Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-wxhwt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-08T15:59:48.290Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Chronic Food Shortages and the Collective Farm System in North Korea

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 March 2016

Extract

This article considers the problem of North Korea's collective farms from a micro-institutional perspective. It begins with an analysis of the collective farming system introduced in 1958, the changes in 1966 that allowed for sub-work teams, and the further reform of 1996 that permitted a new work squad system. The normalization of North Korea's agriculture is not just a technological problem; rather, it requires reform of the collective farms and their incentives: the removal of the inefficient elements in the shorter term and the promotion of family farming in the medium to longer term.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © East Asia Institute 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. Woo-Cumings, Meredith, “The Political Ecology of Famine: The North Korean Catastrophe and Its Lessons,” Asian Development Bank Institute Research Paper 31 (January 2002): 24.Google Scholar

2. Tae-jin, Kwon, “Bug-han-nong-eob-gwa nong-eob-bal-jeon-jeon-lyag [North Korean Agriculture and Strategies for Agricultural Development],” Bug-han-nong-eob-gae-hyeog-eul wi-han gug-je-sa-hoe-ui ji-won [The International Support for North Korean Agriculture with Economic Reform] (Seoul: Korea Rural Economic Institute, 2003), p. 31.Google Scholar

3. Gey, Peter, Kosta, Jiri, and Quaisser, Wolfgang, Crisis and Reform in Socialist Economies (Boulder: Westview, 1987), pp. 173192.Google Scholar

4. Nicksch, Larry, “North Korean Food Shortage: US and Allied Response,” CRS Report to Congress (Washington: Congress Research Service, 1997); and Woon-keun, Kim, “Recent Changes in North Korean Agricultural Polices and Projected Impacts on the Food Shortage,” East Asian Review 11 (Fall 1999): 93–110.Google Scholar

5. Woon-keun, Kim, “The Food Crisis in North Korea: Background and Prospects,” East Asian Review 3, no. 4 (Winter 1996): 58.Google Scholar

6. The FAO visits North Korea every October-November to obtain data on each gross production in the regime before releasing a report. “FAO/WFP and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the DPRK,” October 30, 2003.Google Scholar

7. “North Korea Urgently Needs Food Aid,” Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, November 11, 2003, www.fao.org/english/newsroom/news.Google Scholar

8. Special Report FAO/WFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment, FAO Global Information and Early Warning System on Food and Agriculture World Food Program, December 12, 2002, www.fao.org/docrep.Google Scholar

9. Roy, Phrang, “The Experience of IFAD with the Co-operative of DPR Korea,” paper for the International Forum on the Roles of Cooperatives in the Age of South and North Korea Reconciliation, National Agricultural Cooperative Federation, 2001, pp. 91104.Google Scholar

10. One jeongbo is equal to one hectare.Google Scholar

11. Dae-ho, Oh, Experiences in the Cooperatives' Management (Pyongyang: Social Science Publishing House, 1989).Google Scholar

12. Sung, Kim II, Jeonjip [Complete Works] , vol. 15 (Pyongyang: Social Science Publishing House, 1962), p. 58.Google Scholar

13. Young-hoon, Kim, Hyeong-jin, Jeon, and Sun-cheol, Mun, “Bug-han-ui bun-bae-je-do-e gwan-han yeon-gu [Study of the Distribution System of North Korean Cooperatives],” Korean Research Institute for the Rural Economy (2001): 21.Google Scholar

14. Dictionary of Economy (Pyongyang: Social Science Publishing House, 1989), p. 734.Google Scholar

15. Young-hoon, Kim, “Bug-han-ui hyeob-dongnongjang-ui hyeon-hwanggwa gae-hyeog-bang-an-e gwan-han yeon-gu [A Study on Conditions and Reform Measures of North Korea's Collective Farms],” The Economy of Unification (Seoul: Hyundai Economic Institute, 2001), pp. 3738.Google Scholar

16. Sung-wook, Nam, “Bug-han hyeob-dongnongjang-ui saengsan-seong han-gye-wa nong-eob-gu-jo-gae-hyeog banghyang [North Korean Collective Farms' Productivity Limitation and Agriculture Structure Reorganization Direction],” paper presented at the Korean Society of North Korean Agriculture Spring Academic Symposium, Seoul, 2001, p. 38.Google Scholar

17. Ministry of Agriculture, North Korea, “Bun-jo gwan-li-je-leul jeonghwag-hi sil-si-ha-myeo nong-eob saengsan-e-seo sae-lo-un ang-yang-eul il-eu-kin de dae-ha-yeo [Policy on the exact implementation of sub-work team system and new increase of agricultural production],” Document addressed in the national meeting of all farmers, February 14, 1968.Google Scholar

18. “Bun-jo-gwan-li-je-ui jeonghwag-han i-haeng i-hu nong-eob-ui sae-lo-un heu-leum-e dae-ha-yeo [On the New Waves in Agriculture After the Successful Implementation of the Work Squad Program],” National Convention of Farmers , February 14, 1968.Google Scholar

19. National Intelligence Service, www.nis.go.kr, January 25, 2000.Google Scholar

20. Gim-il-seong jeo-jag-seon-jib [Kim Il Sung's Selected Works] , vol. 4 (Pyongyang: Chosun Labor Party Press, 1960), p. 496.Google Scholar

21. Jai-jin, Seo, “Bug-han nongmin-ui ui-sig byeon-hwa [North Korean Farmers' Consciousness Change],” paper presented at the Korean Rural Sociological Society Academic Conference and General Assembly, Seoul, 2002, p. 137.Google Scholar

22. Man-yoo, Hwang, Bi-mil sa-hoe-in bug-han-sa-hoe-wa jeongchi: ban-yeog, saengmyeong mich kkum-ui ttang [North Korean Society and Politics Within Hidden Secret: The Land of Traitor, Life, and Dream] (Seoul: Hanam, 2001), p. 193.Google Scholar

23. Oberdorfer, Don, The Two Koreas: Contemporary History (Indianapolis, IN: Basic, 1997), pp. 369371.Google Scholar

24. Sung-wook, Nam, Prospects of Grain Production, Consumption, and Trade in North Korea (PhD diss., University of Missouri-Columbia, 1997), pp. 24.Google Scholar

25. Haggard, Stephan and Noland, Marcus, The Politics of Famine in North Korea (Washington, DC: US Committee for Human Rights in North Korea, 2005), pp. 1218.Google Scholar

26. The famine took a heavy toll. Compared with other socialist famines, such as the 1959–1961 Chinese famine and the 1932–1933 Soviet famine, the total number of deaths in the DPRK famine was less, but of course North Korea is a much smaller country. In terms of duration, however, the famine lasted more than five years while other socialist famines lasted 2–3 years at maximum. Lee, Suk, “Food Shortage and Economic Institution in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea” (PhD diss., University of Warwick, 2003), pp. 313315.Google Scholar

27. Sung-wook, Nam, “Grain Shortage and Population Trends in North Korea, 1961–1998,” North Korean Studies Review 2, no. 2 (1999): 219272.Google Scholar

28. Natsios, Andrew S., The Great North Korean Famine (Washington, DC: US Institute of Peace, 2001), pp. 110121.Google Scholar

29. On March 13, 2000, North Korea's Pyongyang Broadcasting reported, “Our leader Kim Jong II has concentrated his efforts on the solution of food problem. In order to solve the shortage of food, he instructed such revolutions as potato revolution, expansion of farmland, expansion of compound micro-organism fertilizer, large-scale rearrangement of farmland, revolution of seeds, expansion of livestock raising and fishing farms. In particular, he expressed his idea of a world-best potato complex in order to improve the agricultural productivity.” Yonhap News, March 23, 2000.Google Scholar

30. On February 24, 1999, North Korea convened the central report meeting in commemoration of the thirty-fifth anniversary of the announcement of “Theses on North Korea's Socialist Agricultural Problems” in Pyongyang. Prime Minister Hong Sung-nam reported, “Kim Jong II understands well the recent condition of North Korea's agriculture and corrected the problems distorting Juche (self-reliance) ideology and impeding the agricultural productivity.” “A Study on Directions for North Korea's Agricultural Policies and South-North Agricultural Cooperation,” Study of North Korea's Agriculture (North Korea's Agriculture Research Group, November 2001): 7.Google Scholar

31. Animals and buildings were excluded from the ownership of collective farms, which suggests the possibility that livestock and houses may be privately owned and traded. Constitution amended on September 1998.Google Scholar

32. The working group chief plays a very significant role in providing the inputs, such as fertilizer, insecticide, and appliances. Operation managers and the chief of each group save a certain amount of the crop secretly during the harvesting season. If this fact is disclosed, they are punished under suspicion of national property theft. The leaders use the saved crops as a self-rescue measure for next year's farming, because the planned quantity is imposed even though the nation doesn't supply satisfactory fertilizer and appliances, and they buy fertilizer or appliances with the crop. Because the lower members of the group also know about the situation, they also share some crops. It is not easy to get fertilizer, however, because fertilizer isn't produced in sufficient amounts. Therefore, incapable chiefs can't find fertilizer, which affects the crops. Eun-sil, Choi, defector interview, “Bug-han hyeob-dongnongjang-ui hyeon-sil-gwa nongmin-saenghwal [The Realities of Collective Farm and Farmers' Life in North Korea],” A Unification Korea (Seoul: Peace Problem Institute, 1999).Google Scholar

33. “Mu-yonghan jib-dan-tongje-e gwan-han bul-pyeong [Complaints About Useless Group Control System],” Monthly Publication Donghwa (May 1999): 123124.Google Scholar

34. Young-hoon, Kim, “Bug-han nong-eob-saengsan-ui bihwal-dongseong: hyeon-sil-gwa won-in [North Korean Agriculture's Production Inactivity: The Reality and Its Causes],” paper presented at the Korean Rural Sociological Society 2002 Academic Conference, Seoul, 2002, p. 106.Google Scholar

35. “The basic distribution method of collective farms is the way embodied in group control system and the most rational and scientific labor remuneration method which is proper to the characteristic of collective cultivation institution and farming production and the ideological consciousness level and technology culture level of agricultural workers. This is the most scientific labor remuneration method that complies with demand of the feature of production facilities' public possession and of the new step of state-operation agriculture development.” Jin-gyo, Lee, Choe-go ji-do-ja gim-il-seong-ui sa-hoe-ju-ui nong-eob-no-dong-ui jae-pyeongga-e gwan-han i-lon [The Theory About Socialistic Farming Labor Remuneration System by the Supreme Leader Kim II Sung] (Pyongyang: Science Encyclopedia, 1986), pp. 1013.Google Scholar

36. Mal-nam, Lee, Junggug gyeongje-wa nong-eob [Chinese Economy and Agriculture] (Seoul: Hak-moon-sa, 1999), pp. 5569.Google Scholar

37. Romania 15.6 percent, East Germany 13.8 percent; North Korea was third among all the socialist countries in the standard of 1986; Kornai, Janos, The Socialist System: The Political Economy of Communism (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992), p. 35.Google Scholar

38. FAO/WFP, “Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea,” November 12, 1999.Google Scholar

39. The total area of North Korea is 12,054,000 ha. Land area is 12,041,000 ha. The DPRK is a mountainous country, with 75 percent of its area in hills and mountains, and an average elevation of 480 meters. Agricultural area is just 15 percent (2,050,000 ha), but 2,000,000 ha (16.6 percent) of land area is crop land, arable land area is 1,700,000 ha (14.1 percent of the total land area), and 300,000 ha are used by permanent crops and 50,000 ha are pasture. Arable land area per person in 1994 was 0.085 ha and was much smaller than any other socialist country, including Bulgaria (0.17 ha per person), Hungary (0.68 ha), and Poland (0.63 ha). Jo-seon jung-ang yeon-gam [The Yearbook of North Korea Central]: The Yearbook of United Chosun (Pyongyang: North Korea Central Bureau of Statistics, 1997).Google Scholar

40. Hugeon, Park, “Transition to Market-Guided Economy: Experience, Lessons, and Implication to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea,” July 12, 2004, available at www.kifs.org, Korea Institute for Future Strategies; Ruediger, Frank, “North Korean Change: Economic Reform and Political Support,” Joint International Seminar of the Advisory on Democratic and Peaceful Unification and the Korea Institute for Future Strategies, Bonn, Germany, May 27, 2004; Gey, Peter, “North Korea: Soviet-Style Reform and the Erosion of the State Economy,” Collected Papers of the German Institute of Seoul, June 2, 2004; Seok, Lee, “Bug-han-eun jeongmal ta-wol-eul deon-jyeossneun-ga [Has North Korean Central Planner Really Thrown in the Towel]?” Bukan gyeongje ribyu [KDI Review on North Korean Economy], June 2004, pp. 17–24; Dong-ho, Jo, “Jung-anggye-hoeg-gyeongje-ui hyeon-sil-hwa: choe-geun bug-han gyeongje-hwal-dong-ui pyeongga-wa bun-seog [Normalization of the Centrally Planned Economic System: Analysis and Assessment of the Recent Economic Actions in North Korea],” Bukan gyeongje ribyu [KDI Review on North Korean Economy], August 2002, pp. 3–17; Ji-ho, Shin, “North Korean Economy Since the July Economic Reform,” Bukan gyeongje ribyu [KDI Review on North Korean Economy], July 2003, pp. 3–14.Google Scholar

41. Sik, Jeong Tae, “Gye-hoeg Ga-gyeog Hyeongseong-gwa Gwan-lyeon-doen Myeoch Ga-ji Mun-je [Some Problems on the Decision of Planned Price],” Economy Building (Pyongyang: Science Encyclopedic Dictionary Publishing Company, October 1957), p. 81.Google Scholar

42. Haseyama, Takahiko, “An Indicative Agricultural Reform of North Korea to Realize the Potential and Sustainable Food Security,” paper presented at the Seminar of Peace and Cooperation, Seoul, August 13, 2004.Google Scholar

43. The World Food Program Emergency Report , October 17, 2005.Google Scholar

44. Joonag daily newspaper, June 8, 2006. The newspaper reported the real situation of the North Korean economy after four years had passed since the economic reform of 2002.Google Scholar

45. Gyeong-ho, Jang, “Bug-han nong-eob-e dae-han gyeongje-gwan-li-che-je-ui byeon-hwa yeonghyang [Impacts the Changes of the Economic Management System Have on Agriculture in North Korea],” paper presented for the conference of the Korean Institute for the Studies of Rural Societies, Seoul, December 30, 2003.Google Scholar