Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-sv6ng Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-14T23:00:47.396Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Moveable Feast: Saint George's Day Celebrations and Religious Change in Early Modern England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

Muriel C. McClendon
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Recent writing on the English Reformation has been dominated by the so-called revisionists. While not all revisionist historians have advanced an identical interpretation of the Reformation, the broad outline of their argument is neatly summarized in the opening lines of J. J. Scarisbrick's The Reformation and the English People: “On the whole, English men and women did not want the Reformation and most of them were slow to accept it when it came.” While earlier writers argued that the Reformation period represented a sharp break in English history with a definitive rejection of Catholicism, revisionists have asserted that there was considerable continuity in the religious life of sixteenth-century men and women. The Catholic Church was strong and vital and commanded considerable loyalty among the laity, and changes to religious doctrine and practice generated considerable hostility. The demise of the Catholic Church in England was not assured, and the success of the Protestant Reformation was the result of a long straggle fought from above that was won only during the middle years of Elizabeth's reign.

The revisionist interpretation has commanded wide attention and support. It currently stands, in many respects, as the new orthodoxy of English Reformation historiography. Most historians now concur on the profound attachment of many men and women to the doctrine and worship of the Catholic Church and their reluctance to abandon them. Nevertheless, a number of questions about the revisionists' interpretation of the Reformation and English religiosity remain.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 38 , Issue 1 , January 1999 , pp. 1 - 27
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Scarisbrick, J. J., The Reformation and the English People (Oxford, 1984), p. 1Google Scholar. Also see Duffy, Eamon, The Stripping of the Altars: Traditional Religion in England, c. 1400–1580 (New Haven, Conn., and London, 1992)Google Scholar; Haigh, Christopher, ed., The English Reformation Revised (Cambridge, 1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Haigh, Christopher, English Reformations: Religion, Politics and Society under the Tudors (Oxford, 1993)Google Scholar; Whiting, Robert, The Blind Devotion of the People: Popular Religion and the English Reformation (Cambridge, 1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Dickens, A. G., The English Reformation (London, 1964)Google Scholar, and “The Early Expansion of Protestantism, 1520–1558,” Archiv für Reformationgeschichte 78 (1987): 187–221Google Scholar; and Cross, Claire, Church and People, 1540–1660: The Triumph of the Laity (London, 1976)Google Scholar.

3 See Patrick Collinson's review of Haigh's, English Reformations in the Times Literary Supplement (22 October 1993), p. 15Google Scholar.

4 Watt, Tessa, Cheap Print and Popular Piety, 1550–1640 (Cambridge, 1991)Google Scholar; Lake, Peter, “Deeds against Nature: Cheap Print, Protestantism and Murder in Early Seventeenth-Century England,” in Culture and Politics in Early Stuart England, ed. Sharpe, Kevin and Lake, Peter (Stanford, Calif., 1993), pp. 257–85Google Scholar. The quotation appears on p. 277. See also Collinson, Patrick, The Birthpangs of Protestant England: Religious and Cultural Change in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (Basingstoke, 1988)Google Scholar; Brigden, Susan, London and the Reformation (Oxford, 1989)Google Scholar; MacCulloch, Diarmaid, The Later Reformation in England, 1547–1603 (London, 1990)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Among the most important studies of ritual in early modern England are Phythian-Adams, Charles V., “Ceremony and the Citizen: The Communal Year at Coventry, 1450–1550,” in Crisis and Order in English Towns, 1500–1700: Essays in Urban History, ed. Clark, Peter and Slack, Paul (London, 1972), pp. 86–116Google Scholar; James, Mervyn, “Ritual, Drama and Social Body in the Late Medieval English Town,” in Society, Politics and Culture: Studies in Early Modern England, ed. Clark, Peter and Slack, Paul (Cambridge, 1986), pp. 16–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sacks, David Harris, “The Demise of the Martyrs: The Feasts of St. Clement and St. Katherine in Bristol, 1400–1600,” Social History 11 (1986): 141–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and “Celebrating Authority in Bristol, 1475–1640,” in Urban Life in the Renaissance, ed. Zimmerman, Susan and Weissman, Ronald F. E. (Newark, Del., 1987), pp. 187–223Google Scholar.

6 Phythian-Adams, “Ceremony and the Citizen”; Berlin, Michael, “Civic Ceremony in Early Modern London,” Urban History Yearbook (1986), pp. 15–27Google Scholar; and Sacks, “Celebrating Authority.”

7 Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, p. 452Google Scholar.

8 Ibid., p. 44; James, “Ritual, Drama”; and Miri Rubin's critical comments on James, in her Corpus Christi: The Eucharist in Late Medieval Culture (Cambridge, 1991), esp. pp. 261–71Google Scholar.

9 Sacks, , “Demise of the Martyrs,” pp. 143–46Google Scholar; Rubin, , Corpus Christi, pp. 265–67, 273–74Google Scholar.

10 Hutton, Ronald, The Rise and Fall of Merry England (Oxford, 1994), p. 27CrossRefGoogle Scholar, notes that many communities did not celebrate the feast, London among them. But he still identifies the day as “one of the national festivals of early sixteenth-century England.”

11 Hogarth, P. J. summarizes the various accounts of the life of Saint George in “St. George: The Evolution of a Saint and His Dragon,” History Today 30 (April 1980): 17–22Google Scholar.

12 de Voragine, Jacobus, The Golden Legend; Or, Lives of the Saints as Englished by William Caxton, ed. Ellis, F. S. (London, 1900), 3:125–43Google Scholar (the quotation appears on p. 128).

13 Hole, Christina, English Folk-Heroes (London, 1948), pp. 114–15Google Scholar; Hogarth, , “St. George,” p. 19Google Scholar; Klaniczay, Gábor, The Uses of Supernatural Power: The Transformation of Popular Religion in Medieval and Early-Modern Europe, trans. Singerman, Susan and ed. Margolis, Karen (Cambridge, 1990), p. 116Google Scholar; Fox, David Scott, Saint George: The Saint with Three Faces (Shooter's Lodge, Windsor Forest, 1983), pp. 59–63, 98–123Google Scholar.

14 Froissart, Jean, Chronicles, trans. and ed. Brereton, Geoffrey (London, 1968), pp. 62, 66–67, 80, 136–37Google Scholar.

15 Hole, , English Folk-Heroes, p. 115Google Scholar; Fox, , Saint George, p. 66Google Scholar; Simpson, Jacqueline, British Dragons (London, 1980), p. 95Google Scholar.

16 Wasson, John M., ed., Records of Early English Drama (hereafter REED): Devon (Toronto, 1986), p. xxxiiiGoogle Scholar; Haigh, Christopher, Reformation and Resistance in Tudor Lancashire (Cambridge, 1975), p. 67Google Scholar; Simpson, British Dragons, plate 13; Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, p. 155Google Scholar. Also see Whiting, , Blind Devotion, pp. 49–51, 54, 203–4, 218Google Scholar.

17 Brigden, , London and the Reformation, pp. 24–25Google Scholar; Tanner, Norman P., The Church in Late Medieval Norwich, 1370–1532 (Toronto, 1984), pp. xii–xiiiGoogle Scholar; Skeeters, Martha C., Community and Clergy: Bristol and the Reformation, c. 1530–c. 1570 (Oxford, 1993), pp. 31, 208Google Scholar, n. 14; Phythian-Adams, Charles, Desolation of a City: Coventry and the Urban Crisis of the Late Middle Ages (Cambridge, 1979), pp. 160, 168, 173, 176, 275Google Scholar; Collinson, , Birthpangs, p. 50Google Scholar. For guilds dedicated to Saint George, see Grace, Mary, ed., The Records of St. George's Gild in Norwich, 1389–1547: A Transcript with an Introduction, Norfolk Record Society, vol. 9 (1937)Google Scholar; Bateson, Mary, ed., Records of the Borough of Leicester (Cambridge, 1905), 3:24, 50Google Scholar; Hole, , English Folk-Heroes, pp. 116–17Google Scholar; White, Eileen, The St. Christopher and St. George Guild of York, Borthwick Papers no. 72 (York, 1987)Google Scholar; Wasson, , ed., REED: Devon, pp. xlvii, liiGoogle Scholar; Westlake, H. F., The Parish Gilds of Mediaeval England (London, 1919), pp. 137–238Google Scholar; Hutton, , Rise and Fall, p. 55Google Scholar.

18 Hole, , English Folk-Heroes, p. 115Google Scholar; Fox, , Saint George, pp. 63–64Google Scholar. Caxton also noted that Saint George was also “the cry of men of war” in Voragine, , Golden Legend, 3:133Google Scholar.

19 For a similar development concerning the expansion of the cult of Saint Landislaus in Hungary, see Klaniczay, , Supernatural Power, pp. 112–20Google Scholar.

20 Fox, , Saint George, pp. 15–16Google Scholar.

21 Voragine, , Golden Legend, 3:129–32Google Scholar.

22 Chambers, E. K., The Medieval Stage (Oxford, 1903), 1:224Google Scholar, 2:132; Wasson, , ed., REED: Devon, pp. xvii, xxiv–xxv, 208–10, 231, 442, 449Google Scholar; Burke, Peter, Popular Culture in Early Modern Europe (London, 1978), p. 194Google Scholar. Most of what is known about these plays comes from later texts. See Chambers's discussion in Medieval Stage, 1:210–27Google Scholar, in which the themes of death and resurrection are more clearly delineated.

23 Collinson, , Birthpangs, p. 50Google Scholar.

24 Cressy, David, Bonfires and Bells: National Memory and the Protestant Calendar in Elizabethan and Stuart England (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1989), p. 4Google Scholar.

25 Finucane, Ronald C., Miracles and Pilgrims: Popular Beliefs in Medieval England (London, 1977), pp. 118–27, 152–72, 210–11Google Scholar; Tanner, , Late Medieval Norwich, pp. 86–87Google Scholar; Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, pp. 165–66Google Scholar; Porter, Enid, The Folklore of East Anglia (London, 1974), pp. 116–17Google Scholar. Cressy, David notes, in Bonfires and Bells, p. 5Google Scholar, that Saint Thomas remained quite popular in England even after his feast was officially struck from the calendar in the sixteenth century.

26 Hutton, , Merry England, p. 55Google Scholar. Phythian-Adams, , in Desolation, pp. 172–73Google Scholar, has noted that one legend claimed Coventry as Saint George's birth and death place, but it does not appear to have been much observed outside that city for the period covered in this essay. On relics of Saint George in England, see Grace, , ed., Records of St. George's Gild, p. 30Google Scholar; Hogarth, , “St. George,” p. 19Google Scholar.

27 For examples of saints who had such connections, see Urlin, Ethel L., Festivals, Holy Days, and Saints Days: A Study in Origins and Survivals in Church Ceremonies and Secular Customs (n.d.; reprint, Detroit, 1979), pp. 32–34, 186–90Google Scholar; Hudson, William and Tingey, John C., eds., The Records of the City of Norwich (London, 1906–1910), 2:liii, 311Google Scholar; Thomas, Keith, Religion and the Decline of Magic (London, 1971), pp. 27–28Google Scholar; Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, p. 162Google Scholar; Phythian-Adams, , Desolation, p. 118Google Scholar; Burke, , Popular Culture, p. 177Google Scholar.

28 Voragine, , Golden Legend, 3:133Google Scholar.

29 Chambers, , Medieval Stage, 1:222Google Scholar; Hole, , English Folk-Heroes, p. 116Google Scholar; Fox, , Saint George, p. 74Google Scholar; Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, pp. 20–21Google Scholar; Hutton, , Rise and Fall, p. 27Google Scholar; Froissart, , Chronicles, pp. 66–67Google Scholar.

30 Wasson, , ed., REED: Devon, pp. 209, 442Google Scholar; Whiting, , Blind Devotion, p. 106Google Scholar; Hutton, , Rise and Fall, p. 27Google Scholar; Haigh, , English Reformations, p. 30Google Scholar.

31 Lander, J. R., Government and Community: England, 1450–1509 (Cambridge, Mass., 1980), p. 165Google Scholar; Haigh, , English Reformations, p. 32Google Scholar; Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, p. 149Google Scholar; Rubin, , Corpus Christi, pp. 278–79Google Scholar; Watt, , Cheap Print, p. 22Google Scholar.

32 Bateson, Mary, ed., Records of the Borough of Leicester (Cambridge, 1905), 3:24–25, 33, 42, 49–50Google Scholar; White, , St. Christopher and St. George Guild, p. 16Google Scholar. The last riding of Saint George at Leicester appears to have been in 1542.

33 Skeeters, , Community and Clergy, pp. 31–32Google Scholar; Phythian-Adams, , Desolation, p. 173Google Scholar; Ingram, R. W., ed., REED: Coventry (Toronto, 1981), pp. 113, 151Google Scholar.

34 Anderson, J. J., ed., REED: Newcastle upon Tyne (Toronto, 1982), pp. xv, 13–14, 16Google Scholar; Wasson, , ed., REED: Devon, pp. 125, 130Google Scholar.

35 Grace, , ed., Records of St. George's Gild, esp. pp. 6–14Google Scholar; McRee, Ben R., “Charity and Gild Solidarity in Late Medieval England,” Journal of British Studies 32 (1993): 219CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and “Unity or Division? The Social Meaning of Guild Ceremony in Urban Communities,” in City and Spectacle in Medieval Europe, ed. Hanawalt, Barbara A. and Reyerson, Kathryn L. (Minneapolis, 1994), pp. 189–207Google Scholar.

36 McRee, Ben R., “Religious Gilds and Civic Order: The Case of Norwich in the Late Middle Ages,” Speculum 67 (1992): 90CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Clark, Peter and Slack, Paul, English Towns in Transition, 1500–1700 (London, 1976), p. 129Google Scholar, who have also observed that many urban guilds “were social clubs for the élite.”

37 Grace, , ed., Records of St. George's Gild, pp. 16–17Google Scholar; McRee, , “Unity or Division,” pp. 196–97Google Scholar.

38 McRee, , “Unity or Division,” pp. 200–201Google Scholar.

39 Hackwood, Frederick W., Dragons and Dragon Slayers (London, n.d.), p. 110Google Scholar; Simpson, , British Dragons, p. 96Google Scholar; McRee, , “Unity or Division,” pp. 195–96Google Scholar, describes the procession's route.

40 Simpson, , British Dragons, p. 96Google Scholar; Porter, , Folklore, p. 60Google Scholar.

41 Grace, , ed., Records of St. George's Gild, p. 20Google Scholar.

42 This and the following two paragraphs are based on McRee, , “Unity or Division,” pp. 198–201Google Scholar.

43 Cozens-Hardy, Basil and Kent, Ernest A., The Mayors of Norwich, 1404–1835: Being Biographical Notes on the Mayors of the Old Corporation (Norwich, 1938), pp. 20–22Google Scholar, outlines Wetherby's political career.

44 The Earl of Suffolk was one of the most powerful aristocrats in East Anglia and also wielded considerable political influence at the court of Henry VI. Lander, J. R., The Wars of the Roses (New York, 1967), p. 65Google Scholar, and Government and Community, pp. 180–88; Storey, R. L., The End of the House of Lancaster, 2d ed. (Gloucester, 1986), pp. 54–57, 40–62, 218–25Google Scholar.

45 For a more extensive treatment of this period of Norwich's history, see Hudson, and Tingey, , eds., Records of Norwich, 2:xliv–ci, 328–38Google Scholar; Storey, , House of Lancaster, pp. 218–25Google Scholar; McRee, , “Religious Gilds,” pp. 83–90Google Scholar; Tanner, Norman, “The Cathedral and the City,” in Norwich Cathedral: Church, City and Diocese, 1096–1996, ed. Atherton, Ian, Fernie, Eric, Harper-Bill, Christopher, and Smith, Hassell (London, 1996), pp. 263–66Google Scholar.

46 McRee, , “Unity or Division,” p. 198Google Scholar.

47 According to P. J. Hogarth, the slaying of a dragon in medieval lore was “an allegory of the triumph of good over evil; of the true faith over paganism,” although sometimes dragons represented “simply evil.” “St. George,” p. 20.

48 McRee, , “Unity or Division,” p. 199Google Scholar.

49 Wetherby had died in 1444 or 1445.

50 Robert Toppes had served as mayor of Norwich four times between 1435 and 1458; Cozens-Hardy, and Kent, , Mayors of Norwich, p. 23Google Scholar.

51 Spitz, Lewis W., ed., The Protestant Reformation (Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1966), p. 15Google Scholar; Brigden, , London and the Reformation, pp. 266–67Google Scholar; Sacks, , “Demise of the Martyrs,” p. 168–69Google Scholar.

52 Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, pp. 4–5Google Scholar.

53 Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, pp. 394–97Google Scholar; Whiting, , Blind Devotion, pp. 71–72Google Scholar.

54 Only the feasts of the Apostles, the Blessed Virgin, Saint George's Day, Ascension Day, the nativity of Saint John the Baptist, All Saints' Day, and Candlemas remained officially recognized; Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, p. 5Google Scholar; Slavin, A. J., ed., Humanism, Reform and Reformation in England (New York, 1969), p. 152Google Scholar.

55 Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, pp. 450–53Google Scholar, and Haigh, , English Reformations, pp. 168–70Google Scholar.

56 Kreider, Alan, English Chantries: The Road to Dissolution (Cambridge, Mass., 1979)Google Scholar, chap. 8; Dickens, , English Reformation, pp. 205–17Google Scholar; Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, pp. 454–56Google Scholar; Haigh, , English Reformations, pp. 171–78Google Scholar.

57 Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, pp. 6–7Google Scholar.

58 Wasson, , ed., REED: Devon, pp. 63, 211Google Scholar; Whiting, , Blind Devotion, pp. 72, 102, 106, 259Google Scholar, and also pp. 110–11 on resistance to the Chantries Act.

59 Ingram, , ed., REED: Coventry, pp. 113, 151Google Scholar; Phythian-Adams, , “Ceremony and the Citizen,” p. 79Google Scholar, and Desolation, pp. 172–73.

60 Palliser, D. M., The Reformation in York, 1534–1553, Borthwick Papers no. 40 (York, 1971), p. 22Google Scholar; White, , St. Christopher and St. George, pp. 16, 19–22Google Scholar.

61 Grace, , ed., Records of St. George's Gild, pp. 28–29Google Scholar.

62 These changes were not sufficient for some of the guild's members, who balked at participating in the 1548 celebration; see McClendon, Muriel C., “‘Against God's Word’: Government, Religion, and the Crisis of Authority in Early Reformation Norwich,” Sixteenth Century Journal 25 (1994): 353–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Haigh, , English Reformations, p. 214Google Scholar.

64 In some places such as Coventry, the celebration was clearly not revived: Ingram, , ed., REED: Coventry, pp. 198–210Google Scholar. Images of Saint George were, according to Hutton, , Rise and Fall, pp. 98–99Google Scholar, set up again in a number of parishes and may have been taken in procession.

65 Clopper, Lawrence M., ed., REED: Chester (Toronto, 1979), pp. liii, 55, 57–62Google Scholar.

66 On the reestablishment of guilds under Mary, see Scarisbrick, , Reformation and the English People, pp. 37–39, 131–33Google Scholar. However, Whiting, , Blind Devotion, pp. 111–12Google Scholar, notes that in the southwest, those guilds “were invariably shorn of their intercessory and image-supportive functions.” Also see Johnston, Alexandra F. and Rogerson, Margaret, eds., REED: York (Toronto, 1979), 1:310 and 318–19Google Scholar for a list of expenditures for the 1554 observance; White, , St. Christopher and St. George, p. 16Google Scholar; and Haigh, , English Reformations, pp. 214–15Google Scholar, on the restoration of other festivities.

67 Norfolk Record Office (hereafter NRO) Minutes of Saint George's Guild, 1452–1602, pp. 210, 203; NRO Assembly Minute Book, 1551–1568, fol. 64r.

68 Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars, pp. 530–33Google Scholar.

69 Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terence, eds., The Invention of Tradition (Cambridge, 1983)Google Scholar. See esp. Hobsbawm's introduction, pp. 1–14.

70 NRO Minutes of Saint George's, pp. 186–87.

71 Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, p. 7Google Scholar; Johnston, and Rogerson, , eds., REED: York, 1:327Google Scholar.

72 NRO Minutes of Saint George's. At the front of the book there is a list of admitted members that covers the years 1555 to 1578.

73 NRO Minutes of Saint George's, p. 214, reprinted in Galloway, David, ed., REED: Norwich, 1540–1642 (Toronto, 1984), p. 47Google Scholar.

74 On Midsummer celebrations, see Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, pp. 25–28Google Scholar; Hutton, , Rise and Fall, 37–44Google Scholar.

75 NRO Minutes of Saint George's, p. 316.

76 Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, pp. 25–28Google Scholar; Urlin, , Festivals, pp. 140–50Google Scholar; Hawes, Timothy, ed., An Index to Norwich City Officers, 1453–1835, Norfolk Record Society, vol. 52 (1986), p. xGoogle Scholar.

77 Galloway, , ed., REED: Norwich, pp. 166, 169, 178, 183, 184, 195, 208Google Scholar, on payments for equipment for the maintenance of the George figure and of the dragon.

78 As suggested by Hutton, , Rise and Fall, p. 115Google Scholar.

79 “An Account of the Company of St. George in Norwich: From Mackerell's Manuscript History,” Norfolk Archaeology 3 (1852): 363–64Google Scholar; Galloway, , ed., REED: Norwich, pp. 184, 208, 231Google Scholar.

80 In 1645, the company had banned the dragon, fools, and whifflers from the procession, along with the customary decorations of the procession route. “An Account of the Company of St. George in Norwich,” p. 354; and Underdown, David, Revel, Riot and Rebellion: Popular Politics and Culture in England, 1603–1660 (Oxford, 1985), p. 259Google Scholar, n. 64.

81 Galloway, , ed., REED: Norwich, pp. xxviii–xxixGoogle Scholar; “An Account of the Company of St. George in Norwich,” esp. pp. 364–74; Simpson, , British Dragons, pp. 101–2Google Scholar.

82 In 1430–31, a Saint George play was performed in Chester. Clopper, , ed., REED: Chester, p. 8Google Scholar.

83 Ibid., p. 261.

84 Borsay, Peter, The English Urban Renaissance: Culture and Society in the Provincial Town, 1660–1770 (Oxford, 1989), p. 181Google Scholar.

85 Clopper, , ed., REED: Chester, pp. 258–60Google Scholar; Bergeron, David M., English Civic Pageantry, 1558–1642 (Columbia, S.C., 1971), pp. 92–94Google Scholar.

86 Collinson, , Birthpangs, p. 50Google Scholar; Haigh, , English Reformations, p. 157Google Scholar.

87 For similar developments concerning the celebration of the feast of Saint Antonin by the London Grocers' Company, see Ward, Joseph P., Metropolitan Communities: Trade Guilds, Identity and Change in Early Modern London (Stanford, Calif., 1997), pp. 112–15Google Scholar. On Martyn, see Haigh, , English Reformations, pp. 1–3Google Scholar.

88 Cressy, , Bonfires and Bells, p. 21Google Scholar.

89 Fox, , Saint George, pp. 7, 72, 93–96Google Scholar.

90 Hobsbawm and Ranger, Invention of Tradition. On the use of symbols to knit together nations as anonymous communities and assert their ancient traditions, see Anderson, Benedict, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origins and Spread of Nationalism, 2d ed. (London, 1991)Google Scholar.