Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-tsvsl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-25T15:08:15.770Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Churches, State and The New Zealand Wars: 1860-1872

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 April 2015

John Stenhouse
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Ever since the Enlightenment, scholars in a variety of disciplines have depicted the Western world as growing inexorably more secular. Modern, secular, and scientific modes of thought, they insist, have steadily driven religion out of the public square. Many have portrayed the secularization of the public sphere as not only inevitable but desirable—a Good Thing. In this article, a case study of the New Zealand wars of the 1860s, I question these assumptions. In Victorian New Zealand during this period, settlers and politicians ejected Christianity from the public square for dark and murky reasons. The Enlightenment grand narrative of secular light banishing religious darkness must be seen for what it is: a powerful modern myth whose historical inadequacies ought carefully to be exposed.

Some context for this case study is essential. Up until the 1860s race relations in New Zealand, Britain's southernmost colony, had been mostly peaceful. The indigenous Maori people had generally welcomed Westerners—explorers, whalers, traders, missionaries, and settlers—into New Zealand. These incoming Pakeha (that is, whites in Maori) lived in a Maori world largely on Maori terms. The Treaty of Waitangi, signed in 1840 between many Maori chiefs and the British Crown, guaranteed the tribes full, exclusive, and undisturbed possession of their lands, forests, and fisheries, and all the rights and priveleges of British subjects. In return Maori ceded sovereignty of New Zealand to the Crown. The Treaty required Maori to sell land to the Crown, not private parties.

Type
New Zealand Symposium
Information
Journal of Law and Religion , Volume 13 , Issue 2 , 1998 , pp. 483 - 507
Copyright
Copyright © Center for the Study of Law and Religion at Emory University 1998

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. See further Turner, F.M., Contesting Cultural Authority: Essays in Victorian Intellectual Life 3–37 (Cambridge U Press, 1993)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2. Orange, Claudia, The Treaty of Waitangi 32–59 (1987)Google Scholar.

3. Olssen, Erik, Where to front Here? Reflections on the Twentieth-Century Historiography of Nineteenth-Century New Zealand, 26 N.Z. J Hist 55 (1992)Google Scholar.

4. Sinclair, K., The Origins of the Maori Wars (1961)Google Scholar; Sinclair, K., A History of New Zealand (1959)Google Scholar; Oliver, W.H., The Story of New Zealand (1960)Google Scholar; Ward, Alan, A Show of Justice: Racial “Amalgamation” in Nineteenth-Century New Zealand (1973)Google Scholar; Dalton, B.J., War and Politics in New Zealand, 1855-1870 (1967)Google Scholar; Wards, Ian, The Shadow of the Land: A Study of British Policy and Racial Conflict in New Zealand, 1832-1852 (1968)Google Scholar; Sinclair, K., Why are Race Relations in New Zealand Better than in South Africa, South Australia or South Dakota? 5 N.Z. J Hist 121–27 (1971)Google Scholar.

5. Belich, James, The New Zealand Wars and the Victorian Interpretation of Racial Conflict 326–30 (1986)Google Scholar.

6. See further Thomas, Nicholas, Colonial Conversions: Difference, Hierarchy, and History in Early Twentieth-Century Evangelical Propaganda, 34 Compar Studies in Soc & Hist 366–89 (1992)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7. See further Baylen, Joseph O. & Gossman, Norbert J., eds, Biographical Dictionary of Modern British Radicals 1830-1870, v 2, 474–78 (1984)Google Scholar; Oliver, W.H., ed, Dictionary of New Zealand Biography Volume One 1769-1869 (hereafter DNZB) 401–02 (1990)Google Scholar.

8. The Auckland Examiner and People's Journal (Dec 11, 1856).

9. Id (January 1, 1857; Sept 9, 1858; April 2, 1857).

10. Id (September 9, 1858; Dec 11, 1856).

11. Id (Jan 8, 1857).

12. Great Britain Parliamentary Papers (hereafter GBPP) [2798] XLI, 48-49. All references are to the Irish U Press edition. For a representative sample of settler letters and petitions see id at 53.

13. G.A. Selwyn to H.J. Tancred April 28, 1860, 48-53 (GBPP, 1861 [2798] XLI) (cited in note 12).

14. GBPP [2798] XLI 60-61 (1861) (cited in note 12).

15. Hawkes Bay Herald (Nov 8, 1860).

16. Hadfield, O., One of England S Little Wars 22, 24–26 (1860)Google Scholar.

17. Hadfield, O., The Second Year of One of England's Little Wars at 4 (1861)Google Scholar; Southern Cross at 3 (April 9, 1861).

18. New Zealand Parliamentary Debates (hereafter NZPD) 186 (Aug 3, 1860); Hadfield, O., A Sequel to “One of England's Little Wars” at 9 (1861)Google Scholar.

19. NZPD 5 316 (08 1860) (cited in note 18)Google Scholar: Hadfield, , A Sequel at 12–13Google Scholar.

20. For the views of settler-politicians see NZPD 3 201 (08 1860)Google Scholar (F.A. Weld) (cited in note 18); Id at 7 211 (August, 1860) (Crosbie Ward); id at 251-53 (Fox); Hadfield, , A Sequel at 6, 14–15 (cited in note 18)Google Scholar.

21. Quoted in MacMorran, Barbara, Octavius Hadfield at 32 (1969)Google Scholar.

22. For the views of both Selwyn and Richmond see GBPP 1861 [2798] XLI, 48-53 (cited in note 12).

23. Selwyn, G.A., Pastoral Letter of the Bishop of New Zealand, to the Members of the Church of England in the Settlement of New Plymouth, passim (1855)Google Scholar.

24. New Zealand Spectator and Cook's Strait Guardian (Aug 11, 1860); Garrett, Helen, Te Manihera: The Life and Times of the Pioneer Missionary Robert Maunsell 216-17, 227 (1991)Google Scholar.

25. Auckland Examiner (May 9, 1860) (I would like to thank Michael Grimshaw for providing me with this and the following reference); Auckland Register at 2-3 (Nov 12, 1860); NZPD 401 (1860) (cited in note 18)Google Scholar; id at 199.

26. Nelson Examiner at 2 (Sept 5, 1860); Taranaki Herald at 2 (May 26, 1860).

27. Auckland Examiner (April 4, 1860).

28. For the views of Lyttelton and Newcastle see Aborigines Protection Soc'y, Occasional Papers No. IV 29–30 (1861)Google Scholar.

29. Stafford, E.W. to Selwyn, G.A., Occasional Papers No. IV. 30 (05 3, 1861)Google Scholar.

30. Auckland Examiner at 2 (April 28, 1860).

31. Mary Anne Martin (Aug 28, 1860) reprinted in Extracts of Letters from New Zealand on the War Question at 18 (1861).

32. Wellington Independent (March 27, 1860).

33. Id.

34. NZPD. 580 (1860) (cited in note 18).

35. Southern Cross (July 17, 1860)

36. Paul, R.B., New Zealand, As It Was and As It Is 25, 39 (1861)Google Scholar; J. Morgan to C.W. Richmond, March 5, 1860, quoted in Scholefield, Guy H., ed, The Richmond-Atkinson Papers 532 (1960)Google Scholar; Drummond, Alison, ed, The Auckland Journals of Vicesimus Lush 1850-1863, 222 (1971)Google Scholar.

37. Howe, K.R., “The Bishop Alien”: Selwyn and the New Zealand Wars of the 1860s, in Limbrick, Warren E., ed, Bishop Selwyn in New Zealand 1841-1868, 94–120Google Scholar, quotations on 109, 110, 114 (1983); Belich, , The New Zealand Wars at 328 (cited in note 5)Google Scholar.

38. Howe, , “The Bishop Alien” at 110 (cited in note 37)Google Scholar.

39. DNZB, I, 2 (cited in note 7)Google Scholar.

40. Hadfield to CMS, April 7, 1864 (quoting Edinburgh Rev at 270 (January 1864), Hadfield Letters. 1838-1869, CMS Archives, quoted in Belich, James, Making Peoples: A History of the New Zealanders, from the Polynesian Settlement to the end of the Nineteenth Century 231 (UHawai'i Press, 1996)Google Scholar.

41. Howe, , “The Bishop Alien” at 110 (cited in note 37)Google Scholar.

42. Id at 111.

43. Quoted in Harrop, A.J., England and the Maori Wars 248 (1937)Google Scholar; Selwyn to Edward Coleridge, December 26, 1865, quoted in Tucker, H.W., Memoir of the Life and Episcopate of George Augustus Selwyn 206–07 (1879)Google Scholar.

44. Tucker, , Memoir at 206–07 (cited in note 43)Google Scholar.

45. DNZB, I, 597–98 (cited in note 7)Google Scholar.

46. Id at I, 285-86.

47. Grace, T.S., A Pioneer Missionary Among the Maoris 1850-1879: Being Letters and Journals of Thomas Samuel Grace, Brittan, S.J.et al, eds, 197–204Google Scholar.

48. Williams, T.C., New Zealand: The Manawatu Purchase Completed; or, the Treaty of Waitangi Broken (1868)Google Scholar.

49. DNZB I, 126-28 (cited in note 7).

50. Domett, Alfred, The Diary of Alfred Domett 1872-1885, Horsman, E.A., ed, 16, 18 (1953)Google Scholar.

51. Nelson Examiner (July 6, 1844).

52. Domett, , Diary at 16–17 (cited in note 50)Google Scholar.

53. Id at 34-35.

54. Spectator (Jan 23, 1864).

55. Richmond, C.W. to Richmond, Emily E., 09 18, 1857, quoted in The Richmond-Atkinson Papers 308Google Scholar; Domett, , Diary at 24–25 (cited in note 50)Google Scholar; for Thomas Arnold's comment see Scholefield, G.H., Notable New Zealand Statesmen: Twelve Prime Ministers 86Google Scholar.

56. For an outstanding brief biography of Russell see DNZB, I, 377–79 (cited in note 7)Google Scholar.

57. For an excellent biography see id at 134-38; on Maori depopulation see Fox, William, The Six Colonies of New Zealand 52, 64 (1851)Google Scholar.

58. NZPD, 325 (Aug 13, 1865) (cited in note 18).