Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-r5zm4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-05T11:16:27.126Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘A transient apparition’: British policy towards the de Valera government, 1932-5

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2016

Deirdre McMahon
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

During the imperial conference of 1930 a senior British official vented his exasperation at the demands of the Irish delegation, commenting ‘surely de Valera could not be worse than this. If their opponents came into power, this might clear the air. We might get rid of this sapping by which we are losing much and gaining little goodwill.’

In retrospect, as many British ministers and officials would have ruefully admitted, this view had much to commend it. But the peculiar circumstances surrounding Eamon de Valera’s accession to power, followed so soon by a major disturbance in Anglo-Irish relations, instead of clearing the air, fogged it with tension, rumour and misunderstanding. In such an atmosphere rational assessments of the new Irish leader and his policy were at a premium.

Type
Articles
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 22 , Issue 88 , September 1981 , pp. 331 - 361
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 1981

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hall, H. Duncan, Commonwealth (London, 1969), p. 813.Google Scholar

2 W T Cosgrave to J.H. Thomas, 21 Nov. 1931 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/93/4020/246).

For permission to quote from copyright material the author would like to express her gratitude to the controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office; the keeper of the Public Records (London); the University of Birmingham Library; Kent County Council; the trustees of the Smuts Archive; and Lord Hankey. Efforts to trace the heirs of Lord Sankey, Lionel Curtis, Sir Charles Dixon and Ernest Brown have failed and the author apologises for any inadvertent breach of copyright.

3 Patrick McGilligan to J. H. Thomas, 21 Nov 1931 (ibid.).

4 Note by Sir Harry Batterbee, 17 Nov. 1931 (ibid.).

5 Pakenham, Frank, Peace by ordeal (2nd ed., London, 1962), pp 334–5.Google Scholar

6 Lecky, WE.H., The leaders of public opinion in Ireland (2nd ed., London, 1871), pp ix-x.Google Scholar

7 Buckland, Patrick, The factory of grievances: devolved government in Northern Ireland, 1921–39 (Dublin, 1979)Google Scholar; Johnson, D.S., ‘Northern Ireland as a problem in the economic war, 1932–8, in I.H.S., 22, no. 86 (Sept. 1980), pp 144–61.Google Scholar

8 MacDonald to Sir Abe Bailey, 22 July 1932 (P.R.O., MacDonald papers, P.R.O. 30/69/1442).

9 Diary, 15 July 1932 (Bodl., Sankey papers, MSS Eng. hist. C509 e.286).

10 MacDonald, Malcolm, Titans and others (London, 1972), p. 60.Google Scholar

11 Memorandum by Thomas, Feb. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 24/228, CP 86 (32)).

12 I.S.C. meeting, 5 May 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

13 Ibid.

14 I.S.C. meeting, 9 May 1932 (ibid.).

15 Hansard 5 (commons), cclxv, 1914 (11 May 1932).

16 Memorandum on the political situation in the Irish Free State by Ralph Glyn, Sept. 1932 (P.R.O., PREM 1/132).

17 MacDonald to Thomas, 7 Sept. 1932 (P.R.O., MacDonald papers, P.R.O. 30/69/678).

18 Note by Glyn, 18 Jan. 1933 (P.R.O., PREM 1/132).

19 Lionel Curtis to Tom Jones, 5 Jan. 1933 (Bodl., Curtis papers, MSS Curtis 90).

20 Smuts to A.Gillett, 13 July 1932 (Cambridge University Library, Smuts papers (microfilm)).

21 Peters to Batterbee, 30 May 1935 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/399/1111 la/179).

22 Peters to Batterbee, 8 Apr. 1932 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/397/11111/119).

23 Minute by B. E. F Gage, 21 July 1932 (P.R.O., F.O. 627/40/U429/15/750).

24 Note by Harding of meeting with P.J. Fleming, 28 July 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/463).

25 Dr Ralph Oldham to ministry of pensions, 17 July 1932 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/397/11111/261).

26 Memorandum by Thomas and Hailsham, 8 June 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/525,1.S.C. (32) 26).

27 Neville Chamberlain to Hilda Chamberlain, 11 June 1932 (Birmingham University Library, Neville Chamberlain papers, NC 18/1/786).

28 Earl of Longford, and O’Neill, Thomas P, Eamon de Valera (London, 1970), p. 286.Google Scholar

29 Papers relating to the parliamentary oath of allegiance in the Irish Free State, and to the land purchase annuities, p. 5 [Cmd. 4056], H.C. 1931–2, xiv, 273.

30 Memorandum by Home Office, 8 Mar. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/500, LPA (32) 5).

31 Memorandum by Foreign Office, 8 Mar. 1932 (ibid., LPA(32)3).

32 Memorandum by Board of Trade, 9 Mar 1932 (ibid., LPA (32) 4).

33 Memorandum by Chamberlain, 8 Mar. 1932 (ibid., LPA (32) 2).

34 Minute by S. D. Waley, 26 June 1932 (P.R.O., T 160/587/F5716/04/1).

35 Neville Chamberlain to Ida Chamberlain, 5 Nov. 1932 (Birmingham University Library, Neville Chamberlain papers, NC 18/1/804).

36 Note by Board of Trade, 25 June 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 24/231, C.P 227 (32), appendix iv).

37 Cabinet meeting, 29 June 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 23/71).

38 Note by Peters, 14 July 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/525, I.S.C (32)44).

39 Unpublished memoirs of Sir Charles Dixon (Royal Commonwealth Society Library, Dixon memoirs, pp 46–7).

40 Memorandum by Thomas including correspondence with dominions, 4 Apr 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/525, I.S.C. (32) 6).

41 Ibid.

42 Ibid.

43 Memorandum by Dominions Office, 11 Apr. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/525, I.S.C. (32) 12).

44 Martin, Ged, ‘The Irish Free State and the evolution of the Commonwealth, 1921–49’ in Hyam, Ronald and Martin, Ged (eds), Reappraisals in British imperial history (London, 1975), p. 206.Google Scholar

45 I.S.C. meeting, 12 Apr. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

46 Dawson, R.M., The development of dominion status (Oxford, 1937), p. 122 Google Scholar; Hall, , Commonwealth, p. 810.Google Scholar

47 Neville Chamberlain to Anne Chamberlain, 22 July 1932 (Birmingham University Library, Neville Chamberlain papers, NC 1/26/468).

48 Whiskard to Harding, 25 July 1932 (P.R.O., D.O. 121/61).

49 Cabinet meeting, 27 Aug. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 23/72).

50 I.S.C. meeting, 27 Sept. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

51 Memorandum by Runciman, 4 Oct. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/525, I.S.C. (32) 68).

52 Neville Chamberlain to Hilda Chamberlain, 26 Nov. 1932 (Birmingham University Library, Neville Chamberlain papers, NC 18/1/807).

53 Minute by Stephenson and Dixon, Nov. 1932 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/384/10725/143).

54 Note by Batterbee, 25 Oct. 1932 (I.S.C. meeting, 25 Oct. 1932, P.R.O., Cab. 27/523, appendix I).

55 I.S.C. meeting, 25 Oct. 1932 (ibid.).

56 Notes by Batterbee, 14, 19 Nov. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/526, I.S.C. (32) 73).

57 I.S.C. meeting, 23 Nov. 1932 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

58 Lord Granard to Thomas, 16 Dec. 1932 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/384/10725/153).

59 Thomas went to Ireland in the spring of 1920 and saw Lloyd George on his return, urging him to stop the flow of munitions to Ireland. A few days later he told the commons prophetically ‘if there is an upheaval, the military, of course, will win. But will that settle the Irish problem? If Dublin runs red with blood tomorrow the Irish problem will remain and be more difficult to solve.’ ( Blaxland, Gregory, J. H. Thomas (London, 1964), pp 142–3.)Google Scholar

60 Dixon memoirs, pp 46–7.

61 Notes by Harding, 28 July, 16, 17 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/463, 473).

62 Note by Harding, 17 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/473).

63 Harding to Thomas, 21 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/474).

64 Explanatory note to draft articles (ibid.).

65 Draft articles (ibid.).

66 Note by Harding, 28 June 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/450).

67 Memorandum by Coupland on ‘Impressions of the political situation in the Irish Free State’, June-July 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/447).

68 In a conversation with the present writer, Lord Garner (private secretary to Malcolm MacDonald) was of the opinion that Harding was such a stickler for office protocol that he would never have permitted an outsider to have any hand in the drafting of an official document.

69 Minute by Harding, 25 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/447).

70 Minute by Harding, 22 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111/474).

71 Hansard 5 (commons), cclxxxi, 726–9 (14 Nov. 1933).

72 De Valera to Thomas, 29 Nov. 1933 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523, I.S.C. meeting, 30 Nov., appendix I).

73 Draft memorandum by Harding, Nov 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/1111 la/16).

74 I.S.C. meeting, 30 Nov. 1933 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

75 Cabinet meeting, 4 Dec. 1933 (P.R.O., Cab. 23/77).

76 I.S.C. meeting, 4 Dec. 1933 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

77 Hansard 5 (commons), cclxxxiii, 1457ff (5 Dec. 1933).

78 Hansard 5 (lords), xl, 335–42 (6 Dec. 1933).

79 Minute by Harding, 19 Dec. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111a/33).

80 South African house of assembly debates, xxii, 49 (30 Jan. 1934).

81 Seanad Eireann deb., xvii, 2015 (7 Dec. 1933).

82 Hansard 5 (commons), cclxxxiii, 114 (22 Nov. 1933).

83 Ibid., col. 217 (22 Nov. 1933).

84 Hankey to MacDonald, 10 Aug. 1930 (P.R.O., MacDonald papers, P.R.O. 30/69/357).

85 Thomas to Rothermere, 25 Jan. 1934 (Kent Archives Office, Thomas papers, U1625/C60).

86 Minute by Harding, 1 Sept. 1934 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/399/11111a/136).

87 Minute by Stephenson, July 1934 (P.R.O., D.O 35/399/11111a/98).

88 Markbreiter (Home Office) to Stephenson, 22 May 1933 (P.R.O., H.O. 45/17517/658446/20).

89 Report of inter-departmental tariff committee, 19 Dec. 1932 (P.R.O., T160/566/F13059/08/1).

90 Minute by Home Office, 29 Nov 1933 (P.R.O., H.O. 45/17517/658446/41).

91 I.S.C. meeting, 6 Mar 1933 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

92 Thomas to Chamberlain and Elliot, 3 Aug. 1933; Elliot to Thomas, 5 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/32).

93 Note by Customs, 2 Aug. 1933 (ibid.).

94 Helmore (Board of Trade) to Marsh, 16 Aug. 1933 (P R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/35).

95 Minute by Fergusson, 15 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., T160/613/F13522/1).

96 Minute by Chamberlain, 17 Aug. 1933 (ibid.).

97 Fergusson to Dominions Office, 30 Aug. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/35).

98 Minute by Whiskard, 4 Sept. 1933 (P R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/39).

99 Note by Dominions Office, Oct. 1933 (P.R.O., D O. 35/268/9249/45).

100 Report of inter-departmental tariff committee, 30 Nov. 1933 (P.R.O. H.O. 45/17517/658446/41).

101 Memorandum by Peters, 4 Dec. 1933 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/49).

102 Report of inter-departmental tariff committee, 8 Dec. 1933 (P.R.O., H.O. 45/17517/658446/41).

103 Hansard 5 (commons), cclxxxiv, 1307 (20 Dec. 1933).

104 Hansard 5 (commons), cclxxviii, 1275 (25 May 1933). The M.P was D. G. Grenfell who represented Gower (Glamorgan).

105 Eddison (department of overseas trade) to Dixon, 6 July 1934 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/398/11111a/98).

106 Note by Board of Trade, 9 Aug. 1934 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/399/11111a/106).

107 Note by Harding, 30 Oct. 1934 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/87).

108 Minute by Waterfield, 19 Nov 1934 (P.R.O., T 160/673/F14026/01/1).

109 Minute by Fisher, 11 Dec. 1934 (ibid.).

110 Brown to Runciman, 9 Nov. 1934 (Cambridge University Library, Baldwin papers, vol. 101).

111 Dickl, Horst, ‘Irland als Faktor der deutschen Aussenpolitik von 1933–45’ in Funke, Manfred (ed.), Hitler, Deutschland und die Mächte: Materiellen zur Aussenpolitik des Dritten Reiches (Bonner Schriften zur Politik und Zeitgeschichte, Band 12, Düsseldorf, 1976), pp 565–76.Google Scholar

112 Thomas to Elliot, 17 Nov. 1934 (P.R.O., D.O. 35/268/9249/87).

113 Report of inter-departmental tariff committee, 23 Nov. 1934 (P.R.O., T 160/673/F14026/01/1).

114 I.S.C. meeting, 29 Nov. 1934 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/523).

115 Memorandum by Thomas, 19 Dec. 1934 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/526, I.S.C. (32)93).

116 Batterbee to MacDonald (telephone conversation), 17 Jan. 1935 (P.R.O., MacDonald papers, P.R.O., 30/69/7).

117 Memorandum by Thomas, 22 Dec. 1934 (P.R.O., Cab. 27/526, I.S.C.(32)95).

118 Thomas to Runciman, 2 Feb. 1935 (P.R.O., T 172/1829).

119 Lecky, W E.H., The leaders of public opinion in Ireland (2nd ed., London, 1871), p. viii.Google Scholar