Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-8zxtt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-15T06:34:21.975Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Analyst Promotions within Credit Rating Agencies: Accuracy or Bias?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 March 2019

Darren J. Kisgen ,
Jordan Nickerson ,
Matthew Osborn  and
Jonathan Reuter
Darren J. Kisgen*
Affiliation:
Kisgen, darren.kisgen@bc.edu,
Jordan Nickerson
Affiliation:
Nickerson, jordan.nickerson@bc.edu,
Matthew Osborn
Affiliation:
Reuter, reuterj@bc.edu, Boston College Carroll School of Management
Jonathan Reuter
Affiliation:
Osborn, m.g.osborn@gmail.com, independent scholar
*
Kisgen (corresponding author), darren.kisgen@bc.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We estimate Moody’s preference for accurate versus biased ratings using hand-collected data on the internal labor market outcomes of its analysts. We find that accurate analysts are more likely to be promoted and less likely to depart. The opposite is true for analysts who downgrade more frequently, who assign ratings below those predicted by a ratings model, and whose downgrades are associated with large negative market reactions. Downgraded firms are also more likely to be assigned a new analyst. These patterns are consistent with Moody’s balancing its desire for accuracy against its corporate clients’ desire for higher ratings.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis , Volume 55 , Issue 3 , May 2020 , pp. 869 - 896
Copyright
Copyright © Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

We thank an anonymous referee, Ramin Baghai (discussant), Nicole Boyson, Thomas Chemmanur, Jess Cornaggia (discussant), Matti Keloharju, Vikram Nanda (discussant), Jeffrey Pontiff, Philip Strahan, brown bag participants at Boston College and Harvard University, seminar participants at Bentley University, Georgia State University, Nova School of Economics and Finance, Rice University, University of Arizona, University of Indiana at Bloomington, University of Kansas, and University of Virginia, and conference participants at the 2015 Economics of Credit Rating Agencies, Credit Ratings and Information Intermediaries Conference, the 2015 Colorado Finance Summit, the 2016 Northeastern University Finance Conference, the 2016 University of Connecticut Risk Management Conference, and the 2017 University of Tennessee “Smokey” Mountain Finance Conference for helpful questions and comments. We are grateful to Abe Losice for describing the criteria by which credit rating agencies are evaluated during annual U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission audits. Before collecting data on analyst career paths from LinkedIn.com, we submitted a proposal to Boston College’s Institutional Review Board (IRB). We were granted an exemption from Boston College IRB review in accordance with 45 CFR 46.101 (b) 4. Our IRB Protocol Number is 16.192.01e. The views expressed in this article are solely those of the authors, who are responsible for the content, and do not necessarily represent the views of our employers. Any remaining errors are our own.

References

Ashcraft, A.; Goldsmith-Pinkham, P.; Hull, P.; and Vickery, J.. “Credit Ratings and Security Prices in the Subprime MBS Market.” American Economic Review, 101 (2011), 115–119.Google Scholar
Baghai, R. P.; Servaes, H.; and Tamayo, A.. “Have Rating Agencies Become More Conservative? Implications for Capital Structure and Debt Pricing.” Journal of Finance, 69 (2014), 1961–2005.Google Scholar
Becker, B., and Milbourn, T.. “How Did Increased Competition Affect Credit Ratings? ” Journal of Financial Economics, 101 (2011), 493–514.Google Scholar
Behr, P.; Kisgen, D. J.; and Taillard, J. P.. “Did Government Regulations Lead to Inflated Credit Ratings? ” Management Science, 64 (2018), 1034–1054.Google Scholar
Bolton, P.; Freixas, X.; and Shapiro, J.. “The Credit Ratings Game.” Journal of Finance, 67 (2012), 85–111.Google Scholar
Bongaerts, D.; Cremers, K. M.; and Goetzmann, W. N.. “Tiebreaker: Certification and Multiple Credit Ratings.” Journal of Finance, 67 (2012), 113–152.Google Scholar
Bouvard, M., and Levy, R.. “Two-Sided Reputation in Certification Markets.” Management Science, 64 (2018), 4755–4774.Google Scholar
Cornaggia, J., and Cornaggia, K. J.. “Estimating the Costs of Issuer-Paid Credit Ratings.” Review of Financial Studies, 26 (2013), 2229–2269.Google Scholar
Cornaggia, J.; Cornaggia, K. J.; and Xia, H.. “Revolving Doors on Wall Street.” Journal of Financial Economics, 120 (2016), 400–419.Google Scholar
Fracassi, C.; Petry, S.; and Tate, G.. “Does Rating Analyst Subjectivity Affect Corporate Debt Pricing? ” Journal of Financial Economics, 120 (2016), 514–538.Google Scholar
Frenkel, S.“Repeated Interaction and Rating Inflation: A Model of Double Reputation.” American Economic Journal: Microeconomics, 7 (2015), 250–280.Google Scholar
Griffin, J. M.; Nickerson, J.; and Tang, D. Y.. “Rating Shopping or Catering? An Examination of the Response to Competitive Pressure for CDO Credit Ratings.” Review of Financial Studies, 26 (2013), 2270–2310.Google Scholar
Griffin, J. M., and Tang, D. Y.. “Did Subjectivity Play a Role in CDO Credit Ratings? ” Journal of Finance, 67 (2012), 1293–1328.Google Scholar
Hong, H., and Kubik, J. D.. “Analyzing the Analysts: Career Concerns and Biased Earnings Forecasts.” Journal of Finance, 58 (2003), 313–351.Google Scholar
Jewell, J., and Livingston, M.. “A Comparison of Bond Ratings from Moody’s S&P and Fitch IBCA.” Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments, 8 (1999), 1–45.Google Scholar
Jorion, P.; Liu, Z.; and Shi, C.. “Informational Effects of Regulation FD: Evidence from Rating Agencies.” Journal of Financial Economics, 76 (2005), 309–330.Google Scholar
Kedia, S.; Rajgopal, S.; and Zhou, X. A.. “Did Going Public Impair Moody’s Credit Ratings? ” Journal of Financial Economics, 114 (2014), 293–315.Google Scholar
Kedia, S.; Rajgopal, S.; and Zhou, X. A.. “Large Shareholders and Credit Ratings.” Journal of Financial Economics, 124 (2017), 632–653.Google Scholar
Kempf, E.“The Job Rating Game: The Effects of Revolving Doors on Analyst Incentives.” Journal of Financial Economics, forthcoming (2019).Google Scholar
Kisgen, D. J.“Credit Ratings and Capital Structure.” Journal of Finance, 61 (2006), 1035–1072.Google Scholar
Kisgen, D. J., and Strahan, P. E.. “Do Regulations Based on Credit Ratings Affect a Firm’s Cost of Capital? ” Review of Financial Studies, 23 (2010), 4324–4347.Google Scholar
Manso, G.“Feedback Effects of Credit Ratings.” Journal of Financial Economics, 109 (2013), 535–548.Google Scholar
Michaely, R., and Womack, K.. “Conflict of Interest and Credibility of Underwriter Analyst Recommendations.” Review of Financial Studies, 12 (1999), 653–686.Google Scholar
Opp, C. C.; Opp, M. M.; and Harris, M.. “Rating Agencies in the Face of Regulation.” Journal of Financial Economics, 108 (2013), 46–61.Google Scholar
Persico, N.; Postlewaite, A.; and Silverman, D.. “The Effect of Adolescent Experience on Labor Market Outcomes: The Case of Height.” Journal of Political Economy, 112 (2004), 1019–1053.Google Scholar
Reuter, J., and Zitzewitz, E.. “Do Ads Influence Editors? Advertising and Bias in the Financial Media.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 121 (2006), 197–227.Google Scholar
Skreta, V., and Veldkamp, L.. “Ratings Shopping and Asset Complexity: A Theory of Ratings Inflation.” Journal of Monetary Economics, 56 (2009), 678–695.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Kisgen et al. supplementary material

Kisgen et al. supplementary material

Download Kisgen et al. supplementary material(File)
File 105.9 KB