Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-m42fx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-17T18:36:56.408Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Written in the Skies: Advertising, Technology, and Modernity in Britain since 1885

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 October 2016

James Taylor
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

New technologies significantly increased the reach of advertising from the late nineteenth century. Some aspects of this phenomenon, such as advances in printing methods, are well known. Others, in particular its controversial leap into the sky, have received far less attention. Though no longer seen as the home of divine portents, the sky did not become “empty space” in the modern era: it was still freighted with significance. This meant that the various attempts made by entrepreneurs from the 1880s to bring advertising to the skies were often met with hostility, even panic. In exploring these responses, this article resists depicting opponents of aerial advertising as oversensitive aesthetes or technophobes. Rather, it explores the ways in which urbanization and commercial development imbued the sky with new meanings. The sky was imagined as man's most valuable connection to nature in an urban society, a precious but endangered part of the nation's heritage, and an essential counterweight to consumer society. Aerial advertising therefore represented an unjustifiable commercialization of a priceless public space. The rejection of this form of advertising did not involve denying modernity, but achieving an accommodation with it.

Keywords

Advertisingmodernitytechnologypublic spacelandscapethe skyurban historyconsumer societyaviationnational identitysecularization
Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 55 , Issue 4 , October 2016 , pp. 750 - 780
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ruskin, John, “Modern Painters,” in Selections and Essays (New York, 1918), 30–31 Google Scholar.

2 Lane, Belden C., Landscapes of the Sacred: Geography and Narrative in American Spirituality (1988; repr., Baltimore, 2002), 15 Google Scholar, 241.

3 Tilley, Christopher, Interpreting Landscapes: Geologies, Topographies, Identities (Walnut Creek, 2010), 31 Google Scholar. See also Tilley, Christopher, A Phenomenology of Landscape: Places, Paths, and Monuments (Oxford, 1994)Google Scholar.

4 Burchardt, Jeremy, Paradise Lost: Rural Idyll and Social Change since 1800 (London, 2002), 9–11 Google Scholar.

5 Silva, Fabio, “The Role and Importance of the Sky in Archaeology: An Introduction,” in Skyscapes: The Role and Importance of the Sky in Archaeology, ed. Silva, Fabio and Campion, Nicholas (Oxford, 2015), 1–7 Google Scholar, at 2.

6 Nicholas Campion, “Skyscapes: Locating Archaeoastronomy within Academia,” in Silva and Campion, Skyscapes, 8–19, at 8–9.

7 Annus, Amar, ed., Divination and Interpretation of Signs in the Ancient World (Chicago, 2010);Google Scholar Levy, David H., The Sky in Early Modern English Literature: A Study of Allusions to Celestial Events in Elizabethan and Jacobean Writing, 1572–1620 (New York, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Walsham, Alexandra, “Sermons in the Sky: Apparitions in Early Modern Europe,” History Today 51, no. 4 (April 2001): 56–63 Google Scholar, at 57–58.

8 Robins, Kevin and Webster, Frank, Times of the Technoculture: From the Information Society to the Virtual Life (London, 1999), 29–30 Google Scholar.

9 Berger, Peter, The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Social Theory of Religion (1967; repr., New York, 1990), 113 Google Scholar.

10 Brown, Callum, The Death of Christian Britain: Understanding Secularisation, 1800–2000 (London, 2000)Google Scholar.

11 Richards, Thomas, The Commodity Culture of Victorian England: Advertising and Spectacle, 1851–1914 (London, 1991), 254–55Google Scholar.

12 Turner, E. S., The Shocking History of Advertising (1952; repr., Harmondsworth, 1965), 256–65Google Scholar. Early experiments in projecting messages into the night sky are briefly discussed in Marvin, Carolyn, When Old Technologies Were New: Thinking about Electric Communication in the Late Nineteenth Century (Oxford, 1988), 184–89Google Scholar.

13 Wiener, Martin J., English Culture and the Decline of the Industrial Spirit, 1850–1980 (Cambridge, 1981)Google Scholar.

14 Rieger, Bernhard and Daunton, Martin, introduction to Meanings of Modernity: Britain from the Late-Victorian Era to World War II, ed. Daunton, Martin and Rieger, Bernhard (Oxford, 2001), 1–21 Google Scholar, at 7–8.

15 “The Man about Town,” County Gentleman: A Sporting Gazette and Agricultural Journal, 26 September 1885, 1223.

16 “The Advertising Balloons of London,” Pall Mall Gazette, 10 May 1886, 4–5.

17 “Our Illustrated Letter,” Manchester Times, 17 October 1885, 7; “Theatrical Gossip,” Era, 1 May 1886, 8; “Falcon Cliff Balloon,” Isle of Man Times and General Advertiser, 4 September 1886, 5.

18 “London Letter,” Western Mail, 8 May 1886, 2; “The Electrical Translucent Captive Advertising Balloon” (advertisement), Era, 28 November 1885, 3.

19 “‘Sky Signs’: A Chat with the Man Who Makes Them,” Pall Mall Gazette, 29 August 1890, 6.

20 “Metropolitan Notes,” Western Mail, 4 September 1890, 4.

21 “F. Sage and Company, Inventors and Patentees of Sky Signs” (Advertisement), Standard, 18 June 1890, 4. For Sage's obituary, see “Chips,” North-Eastern Daily Gazette, 7 October 1898, 4.

22 “Illuminated Advertisements,” Times, 31 January 1899, 7.

23 “Spencer Brothers v. Mellin's Food (Limited),” Times, 29 October 1903, 13.

24 “The Mellin Airship,” Times, 24 June 1902, 10; “The Mellin Airship,” Times, 7 July 1902, 9; “The Airship Journey across London,” Times, 22 September 1902, 8.

25 “Airship Trip over London,” Times, 10 December 1908, 13; Rosebud's WW1 and Early Aviation Image Archive, http://www.earlyaeroplanes.com/archive3.htm.

26 Fearon, Peter, “The Growth of Aviation in Britain,” Journal of Contemporary History 20, no. 1 (January 1985): 21–40 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 24.

27 Paul Bewsher, “Air Advertising,” Daily Mail, 14 January 1919, 4.

28 “Writing on the Sky,” Daily Mail, 1 June 1922, 8; “Writing in the Sky,” Daily Mail, 2 June 1922, 7–8.

29 “Ten Pounds for Photographs of Sky-Writing” (advertisement), Daily Mail, 19 August 1922, 3; “Hospitals’ Appeal,” Manchester Guardian, 2 July 1922, 9.

30 “Sky-Writing,” Daily Mail, 11 August 1924, 8; “Training a Sky-Writer,” Daily Mail, 30 May 1924, 7. Skywriting had reached Paris in October and New York in November 1922: “Far and Near,” Daily Mail, 13 October 1922, 7; “Sky-Writing in U.S.,” Daily Mail, 29 November 1922, 9.

31 “Air Racing at Bournemouth,” Times, 23 August 1926, 7; “Whitsun Air Races,” Times, 4 June 1927, 7.

32 Another British inventor, Harry Grindell Matthews, who claimed in the 1920s to have invented a “death ray,” developed a sky projector using stencils, and demonstrated it in New York and in London, but it does not seem to have been a success, despite excited press coverage: “Signs Painted On the Clouds,” Popular Science Monthly, February 1928, 22; “Sky Messages,” Scotsman, 24 December 1930, 10.

33 See for example “Night Sky-Writing” (advertisement), Surrey Mirror and County Post, 30 January 1931, 8; “Night Skywriting or Sky Projection” (advertisement), Portsmouth Evening News, 7 March 1931, 5.

34 “Sky-Writing,” Times, 15 July 1932, 9; “Night Sky Telegram,” Times, 12 October 1932, 10.

35 “London Startled by Two Moons in Sky,” Daily Express, 11 January 1933, 9.

36 “Sky Advertisements,” Times, 4 July 1930, 21.

37 Advertisement for Air Publicity Ltd, Advertising World 69, no. 2 (February 1937): 59 Google Scholar; idem, Advertising World 69, no. 3 (March 1937): 55 Google Scholar; idem, Advertising World 69, no. 5 (May 1937): 55 Google Scholar.

38 W. Tisbury to Mr. Rodgers, Murray's Tobacco, 24 January 1936, Planning Campaigns and Market Research for Murray's Cigarettes, 1936–43, HAT 50/1/112/1/11, History of Advertising Trust Archive.

39 “Is This the Right Way to Tell the Trade of Advertising Plans?” Advertising World 69, no. 2 (February 1937): 49 Google Scholar.

40 “Voice Over New York,” Times, 15 January 1932, 12.

41 L. David Brook, letter to the editor, Times, 12 July 1954, 5; “News in Brief,” 25 May 1955, 6.

42 “Flying Billboard Ready for Take-Off,” Times, 28 November 2003, 45.

43 For more on the language of “wonder,” see Rieger, Bernhard, Technology and the Culture of Modernity in Britain and Germany, 1890–1945 (Cambridge, 2005), 20–21 Google Scholar.

44 “Our Illustrated Letter,” Manchester Times, 17 October 1885, 7; “Illustrated London Letter,” Aberdeen Weekly Journal, 17 September 1890, 5.

45 J. M. S. Brooke, letter to the editor, Times, 26 August 1890, 3.

46 Letters to the editor, Times, 27 August to 6 September 1890.

47 See for example Editorial, Leeds Mercury, 3 September 1890, 4; Editorial, Birmingham Daily Post, 3 September 1890, 4; Editorial, Liverpool Mercury, 8 September 1890, 5.

48 “The London County Council,” Times, 10 December 1890, 7; “London County Council,” Daily News, 10 December 1890, 2; “London Chit-Chat,” Newcastle Weekly Courant, 31 January 1891, 3; Editorial, Morning Post, 16 March 1891, 5; Sky Signs Act, 1891, 54 & 55 Vict. c. lxxviii.

49 Longstaff, G. B., “What the London County Council Has Done,” A Beautiful World 3 (June 1894): 89 Google Scholar.

50 “London County Council v. Carwardine and Co. (1892),” Times, 2 November 1892, 3; “Madame Tussaud and Sons, Appellants—The London County Council, Respondents (1892),” Times, 11 November 1892, 13.

51 “London Sky Signs,” Times, 1 February 1893, 10; London County Council (General Powers) Act, 1893, 56 & 57 Vict. c. ccxxi; London Building Act, 1894, 57 & 58 Vict. c. ccxiii, part xii.

52 London Building Act, 1894, s. 125. For examples of the legislation being used against advertising flags, see “Flags as ‘Sky Signs,’” Times, 10 December 1924, 11; Times, 2 May 1925, 4. The London County Council was less successful in tackling electric signs: Survey of London: St James Westminster, part 2, ed. Sheppard, F. H. W., vol. 31–32 (London, 1963), 85–100 Google Scholar, online ed., http://www.british-history.ac.uk/survey-london/vols31-2/pt2/pp85-100.

53 “A Retrospect, February 1893–February 1903,” A Beautiful World 9 (May 1903): 19–21 Google Scholar.

54 Burgh Police (Scotland) Act, 1903, 3 Edw. 7, c. 33, s. 76.

55 Public Health Acts Amendment Act, 1907, 7 Edw. 7, c. 53, s. 91.

56 “The Abuses of Public Advertising,” Times, 22 September 1910, 6.

57 Lord Newton, Speech to the House of Lords, 8 May 1923, Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 54 (1923), col. 12.

58 A Bill Intituled An Act to Amend the Law with Respect to the Regulation of Advertisements, Parliamentary Papers, 1923, I.37; Lord Newton, Speech to the House of Lords, 18 March 1924, Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 56 (1924), col. 807.

59 The National Archives (hereafter TNA), HO 45/19714, Aerial Advertising: Sky-Writing, Lord Trenchard to Sir John Salmond, 10 March 1931; TNA, HO 45/19714, J. S. Ross to Messrs Arthur Guinness, Son and Co., 29 June 1931; TNA, HO 45/19714, Major J. C. Savage to the Secretary, Air Ministry, 17 November 1931; TNA, HO 45/19714, S. Dannreuther to Major J. C. Savage, 22 December 1931; TNA, HO 45/19714, D. H. Hacking to Sir Philip Sassoon, 30 June 1933. Savage later went public with the episode: J. C. Savage, letter to the editor, Times, 12 January 1932, 8.

60 “Skywriting at Night,” Times, 1 January 1932, 7. The subsequent correspondence ran from 6 January to 3 February 1932.

61 TNA, AIR 2/636, Sky Sign Advertising (Government Policy), “Notes of a Deputation to the Home Secretary from the Amenities Group of the House of Commons, regarding Sky-Writing,” 22 February 1932.

62 TNA, HO 45/19714, A. H. L. Hardinge to H. R. Boyd, 15 January 1932.

63 Report of the Select Committee on Sky-Writing, Parliamentary Papers, 1931–32, V.623, xvi–xviii.

64 “An Interrupted Silence in Manchester,” Manchester Guardian, 12 November 1937, 13; F. L. Batchelor, letter to the editor, Manchester Guardian, 13 November 1937, 9.

65 Advertisements-Aerial Advertisements and Skywriting, 1930–57, CL/GP/1/3, “Advertising by Means of Aircraft,” 13 May 1938, London Metropolitan Archives (hereafter LMA). For various communications to the Metropolitan Police on the issue, see TNA, MEPO 2/4682, Low Flying by Aircraft Towing Advertisement Banners over Central London.

66 Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 5th series, vol. 301 (15 May 1935), cols. 1698–99; idem, vol. 325 (30 June 1937), cols. 1948–99; idem, vol. 326 (8 July 1937), cols. 537–39; idem, vol. 330 (8 December 1937), cols. 482, 493–94; idem, vol. 338 (20 July 1938), cols. 2191–93.

67 A. P. Herbert, letter to the editor, Times, 21 June 1938, 17; “Bill against ‘Uncivil Aviation,’” Times, 30 July 1938, 8.

68 The committee thought smoke writing “the least objectionable method of aerial advertising”—partly because it happened so rarely—and did not recommend any restriction: Report of the Committee on Control of Flying, Parliamentary Papers, 1938–39, IX.357, 11–13, 28.

69 “Advertising in the Sky,” Times, 8 July 1939, 9.

70 “Civil Restrictions,” Flight, 21 September 1939, 255, Flightglobal, https://www.flightglobal.com/pdfarchive/.

71 TNA, HO 45/19714, Final Report of Inter-Departmental Committee to Consider Home Civil Aviation Policy, 14 July 1944, 14.

72 TNA, BT 245/38, Aerial Advertising: Proposals for Legislation to Prohibit, “Aerial Advertising Bill: Explanatory Notes,” 1955–61.

73 See, for example, Winifred Gordon Fraser, letter to the editor, Times, 16 June 1955, 9.

74 TNA, HLG 71/1719, Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements) Regulations 1948 and Amendment Regulations 1949 and 1951: Aerial Advertising, 1945–58, A. H. M. Irwin to S. G. G. Wilkinson, Ministry of Housing and Local Government, 12 November 1954; TNA, BT 245/38, “Aerial Advertising,” Memorandum by L. C. Nash, 26 October 1959.

75 TNA, HLG 71/1719, Howard Roberts, Clerk of the Council, to Ministry of Housing and Local Government, 9 May 1955; TNA, BT 245/38, F. G. Downing to S. R. Walton, 7 June 1955; TNA, BT 245/38, Dacey to S. R. Walton, Ministry of Transport and Civil Aviation, 31 October 1955.

76 TNA, CAB/128/29/34, Cabinet Minutes, 4 October 1955; TNA, CAB/195/14/11, Cabinet Notes, 4 October 1955; TNA, HLG 71/1719, “Aerial Advertising: Instructions to Parliamentary Counsel to Prepare Bill”; Civil Aviation (Licensing) Act, 1960, 8 & 9 Eliz. 2, c. 38.

77 The word “aircraft” in the bill legally encompassed balloons and kites: Earl Bathurst, Speech to the House of Lords, 17 May 1960, Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 223 (1960), cols. 912–13.

78 “Private Flying,” Flight International, 6 January 1972, 16.

79 C. Graham South, letter to the editor, Flight International, 7 October 1978, 1313; “Straight and Level,” Flight International, 28 March 1981, 927.

80 “A Happy Illegal Birthday,” Daily Mail, 17 March 1981, 10; “The Unlawful Greeting,” Flight International, 14 November 1981, 1466.

81 Iain Sproat to Ian Gow, 12 April 1983, Margaret Thatcher Foundation, http://fc95d419f4478b3b6e5f-3f71d0fe2b653c4f00f32175760e96e7.r87.cf1.rackcdn.com/830412%20Sproat%20to%20Gow%20AERIAL%20ADS%20THCR%202-6-2-173%20part4%20f4.pdf.

82 Iain Sproat, Speech to the House of Commons, 29 July 1982, Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 6th series, vol. 28 (1982), col. 620W.

83 Sproat to Gow, 12 April 1983.

84 “Return of Aerial Advertising,” Times, 11 October 1983, 3; Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 6th series, vol. 50 (13 December 1983), col. 389W.

85 The Civil Aviation (Aerial Advertising) Regulations, 1983, no. 1885; The Civil Aviation (Aerial Advertising) (Captive Balloons) Regulations, 1984, no. 474.

86 Wiener, English Culture.

87 A. Verdon-Roe, letter to the editor, Times, 13 January 1932, 13.

88 Rieger, Technology and the Culture of Modernity, 16, 5.

89 “The Airship Journey across London,” Times, 22 September, 1902, 8.

90 “Proves Value of an Airship,” San Francisco Call, 21 September 1902, 19. This did not change in the interwar years, when Britain was haunted by fear of the bomber: Holman, Brett, The Next War in the Air: Britain's Fear of the Bomber, 1908–1941 (Farnham, 2014)Google Scholar; Holman, Brett, “The Phantom Airship Panic of 1913: Imagining Aerial Warfare in Britain before the Great War,” Journal of British Studies 55, no. 1 (January 2016): 99–119 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

91 Gruffudd, Pyrs, “Reach for the Sky: The Air and English Cultural Nationalism,” Landscape Research 16, no. 2 (1991): 19–24 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 20.

92 TNA, AIR 2/636, “Notes of a Deputation”; Margot Asquith, letter to the editor, Times, 21 January 1932, 8; Carmichael Thomas, letter to the editor, Times, 19 January 1932, 8; “The Sky Billposting Co., Ltd,” Times, 6 January 1932, 11.

93 “The Sky Billposting Co., Ltd,” Times, 6 January 1932, 11. See also Lionel Curtis, letter to the editor, Times, 3 February 1932, 8.

94 “Writing on the Sky,” Daily Mail, 1 June 1922, 8.

95 “Sky Writing by Aircraft,” Times, 18 August 1922, 5. Carton was a versatile journalist who did not have a background in aeronautics: “Obituary: Mr. Ronald Carton,” Times, 11 July 1960, 14. For other overenthusiastic predictions, see Marvin, When Old Technologies Were New, 184–89.

96 All of the forms of sky advertising discussed in this article were also occasionally used by politicians, but it was the commercial uses which were more prevalent and attracted the most attention. One of the earliest examples of sky advertising for political ends was a captive balloon displaying the slogan “Vote for Vicary Gibbs” during the 1892 election: “Bubbles,” Funny Folks, 23 July 1892, 234.

97 Hewitt, John, “Poster Nasties: Censorship and the Victorian Theatre Poster,” in Visual Delights: Essays on the Popular and Projected Image in the 19th Century, ed. Popple, Simon and Toulmin, Vanessa (Trowbridge, 2000), 154–69Google Scholar, at 157; Nevett, T. R., Advertising in Britain: A History (London, 1982), 86–92 Google Scholar.

98 Hewitt, “Poster Nasties,” 154–56; Welsh, David, Underground Writing: The London Tube from George Gissing to Virginia Woolf (Liverpool, 2010), 61–65 Google Scholar.

99 Gissing, George, In the Year of Jubilee (1894; repr., London, 1947), 309 Google Scholar, 424.

100 “The Formula of British Conquest” (advertisement), Illustrated London News, 27 August 1887, 249; “Pears’ Soap” (advertisement), Illustrated London News, 29 October 1887, 524; “Clarke's ‘Pyramid’ Night Lights” (advertisement), Illustrated London News, 10 August 1895, 189. Thirteen years after Pears’ advertisement, US firm Quaker Oats actually did place an advertisement on Dover's cliffs, to widespread disgust: Readman, Paul, “Preserving the English Landscape, c. 1870–1914,” Cultural and Social History 5, no. 2 (2008): 197–218 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 205–6.

101 Richards, Commodity Culture, 165.

102 “Brooke's Soap” (advertisement), Illustrated London News, 22 November 1890, 665; “Pears’ Soap” (advertisement), in Kiralfy, Imre, Paris in London 1902: Guide and Catalogue (London, 1902), 18 Google Scholar.

103 “Advertising in Excelsis,” Punch's Almanack for 1886, 7 December 1885, 18.

104 Kenneth Folingsby, Meda: A Tale of the Future (privately published, n. d.), 105–7. The story was written in 1888.

105 de l'Isle-Adam, Villiers, “Celestial Advertising,” in Sardonic Tales, trans. Miles, Hamish (New York, 1927), 44 Google Scholar.

106 The story was first published in the American magazine Forum in 1889. See also Kuppord, Skelton, A Fortune from the Sky (London, 1903)Google Scholar and George Allan England, “A Message from the Moon: The Story of a Great Coup,” Pearson's Magazine, April 1907. Plot summaries of both can be found in Bleiler, Everett F., Science-Fiction: The Early Years (Kent, 1990), 223 Google Scholar, 416.

107 “Aerial Advertisements,” Spectator, 30 August 1890, 12. For similar sentiments, see Editorial, Birmingham Daily Post, 3 September 1890, 4; Arthur Severn, letter to the editor, Times, 13 October 1890, 7.

108 Lionel Curtis, letter to the editor, Times, 6 January 1932, 11; Guy Dawber, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 47, q. 429.

109 Lord Dickinson, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 68, q. 623.

110 Rappaport, Erika, “Art, Commerce, or Empire? The Rebuilding of Regent Street, 1880–1927,” History Workshop Journal 53, no. 1 (Spring 2002): 94–117 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 95.

111 Rappaport, Erika, Shopping for Pleasure: Women in the Making of London's West End (Princeton, 2001), 17 Google Scholar, see also 176.

112 Richards, Commodity Culture, 16.

113 Dennis, Richard, Cities in Modernity: Representations and Productions of Metropolitan Space, 1840–1930 (Cambridge, 2008), 30 Google Scholar.

114 Readman, Paul, “Landscape Preservation, ‘Advertising Disfigurement,’ and English National Identity, c. 1890–1914,” Rural History 12, no. 1 (April 2001): 61–83 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 76.

115 Gilbert, David, “ London of the Future: The Metropolis Reimagined after the Great War,” Journal of British Studies 43, no. 1 (January 2004): 91–119 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 92, 114.

116 Ibid., 113–14; Saler, Michael, The Avant-Garde in Interwar England: Medieval Modernism and the London Underground (Oxford, 1999)Google Scholar. Pick gave evidence to the 1932 Select Committee.

117 Lionel Curtis, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 81, qq. 710–11.

118 “The Advertising Balloons of London,” Pall Mall Gazette, 10 May 1886, 4–5. See also “Our Illustrated Letter,” Manchester Times, 17 October 1885, 7.

119 They could also be the subject of legal proceedings: “The Queen v. Messrs T. H. White and Co.,” Belfast News-Letter, 17 October 1889, 6.

120 TNA, MEPO 2/8458, History of Sky-Advertising over London, 1920–49, Sir William Horwood to the Under Secretary of State, Home Office, 28 September 1922; TNA, MEPO 2/8458, Horwood to the Secretary, Air Ministry, 26 November 1920. For more on road safety see Moran, Joe, “Crossing the Road in Britain, 1931–1976,” Historical Journal 49, no. 2 (June 2006): 477–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

121 A Tired Member of the Public, letter to the editor, Times, 8 May 1937, 15; Maurice Healy, letter to the editor, Times, 25 June 1938, 13.

122 Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 5th series, vol. 568 (1 April 1957), cols. 18–9W.

123 Rappaport, “Art, Commerce, or Empire?,” 104, 96.

124 Dennis, Cities in Modernity, 40.

125 Dennis, Richard, “‘Babylonian Flats’ in Victorian and Edwardian London,” London Journal 33, no. 3 (November 2008): 233–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

126 Forster, E. M., Howards End (1910; repr., London, 1992), 115 Google Scholar.

127 For discussions of sky signs in the context of the “light and air” debates see “Sky Signs,” Graphic, 6 September 1890, 251; Editorial, Bristol Mercury and Daily Post, 11 December 1890, 5; “Special Notes,” Reynolds's Newspaper, 4 January 1891, 8. For more on light and air, see Rooney, David, “Visualization, Decentralization and Metropolitan Improvement: ‘Light-and-Air’ and London County Council Photographs, 1899–1908,” Urban History 40, no. 3 (August 2013): 462–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

128 “Writing in the Sky,” Daily Mail, 2 June 1922, 7–8; “The Sky Writer,” Daily Mail, 13 June 1922, 7.

129 Lord Newton, Speech to the House of Lords, 8 May 1923, Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 54 (1923), col. 12.

130 Editorial, Scotsman, 17 May 1923, 6.

131 “Political Notes,” Observer, 20 May 1923, 12.

132 Huxley, Aldous, Brave New World (1932; repr., London, 1994), 67 Google Scholar.

133 Sommerfield, John, May Day (1936; repr., London, 2010), 189 Google Scholar.

134 Jackson, Mark, The Age of Stress: Science and the Search for Stability (Oxford, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

135 “Sky Signs,” Graphic, 6 September 1890, 251.

136 Oxford Graduate, letter to the editor, Times, 3 September 1890, 6. See also Editorial, Glasgow Herald, 8 September 1890, 6.

137 Mary C. Webb, letter to the editor, Times, 25 January 1932, 8.

138 Mansell, James G., “Neurasthenia, Civilization, and the Sounds of Modern Life: Narratives of Nervous Illness in the Interwar Campaign against Noise,” in Sounds of Modern History: Auditory Cultures in 19th- and 20th-Century Europe, ed. Morat, Daniel (New York, 2014), 278–303 Google Scholar, at 287.

139 Quoted in Agar, Jon, “Bodies, Machines and Noise,” in Bodies/Machines, ed. Morus, Iwan Rhys (Oxford, 2002), 197–220 Google Scholar, at 203.

140 Pirie, Gordon, “Incidental Tourism: British Imperial Air Travel in the 1930s,” Journal of Tourism History 1, no. 1 (March 2009): 49–66 CrossRefGoogle Scholar at 50–52.

141 “Noise of Aeroplanes,” Times, 15 December 1937, 18; C. H. Robinson, letter to the editor, Times, 18 April 1938, 6.

142 L. Finch to the London County Council, 30 April 1938, CL/GP/1/3, LMA; see also Claude Garnett to the London County Council, 15 May 1938, CL/GP/1/3, LMA.

143 Anthony Crossley, letter to the editor, Times, 18 May 1935, 10; Mrs. Ponsonby, letter to the editor, Times, 24 May 1935, 12; Thistle, letter to the editor, Times, 15 May 1937, 13; A. P. Herbert, letter to the editor, Times, 21 June 1938, 17; Dr. Geoffrey Bourne, letter to the editor, Times, 25 June 1938, 8; C. Weller Kent, letter to the editor, Times, 2 July 1938, 8.

144 Woolf, Virginia, Mrs. Dalloway (1925; repr. Ware, 2003), 15–16 Google Scholar.

145 Harvey, David, The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change (Cambridge, MA, 1990),Google Scholar chap. 16. See also Sloterdijk, Peter, In the World Interior of Capital (Cambridge, 2014), 251 Google Scholar.

146 E. Boyer-Brown, letter to the editor, Times, 29 August 1890, 10.

147 Dunedin, letter to the editor, Times, 15 January 1932, 13.

148 Report of the Select Committee on Sky-Writing, vi.

149 The quote is from a petition signed by 17 Richmond householders to their local council: “Protest on Advertising from the Air,” Times, 18 June 1955, 4.

150 Editorial, Flight, 1 July 1955, 1.

151 Savage, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 2–3, q. 2.

152 Robins and Webster, Times of the Technoculture, 29–30.

153 Quoted in Houghton, Walter E., The Victorian Frame of Mind, 1830–1870 (New Haven, 1957), 73 Google Scholar.

154 Froude, J. A., The Nemesis of Faith (London, 1849), 28 Google Scholar.

155 Jankovic, Vladimir, “The Politics of Sky Battles in Early Hanoverian Britain,” Journal of British Studies 41, no. 4 (October 2002): 429–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Charles P. Knight, letter to the editor, Times, 15 October 1859, 11.

156 Henchman, Anna, The Starry Sky Within: Astronomy and the Reach of the Mind in Victorian Literature (Oxford, 2014)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Anderson, Katharine, “Looking at the Sky: The Visual Context of Victorian Meteorology,” British Journal for the History of Science 36, no. 3 (September 2003): 301–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jankovic, Vladimir, Reading the Skies: A Cultural History of the English Weather, 1650–1820 (Chicago, 2001)Google Scholar; Hamblyn, Richard, The Invention of Clouds: How an Amateur Meteorologist Forged the Language of the Skies (London, 2002)Google Scholar.

157 Thornes, John E., John Constable's Skies: A Fusion of Art and Science (Birmingham, 1999)Google Scholar; Thornes, John E., “Cultural Climatology and the Representation of Sky, Atmosphere, Weather and Climate in Selected Art Works of Constable, Monet and Eliasson,” Geoforum 39, no. 2 (March 2008): 570–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Anderson, “Looking at the Sky.”

158 Thomas Hardy, Far from the Madding Crowd (1874), quoted in Dewitt, Anne, Moral Authority, Men of Science, and the Victorian Novel (Cambridge, 2013), 101 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

159 Wheeler, Michael, introduction to Ruskin and Environment: The Storm-Cloud of the Nineteenth Century, ed. Wheeler, Michael (Manchester, 1995), 1–9 Google Scholar, at 3.

160 See for example J. C., letter to the editor, Times, 29 August 1890, 10; J. M. S. Brooke, letter to the editor, Times, 4 September 1890, 5; “An Artist on Pictorial Advertisements,” Birmingham Daily Post, 13 May 1893, 6.

161 “New L.C.C. Chief Engineer,” Times, 9 July 1930, 13; Leslie Scott, letter to the editor, Times, 16 January 1932, 6.

162 Lewis R. Farnell, letter to the editor, Times, 8 January 1932, 11; Herbert Baker, letter to the editor, Times, 13 January 1932, 13.

163 “The Sky Billposting Co., Ltd,” Times, 6 January 1932, 11.

164 Powys, T. F., Mr. Weston's Good Wine (1927; repr., London, 1960)Google Scholar.

165 Connor, Steven, The Matter of Air: Science and the Art of the Ethereal (London, 2010)Google Scholar, the quotations at 37–38, 272–74, 281, 275.

166 Lane, Landscapes of the Sacred, 15, 59, 37.

167 Peter Mandler, “Against ‘Englishness’: English Culture and the Limits to Rural Nostalgia, 1850–1940,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 6th ser., 7 (December 1997): 155–75.

168 Readman, “Landscape Preservation,” 66.

169 Banner, Stuart, Who Owns the Sky? The Struggle to Control Airspace from the Wright Brothers on (Cambridge, MA, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Banner only briefly touches on aerial advertising: 26.

170 J. B. Hilditch, letter to the editor, Times, 6 September 1890, 4; idem, letter to the editor, Times, 27 August 1890, 7. See also Editorial, Times, 3 September 1890, 7.

171 G. M. Trevelyan, letter to the editor, Times, 13 January 1932, 13.

172 Edward Jenks, letter to the editor, Times, 12 January 1932, 8.

173 “Conservative Vandalism,” Funny Folks, 22 May 1886, 161.

174 For a similar image, see “Illustrated London Letter,” Aberdeen Weekly Journal, 17 September 1890, 5.

175 Miss Agnes Mure Mackenzie, letter to the editor, Times, 14 January 1932, 13; W. Foxley Norris, letter to the editor, Times, 15 January 1932, 13; Editorial, Times, 3 February 1932, 13.

176 L. Curtis, letter to the editor, Times, 6 January 1932, 11.

177 Herbert Baker, letter to the editor, Times, 13 January 1932, 13; George Clausen, letter to the editor, Times, 13 January 1932, 13; W. Foxley Dean, letter to the editor, Times, 15 January 1932, 13.

178 David Holbrook, letter to the editor, Times, 3 August 1982, 9.

179 Quoted in Lavin, Deborah, From Empire to International Commonwealth: A Biography of Lionel Curtis (Oxford, 1995), 264 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

180 J. B. Hilditch, letter to the editor, Times, 6 September 1890, 4.

181 “A Retrospect, February 1893–February 1903,” A Beautiful World, 9 (May 1903): 7 Google Scholar.

182 Lord Balfour of Burleigh, Speech to the House of Lords, 24 June 1920, Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 40 (1920), cols. 786–87.

183 Scannell, Paddy and Cardiff, David, A Social History of British Broadcasting: Volume One 1922–1939 (Oxford, 1991), 230 Google Scholar; Crisell, Andrew, An Introductory History of British Broadcasting, 2nd ed. (1997; repr., London, 2002), 84–85 Google Scholar.

184 Savage, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 5, q. 4; Thomas V. Church, letter to the editor, Times, 19 January 1932, 8.

185 This subject is covered at length in Stefan Schwarzkopf, “Respectable Persuaders: The Advertising Industry and British Society, 1900–1939” (PhD diss., University of London, 2008).

186 Alfred H. Angus, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 140, q. 1491.

187 Savage, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 14, q. 78.

188 S. Pearce-Smith, letter to the editor, Flight, 22 July 1955, 142.

189 Lord Newton claimed that many advertisers supported a skywriting ban because it was “desperately expensive.” Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 54 (15 May 1923), col. 161.

190 Angus, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 140, q. 1491; C. R. Vail, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 128, q. 1363.

191 Around this time, Shell established itself as an enlightened company by working closely with preservationist groups to remove its “unsightly” enamel signs and boards from the countryside, a policy which proved very lucrative: Hewitt, John, “The ‘Nature’ and ‘Art’ of Shell Advertising in the Early 1930s,” Journal of Design History 5, no. 2 (April 1992): 121–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

192 Richardson Evans, letter to the editor, Times, 18 April 1900, 11.

193 Editorial, Times, 22 March 1900, 9.

194 Owen Williams, letter to the editor, Times, 17 December 1954, 9; E. Owen Williams, letter to the editor, Times, 28 December 1954, 7.

195 Chicago was an exception, regulating sky signs from 1905, and outlawing rooftop-mounted electric signs in 1911: Treu, Martin, Signs, Streets, and Storefronts: A History of Architecture and Graphics along America's Commercial Corridors (Baltimore, 2012), 74 Google Scholar.

196 But restrictions were introduced in 1929: Leach, William R., Land of Desire: Merchants, Power, and the Rise of a New American Culture (London, 1994), 343 Google Scholar.

197 “Eiffel Tower Night Sign,” Manchester Guardian, 3 July 1925, 11; “Eiffel Tower Anniversary,” Times, 4 May 1929, 11; “Georges-Marie Haardt: Publicity, Adventure, Knowledge,” Times, 3 July 1972, 13.

198 “Our London Correspondence,” Manchester Guardian, 3 May 1928, 10.

199 TNA, AIR 2/636, Major J. C. Savage, “Sky-Writing by Day,” 1; “Speaking of Pictures … Skywriters Ply their Trade High in Summer Heavens,” Life, 19 August 1940, 6–8. Pepsi's rival Coca-Cola was soured on the new technology, however: when deploying it in a Cuban campaign, its message “Tome Coca-Cola” (“Drink Coca-Cola”) was blurred by the wind so that it read “Teme Coca-Cola” (“Fear Coca-Cola”). Pendergrast, Mark, For God, Country and Coca-Cola: The Definitive History of the World's Most Popular Soft Drink (London, 2000), 169 Google Scholar.

200 Sivulka, Juliann, Soap, Sex, and Cigarettes: A Cultural History of American Advertising (London, 1998), 182 Google Scholar.

201 Editorial, Manchester Guardian, 14 October 1927, 10.

202 TNA, AIR 2/636, Savage, “Sky-Writing by Day,” 3–4 and appendix 5.

203 Skywriting scenes occur in Wings in the Dark (1935), The Wizard of Oz (1939), and Reunion in France (1942). The Bat Signal, used to summon Batman and Robin to Gotham City Police headquarters, made its first comic-book appearance in 1942: Reinhart, Mark S., The Batman Filmography, 2nd ed. (Jefferson, 2013), 13 Google Scholar.

204 David Holbrook, letter to the editor, Times, 3 August 1982, 9.

205 Savage was exasperated that few of his critics had even witnessed his skywriting: Savage, Select Committee on Sky-Writing, 21, q. 177; J. C. Savage, letter to the editor, Times, 23 January 1932, 6.

206 Burchardt, Paradise Lost, 9, 158.

207 For more on “real and imagined” space, see Stock, Paul, “The Real-and-Imagined Spaces of Philhellenic Travel,” European Review of History 20, no. 4 (August 2013): 523–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 527.

208 Walsham, “Sermons in the Sky,” 57–58.

209 For a recent example, see Anna Franklin, review of Under Electric Clouds, 11 February 2015, Film New Europe Association, http://www.filmneweurope.com/news/region/item/110213-fne-at-berlinale-2015-competition-under-electric-clouds.

210 Campion, Nicholas, “The Moral Philosophy of Space Travel: A Historical Review,” in Commercial Space Exploration: Ethics, Policy and Governance, ed. Galliott, Jai (Farnham, 2015), 9–22 Google Scholar, at 11.

211 Karl Grossman, “Disgrace into Space,” Ecologist, March 2001, online ed., http://www.space4peace.org/articles/ecologist.htm. For a fuller discussion of the legal ramifications, see Zeldine O'Brien, “Advertising in Space: Sales at the Outer Limits,” in Galliott, Commercial Space Exploration, 91–106.