Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-n9wrp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-20T00:06:03.441Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Models of education in Plutarch*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 January 2010

Timothy E. Duff
Timothy E. Duff
Affiliation:
University of Reading
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

This paper examines Plutarch's treatment of education in the Parallel Lives. Beginning with a close reading of Them. 2, it identifies two distinct ways in which Plutarch exploits the education of his subjects: in the first, a subject's attitude to education is used to illustrate a character presented as basically static (a ‘static/illustrative’ model); in the second, a subject's education is looked at in order to explain his adult character, and education is assumed to affect character (a ‘developmental’ model). These two models are often associated with two different forms of discourse: anecdotal for the static/illustrative model and analytical for the developmental. The developmental model, furthermore, is closer to Plutarch's thinking in theoretical discussions of character in the Moralia; the static/illustrative model to Plutarch's treatment of character in the Lives more generally, where anecdotal treatments predominate. The coexistence of these two models is probably to be seen as the result of a tension between Plutarch's philosophical thinking and his biographical practice: those few passages in the Lives which assume a developmental model occur in contexts where either Platonic texts or the activity of philosophers are being discussed.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Hellenic Studies , Volume 128 , November 2008 , pp. 1 - 26
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Anderson, G. (1993) The Second Sophistic. A Cultural Phenomenon in the Roman Empire (London and New York)Google Scholar
Ash, R. (1997) ‘Severed heads: individual portraits and irrational forces in Plutarch’s Galba and Otho'’, in Mossman, J.M. (ed.), Plutarch and his Intellectual World. Essays on Plutarch (London) 189–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barbu, N.I. (1934) Les Procédés de lapeinture des caractères et la vérité historique dans les biographies de Plutarque (Paris)Google Scholar
Bergen, K. (1962) Charakterbilder bei Tacitus und Plutarch (Diss. Cologne)Google Scholar
Bowie, E.L. (1991) ‘Hellenes and Hellenism in Writers of the 2nd Sophistic’, in Saïd, S. (ed.), ‘EΔΔHNIΣMOΣ’. Quelques jalons pour une histoire de l'identité grecque, Actes du Colloque de Strasbourg 25–7 octobre 1989 (Leiden) 183–204Google Scholar
Brenk, F.E. (1977) In Mist Apparelled. Religious Themes in Plutarch's Moralia and Lives (Leiden)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carena, C. (1983) Translation in Carena, Manfredini and Piccirilli (1983)Google Scholar
Carena, C., Manfredini, M. and Piccirilli, L. (1983) (eds), Le Vite di Temistocle e di Camillo (Milan)Google Scholar
Carney, T.F. (1961) A Biography of C. Marius: an inaugural lecture given in the University College of Rhodesia and Nyasaland (Proceedings of the African Classical Associations Supplement 1, Salisbury, Rhodesia)Google Scholar
Cooper, C. (2002) ‘Aristoxenos, περì βíων and Peripatetic biography’, Mouseion ser. 3, 2 (=EMC/CV 46) 307–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dihle, A. (1956) Studien zur griechischen Biographie (Abhandlungen der Akademie der Wissenschaften in Göttingen, Philologische-historische Klasse 3, 37, Göttingen)Google Scholar
Duff, T.E. (1999) Plutarch's Lives. Exploring Virtue and Vice (Oxford)Google Scholar
Duff, T.E. (2003) ‘Plutarch on the childhood of Alkibiades’, Proceedings of the Cambridge Philological Society 49, 89–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Duff, T.E. (2008) ‘The Opening of Plutarch's Life of Themistokles’, GRBS 48, 159–79Google Scholar
Duff, T.E. (forthcoming, a) ‘Plutarch's Themistokles and Camillus’, in Humble, N. (ed.), Parallelism in Plutarch's Lives (London)Google Scholar
Duff, T.E. (forthcoming, b) ‘“Loving too much”: the text of Plutarch, Themistokles 2.3’, Philologus 153 (2009)Google Scholar
Ferrara, G. (1964) ‘Temistocle e Solone’, Maia 16, 55–70Google Scholar
Frazier, F. (1996) Histoires et morale dans les Vies parallèles de Plutarque (Paris)Google Scholar
Frost, F.J. (1971) ‘Themistocles and Mnesiphilus’, Historia 20, 20–5Google Scholar
Frost, F.J. (1980) (ed.) Plutarch's Themistocles. A Historical Commentary (Princeton) (revised edn, Chicago 1998)Google Scholar
Giannantoni, G. (1990) Socratis et Socraticorum Reliquiae, 4 vols. (Naples)Google Scholar
Gill, C. (1983) ‘The question of character development: Plutarch and Tacitus’, CQ 33, 469–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gill, C. (1990) ‘The Character-Personality Distinction’, in Pelling (1990c) 1–31Google Scholar
Gill, C. (1996) Personality in Greek Epic, Tragedy, and Philosophy: the Self in Dialogue (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gill, C. (2006) The Structured Self in Hellenistic and Roman Thought (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gomme, A.W. (1945) (ed.) A Historical Commentary on Thucydides, 1. Introduction and Commentary on Book I (Oxford)Google Scholar
Hamilton, J.R. (1969) Plutarch: Alexander. A Commentary (Oxford) (reprinted Stadter, P.A. (ed.) London 1999)Google Scholar
Hands, A.R (1974) ‘Postremo suo tanto ingenio utebatur’, CQ 24, 312–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holden, H.A. (1884) πλοντάρχον Θεμιστοκλήζ. Plutarch's Life of Themistocles with introduction, critical and explanatory notes, indices and map (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Hornblower, S. (1991) A commentary on Thucydides, vol. 1 (Oxford)Google Scholar
Jones, C.P. (1966) ‘Towards a Chronology of Plutarch's Works’, JRS 56, 61–74 (reprinted in Scardigli (1995) 75–123)Google Scholar
Larmour, D.H.J. (1992) ‘Making parallels: Synkrisis and Plutarch's “Themistocles and Camillus”’’, ANRW 2.33.6, 4154–200Google Scholar
Lefkowitz, M.R. (1981) The Lives of the Greek Poets (London)Google Scholar
Lombardi, M. (1996) ‘Il principio dell’ εικίζ nel racconto biografico plutarcheo’, RCCM 38, 91–102Google Scholar
Lombardi, M. (1997) ‘Questioni di etica e ritratto biografico nelle “Vite” di Plutarco: la μεταβολή del carattere’, Orpheus 18, 375–95Google Scholar
Madvig, J.N. (1871) Adversaria critica ad scriptores Graecos I (Copenhagen) (reprinted Hildesheim 1967)Google Scholar
Marr, J.L. (1998) (ed.) Plutarch. Life of Themistocles (Warminster)Google Scholar
Martin, H. (1961) ‘The character of Plutarch's Themistocles’, TAPA 92, 326–39Google Scholar
Moles, J.L. (1988) (ed.) Plutarch. The Life of Cicero (Warminster)Google Scholar
Moreno, A. (2007) ‘Abusing Alcibiades’, in G.S. Rousseau (ed.), Children and Sexuality. From the Greeks to the Great War (London) 75–84Google Scholar
Nikolaidis, A.G. (2005) ‘Plutarch's methods: his cross-references and the sequence of the Parallel Lives’, in Pérez Jiménez, A. and Titchener, F. (eds), Historical and Biographical Values of Plutarch's Works. Studies devoted to Professor Philip A. Stadter by the International Plutarch Society (International Plutarch Society, Malaga and Utah) 283–324Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1988) ‘Aspects of Plutarch';s characterisation’, ICS 13.2, 257–74 (reprinted with revisions in id. (2002a) 283–300)Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1989) ‘Plutarch: Roman heroes and Greek culture’, in Griffin, M.T. and Barnes, J. (eds), Philosophia Togata. Essays on Philosophy and Roman Society (Oxford) 199–232Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1990a) ‘Childhood and personality in Greek biography’, in id. (1990c) 213–44 (reprinted with revisions in id. (2002a) 301–38)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1990b) ‘Truth and fiction in Plutarch's Lives’, in Russell (1990) 19–52 (reprinted with revisions in Pelling (2002a) 143–70)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1990c) (ed.) Characterization and Individuality in Greek Literature (Oxford)Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1996) ‘Prefazione’, in Albini, F. (ed.), Plutarco. Vita di Coriolano. Vita di Alcibiade (Milan) xx–lviiiGoogle Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (1997) (ed.) Plutarco. Vite Parallele: Filopemene – Tito Flaminino (Milan) (Italian translation by Melandri, E.)Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (2000) ‘Rhetoric, paideia, and psychology in Plutarch's Lives’, in Van der Stockt, L. (ed.), Rhetorical Theory and Praxis in Plutarch. Acta of the IVth International Congress of the International Plutarch Society, Leuven, July 3–6, 1996 (Collection d’Études Classiques 11, Louvain and Namur) 331–9 (reprinted with revisions in Pelling (2002a) 339–47)Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (2002a) Plutarch and History. Eighteen Studies (London)Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (2002b) ‘Postscript (2001). Constructing personality: a tale of two Gills’ [Addendum to ‘Childhood and Personality in Greek Biography’], in id. (2002a) 321–9Google Scholar
Pelling, C.B.R. (2007) ‘De Malignitate Herodoti? Plutarch, Herodotos and the Persian Wars’, in Bridges, E.E., Hall, E.M. and Rhodes, P.J. (eds), Cultural Responses to the Persian Wars: from antiquity to the third millenium (Oxford) 145–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perrin, B. (1914) Plutarch's Lives 2. Themistocles and Camillus, Aristides and Cato Major, Cimon and Lucullus (Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge, MA and London)Google Scholar
Piccirilli, L. (1982) ‘L’ “apokeryxis”di Temistocle’, in Studi in onore di A. Biscardi (Milan) 343–54Google Scholar
Piccirilli, L. (1983) Introduction and commentary, in Carena, Manfredini and Piccirilli (1983)Google Scholar
Piccirilli, L. (1989) ‘La tradizione “nera” nelle biografie plutarchee degli Ateniesi del sesto e del quinto secolo’, in Ceresa-Gastaldo, A. (ed.), Gerolamo e la biografia letter aria (Pubblicazioni del Dipartimento di Archeologia, Filologia Classica e Loro Tradizioni, NS 125, Genoa) 5–21Google Scholar
Russell, D.A. (1963) ‘Plutarch's Life of Coriolanus’, JRS 53, 21–8 (reprinted in Scardigli (1995) 357–72)Google Scholar
Russell, D.A. (1966) ‘On Reading Plutarch’s Lives’, G&R NS 13, 139–54 (reprinted in Scardigli (1995) 75–94)Google Scholar
Russell, D.A. (1973) Plutarch (London) (reprinted with forward by Mossman, J., London 2001)Google Scholar
Russell, D.A. (1990) (ed.) Antonine Literature (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scardigli, B. (1995) (ed.) Essays on Plutarch's Lives (Oxford)Google Scholar
Stadter, P.A. (1975) ‘Plutarch's Comparison of Pericles and Fabius Maximus’, GRBS 16, 77–85 (reprinted in Scardigli (1995) 155–64)Google Scholar
Stadter, P.A. (1987) ‘The Rhetoric of Plutarch’s Pericles’, AncSoc 18, 251–69Google Scholar
Stadter, P.A. (1989) (ed.) A Commentary on Plutarch's Pericles (Chapel Hill, NC and London)Google Scholar
Stadter, P.A. (1991) ‘Pericles among the intellectuals’, ICS 16, 111–24Google Scholar
Stadter, P.A. (1996) ‘Anecdotes and the thematic structure of Plutarchean biography’, in Fernández Delgado, J.A. and Pordomingo Pardo, F. (eds), Estudios sobre Plutarco: Aspectos formales. Actas del IV Simposio Español sobre Plutarco. Salamanca, 26 a 28 de Mayo de 1994 (Madrid) 291–303Google Scholar
Swain, S.C.R. (1988) ‘Plutarch's Philopoemen and Flamininus’, ICS 13.2, 335–47Google Scholar
Swain, S.C.R. (1989) ‘Character Change in Plutarch’, Phoenix 43, 62–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Swain, S.C.R. (1990) ‘Hellenic culture and the Roman heroes of Plutarch’, JHS 110, 126–45 (reprinted in Scardigli (1995) 229–64)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Swain, S.C.R. (1996) Hellenism and Empire. Language, Classicism and Power in the Greek world AD 50–250 (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trapp, M.B. (1990) ‘Plato's Phaedrus in second-century Greek literature’, in Russell (1990) 141–73Google Scholar
Walsh, J.J. (1992) ‘Syzygy, Theme and History. A Study in Plutarch's Philopoemen and Flamininus’, Philologus 136, 208–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wardman, A.E. (1974) Plutarch's Lives (London)Google Scholar
Whitmarsh, T. (2001) Greek Literature in the Roman Empire (Oxford)Google Scholar
Whitmarsh, T. (2005) The Second Sophistic (Greece and Rome New Surveys in the Classics 35, Oxford)Google Scholar
Yaginuma, S. (1992) ‘Plutarch's language and style’, ANRW 2.33.6, 4726–42Google Scholar
Ziegler, K. (1934) ‘Plutarchstudien’, RhM 83, 211–50Google Scholar