Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-jbqgn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-26T01:56:59.491Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Are Military and Medical Ethics Necessarily Incompatible? A Canadian Case Study

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Christiane Rochon  and
Bryn Williams-Jones
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Military physicians are often perceived to be in a position of ‘dual loyalty’ because they have responsibilities towards their patients but also towards their employer, the military institution. Further, they have to ascribe to and are bound by two distinct codes of ethics (i.e., medical and military), each with its own set of values and duties, that could at first glance be considered to be very different or even incompatible. How, then, can military physicians reconcile these two codes of ethics and their distinct professional/institutional values, and assume their responsibilities towards both their patients and the military institution? To clarify this situation, and to show how such a reconciliation might be possible, we compared the history and content of two national professional codes of ethics: the Defence Ethics of the Canadian Armed Forces and the Code of Ethics of the Canadian Medical Association. Interestingly, even if the medical code is more focused on duties and responsibility while the military code is more focused on core values and is supported by a comprehensive ethical training program, they also have many elements in common. Further, both are based on the same core values of loyalty and integrity, and they are broad in scope but are relatively flexible in application. While there are still important sources of tension between and limits within these two codes of ethics, there are fewer differences than may appear at first glance because the core values and principles of military and medical ethics are not so different.

Type
Independent Articles
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 44 , Issue 4: Health Reform: Assessing the Affordable Care Act and Moving Forward , Winter 2016 , pp. 639 - 651
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2016

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Sidel, V. W. and Levy, B. S., “Physician-Soldier: A Moral Dilemma,” in Beam, T. E. and Sparino, L. R., Military Medical Ethics (Falls Church, VA: Office of the Surgeon General, 2003): at 293–312; E. D. Pellegrino, “The Moral Foundations of the Patient-Physician Relationship: The Essence of Medical Ethics,” in T. E. Beam and L. R. Sparino, Military Medical Ethics (Falls Church, VA: Office of the Surgeon General, 2003): at 3-21; G. J. Annas, “Military Medical Ethics—Physician First, Last, Always,” New England Journal of Medicine 359, no. 11 (2008): 1087-1090; World Medical Association, “WMA Declaration of Geneva,” January 10, 2006, available at <http://www.wma.net/en/30publications/10policies/g1/> (last visited November 1, 2016).Google Scholar
Allhoff, F., ed., Physicians at War: The Dual Loyalty Challenge (New York, NY: Springer, 2008).Google Scholar
See Sidel and Levy, supra note 1; Beam, T. E. and Howe, E. G., “A Proposed Ethic for Military Medicine,” in Military Medical Ethics, in Beam, T. E. and Sparino, L. R., Military Medical Ethics (Falls Church, VA: Office of the Surgeon General, 2003): at 851–865.Google Scholar
London, L., Rubenstein, L. S., Baldwin-Ragaven, I., and Van Es, A., “Dual Loyalty among Military Health Professionals: Human Rights and Ethics in Times of Armed Conflict,” Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 15, no. 4 (2006): 381–391; S. R. Benatar and R. E.G. Upshur, “Dual Loyalty of Physicians in the Military and in Civilian Life,” American Journal of Public Health 98, no. 12 (2008): 2161-2167.Google Scholar
Gross, M. L., Bioethics and Armed Conflict: Moral Dilemmas of Medicine and War (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2006).Google Scholar
Eriksson, S., Höglund, A. T., and Helgesson, G., “Do Ethical Guidelines Give Guidance? A Critical Examination of Eight Ethics Regulations,” Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 17, no. 1 (January 2008): 15–29; E. E. Morrison, Ethics in Health Administration: A Practical Approach for Decision Makers (Jones & Bartlett Publishers, 2010).Google Scholar
Rochon, C., “Dilemmas in Military Medical Ethics: A Call for Conceptual Clarity,” BioéthiqueOnline 4, no. 26 (December 17, 2015), available at <http://bioethiqueonline.ca/4/26> (last visited November 1, 2016).Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “DND and CF Code of Values and Ethics,” July 15, 2013, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/en/about/code-of-values-and-ethics.page?#f.code1> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Koch, T., “Weaponising Medicine: ‘Tutti Fratelli,’ No More,” Journal of Medical Ethics 32, no. 5 (May 1, 2006): 249–255; Gross, supra note 5; M. L. Gross, “Military Medical Ethics: A Review of the Literature and a Call to Arms,” Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 22, no. 1 (2013): 92-109; London et al., supra note 4; S. H. Miles, “The New Military Medical Ethics: Legacies of the Gulf Wars and the War on Terror,” Bioethics 27, no. 3 (March 2013): 117-123; Sidel and Levy, supra note 1.Google Scholar
Robinson, P., de Lee, N., and Carrick, D., eds., Ethics Education in the Military (Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2013).Google Scholar
Hartle, A. E., “The Profession of Arms and the Officer Corps,” in Beam, T. E. and Sparino, L. R., eds., Military Medical Ethics (Falls Church, VA: Office of the Surgeon General, 2003): 127–156.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Canadian Forces Officer General Specification,” Government of Canada, October 1994, at p. ii–iii.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” Ottawa, ON: Defence Ethics Programme, National Defence, January 2002, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/assets/FORCES_Internet/docs/en/about/fundamentals-fondements-eng.pdf> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Kasurak, P. C., “Civilianization and the Military Ethos: Civil-Military Relations in Canada,” Canadian Public Administration 25, no. 1 (1982): 108–129, at 108, available at <http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1754-7121.1982.tb02067.x/full> (last visited November 2, 2016); see Robinson, de Lee, and Carrick, supra note 10.Google Scholar
Id. (Kasurak).Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, Duty with Honour: The Profession of Arms in Canada, 2nd ed. (Ottawa, ON: Government of Canada, 2009): at 2.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Defence Ethics Programme,” March 3, 2014, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/en/about/defence-ethics.page> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Terms of Reference: Defence Ethics Program,” December 21, 1997, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/en/about/ethics-terms-reference-letter.page?> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” supra note 13.Google Scholar
Treasury Board of Canada, “Values and Ethics Code for the Public Sector,” Code, December 15, 2011, available at <http://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/pol/doc-eng.aspx?id=25049> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
See Department of National Defence, “DND and CF Code of Values and Ethics,” supra note 8.Google Scholar
See Department of National Defence, Duty with Honour: The Profession of Arms in Canada, supra note 16.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Statement of Defence Ethics,” September 27, 2013, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/en/about/statement-of-defence-ethics.page?> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” supra note 3; Department of National Defence, “DND and CF Code of Values and Ethics,” supra note 8.Google Scholar
This “values-based” approach to ethics is explicitly articulated in the DEP as being in contrast to other common approaches that are either compliance-based (i.e., formal rule following, a traditional feature of strongly hierarchical military institutions) or prevention-based (to identify and manage patterns or departments where risks are greatest); Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” supra note 3.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Defence Ethics Programme,” supra note 17.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, Introduction to Defence Ethics: Student Manual, 2nd ed. (Ottawa, ON: Government of Canada, 2005): 20.Google Scholar
Rest, J., “Background: Theory and Research,” in Moral Development in the Professions: Psychology and Applied Ethics (New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., 1994): 1–26, at 8.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” supra note 3.Google Scholar
See Hartle, supra note 11.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” supra note 3.Google Scholar
Id., at 7-8.Google Scholar
Walzer, M., “Two Kinds of Military Responsibility,” in Matthews, L. J. and Brown, D. E., eds., The Parameters of Military Ethics (Toronto: Pergamon Press Canada, 1989): 67–72.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, “Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics,” supra note 3.Google Scholar
Id., at 28.Google Scholar
Id., at 29.Google Scholar
Dursun, S., Morrow, R. O., and Beauchamp, D. L. J., “2003 Defence Ethics Survey Report,” Ottawa, ON: Director Human Resources Research and Evaluation, Government of Canada, February 2005, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/assets/FORCES_Internet/docs/en/about-reports-pubs-ethics/2003-ethics-survey-report.pdf> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Fraser, K., “The 2007 Defence Ethics Survey: Summary of the Overall CF and DND Findings for Decision-Makers,” Ottawa, ON: Defence R&D Canada, Director General Military Personnel Research & Analysis, Government of Canada, August 2008, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/assets/FORCES_Internet/docs/en/about-reports-pubs-ethics/2007-ethics-survey-report.pdf> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Messervey, D. L., Howell, G. T., Gou, T., and Yelle, M., “2010 Defence Ethics Survey Report,” DGMPRA TM 2011-037, Ottawa, ON: Defence R&D Canada, Director General Military Personnel Research & Analysis, Government of Canada, December 2011, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/assets/FORCES_Internet/docs/en/about-reports-pubs-ethics/2010-ethics-survey-report.pdf> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Kelloway, E. K., Barling, J., Harvey, S., Adams-Roy, Major J. E., and Wild, W. R., “Ethical Decision Making in the DND: The Development of a Measuring Instrument. Sponsor Research Report 99-14,” National Defense Director Human Ressources Research and Evaluation, Ottawa, Canada, 1999, available at <http://www.forces.gc.ca/assets/FORCES_Internet/docs/en/about-reports-pubs-ethics/ethical-values-assessment-phase-1.pdf> (last visited November 2, 2016).Google Scholar
See Fraser, supra note 40, at 21.Google Scholar
Durand, G., Introduction générale à la bioéthique: histoire, concepts et outils (Les Editions Fides, 2005); N. Didier, L'évolution de la pensée en éthique médicale (Paris: Connaissances et Savoirs, 2005).Google Scholar
World Medical Association, “WMA Declaration of Geneva,” January 10, 2006, available at <http://www.wma.net/en/30publications/10policies/g1/> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
World Medical Association, “WMA International Code of Medical Ethics,” “WMA International Code of Medical Ethics,” January 10, 2006, available at <http://www.wma.net/en/30publications/10policies/c8/> (last visited November 2, 2016).+(last+visited+November+2,+2016).>Google Scholar
Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” CMA, 1956, available at <http://www.royalcollege.ca/rcsite/documents/bioethics/cma-code-ethics-1956.pdf> (last visited December 5, 2016).+(last+visited+December+5,+2016).>Google Scholar
Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” 2004, available at <http://www.cma.ca/code-of-ethics>. It is important to note that in Canada, each province has its own medical association, working under the umbrella of the Canadian Medical Association. An exception is the Quebec the Code of Ethics of Physicians Gouvernement du Québec, Code of Ethics of Physicians., which is written into the Medical Act and Professional Act of the Quebec Civil Code, and so is somewhat distinct from the CMA Code of Ethics because it also has the force of law. Also, in Canada, the medical profession is characterized by a distinction between primary care physicians (General practitioners) and specialists. The latter are represented by The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, whose bylaws adhere to the CMA code of ethics. See Gouvernement du Québec, Code of Ethics of Physicians, CQLR c M-9, R. 17, available at <http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge.php?type=3&file=/M_9/M9R17_A.HTM> (last visited November 3, 2016)...+It+is+important+to+note+that+in+Canada,+each+province+has+its+own+medical+association,+working+under+the+umbrella+of+the+Canadian+Medical+Association.+An+exception+is+the+Quebec+the+Code+of+Ethics+of+Physicians+Gouvernement+du+Québec,+Code+of+Ethics+of+Physicians.,+which+is+written+into+the+Medical+Act+and+Professional+Act+of+the+Quebec+Civil+Code,+and+so+is+somewhat+distinct+from+the+CMA+Code+of+Ethics+because+it+also+has+the+force+of+law.+Also,+in+Canada,+the+medical+profession+is+characterized+by+a+distinction+between+primary+care+physicians+(General+practitioners)+and+specialists.+The+latter+are+represented+by+The+Royal+College+of+Physicians+and+Surgeons+of+Canada,+whose+bylaws+adhere+to+the+CMA+code+of+ethics.+See+Gouvernement+du+Québec,+Code+of+Ethics+of+Physicians,+CQLR+c+M-9,+R.+17,+available+at++(last+visited+November+3,+2016)..>Google Scholar
Veatch, 1995.Google Scholar
Callahan, D. and Jennings, B., “Ethics and Public Health: Forging a Strong Relationship,” American Journal of Public Health 92, no. 2 (2002): 169–176; see Durand, supra note 45.Google Scholar
Marchand, M., “La déontologie médicale,” in Histoire de l'éthique médicale et infirmière, Les Presses de l'Universtié de Montréal (Montréal, Canada: Durand, G. et coll., 2000): at 353–361.Google Scholar
World Medical Association, Medical Ethics Manual, 2nd ed., 2009, available at <http://www.wma.net/en/30publications/30ethicsmanual/> (last visited November 3, 2016); Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” 1996, available at <https://www.cma.ca/Assets/assets-library/document/en/advocacy/policy-research/CMA_Policy_Code_of_ethics_of_the_Canadian_Medical_Association_Update_2004_PD04-06-e.pdf> (last visited December 5, 2016).+(last+visited+November+3,+2016);+Canadian+Medical+Association,+“CMA+Code+of+Ethics,”+1996,+available+at++(last+visited+December+5,+2016).>Google Scholar
Id. (World Medical Association).Google Scholar
Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” 1970, available at <http://www.royalcollege.ca/rcsite/documents/bioethics/cma-code-ethics-1970.pdf> (last visited December 5, 2016).+(last+visited+December+5,+2016).>Google Scholar
Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” 1996, available at <http://www.royalcollege.ca/rcsite/documents/bioethics/cma-code-ethics-1996.pdf> (last visited December 5, 2016).+(last+visited+December+5,+2016).>Google Scholar
See Pellegrino, supra note 1, at 10.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Blank, L., Kimball, H., McDonald, W., and Merino, J., “Medical Professionalism in the New Millennium: A Physician Charter 15 Months Later,” Annals of Internal Medicine 138, no. 10 (May 20, 2003): 839–841.Google Scholar
ABIM Foundation, ACP–ASIM Foundation, and European Federation of Internal Medicine, “Medical Professionalism in the New Millennium: A Physician Charter,” Annals of Internal Medicine 136, no. 3 (February 5, 2002): 243–246.Google Scholar
Allmark, P., “An Argument for the Use of Aristotelian Method in Bioethics,” Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 9, no. 1 (March 2006): 69–79.Google Scholar
See Canadian Medical Association, supra note 49.Google Scholar
See Department of National Defence, supra note 27.Google Scholar
See Department of National Defence, supra note 23.Google Scholar
Department of National Defence, supra note 8.Google Scholar
Canadian Medical Association, supra note 49.Google Scholar
Eriksson, S., Helgesson, G., and Höglund, A. T., “Being, Doing, and Knowing: Developing Ethical Competence in Health Care,” Journal of Academic Ethics 5, nos. 2-4 (2007): 207–216; Eriksson, Höglund, and Helgesson, supra note 6.Google Scholar
Id. (Eriksson, Helgesson, and Höglund, “Being, Doing, and Knowing”); Eriksson, Höglund, and Helgesson, supra note 6.Google Scholar
See Department of National Defence, supra note 3.Google Scholar
See Department of National Defence, supra note 8.Google Scholar
See Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” supra note 49.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Kass, N. E., “Public Health Ethics from Foundations and Frameworks to Justice and Global Public Health,” Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 32, no. 2 (2004): 232–342; M. J. Roberts and M. R. Reich, “Ethical Analysis in Public Health,” The Lancet 359, no. 9311 (March 23, 2002): 1055-1059.Google Scholar
Bayer, R. and Fairchild, A. L., “The Genesis of Public Health Ethics,” Bioethics 18, no. 6 (November 2004): 473–492.Google Scholar
Levin, B. W., Wolder, B., and Fleischman, A. R., “Public Health and Bioethics: The Benefits of Collaboration,” American Journal of Public Health 92, no. 2 (February 1, 2002): 165–167; see Kass, supra note 76; Callahan and Jennings, supra note 52.Google Scholar
Childress, J. F., Faden, R. R., Gaare, R. D., Gostin, L. O., Kahn, J., Bonnie, R. J., Kass, N. E., Mastroianni, A. C., Moreno, J. D., and Nieburg, P., “Public Health Ethics: Mapping the Terrain,” Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethic 30, no. 2 (2002): 170–178, at 177.Google Scholar
Canadian Medical Association, “CMA Code of Ethics,” supra note 49.Google Scholar
See Benatar and Upshur, supra note 4.Google Scholar
Woodgate, J., “An Analysis of the Canadian Defense Ethics Program Decision-Making Guidance,” Faculty of the U.S. ArmyCommand and General Staff College, 2004, available at <http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a428670.pdf> (last visited November 3, 2016).+(last+visited+November+3,+2016).>Google Scholar
Hunt, M. R., Sinding, C., and Schwartz, L., “Tragic Choices in Humanitarian Health Work,” Journal of Clinical Ethics 23, no. 4 (2012): 338–344, at 3.Google Scholar
See Eriksson, Helgesson, and Höglund, “Being, Doing, and Knowing,” supra note 68.Google Scholar
Mellor, C., “The Canadian Medical Code of Ethics Annoted for Psychiatrists,” 1978, available at <http://ww1.cpa-apc.org:8080/publications/position_papers/cma.asp> (last visited November 3, 2016).Google Scholar
Neilson, G., “The 1996 CMA Code of Ethics Annoted for Psychiatrist,” Canadian Psychiatric Association, 2002, available at <http://www.capda.ca/docs/default-source/ethics-codes-and-practice-guidelines-for-assessment/canadian-psychiatric-association-the-cma-code-of-ethics-annotated-for-psychiatrists-2002.pdf?sfvrsn=2> (last visited November 3, 2016).Google Scholar
British Medical Association, “Ethical Decision-Making for Doctors in the Armed Forces BMA Medical Ethics Department,” 2012, available at <http://bma.org.uk/support-at-work/ethics/armed-forces-ethical-decision-making-toolkit> (last visited November 3, 2016).+(last+visited+November+3,+2016).>Google Scholar