Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-5lx2p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-01T16:24:25.697Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Clio and Clifford Geertz

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 April 2010

C. Fasseur
C. Fasseur
Affiliation:
University of Leiden
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

It is now more than 25 years ago that the American anthropologist Clifford Geertz published his well-known book Agricultural Involution. The processes of ecological change in Indonesia. In this excellently written essay, Geertz to argue that involution rather than evolution had occurred in Java during the past century and a half. This process was said to be responsible for the stagnating development, the depression, on the Javanese countryside which was so easily discernable when Geertz was conducting his field research in East-Central Java during the 1950s within the framework of the so-called Mojokuto project, in which Mojokuto was the equivalent of the American Middletown. In brief, the involution thesis boils down to the theory that as a result of Dutch colonial intervention at the start of the nineteenth centuryJavanese rural society developed a very high degree of social homogeneity, while balancing on the edge of the minimum of subsistence or below it. This society was characterized by the absence of sharp class-differences or a clear social stratification, the presence of ‘shared poverty’ and the necessity, as the island became more and more densely populated, to cut the (rice) cake in smaller and smaller parts.

Type
Articles
Information
Itinerario , Volume 14 , Issue 2 , July 1990 , pp. 71 - 80
Copyright
Copyright © Research Institute for History, Leiden University 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Geertz, Clifford, Agricultural Involution. The Processes of Ecological Change in Indonesia (Berkeley 1963) 53.Google Scholar

2 Geertz, Clifford, ‘Culture and Social Change. The Indonesian Case’, Man 19 (1984) 511–532, especially 525 n. 5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 Ibidem, 512.

4 Husken, Frans, Een dorp op Java. Sociale differentialie in een boerengemeenschap, 1850–1980 village in java. Social differentiation in a rural community, 1850–1980) (Amsterdam 1988).Google Scholar

5 White, Benjamin, ‘Agricultural Involution’ and its Critics. Twenty Years after Clifford Geertz (The Hague 1983) 29–31.Google Scholar

6 Geertz, ‘Culture and Social Change’, 525 n. 5.

7 Fasseur, C., Kultuurstelsel en koloniale baten. De Nederlandse exploitatie van Java 1840–1860 (The Cultivation System and colonial profits. The Dutch exploitation of Java 1840–1860) (Leiden 1975); a revised edition in English will be published in early 1991 by Cornell University Southeast Asia Program, titled The Politics of Colonial Exploitation:Java, the Dutch and the Cultivation System.Google Scholar

8 Reinsma, R., Het verval van het cultuurstelsel (The decline of the cultivation system) ('s-Gravenhage 1955).Google Scholar

9 Elson, R.E., Javanese Peasants and the Colonial Sugar Industry. Impact and Change in an East Java Residency 1830–1940 (Singapore 1984).Google Scholar

10 Fernando, Radin, Peasants and Plantation Economy. The Social Impact of the European Plantation Economy in Cirebon Residency from the Cultivation System to the End of the. Eirst Decade of Twentieth Century (unpublished thesis; Monash University 1982);Google ScholarKnight, G.R., 'Capitalism and Commodity Production injava’ in: Alavi, Hamza ed., Capitalism and Colonial Production (London and Canberra 1982) 119–158Google Scholar.

11 Elson, R.E., The Cultivation System and ‘Agricultural Involution’ (Melbourne 1978).Google Scholar

12 Fasseur, C., ‘The Cultivation System and its Impact on the Dutch Colonial Economy and the Indigenous Society in Nineteenth-Century Java’ in: Bayly, C.A. and Kolff, D.H.A. ed., Two Colonial Empires (Leiden 1986) 137–154.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

13 Fasseur, C., ‘Some Remarks on the Cultivation System’ in: Acta Historiae Neerlandicae X (The Hague 1978) 143–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14 Fernando, Peasants and Plantation Economy, i.

15 Boomgaard, Peter, Children of the Colonial State. Population Growth and Economic Development injava, 1795–1880 (Amsterdam 1989).Google Scholar See also the highly critical review of this Ph.D. thesis by Roger Knight, ‘Nineteenth-Century Java: Some Recent Studies by Boom-gaard’, Peter, Asian Studies Review 14, 2 (11. 1990) 218–222Google Scholar.

16 Ibidem, 100.

17 Geertz, ‘Culture and Social Change’, 528 n. 17.

18 Verbaal of 25 Februar y 1862, no. 19, Archives of the Ministry of the Colonies 1850–1900, no. 1154, General State Archives, The Hague.

19 Boomgaard, , Children of the Colonial State, 100.Google Scholar

20 Geertz, , ‘Culture and Social Change’, 518–519.Google Scholar

21 Hüsken, , Een dorp op Java, 125.Google Scholar

22 Peper, Bram, ‘Population Growth in java in the 19th Century. A New Interpretation’ in: C. , Fasseur ed., Geld en geweten (Money and conscience) I (The Hague 1980) 131–151.Google Scholar

23 White, Benjamin, ‘Demand for Labour and Population Growth in Colonial Java’, Human Ecology 1 (1973) 244;CrossRefGoogle ScholarBoomgaard, Peter, ‘Female Labour and Population Growth on Nineteenth-Century Java’, Review of Indian and Malayan Affairs 15, 2 (1981) 19Google Scholar.

24 Geertz, ‘Culture and Social Change’, 525 n. 2.

25 Boeke, J.H., Dorpsherstel (Village reconstruction) (Leiden 1952) 17.Google Scholar

26 Elson, R. E., ‘Sugar Factory Workers and the Emergence of “Free Labour”’, Modern Asian Studies 20 (1986) 139–174, especially 172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar