Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-gvh9x Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-18T07:32:23.017Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Community policing and the politics of local development in Tanzania*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 November 2014

Charlotte Cross
Charlotte Cross*
Affiliation:
School of Social Sciences, University of Northampton, Park Campus, Boughton Green Road, Northampton, NN2 7AL, United Kingdom
*
Email: charlotte.cross@northampton.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper explores how the concept of ‘community policing’ has been understood and implemented in Tanzania. Whilst community policing is locally considered to be a very effective means of preventing crime and improving neighbourhood safety, the extent to which it constitutes a more accountable, responsive or ‘democratic’ form of policing, as assumed by proponents, is questionable. Based on research conducted in the city of Mwanza, this paper explains these outcomes in terms of continuities between forms of popular mobilisation that developed during Tanzania's socialist one-party era, and particularly the co-optation by the ruling party of sungusungu vigilantism, and understandings of the role of citizen participation in local development today. However, this paper suggests that as multiparty political competition becomes increasingly competitive, the sustainability of this model of community policing may be undermined, as citizens challenge the notion that they are obliged to provide resources for development directed from above.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Modern African Studies , Volume 52 , Issue 4 , December 2014 , pp. 517 - 540
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

This paper is based on PhD research funded by the Africa Power and Politics research consortium (www.institutions-africa.org). I would like to thank Stephen John Shipula for his assistance during fieldwork, and John Giblin, Katie McKeown and two anonymous reviewers for constructive comments on earlier drafts of this paper. All errors and omissions are my own.

References

REFERENCES

Abrahams, R. 1987. ‘Sungusungu village vigilante groups in Tanzania’, African Affairs 86, 343: 179–96.Google Scholar
Abrahams, R. 1989. ‘Law and order and the state in the Sukuma and Nyamwezi area of Tanzania’, Africa 59, 3: 356–70.Google Scholar
Abrahams, R. & Bukurura, S.H.. 1992. ‘Party, bureaucracy and grassroots initiatives in a socialist state: the case of sungusungu village vigilantes in Tanzania’, in Hann, C.M., ed. Socialism: ideals, ideologies and local practice. Abingdon: Routledge, 77–87.Google Scholar
Anderson, D.M. & Killingray, D.. 1991. ‘Consent, coercion and colonial control: policing the empire, 1830–1940’, in Anderson, D.M. & Killingray, D., eds. Policing the Empire: government, authority and control, 1830–1940. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1–17.Google Scholar
Baker, B. 2005. ‘Multi-choice policing in Uganda’, Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy 15, 1: 19–41.Google Scholar
Baker, B. 2007. ‘Reconstructing a policing system out of the ashes: Rwanda's solution’, Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy 17, 4: 344–66.Google Scholar
Baker, B. 2008. ‘Community policing in Freetown, Sierra Leone: foreign import or local solution?’, Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 2, 1: 23–42.Google Scholar
Baker, B. 2009. ‘A policing partnership for post-war Africa? Lessons from Liberia and southern Sudan’, Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy 19, 4: 372–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bienen, H. 1970. Tanzania: party transformation and economic development. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Brogden, M. 2002. ‘Implanting community policing in South Africa: a failure of history, of context and of theory’, Liverpool Law Review 24, 3: 157–79.Google Scholar
Brogden, M. 2004. ‘Commentary: community policing: a panacea from the west’, African Affairs 103, 413: 635–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brogden, M. 2005. ‘“Horses for courses” and “thin blue lines”: community policing in transitional society’, Police Quarterly 8, 1: 64–98.Google Scholar
Bukurura, S.H. 1994a. ‘The maintenance of order in rural Tanzania: the case of Sungusungu’, Journal of Legal Pluralism 34: 1–29.Google Scholar
Bukurura, S.H. 1994b. ‘Sungusungu and the banishment of suspected witches in Kahama’, in Abrahams, R., ed. Witchcraft in Contemporary Tanzania. Cambridge: African Studies Centre, University of Cambridge, 61–9.Google Scholar
Bukurura, S.H. 1996. ‘Combating crime among the Sukuma and Nyamwezi of West-Central Tanzania’, Crime, Law and Social Change 24: 257–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burton, A. 2003. ‘“Brothers by day”: colonial policing in Dar es Salaam under British rule, 1919–61’, Urban History 30, 1: 63–91.Google Scholar
Caplan, P. 1992. ‘Socialism from above: the view from below’, in Forster, P. & Maghimbi, S., eds. The Tanzanian Peasantry: economy in crisis. Aldershot: Avebury, 103–23.Google Scholar
Campbell, H. 1989. ‘Popular resistance in Tanzania: lessons from the sungusungu’, African Development 14, 4: 5–43.Google Scholar
Chaliga, A. 2008. Local Autonomy and Citizen Participation in Tanzania: from a local government reform perspective. Research for Poverty Alleviation (REPOA) Special Paper 08.26. Dar es Salaam: REPOA.Google Scholar
Cleaver, F. & Toner, A.. 2006. ‘The evolution of community water governance in Uchira, Tanzania: the implications for equality of access, sustainability and effectiveness’, Natural Resources Forum 30, 3: 207–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI). 2006. The Police, The People, The Politics: police accountability in Tanzania. New Delhi: CHRI.Google Scholar
Cornwall, A. 2006. ‘Historical perspectives on participation in development’, Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 44, 1: 62–83.Google Scholar
Dill, B. 2009. ‘The paradoxes of community-based participation in Dar es Salaam’, Development and Change 40, 4: 717–43.Google Scholar
Ellison, G. 2007. ‘Fostering a dependency culture: the commodification of community policing in a global marketplace’, in Goldsmith, A. & Sheptycki, J., eds. Crafting Transnational Policing: police capacity building and global policing reform. Oxford: Hart, 203–42.Google Scholar
European Union (EU) Election Observation Mission. 2010. Tanzania Final Report: general election October 2010.Google Scholar
Ewald, J. 2011. Challenges for the Democratisation Process in Tanzania: moving towards consolidation 50 years after independence? Gothenburg: University of Gothenburg.Google Scholar
Grawert, E. 2009. Departures from Post-Colonial Authoritarianism. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Green, M. 2010a. ‘After ujamaa? cultures of governance and the representation of power in Tanzania’, Social Analysis 54, 1: 15–34.Google Scholar
Green, M. 2010b. ‘Making development agents: participation as a boundary object in international development’, Journal of Development Studies 46, 7: 1240–63.Google Scholar
Hangaya, M. 1989. ‘The state and the peasantry in Tanzania: lessons from sungusungu/basalama of Shinyanga’. University of Dar es Salaam, MA dissertation.Google Scholar
Heald, S. 2002. ‘Domesticating leviathan: sungusungu groups in Tanzania’. London: London School of Economics, Crisis States Research Centre, Working Paper 16.Google Scholar
Heald, S. 2006. ‘State, law and vigilantism in northern Tanzania’, African Affairs 105, 419: 265–83.Google Scholar
Hills, A. 2012. ‘Lost in translation: why Nigeria's police don't implement democratic reforms’, International Affairs 88, 4: 739–55.Google Scholar
Hoffman, B. & Robinson, L.. 2009. ‘Tanzania's missing opposition’, Journal of Democracy 20, 4: 123–36.Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch. 2013. ‘Treat Us Like Human Beings’: discrimination against sex workers, sexual and gender minorities, and people who use drugs in Tanzania. New York, NY: Human Rights Watch.Google Scholar
Jennings, M. 2003. ‘“We must run while others walk”: popular participation and development crisis in Tanzania, 1961-9’, Journal of Modern African Studies 41, 2: 163–87.Google Scholar
Jennings, M. 2007. ‘“A very real war”: popular participation in development in Tanzania during the 1950s & 1960s’, International Journal of African Historical Studies 40, 1: 71–95.Google Scholar
Kakoti, G.R. 1998. ‘Community crime prevention in Africa: a study of sungusungu citizen patrols in Tanzania’. Indiana University, MA dissertation.Google Scholar
Killingray, D. 1986. ‘The maintenance of law and order in British colonial Africa’, African Affairs 85, 340: 411–37.Google Scholar
Kyed, H. 2010. ‘The contested role of community policing: “new” non-state actors in the plural legal landscape of post-war Mozambique’. Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies (DIIS), Working Paper 2010:26.Google Scholar
Lange, S. 2008. ‘The depoliticisation of development and the democratisation of politics in Tanzania: parallel structures as obstacles to delivering services to the poor’, Journal of Development Studies 44, 8: 1122–44.Google Scholar
Legal and Human Rights Centre (LHRC). 2012. Tanzania Human Rights Report 2011. Dar es Salaam: LHRC.Google Scholar
Legal and Human Rights Centre (LHRC). 2013. Tanzania Human Rights Report 2012. Dar es Salaam: LHRC.Google Scholar
Levine, K. 1972. ‘The TANU ten-house cell system’, in Cliffe, L. & Saul, J., eds. Socialism in Tanzania, Volume 1. Dar es Salaam: East African Publishing House, 329–37.Google Scholar
Makulilo, A.B. 2011. ‘“Watching the watcher”: an evaluation of local election observers in Tanzania’, Journal of Modern African Studies 49, 2: 241–62.Google Scholar
Mallya, E. 1994. ‘Law and order in Tanzania: the prime vote winner’, Police Studies: International Review of Police Development 17, 3: 69–81.Google Scholar
Marenin, O. 2009a. ‘Foreword’, in Wisler, D. & Onwudiwe, I.D., eds. Community Policing: international patterns and comparative perspective. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, vii–xii.Google Scholar
Marenin, O. 2009b. ‘The futures of policing African states’, Police Practice and Research 10, 4: 349–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marsland, R. 2006. ‘Community participation the Tanzanian way: conceptual contiguity or power struggle?’ Oxford Development Studies 34, 1: 65–79.Google Scholar
Masanja, P. 1992. ‘Some notes on the Sungusungu movement’, in Forster, P.G. & Maghimbi, S., eds. The Tanzanian Peasantry: economy in crisis. Aldershot: Avebury, 203–15.Google Scholar
Mesaki, S. 2009. ‘The tragedy of ageing: witchcraft killings and poor governance among the Sukuma’, in Haram, L. & Yamba, C.B., eds. Dealing with Uncertainty in Contemporary African Lives. Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet, 72–90.Google Scholar
Mwaikusa, J.T. 1995. ‘Maintaining law and order in Tanzania: the case of sungusungu defense groups’, in Semboja, J. & Therkildsen, O., eds. Service Provisioning under Stress in East Africa. Copenhagen: Centre for Development Research, 166–78.Google Scholar
Nelson, N. & Wright, S.. 1995. ‘Participation and power’, in Nelson, N. & Wright, S., eds. Power and Participatory Development: theory and practice. London: ITDG, 1–18.Google Scholar
Norman, A.S. & Massoi, L.. 2010. ‘Decentralization by devolution: reflections on community involvement in planning process’, Educational Reviews 5: 314–22.Google Scholar
Pratt, C. 1979. ‘Tanzania's transition to socialism: reflections of a democratic socialist’, in Mwansasu, B.U. & Pratt, C., eds. Towards Socialism in Tanzania. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 193–236.Google Scholar
Pratten, D. & Sen, A.. 2008. ‘Global vigilantes: perspectives on justice and violence’, in Pratten, D. & Sen, A., eds. Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press, 1–24.Google Scholar
Rabé, P. & Kamanzi, A.. 2012. ‘Power analysis: a study of participation at the local level in Tanzania’. Leiden: Leiden University African Studies Centre, Working Paper 105.Google Scholar
Ruteere, M. & Pommerolle, M.. 2002. ‘Democratizing security or decentralizing repression? The ambiguities of community policing in Kenya’, African Affairs 102, 409: 587–607.Google Scholar
Safer Cities Dar es Salaam. 2000. ‘Crime and Policing Issues in Dar es Salaam Focusing on Community Neighbourhood Watch Groups: “Sungusungu”’. Paper presented at the Sub-Saharan Executive Policing Conference, International Association of Chiefs of Police, Durban, 27–30 August, 2000.Google Scholar
Schneider, L. 2007. ‘High on modernity? Explaining the failings of Tanzanian villagisation’, African Studies 66, 1: 9–38.Google Scholar
Shaidi, L.P. 1989. ‘Crime, justice and politics in contemporary Tanzania: state power in an underdeveloped social formation’, International Journal of the Sociology of Law 17, 3: 247–71.Google Scholar
Shivji, I. 1990. State Coercion and Freedom in Tanzania. Roma: National University of Lesotho.Google Scholar
Skolnick, J.H. & Bayley, D.H.. 1988. Community Policing: issues and practices around the world. Washington DC: National Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
Stavrou, A. & O'Riordan, J.. 2005. Victimisation in Tanzania: surveys of crime in Arusha, Dar es Salaam and Mtwara. Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies.Google Scholar
Tanzania Police Force (TPF). 2008a. Annual Report for the Year 2008. Dar es Salaam: TPF.Google Scholar
Tanzania Police Force (TPF). 2008b. Utaratibu wa Kuanzisha Vikundi vya Ulinzi Shirikishi katika Shehia, Mtaa, Kijiji na Kitongoji. Dar es Salaam: TPF.Google Scholar
Tanzania Police Force (TPF). 2009. Annual Report for the Year 2009. Dar es Salaam: TPF.Google Scholar
Tibasana, L.M. 2002. ‘Effective administration of the police and prosecution in criminal justice: the practice and experience of the United Republic of Tanzania’. Paper presented at the United Nations Asia and Far East Institute for the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders 120th International Senior Seminar, Tokyo, 15 January–14 February, 2002.Google Scholar
Tilley, N. 2008. ‘Modern approaches to policing: community, problem-oriented and intelligence-led’, in Newburn, T., ed. Handbook of Policing. Second edition. Cullompton: Willan, 373–403.Google Scholar
Transparency International. 2012. East Africa Bribery Index 2012. Nairobi: Transparency International-Kenya.Google Scholar
Tripp, A. 1992. ‘Local organisations, participation and the state in urban Tanzania’, in Hyden, G. & Bratton, M., eds. Governance and Politics in Africa. Boulder, CA: Lynne Reiner, 221–42.Google Scholar
Widner, J. 2001. Building the Rule of Law. New York, NY: W.W. Norton.Google Scholar
Daily News. 2011. ‘Politicking disturbing community policing efforts’, 12 July.Google Scholar
Tanzania Daima. 2009. ‘CHADEMA yakataa polisi jamii’, 15 December.Google Scholar
The Guardian. 2011. ‘Why Tanzania needs community policing system’, 27 March.Google Scholar
The Guardian. 2013. ‘Police officers not enough says Silima’, 2 February.Google Scholar
Secretary of community policing-C, Mwanza, 23.11.11.Google Scholar
Survey participant-10, 47-year-old male, Mwanza, 31.7.11.Google Scholar
Survey participant-13, 22-year-old female, Mwanza, 1.8.11.Google Scholar
Survey participant-14, 17-year-old male, Mwanza, 1.8.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-B 3, Mwanza, 6.11.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-B 4, Mwanza, 16.11.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-C 5, Mwanza, 18.11.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-C 6, Mwanza, 23.11.11.Google Scholar
Ward Executive Officer-C, former secretary of sungusungu, Mwanza, 16.8.2011.Google Scholar
Daily News. 2011. ‘Politicking disturbing community policing efforts’, 12 July.Google Scholar
Tanzania Daima. 2009. ‘CHADEMA yakataa polisi jamii’, 15 December.Google Scholar
The Guardian. 2011. ‘Why Tanzania needs community policing system’, 27 March.Google Scholar
The Guardian. 2013. ‘Police officers not enough says Silima’, 2 February.Google Scholar
Secretary of community policing-C, Mwanza, 23.11.11.Google Scholar
Survey participant-10, 47-year-old male, Mwanza, 31.7.11.Google Scholar
Survey participant-13, 22-year-old female, Mwanza, 1.8.11.Google Scholar
Survey participant-14, 17-year-old male, Mwanza, 1.8.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-B 3, Mwanza, 6.11.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-B 4, Mwanza, 16.11.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-C 5, Mwanza, 18.11.11.Google Scholar
Ten-cell leader-C 6, Mwanza, 23.11.11.Google Scholar
Ward Executive Officer-C, former secretary of sungusungu, Mwanza, 16.8.2011.Google Scholar