Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-m42fx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-16T13:28:00.095Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Recidivism Regarded From the Environmental and Psycho-Pathological Standpoints

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 November 2020

J. F. Sutherland*
Affiliation:
Lunacy for Scotland

Extract

The foregoing examples of degenerates, obsessionists, feeble-minded and mentally warped could be multiplied indefinitely. They present minor and less striking phases of the degeneracy and mental disorders met with in asylums, and require, whether at large or in confinement, some part of the care, supervision, and treatment which are accorded to the major degenerates whom it has been found necessary to certify as fitted for detention in asylums. In these institutions may be seen paretic dements, paranoiacs, precocious dements (katatoniacs), maniacs, imbeciles, terminal dements, etc., prone to, and who may have committed, arson; folies circulaires, hysterics, maniacs, moral imbeciles, and imbeciles prone to malicious mischief or criminal prankishness; erotics, senile dements, paretic dements, alcoholics, maniacs, epileptics, and imbeciles prone to indecent propensities, rape, sexual perversion, and the entire gamut of erotic besetments; general paralytics (first stage), imbeciles, kleptomaniacs, climacterics, prone to, and who may have fallen into the hands of the authorities for, theft; homicidal maniacs, epileptics, katatoniacs, paranoiacs, puerperals, alcoholics, and dipsomaniacs who may have committed crimes of blood, cruelty and violence before certification, or who by mere accident may not. These are the many points where criminality and lunacy touch, and it seems at present either a question of the degree of the mental warp or its non-detection which decides whether the asylum or the gaol shall be the destiny of such.

Type
Part I.—Original Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 1908

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

(1) Vide Article II, p. 568, July, 1907, of Journal of Mental Science.

(2) Mendel, Berlin, Lietbaden der Psychiatrie, 1907.

(3) Vide “Morison Lectures,” Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh, 1906.

(4) Science article in Scotsman, December, 1907.

(5) Sitting in Edinburgh, June, 1906.

(6) “The Jurisprudence of Intoxication,” by J. F. Sutherland, Edinburgh Judicial Review, July, 1898.

(7) Criminal Responsibility, Clarendon Press.

(8) The Right Hon. H. Gladstone, M.P., Home Secretary, at City of London Magistrates' Club, December, 1907.

(9) Tra la Perduta Gente, by Signor Rosadi, 1907.

Errata.—“Article I, p. 346, total convictions, Class II, 103,933; grand total, Classes I and II, 124,223; number of individuals, Class I, 7,400, Class II, 32,600, and both, 40,000; p. 352, line twenty-second, the figures are 32,500, and line thirtyninth, apprehensions, etc., should be 810,950, or 1 to 40 of population, and convictions 1 to 49, and number of individuals 149,300, or 1 to 220; p. 353, total for breach of peace and drunkenness, 293,260, of vagrancy, 36,298, and of Class II, 711,020; grand total of apprehensions, I and II, 810,950, and of convictions, 660,300, and of number of individuals, 149,300; p. 354, first line, apprehended number, 810,950, and ninth line, paltry offences, 711,020, or 87 per cent, of all, or 1 to 46 of population; p. 355, line third, 304,790, line fourth, 1 to 107 and 36,300, line fifth, 1 to 900, and line sixth, 369,935, or 52 per cent.

Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.