No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Certificate of Title: A Discussion of Contemporary Challenges to the Protection of Land Interests in Uganda
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 November 2022
Abstract
Certificates of title are a feature of the Torrens system of land registration which originated in Australia and which operates in Uganda. The system confers primary responsibility to register title, and guarantee its security, upon the state. A certificate of title is indefeasible and conclusive evidence of ownership, except in cases of fraud by the registered proprietor. This article uses a doctrinal legal research approach to analyse the legal framework on certificates of title, citing court decisions to give an interpretive lens to the law. It finds that the almost century-old system remains immature and its actualization is hampered by the socio-political context of Uganda. Certificates of title are a feature of a capitalist order and produce unfavourable outcomes, including fraud through double titling, illegal entries in the register and spurious caveats. Government needs to address the socio-political and administrative challenges inhibiting the evolution and practical application of the Torrens system in Uganda.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of SOAS University of London
Footnotes
*
Senior Lecturer at the School of Law, Makerere University. The author is grateful to Derrick Kunyiga Kizito, former LLB student at the School of Law, for collecting materials for the article.
References
1 JW Bruce and SE Migot-Adholla (eds) Searching for Land Tenure Security in Africa (1994, Kendall/Hunt).
2 Agbosu, LK “Land registration in Ghana: Past, present and the future” (1990) 34/2 Journal of African Law 104CrossRefGoogle Scholar; HWO Okoth-Ogendo “African land tenure reform” in J Heyer et al (eds) Agricultural Development in Kenya: An Economic Perspective (1976, Oxford University Press).
3 See Re An Application by GNM Mallo [1964] vol 1 East Africa at 31.
4 Laws of Uganda, Registration of Titles Act (RTA), cap 230, sec 59.
5 Feder, G and Onchan, T “Land ownership security and investment in Thailand” (1987) 69/2 American Journal of Agricultural Economics 311CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 P To, S Mahanty and A Wells-Deng “From ‘land to the tiller’ to the ‘new landlords’? The debate over Vietnam's latest land reforms” (2019) 8/8 Land 120, doi: 10.3390/land8080120, available at: <www.mdpi.com/journal/land> (last accessed 7 October 2022).
7 R Tchatchoua-Djomo et al “Defusing land disputes? The politics of land certification and dispute resolution in Burundi” (2020) 51/6 Development and Change 1454 at 1456, 1480.
8 Ibid.
9 H De Soto The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else (2000, Basic Books).
10 Id at 10; Makerere Institute of Social Research and the Land Tenure Center, Land Tenure and Agricultural Development in Uganda (June 1989).
11 J Oloka-Onyango When Courts Do Politics: Public Interest Law and Litigation in East Africa (2017, Cambridge Scholars Publishing) at 206.
12 K Deininger Land Policies for Growth and Poverty Reduction: World Bank Policy Research Report (2003, World Bank and Oxford University Press) at xxi.
13 N Kanji, L Cotula, T Hilhorst, C Toulmin and W Witten “Can land registration serve poor and marginalized groups?” (2005, International Institute for Environment and Development) at 1, available at: <https://pubs.iied.org/pdfs/12518IIED.pdf> (last accessed 6 December 2020).
14 Id at 2.
15 SE Migot-Adholla, F Place and W Oluoch-Kosura “Security of tenure and land productivity in Kenya” in Bruce and Migot-Adholla (eds) Searching for Land Tenure Security in Africa, above at note 1; JK Green “Evaluating the impact of consolidation of holdings, individualization of tenure, and registration of title: Lessons from Kenya” (1987, Land Tenure Center, University of Wisconsin–Madison paper 129); JP Plateau “Does Africa need land reform?” in C Toulmin and J Quan (eds) Evolving Land Rights, Policy and Tenure in Africa (2000, IIED).
16 Easterly, W “Institutions: Top down and bottom up?” (2008) 98/2 American Economic Review 95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 K Deininger and G Feder Land Registration, Governance, and Development: Evidence and Implications for Policy (2009, Oxford University Press) at 325.
18 I Shivji “Lawyers in neoliberalism: Authority's professional supplicants or society's amateurish conscience”, at 11, 17–19, available at: <http://mokoro.co.uk/land-rights-article/lawyers-in-neoliberalism-authoritys-professional-supplicants-or-societys-amateurish-conscience/> (last accessed 19 October 2022).
19 JM Baland and JA Robinson “Land and power” (2003, Centre for Economic Policy Research discussion paper 3800).
20 D Allen and D Lueck “Contract choice in modern agriculture: Cash rent versus crop share” (1992) 35/2 Journal of Law and Economics 397.
21 L Darkwa and P Attuquayefio “Killing to protect? Land guards, state subordination and human rights in Ghana” (2012) 9/17 Sur International Journal on Human Rights 141 at 143, 146–49.
22 Deininger and Feder Land Registration, above at note 17.
23 Besley, T “Property rights and investment incentives: Theory and evidence from Ghana” (1995) 103/5 Journal of Political Economy 903CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
24 Deininger and Feder Land Registration, above at note 17.
25 Id at 256.
26 Id at 238.
27 Id at 329.
28 Before the formation of Uganda as a sovereign entity, Buganda was one of the kingdoms that existed in the 19th century to the north of what came to be known as Lake Victoria in the East Africa region. It had a relatively organized political system and occupied a dominant political place in colonial Uganda and at independence. The kingdom of Buganda still exists as a recognized cultural institution under the laws of Uganda.
29 Meaning “ultimate owner of all land”.
30 HW West The Mailo System in Buganda: A Preliminary Case Study in African Land Tenure (1964, Government Printer) at 2–7; AB Mukwaya Land Tenure in Buganda: Present-day Tendencies (1953, East African Institute of Social Research / The Eagle Press no 1) at 12.
31 Hanson, H “A historical perspective on land transfer: ‘Showing the land’, survey, and registration in (B)Uganda from 1900–1950” (2011) 17/1 East African Journal of Peace and Human Rights 285Google Scholar at 286–87; West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 5.
32 Ibid; Hanson, ibid.
33 West, id at 5 and 9; Hanson, id at 3.
34 Ibid.
35 Id at 1.
36 West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 2.
37 Id at 6.
38 Oloka-Onyango, When Courts Do Politics, above at note 11 at 188.
39 East Africa Royal Commission Report: East Africa Royal Commission, 1953–1955 (1955, HMSO), chap 23.
40 Coldham, S “The effects of registration of title upon customary land rights in Kenya” (1978) 22/2 Journal of African Law 91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
41 West The Mailo System, above at note 30; Timoni Mwenge v Serwano Migade, miscellaneous cause no 19 [1933] 5 ULR at 97.
42 Massie, EC “The Torrens system of land registration and transfer” (1900) 6/4 Virginia Law Review 214Google Scholar at 215, 221.
43 Ibid; Real Property Act of 1858 (South Australia) 21 Vict c15, available at: <https://www.foundingdocs.gov.au/resources/transcrips/sa8_doc_1858.pdf> (last accessed 21 October 2022).
44 Goldner, B “The Torrens system of title registration: A new proposal for effective implementation” (1981) 29/661 UCLA Law Review 661Google Scholar at 663–66.
45 Massie “The Torrens system”, above at note 42 at 215.
46 Oloka-Onyango, When Courts Do Politics, above at note 11.
47 Sir R Torrens An Essay on the Transfer of Land by Registration (1882, Cobden Club), cited in Massie “The Torrens system”, above at note 42 at 216.
48 Ibid.
49 Massie “The Torrens system”, above at note 42 at 220.
50 E Massie “Reform of our land laws” (Sept 1905) 11/5 The Virginia Law Register 359 at 365.
51 Id at 367.
52 Id at 364.
53 DH Van Doren “The Torrens system of land registration” (April 1917) 17/4 Columbia Law Review 354 at 355.
54 Massie “The Torrens system”, above note 42 at 218.
55 Ibid.
56 J Nangwala, personal remark on paper by P Walubiri “Indefeasibility of title: An eroded concept in Uganda” (paper presented at The Bar-Bench Engagement organized by the Uganda Law Society, 6 November 2020).
57 Massie “The Torrens system”, above at note 42 at 216.
58 Van Doren, “The Torrens system”, above at note 53 at 355.
59 E Massie, RG Brown and AV Cannon “Report of the Committee on the Torrens system and registration of title to land” (1914) 20/7 The Virginia Law Register 481 at 482–85.
60 Massie “Reform of our land laws”, above at note 50 at 365.
61 Hanson “A historical perspective”, above at note 31 at 288.
62 West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 12–13.
63 Hanson “A historical perspective”, above at note 31 at 288.
64 West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 165.
65 Registration of Documents Ordinance 1904, sec 4.
66 West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 13.
67 HB Thomas and AE Spencer A History of Uganda Land and Surveys, and of the Uganda Land and Survey Department (1938, Government Printer) at 52.
68 Hanson “A historical perspective”, above at note 31 at 298.
69 West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 13–14.
70 Id at 165.
71 Id at 18.
72 Ibid; JT Mugambwa Source Book of Uganda's Land Law (2002, Fountain Publishers) at 142.
73 Willy, LA “Compulsory acquisition a constitutional matter: The case of Africa” (2018) 62/1 Journal of African Law 77Google Scholar at 98 defines mailo as “a legal form of landlordism developed in the 1900s to reward certain kingdoms … under which … land was allocated in square miles”.
74 Hanson “A historical perspective”, above at note 31 at 292.
75 Id at 11, 4, 1.
76 West The Mailo System, above at note 30 at 20–21.
77 Ibid.
78 SR Simpson Land Law & Registration (1976) at 22.
79 Land (Amendment) Act 2004, secs 3(a) and 41.
80 Land (Amendment) Act 2004, sec 41.
81 See the RTA, secs 71–75.
82 Id, sec 37.
83 Ibid.
84 High Court civil suit no 87 of 2009.
85 Civil appeal no 6 of 2013.
86 Civil appeal no 15 of 2017.
87 Walubiri “Indefeasibility of title”, above at note 56.
88 R Agaba, “Interdicted Lands Commissioner Kulata to face trial” (3 December 2018) PML Daily, available at: <https://www.pmldaily.com/news/2018/12/> (last accessed 30 December 2020).
89 The Commission of Inquiries Act, cap 166, Legal Notice no 2 of 2017.
90 J Olanyo, “Land Registrar admits to issuing fake land titles” (1 December 2018) The Observer, available at: <https://observer.ug/news/headlines/59374-land-registrar-admits-to-issuing-fake-land-titles> (last accessed 10 May 2022).
91 RTA, sec 37(1).
92 Simpson Land Law & Registration, above at note 78 at 16.
93 B Perrins Understanding Land Law (3rd ed, 2000, Cavendish Publishing Ltd) at 69.
94 Land Act, secs 29 and 31 (as amended).
95 Id, secs 33(1) and 33(9).
96 Civil suit no 241 of 2015.
97 J Hogg “Registration of title to land” (1918) 28/1 The Yale Law Journal 50 at 58.
98 [1953] 7 ULR 31.
99 Tripp, AM “Women's movements, customary law, and land rights in Africa: The case of Uganda” (2004) 36/4 Africa Studies Quarterly 2Google Scholar.
100 Ndigejjerawa v Kizito and Kubulwamwana [1953] 7 ULR 31.
101 [1960] EA 926(U).
102 [1954] 7 ULR 68.
103 [1972] EA 227.
104 P Stubbs “Equitable priorities and the failure to caveat” (1989) 6/2 Auckland University Law Review 199 at 199.
105 RTA, secs 59, 64 and 176.
106 Id, sec 183.
107 Civil appeal no 40 of 1997.
108 Civil suit no 536 of 2012.
109 Nambalu Kintu v Efulaimu [1975] HCB 221.
110 TRM “Property: registration of land titles: Inconclusiveness of a Torrens title” (1923) 12/1 California Law Review at 49.
111 Follette v Pacific Light and Power Corp [1922] 64 Cal Doc 7 208 Pac 295; also TRM, above at note 110 at 51.
112 Walubiri “Indefeasibility of title”, above at note 56.
113 RTA, sec 178.
114 Civil suit no 2890 of 2016.
115 OXFAM, “Locked out: How unjust land systems are driving inequality in Uganda”, 2019, available at: <https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/Land%20and%20inequality%20in%20Uganda_November%202019.pdf> (last accessed 18 August 2021).
116 Secs 31, 35.
117 Civil appeal no 12 of 1985.
118 Land Act, sec 29(2); Land (Amendment) Act, sec 3(a).
119 Civil appeal no 2 of 2004.
120 Land (Amendment) Act 2010, sec 3(b).
121 Id, sec 32(a).
122 Land Act, sec 35(2).
123 Civil appeal no 2 of 2007.
124 OXFAM “Locked out”, above at note 115 at 11.
125 TRM “Property”, above at note 110 at 52.
126 Uganda Posts and Telecommunications v Lutaaya, Supreme Court civil appeal no 36 of 1995.
127 TRM “Property”, above at note 110.
128 The Constitution (Land Evictions) (Practice) Directions, 2021 (Legal Notice no 2 of 2021), principles 3 and 5, available at: <http://www.judiciary.go.ug/files/downloads/Land%20Evictions%20Practice%20Directions%202021.pdf> (last accessed 6 May 2022).
129 RTA, secs 64(1), 176(c), 178(a) and 181.
130 Supreme Court civil appeal no 12 of 1985.
131 Supreme Court civil appeal no 4 of 2006.
132 HC Black Black's Law Dictionary (6th ed, 1994, Publisher's Editorial Staff) at 600. Also see the case note at 22.
133 Ibid.
134 Supreme Court civil appeal no 22 of 1992, Wambuzi CJ at 7.
135 The appellant lived and ran a law firm on the land.
136 Mary Buyondo, above at note 114 at 13; Uganda Posts, above at note 126.
137 Civil suit no 66 of 2007.
138 Tripp “Women's movements”, above at note 99 at 2.
139 W Monteith and L Camfield “‘Don't you want us to eat?’: The moral economy of a Ugandan marketplace” (2021) Critical African Studies at 5, doi: 10.1080/21681392.2021.1964996.
140 Makerere Institute of Social Research, Land Tenure, above at note 10.
141 R Nakayi “The politics of land law reforms in neoliberal Uganda” in J Wiegratz, G Martiniello and E Greco (eds) The Making of Neoliberal Uganda: The Political Economy of State and Capital after 1986 (2018, ZED Books).
142 J Wiegratz Neoliberal Moral Economy: Capitalism, Socio-Cultural Change and Fraud in Uganda (2016, Rowman and Littlefield).
143 R Nakayi “The perceived protection of tenants on registered land against evictions: An assessment of the legal challenges faced by victims of land evictions in Kampala and Wakiso districts” (2016, PILAC working paper 4).
144 P Shipton “The Kenyan land tenure reform: Misunderstandings in the public creation of private property” in RE Downs and P Reyna (eds), Land and Society in Contemporary Africa (1988, University Press of New England).
145 Government of Uganda Uganda Vision 2040 at 6, available at: <http://www.npa.go.ug/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/VISION-2040.pdf> (last accessed 21 October 2022).
146 Afrobarometer “A never-ending problem: Ugandans say corruption level has increased, rate government fight against corruption poorly” Dispatch no 435 of 24 March 2021, available at: <https://www.afrobarometer.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/ad435-most_ugandans_say_corruption_has_increased-afrobarometer_dispatch-22march21.pdf> (last accessed 21 October 2022).
147 Transparency International Uganda, “A stakeholder's guide in the fight against corruption in Uganda's land sector” at 15, 9, available at: <https://tiuganda.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Land-and-Corruption-hand-book.pdf> (last accessed 25 August 2021).
148 Tripp “Women's movements”, above at note 99 at 1.
149 Constitution of Uganda, art 237(3); Land Act, sec 3.
150 O Odoom The Commons in an Age of Uncertainty: Decolonizing Nature, Economy, and Society (2020, University of Toronto Press) at xii.
151 Ye, R “Torrens and customary land tenure: A case study of the Land Titles Registration Act 2008 of Samoa” (2009) 40 Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 827CrossRefGoogle Scholar at 851.
152 Land Act, secs 3, 88 and 27.
153 Id, secs 4 and 8.
154 Government of Uganda “The Uganda National Land Policy 2013”, para 40, available at: <http://landportal.info/sites/default/files/the_uganda_national_land_policy-_february_2013.pdf> (last accessed 13 August 2021).
155 Id, para 41(ii).
156 Tripp “Women's movements”, above at note 99 at 1.
157 Land Act, sec 9.
158 M Musinguzi and M Kisakya “ Discrepancy between survey practice and legislation in Uganda” (paper presented at First Conference on Advances in Geomatics Research, Kampala, August 2021) at 133–34, available at: <https://cedat.mak.ac.ug/publications/discrepancy-between-survey-practice-and-legislation-in-uganda/> (last accessed 30 November 2021).
159 Id at 136.
160 Id at 134.
161 R Chileshe and H Shamaoma “Examining the challenges of cadastral surveying practice in Zambia” (2014) 3/1 South African Journal of Geomatics at 53, 59, 60.
162 Private Sector Foundation Uganda (PSFU) “Review of the legal framework for land administration: surveying and mapping issues paper 2010”, available at: <https://mlhud.go.ug/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Draft-Final-Issues-Paper-Survey-and-Mapping-Workshop-Jan-2013.pdf> (last accessed 28 August 2021).
163 Id at 42–43.
164 High Court civil suit no 640 of 2013.
165 Government of Uganda “Uganda National Land Policy”, above at note 154, paras 107–10.
166 Transparency International “A stakeholder's guide”, above at note 147 at iv and 15.
167 Above at note 108.
168 Deininger and Feder Land Registration, above at note 17 at 325.
169 M Wambi “I resisted hefty bribes – land registrar” (23 August 2017) Uganda Radio Network, available at: <https://ugandaradionetwork.com/story/i-resisted-big-bribe-says-lands-senior-registrar> (last accessed 10 May 2022).
170 Supreme Court civil appeal no 3 of 2014.
171 UBC Act, sec 6(a).
172 High Court civil suit no 326 of 2011; Civil appeal no 12 of 2014.
173 This is normally issued when the original is obliterated or cannot be found.
174 Government of Uganda “Uganda National Land Policy”, above at note 154, paras 104–106.
175 Kampala Bottlers, above at note 134.
176 Above at note 170.
177 Civil suit no 690 of 2004 [2014].
178 RTA, sec 2(1).
179 Uganda Posts, above at note 126.
180 Walubiri “Indefeasibility of title”, above at note 56.
181 Ibid.
182 “Bamugemereire report on land to be turned into law – Museveni” (23 April 2022) The Independent, available at: <https://www.independent.co.ug/bamugemereire-report-on-land-to-be-turned-into-law-musevei> (last accessed 10 May 2022).