-ye moshārekat-e Irān-e eslāmi.” In Etelā'āti dar bāreh-ye ahzāb va jenāh-hā-ye siyāsi-ye Irān-e emruz. Tehran: Nashr-e vozarā', 1387 [2008].Google Scholar
Shams, Abdollah. Qānun-e asāsi: az farmān-e mashrutiyat tā emruz. Tehran: Dark, 1386 [2007].Google Scholar
Sorush, 'Abdolkarim. “Farbehtar az idi'olozhi.” In Farbehtar az idi'olozhi. Tehran: Mo'asseseh-ye farhangi-e Serāt, 1372 [1993].Google Scholar
Stecklow, Steve, Dehghanpisheh, Babak, and Torbati, Yeganeh. “Khamenei Controls Massive Financial Empire Built on Property Seizures.” Reuters. November 11, 2013.Google Scholar
Weber, Max. “Science as a Vocation.” In From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology edited by Gerth, H. H. and Wright Mills, C.. New York: Routledge, 1991.Google Scholar