Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-c9gpj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-09T03:51:48.589Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Henry George the Prophet

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2009

Bob Lawson-Peebles
Bob Lawson-Peebles
Affiliation:
University of Sussex
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Gilded Age saw the emergence of a number of figures who produced alternative theories to the dominant doctrine of laissez-faire. One such alternative theorist was Henry George (1839–97), a man of pronounced individualist proclivities who invoked the Jeffersonian tradition of sturdy agrarian independence as a corrective to an unbalanced economy which, he believed, was driving a destructive wedge between rich and poor. Today, George is regarded primarily as an economic reformer and his best-selling book with its jingling title, Progress and Poverty (1879), is read for its analysis of post-bellum America and for the panacea that it propounds: a levy on the value of land which, because it was designed to replace all other taxes, came to be called the Single Tax. In contrast, George's religious beliefs have received scant attention from his biographers and historians of the period, who have done little more than note that he was a devout Christian. This oversight has been rectified in a recent article by Fred Nicklason, ‘ Henry George: Social Gospeller ’, which draws attention to the religious orientation of George's writings and discusses his relations with churchmen. Yet although Nicklason stresses the importance of George's religious activity, he asserts that ‘ George himself moved from an initial concern for the single tax as a social reform to a deep-seated regard for its divine sanction ’. I believe that this is a misconception of George, and I shall try to show that his visionary experience led him to regard himself as a religious leader and prompted him to formulate his social theory. I also hope to demonstrate that his messianic pretensions grew with his following and that it was his religious role, rather than the Single Tax, which during his lifetime not only made disciples but also influenced theorists who were otherwise unsympathetic to his economic bolus.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 10 , Issue 1 , April 1976 , pp. 37 - 51
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1976

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Aaron, Daniel, Men of Good Hope (New York: OUP, 1961)Google Scholar; Barker, Charles A., Henry George (New York: OUP, 1955)Google Scholar; Birnie, Arthur, Single-Tax George (London: Nelson, 1939)Google Scholar; Geiger, George R., The Philosophy of Henry George (New York: MacMillan, 1933)Google Scholar; Hofstadter, Richard, Social Darwinism in American Thought (New York: Braziller, 1959), p. 107Google Scholar; Rose, Edward J., Henry George (New York: Twayne, 1968)Google Scholar.

2 Nicklason, Fred, ‘Henry George: Social Gospeller’, American Quarterly, 22 (1970), 649–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 George, Henry, ‘Spiritual Manifestations’, unidentifiable newspaper cutting in Henry George Scrapbooks, New York Public LibraryGoogle Scholar (hereafter cited as NYPL).

4 The Californian, 14 July 1866. Cf. George, Henry Jnr, The Life of Henry George (1900; rpt. New York: Schalkenbach, 1971), pp. 63–7Google Scholar (hereafter cited as Life).

5 George, Henry, ‘A Study of Political Economy’, Lecture at the University of California, 9 03 1877Google Scholar, NYPL. Life, pp. 274–80Google Scholar. Reeves, Clyde E., ‘Henry George's Speaking on Land Reform Movements: the West Coast “Training Phase”’, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 24 (1965), 51–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 George, , ‘Moses’, Speech first given in San Francisco, 06 1878, NYPLGoogle Scholar; ‘Why Work Is Scarce, Wages Low, and Labor Restless’, Speech in San Francisco, 26 03 1878, NYPLGoogle Scholar.

7 George, , Progress and Poverty (New York: Schalkenbach, 1971), Introduction, p. 11Google Scholar; Bk. X, ch. 3, p. 508; Bk. X, ch. 5, p. 552. Life, pp. 310, 321.

8 E.g. Aaron, op. cit., p. 75; Young, Arthur N., The Single Tax Movement in the United States (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press, 1916), pp. 23–4Google Scholar.

9 Gerrit Smith, Speech to the House of Representatives, 21 February 1854, reprinted in Gerrit Smith and Land Monopoly, ed. William Lloyd Garrison Jnr. (Chicago: Public Publishing Co., 1906).

10 Chapman, John Jay, Letter to Elizabeth Chanler, 31 December 1897, John Jay Chapman and his Letters, ed. De Wolfe Howe, M. A. (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1937), p. 174Google Scholar.

11 George, Letter to Thomas Walker, 13 September 1882, microfilm of selected correspondence, Library, London School of Economics.

12 Reminiscence by Steers, A. J. dated 1900, Father McGlynn: The Cross of a New Crusade (New York: Dr McGlynn Memorial Association, 1916), p. 30, NYPLGoogle Scholar.

13 Behrends, A. J. F., Socialism and Christianity (New York: Baker & Taylor, 1886), pp. 72–4Google Scholar; Coleman, James V., ‘George and Democracy’, an address before the Society of Alumni, Georgetown College, 27 06 1887, NYPLGoogle Scholar; Mallock, W. H., Property and Progress (London: Murray, 1884), p. 79Google Scholar; Walker, Francis A., Land and its Rent (London: MacMillan, 1883)Google Scholar.

14 George, , Social Problems (London: Henry George Foundation of Great Britain, 1931), pp. 73, 211Google Scholar.

15 London Register, 12 January 1884; Oban Times, 23 February 1884; Fitzgibbon, E. G., The Essence of Progress and Poverty Extracted from the American of Henry George and Done Into and Dealt With in Plain English (London: Swan, Sonnenschein, 1884)Google Scholar; An Elementary System of Socialism, Theoretical and Practical, by a Disciple of Mr Henry George (Oxford: Shrimpton, 1884)Google Scholar.

16 Duke of Argyll, , ‘The Prophet of San Francisco’, Nineteenth Century Magazine, no. 86 (04 1884), pp. 546 ffGoogle Scholar. Oxford English Dictionary (Oxford: OUP, 1933)Google Scholar; Dictionary of American English (London: OUP, 1960)Google Scholar.

17 Oswald, Felix L., ‘Henry George, an Apostle of Reform’, Chatauquan, 26 (1898), 416Google Scholar. Garland, Hamlin, A Son of the Middle Border (1917; rpt. New York: MacMillan, 1962), p. 321Google Scholar.

18 George, , ‘Is Our Civilization Just to Workingmen?’, Address given at The Church Congress, 1884, NYPLGoogle Scholar; ‘The Crime of Poverty’, Address to the Burlington Assembly of the Knights of Labor, Iowa, 1 April 1885, NYPL; ‘Workingmen and the Churches’, The Nation 40 (2 04 1885), pp. 274–5Google Scholar.

19 Life, ch. 8; Post, Louis F. & Leubuscher, Fred C., Henry George's 1886 Campaign (1887; rpt. New York: Henry George School, 1961)Google Scholar; New York Sun, 6 October 1886; New York Journal, 7 November 1886; McGlynn, Edward, ‘Lessons of the New York City Election’, North American Review, 143 (1886), 572–3Google Scholar.

20 Young, op. cit., p. 104; George, editorial in the final edition of The Standard, 31 August 1892; ‘The New Party’, North American Review, 145 (1887), 1–7Google Scholar; Programme of Anti-Poverty Society Meeting, 16 October 1887, NYPL; George, , ‘Thou Shalt Not Steal’, Speech to the Anti-Poverty Society, 8 05 1887, NYPLGoogle Scholar.

21 ‘Thy Kingdom Come’, Address at City Hall, Glasgow, 28 April 1889, NYPL; ‘The Single Tax Faith’, Address at Bridgeton, Scotland, 31 May 1889, NYPL; Speech at Art Institute, Chicago, 29 August 1893, NYPL; New York Times, 20 October 1897, reporting a speech by George of the previous evening; Rose, Henry, The New Political Economy: The Social Teaching of Carlyle, Ruskin, and Henry George (London: Spears, 1891), p. 113Google Scholar; ‘Wheel-barrow’, rev. of Progress and Poverty, Open Court, 2 (1889), 1415.

22 Life, p. 607. Cooper, James Fenimore, The Prairie (New York: Signet, 1964), p. 401Google Scholar.

23 New York Herald, 1 November 1897; The Illustrated American, 22 (1897), 621–3; Yardley, Edmund, Tributes at the Funeral of Henry George (1905; rpt. New York: Schalkenbach, 1939). pp. 35, 55Google Scholar.

24 Hofstadter, Richard, Anti-lntellectualism in American Life (London: Cape, 1964)Google Scholar; Ritchie, David George, Natural Rights (London: Allen & Unwin, 1894), p. 85Google Scholar; George, , The Science of Political Economy (1898; rpt. New York: Schalkenbach, 1968), pp. 59–60, 200–209Google Scholar.

25 George, , Address before Ministers of Religion, San Francisco, 6 02 1890, NYPLGoogle Scholar; Protection or Free Trade (1885; rpt. London: Kegan Paul, 1903), p. 299Google Scholar.

26 Commons, John R. et al. , History of Labour in the United States (New York: MacMillan, 1918), vol. 1, pp. 562–3Google Scholar; Pfeifer, Edward J., ‘The Scientific Source of Henry George's Evolutionary Theories’, Pacific Historical Review, 36 (1967), 397–403CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Life, p. 496n; Carnegie, Andrew, The Gospel of Wealth and Other Timely Essays, ed. Kirkland, E. C. (Cambridge Mass.: Belknap Press, 1962)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Farrell, F., ‘Sonnet to Henry George’, Australian Standard, 7 09 1889Google Scholar; Miller, Marion Mills, ‘The Man Sent of God’, in ed. Rees, Mabel L., Georgeist Poems (New York: Henry George School, 1964)Google Scholar; Garland, Hamlin, ‘Memories of Henry George’, The Libertarian, 5 (1925), 281–2Google Scholar; Life, p. 507; Plymouth Mercury, 16 January 1884, reporting George's speech of the previous evening.

28 Lewis, Arthur M., Ten Blind Leaders of the Blind (Chicago: Kerr, 1919), p. 43Google Scholar; Simons, Algie M., Single Tax and Socialism (Chicago: Kerr, 1899)Google Scholar; General Fisk, Clinton B., ‘Henry George and the Rum Power’, Arena, 1 (1890), 310Google Scholar; Life, p. 432; Behrends, A. J. F., Socialism and Christianity (New York: Baker & Taylor, 1886), p. 59Google Scholar; Vedder, Henry, Socialism and the Ethics of Jesus (New York: MacMillan, 1912), p. 265Google Scholar; Dorn, Jacob Henry, Washington Gladden, Prophet of the Social Gospel (Columbus: Ohio State Univ. Press, 1966), pp. 214–5Google Scholar; May, Henry F., Protestant Churches in Industrial America (1949; rpt. New York Octogan, 1963), pp. 242–3Google Scholar.

29 Rev. Brann, Henry A., ‘Henry George and his Land Theories’, Catholic World, 44 (1887), 810–28Google Scholar; Mahon, Robert J., ‘A Demurrer to Henry George's Complaint’, Catholic World, 46 (1888), 588Google Scholar; Ely, Richard T., Property and Contract (London: MacMillan, 1914), p. 779Google Scholar.

30 Rev. Victor, Cathrein S. J., The Champions of Agrarian Socialism: A Refutation of Emile de Lavelaye and Henry George (Buffalo: Peter Paul and Brother, 1889), pp. 107–114Google Scholar. Rev. Edward, A. Higgins S. J., The True Philosophy of the Land Question; Fallacies of Henry George Exposed and Refuted (Cincinnati: Keating, 1887), p. 14Google Scholar; Rev. Smith, John Talbot, ‘Where Henry George Stumbled’, Catholic World, 45 (1887), 116–123Google Scholar.

31 Father John A. Ryan, ‘Henry George and Private Property’, and ‘The Ethical Arguments of Henry George Against Private Ownership of Land’, Catholic World, 93 (1911), 289–300, 483–92Google Scholar; Distributive Justice (New York: MacMillan, 1916), pp. 28, 133Google Scholar.

32 Visser, W. A.Hooft, 'T, The Background of the Social Gospel in America (Haarlem: Willink & Zoon, 1928), pp. 170–6Google Scholar; Smith, Timothy L., Revivalism and Social Reform: American Protestantism at the End of the Civil War (New York: Harper, 1957), pp. 149. 236Google Scholar.

33 Rauschenbusch, Walter, Christianity and the Social Order (New York: MacMillan, 1912), p. 210Google Scholar; Christianizing the Social Order (New York: MacMillan, 1914), p. 399Google Scholar; Hopkins, Charles H., The Rise of the Social Gospel in American Protestantism, 1865–1915 (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 1940), pp. 215 ffGoogle Scholar; Herron, George D., The Christian Society (London: Clarke, 1894), pp. 22–3Google Scholar; A Plea for the Gospel (London: Allenson, 1898), pp. 26–7Google Scholar; editorial in The Kingdom, 10 (1897), no. 13; Dombrowski, James, The Early Days of Christian Socialism in America (1936; rpt. New York: Octagon, 1966), p. 182 ffGoogle Scholar.

34 Gronlund, Laurence, The Co-operative Commonwealth (Cambridge Mass.: Belknap Press, 1965)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Socialism v. Tax Reform (New York: New York Labor Library, 1887)Google Scholar; Our Destiny (London: Swan, Sonnenschein, 1890), pp. i, vii, 165Google Scholar.

35 Lewis Mumford, ‘Utopia, the City and the Machine’; Northrop Frye, ‘Varieties of Literary Utopia’; Adam Ulam, ‘Socialism and Utopia’; all in ed. Manuel, Frank E., Utopias and Utopian Thought (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1966)Google Scholar; Bellamy, Edward, Looking Backward 2000–1887 (New York: Signet, 1960), pp. 192–4Google Scholar; Equality (London: Heinemann, 1897), ch. 31, particularly p. 234Google Scholar.

36 Scott, W. A., ‘Henry George and His Economic System’, New World, 7 (1898), 87 ffGoogle Scholar.

37 I am grateful to the Ford of Britain Trust for financial assistance towards my research in New York; to the staff in the Economics Division of the New York Public Library for their kind help; and particularly to Professor Marcus Cunliffe of the University of Sussex for his encouragement and advice.