Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-wxhwt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-08T12:53:28.497Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Liberia and the Universal Negro Improvement Association: The background to the abortion of Garvey's scheme for African colonization

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

M. B. Akpan
M. B. Akpan
Affiliation:
University of Lagos
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In July 1924, the Liberian government suddenly banned the Universal Negro Improvement Association from Liberia, and this after over four years of apparent co-operation with the Association in its plans to settle New World Negroes in Liberia and generally to aid Liberia financially. Yet the ban could not have surprised anyone familiar with Liberian matters. The Liberian economy, which at the advent of the Association in 1920 was in a very bad state, was beginning to recover independently of the Association. Moreover, Britain and France, which had colonies nearby, abhorred the Association's anti-colonialism crusade, and Liberia feared to alienate these powers. But most importantly, the ruling Americo-Liberian class feared that the Association's immigrants might challenge its already entrenched, privileged position in Liberia, and probably end its exploitation and oppression of Liberia's indigenous African population, which provided labour and revenue for this class and for the Liberian government generally.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 14 , Issue 1 , January 1973 , pp. 105 - 127
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1973

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Cronon, E. D., Black Moses: the Story of Marcus Garvey and the Universal Negro Improvement Association (Madison, 1964), 60.Google Scholar

2 For example, in Garvey, A. J., The Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey (New York, 1923), II,Google Scholar written by Garvey's wife, and understandably sympathetic to the Association, only four pages (164–7) are devoted to its colonization and development activities in Liberia. Her recent book, Garvey and Garveyism (Kingston, 1963), devotes only six pages (140–5) to these activities.Google ScholarWest's, RichardBack to Africa: A History of Sierra Leone and Liberia (London, 1970),Google Scholar is critical of Garvey, but discusses the Association's activities in Liberia in only four pages (270–3). Chalk's, Frank ‘Du Bois and Garvey confront Liberia: two Incidents of the Coolidge Years', Canadian Journal of African Studies, 1, no. 2 (1967), 135–41, examines fairly objectively the interests and plans which Du Bois and Garvey had for Liberia, and the extent to which they materialized.Google Scholar

3 See below p. 4 for explanation of the term 'Americo-Liberian'.

4 Garvey, , Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey, II, 364;Google ScholarGarvey and Garveyism, 140–I.

5 United States National Archives: Records of the Department of State relating to the Internal Affairs of Liberia 1909–1929,882.00/705, Johnson, J. L. to United States Secretary of State, Monrovia, 16 July 1921: enclosure, Garvey ‘to whom it may concern’, 1 Feb. 1921;Google Scholaribid. Garvey to Johnson, 1 Feb. 1921. Hereafter, these Records will be abbreviated as R.D.S.L.; the United States Secretary of State as ‘Secretary’, and the Archives as U.S.N.A.

6 Johnson was son-in-law of President King, son of the former Liberian President, Hilary R. W. Johnson (1884–92), a general in the Liberian army, and Mayor of Monrovia.

7 R.D.S.L. 882.00/705, Johnson, J. L. to Secretary, Monrovia, 16 July 1921: enclosure, Critchiow to Garvey, Monrovia, 24 July 1921.Google Scholar

8 Critchiow to Garvey, 24 July 1921, in R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

9 Ibid.

10 R.D.S.L. 882.00/705: enclosure, A. J. Henry to Thompson, Monrovia, 1 July 1921.

11 Garvey, , Garvey and Garveyism, 144.Google Scholar

12 Garvey, , Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey, 11, 366.Google Scholar

13 Cronon, , op. cit. 126;Google ScholarGarvey, Garvey and Garveyism, 141–2.Google Scholar

14 Acts of the Liberian Legislature, 1924–1925;Google ScholarCronon, , op. cit. 129.Google Scholar

15 Cronon, , op. cit. 130.Google Scholar

16 In 1919, C. D. B. King received 4,000 votes at the presidential elections, in which he was the only candidate. As the votes were usually inflated, and as the majority of the voters were Americo-Liberians, we might place the total Americo-Liberian population at about 5,000 about 1919. R.D.S.L. 882.00/772, Faulkner, T. J. R., ‘An Appeal to Reason [to the Liberian Public]’, Monrovia, 22 Dec. 1927.Google Scholar

17 Akpan, M. B., ‘The African Policy of the Liberian Settlers 1841–1932: A Study of the “Native” Policy of a non-colonial Power in Africa’ (Ph.D. Thesis, Ibadan University, 1968), 337–8.Google Scholar

18 Howard, Daniel E., Inaugural Address, 1 Jan. 1912;Google Scholar R.D.S.L. 882.00/730, S. P. Hood to Secretary, Monrovia, 26 Sept. 1922: enclosure, Sidney de la Rue to Hood, Monrovia, 14 Sept. 1922; Buell, R. L., The Native Problem in Africa (New York, 1928), II, 752.Google Scholar

19 U.S.N.A. Despatches of United States Ministers at Monrovia, 856.32, Smyth to Evarts, Monrovia, 22 Feb. 1881; R.D.S.L. 882.00/548, Elliot to Secretary, Freetown, July 1916.

20 Jones, H. A., ‘The struggle for political and cultural unification in Liberia’ (Ph.D. Thesis, North-Western University, 1962), 196.Google Scholar

21 Public Record Office, London: F.O. 84/1559, ‘Record of Proceedings, Liberian Boundary Mixed Commission’, 16 April 1879; Elliot, op. cit.

22 MS. American Colonization Society: Liberian Letters, 23, Sept. 1885, ‘Memorandum of Educated Grebos to President Johnson’; MS. A.C.S. Liberian Letters (uncatalogued), Chief Yula Gyude to Ormond Wilson, Cape Palmas, 15 Feb. 1910.

23 Only during the presidency of William V. S. Tubman (1944–71) were reforms introduced to give the Africans almost equal political rights with the settlers. These included the extension in of the franchise to all adult African males who paid the hut-tax, which did away with the ‘delegate’ system.

24 Akpan, , op. cit. 190–2; 267–70.Google Scholar

25 Taylor, H. R., Jungle Trader (London, 1939), 237;Google ScholarLiberian National Archives, Monrovia: Executive Mansion Papers: Cape Palmas Judiciary Department, 1921, Yancy to Barclay, Harper, I Nov. 1921; R.D.S.L. 882.00/580, Bundy to Secretary, Monrovia, 20 Feb. 1918. Hereafter, the Liberian Archives will be indicated by L.N.A.Google Scholar

26 R.D.S.L. 882.00/656, Kimberley, 18 July 1920, ‘Excerpts of Statement of Commissioner Mitchell with regards to the Republic of Liberia’; L.N.A. Report of the Secretary of the Treasury to the Senate and House of Representatives of the Republic of Liberia, Dec. 1921, 13–14.

27 Akpan, , OP. Cit. 367.Google Scholar

28 League of Nations: Report of the International Commission of Inquiry into the Existence of Slavery and forced Labour in the Republic of Liberia (Monrovia, 1930), 147–52.

29 Mills, D., Through Liberia (London, 1926), 63.Google Scholar

30 Prior to 1916 it was the poll-tax, levied haphazardly only from Africans living in, or visiting the Liberian settlements on the coast.

31 Jones, , op. cit. 216.Google Scholar

32 L.N.A. Report of the Secretary of the Treasury for the fiscal Year ended I Oct. 1919 to 30 Sept.. 1920, 16–17.

33 R.D.S.L. 882/5048, Bundy to Secretary, Monrovia. 20 Oct. 1920: enclosure, Sawyer to Mitchell, Monrovia, 6 Sept. 1920.

34 King, C. D. B., Annual Message, 13 Dec. 1923;Google Scholar L.N.A. Report of the Secretary of the Treasury for the fiscal Year ended 30 Sept. 1924, 5–6; Grimes, D. D., ‘The Economic Development of Liberia’ (M.A. Thesis, New York University, 1955), 18;Google ScholarBrown, G. W., The Economic History of Liberia (Washington, 1941), 184.Google Scholar

35 L.N.A. Report of the Secretary of the Treasury for the Fiscal Year ended 1 Oct. 1919 to 30 Sept. 1920, 10.

36 The Americo-Liberians, and educated Africans possessing the franchise were liable to a real-estate tax, license fees, school-tax, and judicial fees.

37 R.D.S.L. 882.00/591: enclosure, Report of the Secretary of War and Interior on his Trip to the Hinterland, February sixteenth to May thirty-first, 1918, Monrovia, 18 June 1918; C. D. B. King, Annual Message, 22 Dec. 1927.

38 Mitchell, T. C., ‘Report on Work in the Hinterland during 1916–1917 and 1918’, Monrovia, 30 May 1918, enclosed in R.D.S.L. 882.00/591, Bundy to Secretary, Monrovia, 24 Nov. 1918.Google Scholar

39 Durrant, R. E., Liberia: A Report by the Special Commissioner in West Africa for the African International Corporation Limited (London, 1925), 11–12.Google Scholar

40 Barclay, A., Annual Message, 15 Dec. 1904.Google Scholar

41 Sharpe, A., ‘The Hinterland of Liberia’, The Geographical Journal, LV (1920), 302;Google Scholar R.D.S.L. 882.00/365, Young, C. to United States War Department, Monrovia, 7 Oct. 1915; R.D.S.L. 882.00/658, Bundy, ‘Quarterly Diplomatic Report’, Monrovia, 2 Aug. 1919.Google Scholar

42 Howard, D. E., Annual Message, 19 Sept. 1916; Young, op. Cit.Google Scholar

43 R.D.S.L. 882.00/673, Bannermann, R. C., ‘Report on Conditions in Liberia’, New York, 2 Oct. 1920.Google Scholar

44 Buell, R. L., Liberia: a Century of Survival 1847–1947 (Philadelphia, 1947), 26.Google Scholar

45 Bannerman, , op. cit.,Google ScholarStarr, F., ‘Liberia after the World War’, Journal of Negro History, X (1925), 113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

46 King, C. D. B., Inaugural Address, 7 Jan. 1924, 2–3.Google Scholar

47 Buell, , The Native Problem in Africa, II, 769–70.Google Scholar

48 R.D.S.L. 882/o32/43, Bur to American Minister Resident, Monrovia, 1 Feb. 1923.

49 Butler, A. H., Intelligence Bureau: Liberia Bulletin, 13 July 1920;Google Scholar Buell, Liberia, a Century of Survival.…, 22–8.

50 Buell, , Liberia, a Century of Survival…, 28.Google Scholar

51 L.N.A. Report of the Secretary of the Treasury for the fiscal Year ended 1 Oct. 1919, to 30 Sep. 1920, 9; also Bannerman, op.cit.

52 Cronon, , op. cit. 106–8.Google Scholar

53 For reference to the tapering off of immigration to Liberia see E. Lyon, ‘A valuable and interesting Summary of Important Facts which had attracted International Attention’, Monrovia, 18 May 1909, in U.S.N.A. Despatches of United States Ministers at Monrovia, 12083/240–241; A.C.S. Eighty-Ninth Annual Report, Jan. 1906, 4, II; Ninetieth Annual Report, Jan 1907, 2–4, 10.

54 Cronon, op. Cit. 77.

55 Critchiow to Garvey, 24 July 1921. R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

56 Ibid.

57 Ibid.

58 Ibid.

59 R.D.S.L. 882.00/705: enclosure, Henry to Thompson, 1 July 1921.

60 Ibid.

61 Critchiow to Garvey, 24 July 1921, R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

62 Akpan, op. cit. 423–4.

63 League of Nations: Report of the International Commission of Inquiry…, 110–15, 168–70; R.D.S.L. 882.00/775, Francis to Secretary, Monrovia, 29 May 1928.

64 King, , Inaugural Address, 5 Jan 1920, 5.Google Scholar

65 Garvey, , The Philosophy and Opinions…, II, 364–5.Google Scholar

66 Akpan, , op. cit. 422.Google Scholar

67 Critchiow to Garvey, 24 July 1921, in R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

68 Ibid.

69 Ibid.

70 R.D.S.L. 882.00/705: enclosure, Henry to Thompson, I July 1921.

71 Critchlow to Garvey, 24 July 1921, R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

72 Barclay, A., Inaugural Address, Jan. 1904, in Liberia Bulletin, xxv, Nov. 1904, 72–96;Google Scholar Also ibid. xxviii, Feb. 1906, 62.

73 King, , Inaugural Address, 5 Jan 1920, 15.Google Scholar

74 R.D.S.L. 882.00/705: enclosure, Henry to Thompson, I July 1927.

75 Buell, , The Native Problem in Africa, II, 734.Google Scholar

76 R.D.S.L. 882.032/43, Bur to American Minister, Monrovia, I Feb. 1923; Buell, , The Native Problem in Africa, II, 767.Google Scholar

77 King, , Inaugural Address, 7 Jan. 1924, 9.Google Scholar

78 King, , Annual Message, 13 Dec. 1923, 7.Google Scholar

79 Ibid. 4, 8.

80 King, , Inaugural Address, 7 Jan 1924, 10.Google Scholar

81 King, , Annual Message, 13 Dec. 1923, 6–7.Google Scholar

82 King, , Annual Message, 20 Oct. 1926, 10.Google Scholar

83 The final agreement between the Liberian Government and Firestone was signed in 1926. See Buell, , The Native Problem in Africa, II, 882–3;Google ScholarKing, C. D. B., Annual Message, 22 Dec. 1927, 13.Google Scholar

84 King, , Inaugural Address, 7 Jan. 1924, 3.Google Scholar

85 Cronon, , op. cit. 194.Google Scholar

86 R.D.S.L. 882.00/703A, cable of American State Department to Johnson, Washington D.C. 25 May 1921.

87 R.D.S.L. 882.00/705, Johnson to Secretary, Monrovia, 16 July 1921.

88 R.D.S.L. 882.00/739, DuBois to Secretary, New York, 24 Mar. 1924. Also ibid. 882.00/742, U.S. State Department: ‘Memorandum of Conversation with Mr. DuBois, Special Representative of the President at the Inauguration of President King of Liberia’, 26 Mar. 1924.

89 R.D.S.L. 882.00/741, Hood to Secretary, Monrovia, 4 Mar. 1924.

90 Garvey, , Garvey and Garveyim, 129.Google Scholar

91 Critchlow to Garvey, 24 June 1921, R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

92 King, , Inaugural Address, 7 Jan. 1924, 10.Google Scholar

93 Chalk, , op. cit. 136;Google ScholarWest, , op. cit. 270;Google ScholarCronon, , op. cit. 130.Google Scholar

94 West, , op. cit. 270.Google Scholar

95 Ibid.

96 Ibid. 271.

97 Chalk, , op. cit. 136.Google Scholar

98 Akpan, , op. cit. 434–8;Google ScholarGreenwall, H. J. and Wild, R., Unknown Liberia (London, 1936), 203.Google Scholar

99 Critchiow to Garvey, 24 June 1921, R.D.S.L. 882.00/705.

100 Chalk, , op. cit. 141.Google Scholar

101 L.N.A. ‘An Act approving the Deportation of the emissaries of the Universal Negro Improvement Association by King, H. E. C. D. B., President of Liberia’, approved 14 Jan. 1925, Acts, 1924–1925.Google Scholar

102 Chalk, , op. cit. 141.Google Scholar

103 Cronon, , op. cit. 130.Google Scholar

104 Cronan, , op. cit. 131.Google Scholar