Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-vsgnj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T10:30:39.727Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Balance Sheets for the Acquisition, Retention and Loss of European Empires Overseas*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 June 2011

Patrick Karl O'Brien  and
Leandro Prados de la Escosura
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Our essay will critically survey and attempt to offer an overall interpretation of a growing volume of publications by historians who have attempted to evaluate the costs and benefits for Europe's domestic economies flowing from some five centuries of involvement with empires overseas. That involvement began with the conquest of Ceuta by the Portuguese in 1417 and passed through two epochs: 1417-1825 and 1825-1974. After a first conjuncture marked by the French Revolution, a quarter of a century of global warfare and movements for independence in Southern America, Britain emerged as the hegemonic imperial power in Europe. Its major rivals for commerce and dominion in Africa, Asia and the Americas (Portugal, Spain, France and Holland) ceded control over parts of their possessions overseas to Britain or (in the cases of Spain and Portugal), lost sovereignty over their colonies in Latin America.

Type
Articles
Information
Itinerario , Volume 23 , Issue 3-4 , November 1999 , pp. 25 - 52
Copyright
Copyright © Research Institute for History, Leiden University 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 See the massive bibliographies included in the new series edited by Russell-Wood, John ed., An Expanding World: The European Impact on World History, 1450–1800 (Aldershot 1995)Google Scholar.

2 Offer seems unconvinced by the polemical tradition surveyed by Wood, British Economists and Empire, which is based on the assumption that the costs and benefits of empires are separable in the ways proposed by this essay ‘Costs and Benefits, Peace and War’. Wood, John, British Economists and Empire (London 1993)Google Scholar; Offer, , ‘Costs and Benefits, Peace and War’, 690–711Google Scholar.

3 Fischer, Wolfram, McInnis, R. Marvin, and Schneider, Jurgen eds, The Emergence of a World Economy, 1500–19141: 1500–1850 (Wiesbaden 1986)Google Scholar.

4 Braudel, Fernand, Civilization and Capitalism, 15th-18th Century I: The Perspective of the World (New York 1984)Google Scholar.

5 Forsyth, Peter and Nicholas, Stephen, ‘The Decline of Spanish Industry and the Price Revolution: A Neo-Classical Analysis’, Journal of European Economic History 12/3 (1983) 601–610Google Scholar.

6 Steensgaard, Niels, ‘Commodities, Bullion and Services in Intercontinental Transactions before 1750’ in: Pohl, Hans ed., The European Discovery of the World and Its Economic Effects on Pre-Industrial Society, 1500–1800 (Stuttgart 1990) 9–24Google Scholar.

7 Barrett, Ward B., ‘World Bullion Flows’ in: Tracy, James ed., The Rise of Merchant Empires: Long-Distance Trade in the Early Modern World, 1350–1750 (Cambridge 1990) 224–254CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Flynn, Dennis O. and Giraldez, Arturo eds, Metals and Monies in An Emerging Global Economy (Aldershot/Hampshire 1997)Google Scholar.

9 Parker, Geoffrey, ‘Europe and the Wider World 1500-1700: The Military Balance’ in: Tracy, James D. ed., The Political Economy of Merchant Empires (Cambridge 1991) 161–195CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Tilly, Charles, Coercion, Capital and European States, AD 990–1990 (Cambridge 1990)Google Scholar.

11 Jones, Eric, The European Miracle: Environments, Economies, and Geopolitics in the History of Europe and Asia (Cambridge 1981) 104–153Google Scholar.

12 Yun-Casallila, Bartolome, ‘The American Empire and the Spanish Economy: An Institutional and Regional Perspective’, Revista de Historia Economica XVI/I (1998) 123–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar And Pedreira, Jorge, ‘To Have and To Have Not: The Economic Consequences of Empire’, Revista de Historia Economica XVI/1 (1998) 93–122CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Pedreira, Jorge, ‘La Economia Portuguesa y el fin del Imperio Luso Brasileno’ in: De La Escosura, Leandro Prados and Amarel, Samuel eds, La Independencia Americana: Consecuencias (Madrid 1993) 219–252. AndGoogle ScholarThompson, Ian A.A. and Yun-Casalilla, Bartolome eds, The Castillian Crisis of the Seventeenth Century: New Perceptions on the Economic and Social History of Seventeenth-Century Spain (Cambridge 1994)Google Scholar.

14 Butel, Paul and Crouzet, Francois, ‘Empire and Economic Growth: The Case of France’, Revista de Historia Económica e Social I (1998) 177–194CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Butel, Paul, ‘France, the Antilles and Europe in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries: Renewals of Foreign Trade’ in: Tracy, James D. ed., The Rise of Merchant Empires: Long Distance Trade in the Early Modern World, 1350–1750 (Cambridge 1990) 153–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Emmer, Pieter, ‘The Economic Impact of the Dutch Expansion Overseas 1570–1870’, Revista de Historia Económica XVI (1998) 157–176CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 de Vries, Jan and van der Woude, Ad, The First Modern Economy: Success, Failure, and Perseverance of the Dutch Economy, 1500–1815 (Cambridge 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Engerman, Stanley, ‘British Imperialism in a Mercantilist Age, 1492–1849: Conceptual Issues and Empirical Problems’, Revista de Historia Económica XVI (1998) 195–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Esteban, Javier Cuenca, ‘The Rising Share of British Industrial Exports in Industrial Output, 1700–1851’, The Journal of Economic History 57 (1997) 879–909CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

20 O'Brien, Patrick and Engerman, Stanley, ‘Exports and the Growth of the British Economy from the Glorious Revolution to the Peace of Amiens’ in: Solow, Barbara L. ed., Slavery and the Rise of the Atlantic System (Cambridge 1991) 177–209CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 O'Brien, Patrick, ‘Inseparable Connections: Trade, Economy, Fiscal State and the Expansion of Empire’ in: Marshall, Peter ed., The Oxford History of the British Empire II (Oxford 1998) 53–78Google Scholar.

22 Cited by: Kennedy, Paul, The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers: Economic Change and Military Conflict from 1500 to 2000 (London 1988) 123Google Scholar.

23 Gomes, Leonard, Foreign Trade and the National Economy (London 1987) 63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Bergesen, Albert ed., Studies of the Modern World-System (New York 1980) 237–238 andGoogle ScholarClark, George, The Balance Sheet of Imperialism (New York 1936) 23–28Google Scholar.

25 Porter, Bernard, Critics of Empire: British Radical Attitudes to Colonialism in Africa, 1895–1914 (London and New York 1968)Google Scholar.

26 Nunez, Clara-Eugenia ed., Debates and Controversies in Economic History (Madrid 1998)Google Scholar.

27 Davies, Lance E. and Huttenback, Robert A., Mammon and the Pursuit of Empire: The Political Economy of British Imperialism, 1860–1912 (Cambridge 1986)Google Scholar.

28 Bairoch, Paul, Economics and World History: Myths and Paradoxes (New York 1993)Google Scholar.

29 De La Escosura, Leandro Prados and Amaral, Samuel eds, La Independencia Americana: Consecuencias Económicas (Madrid 1993)Google Scholar.

30 Fraile, Pedro and Escribano, Alvaro, ‘The Spanish 1898 Disaster: The Drift towards National Protectionism’, Revista de Historia Económica XVI/1 (1998) 265–290CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 Clarence-Smith, William, ‘The Economic Dynamics of Spanish Colonialism in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries’, Itinerario XV/1 (1991) 71–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 The British Empire was nearly three times the area of the French empire; Clark, , The Balance Sheet of Imperialism, 23–28Google Scholar.

33 Brunschwig, Henri, Mythes et Realités de l'Impérialisme Colonial Français, 1871–1914 (Paris 1960)Google Scholar.

34 Snyder, Jack, Myths of Empire: Domestic Politics and International Ambition (Ithaca 1991)Google Scholar.

35 Especially for Italy see Federico, Giovanni, ‘Italy's Late and Unprofitable Forays into Empire’, Revista de Historia Económica XVI (1998) 377–402CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

36 Bairoch, Paul, Commerce Exterieur et Developpement Economique de l'Europe au XIXe Siècle (Paris 1976)Google Scholar is the best source for European data - see Nunez, , Debates and Controversies, 42–53Google Scholar.

37 The taxonomy of these arguments is critically appraised in Cain, Peter J., ‘Was it Worth Having? The British Empire, 1850–1950’, Revista de Historia Económica e Social XVI /I (1998) 351–376CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Edelstein, Michael, ‘Imperialism: Cost and Benefit’ in: Floud, Roderick and McCloskey, Donald eds, The Economic History of Britain since 1700 II (Cambridge 1994) 197–216Google Scholar.

39 Fraile, Pedro, Industrialización y Groupos de Presion: La Económoa Politica de la Proteccion en Espana (Madrid 1991)Google Scholar.

40 Lains, Pedro, ‘An Account of the Portuguese African Empire’, Revista de Historia Económica XVI (1998) 235–264CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 The Dutch case is perhaps almost analgous to the British - Van der Eng, Pierre, ‘Exploring Exploitation: The Netherlands and Colonial Indonesia, 1870–1939’, Revista de Historia Económica XVI (1998) 235–264Google Scholar.

42 Doyle, Michael W., Empires (Ithaca 1986)Google Scholar.

43 Kennedy, Paul, The Rise and Fall of British Naval Mastery (1983)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

44 See Blaut, James M., The Colonizer's Model of the World: Geographical Diffusionism and Eurocentric History (New York 1993)Google Scholar.

45 Alonso, Blanca Sanchez, Las Causas de la Emigración Espanola, 1880–1930 (Madrid 1995)Google Scholar.

46 Baines, Dudley, Emigration from Europe (Basingstoke 1991)Google Scholar.

47 Barratt-Brown, Michael, The Economics of Imperialism (Harmondsworth 1974)Google Scholar.

48 Fieldhouse, David K., Economics and Empire, 1830–1914 (London 1973)Google Scholar.

49 Davis, and Huttenbuck, , Mammon and the Pursuit of Empire, 106–110Google Scholar.

50 Bairoch, , Economics and World History, 77–81Google Scholar.

51 Hobson, John, Imperialism (Ann Arbor 1967)Google Scholar; Federico, ‘Italy's Late and Unprofitable Forays into Empire’, and Kennedy, William P., Industrial Structure, Capital Markets and the Origins of British Economic Decline (Cambridge 1987)Google Scholar.

52 Fraile, and Escribano, , ‘The Spanish 1898 Disaster’, 265–290 andGoogle ScholarMote, jordi Maluquer De, ‘El Mercardo Colonia Antillano en el Siglo XIX’ in: Nadal, Jordi and Torella, Gabriel eds, Agricultura, Commercio Colonial y Credmiento Economico en la Espagna Contemporanea (Barcelona 1974) 64–73Google Scholar.

53 Thornton, Archie, The Imperial Idea and Its Enemies (London 1959)Google Scholar.

54 Hobson, John M., The Wealth of States: A Comparative Sociology of International Economic and Political Change (Cambridge 1997) contains an excellent discussion of these problemsGoogle Scholar.

55 O'Brien, Patrick K., ‘The Security of the Realm and the Growth of the Economy 1688–1914’ in: Clarke, Peter and Trebilcock, Clive eds, Understanding Decline: Perceptions and Realities of British Economic Perfomance (Cambridge 1997) 61–72Google Scholar.

56 Lains, , ‘An Account of the Portuguese African Empire’, 235–264 andGoogle ScholarFederico, , ‘Italy's Late and Unprofitable Forays into Empire’, 352–376Google Scholar.

57 Clark, , The Balance Sheet of Imperialism, 36–38Google Scholar.

58 Offer, Avner, ‘The British Empire: A Waste of Money?’, Economic History Review 45/3 (1993) 215–238CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

59 Beckett, Ian and Gooch, John eds, Politicians and Defence: Studies in the Formulation of British Defence Policy (Manchester 1981)Google Scholar.

60 Keylor, William R., The Twentieth-Century World: An International History (New York/Oxford 1984)Google Scholar.

61 Hobson, The Wealth of States.

62 Williamson, Jeffrey, ‘Globalization Convergence and History’, The Journal of Economic History 56/2 (1996) 277–306 andCrossRefGoogle ScholarOffer, Avner, The First World War: An Agrarian Interpretation (Oxford 1989)Google Scholar.

63 O'Brien, Patrick K., ‘Intercontinental Trade and the Development of the Third World since the Industrial Revolution’, Journal of World History 8 (1997) 75–133CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

64 Betts, Raymond F., Europe Overseas: Phases of Imperialism (New York 1968)Google Scholar.

65 Bogart, Ernest L., Direct and Indirect Costs of the Great World War (New York 1919)Google Scholar.

66 Feinstein, Charles H. ed., Banking, Currency, and Finance in Europe between the Wars (Oxford 1995)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 Trachtenberg, Mark, Reparations in World Politics: France and European Economic Diplomacy (New York 1980)Google Scholar.

68 Capie, Forrest, Tariffs and Growth: Some Illustrations from the World Economy, 1850–1940 (Manchester 1994)Google Scholar.

69 Feinstein, Charles H., Temin, Peter and Toniolo, Gianni eds, The European Economy between the Wars (Oxford 1997)Google Scholar.

70 Maier, Charles S., Recasting Bourgeois Europe: Stabilization in France, Germany, and Italy in the Decade after World War I (Princeton 1975) andGoogle ScholarBroadberry, S.N., The Productivity Race: British Manufacturing in International Perspective, 1820–1990 (Cambridge 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

71 Zieberg, Georg e, World Economy and World Politics (Oxford 1990)Google Scholar.

72 van der Wee, Herman, Prosperity and Upheaval: The World Economy, 1948–1980 (Berkeley 1986)Google Scholar.

73 Lains, , ‘An Account of the Portuguese African Empire’, 235–264Google Scholar.

74 Balfour, Sebastian, The End of the Spanish Empire, 1898–1923 (Oxford 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

75 Cain, Peter J. and Hopkins, A.G., British Imperialism: Crisis and Deconstruction, 1914–1990 (London 1993)Google Scholar.

76 Alford, Bernard, Britain in the World Economy since 1880 (London 1996)Google Scholar.

77 Fieldhouse, David K., Colonial Empires since the Eighteenth Century (New York 1967)Google Scholar.

78 Betts, Raymond F., France and Decolonisation, 1900–1960 (New York 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

79 Federico, , ‘Italy's Late and Unprofitable Forays into Empire’, 377–402Google Scholar.

80 Rogowski, Ronald, Commerce and Coalitions: How Trade Affects Domestic Political Alignments (Princeton 1989)Google Scholar.

81 Van der Eng, , ‘Exploring Exploitation’, 291–321 andGoogle ScholarFitzgerald, Edward, ‘Did France's Colonial Empire Make Economic Sense? A Perspective from the Postwar Decade 1946–1956’, The Journal of Economic History XLVIII/2 (1988) 373–385CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

82 Maier, Charles S., In Search of Stability: Explorations in Historical Political Economy (Cambridge 1987)Google Scholar.

83 Johns, Richard A., Colonial Trade and International Exchange: The Transition from Autarky to International Trade (London/New York 1988)Google Scholar.

84 Crafts, Nicholas and Toniolo, Gianni eds, Economic Growth in Europe since 1945 (Cambridge 1996)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

85 Reynolds, Lloyd G., Economic Growth in The Third World, 1850–1980 (New Haven 1985)Google Scholar.

86 Lipson, Charles, Standing Guard: Protecting Foreign Capital in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries (Berkeley 1985)Google Scholar.

87 Kupchan, Charles A., The Vulnerability of Empire (Ithaca 1994)Google Scholar.

88 French, David, The British Way of Warfare, 1688–2000 (London 1990)Google Scholar.

89 Havinden, Michael and Meredith, David, Colonialism and Development: Britain and Its Tropical Colonies, 1850–1960 (London 1993)Google Scholar.

90 Kupchan, , The Vulnerability of Empire (Ithaca 1994)Google Scholar.

91 Holland, Robert F., European Decolonisation, 1918–1981: An Introductory Survey (Houndsmills 1985)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

92 Lynch, Frances M.B., France and the International Economy: From Vichy to the Treaty of Rome (London 1997)Google Scholar.

93 Darwin, John, Britain and Decolonisation: The Retreat from Empire in the Post-War World (Basing-stoke 1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

94 Offer, Avner, ‘The British Empire: A Waste of Money?’, Economic History Review 45/ 3 (1993) 215–238CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

95 Feinstein, Charles, ‘The End of Empire and the Golden Age’ in: Clarke, Peter and Trebilcock, Clive eds, Understanding Decline: Perceptions and Realities of British Economic Performance (Cambridge 1997) 212–233Google Scholar.

96 Webb, Michael, The Political Economy of Policy Coordination: International Adjustment since 1945 (Ithaca 1995)Google Scholar.

97 Lynch, ‘France and the International Economy’.

98 Landes, David, The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are so Rich and Some Are so Poor (London 1998)Google Scholar.

99 Liberman, Peter, Does Conquest Pay? The Exploitation of Occupied Industrial Societies (Princeton 1996)Google Scholar.