Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T15:48:07.626Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Guatemalan Military Since the Peace Accords: The Fate of Reform Under Arzú and Portillo

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

J. Mark Ruhl
J. Mark Ruhl*
Affiliation:
Dickinson College
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Guatemalan military dominated the country's politics for nearly half a century, but its political power declined during the 1990s. Democratically elected presidents Alvaro Arzú (1996–2000) and Alfonso Portillo (2000–2004) subordinated the armed forces to their authority and thereby gained an unprecedented opportunity to reduce the role of the military and institutionalize democratic civil-military relations. Unfortunately, neither of these tasks was accomplished. An analysis of the level of democratic control, combining Alfred Stepan's military prerogatives indicators with a newer system of measurement and classification designed by Samuel Fitch, shows that the armed forces retained substantial institutional autonomy and de facto legal immunity when Portillo left office in 2004. The role of the military in Guatemalan society, moreover, expanded again under Portillo after declining under Arzú. This study finds that the lack of sufficient civilian commitment to reform, rather than resistance from the armed forces, was the principal cause of these disappointing outcomes.

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 47 , Issue 1 , Spring 2005 , pp. 55 - 85
Copyright
Copyright © University of Miami 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aguilera Peralta, Gabriel. 2001. Guatemalan scholar. Author interview. Guatemala City, July.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 2002a. Guatemala: the Lethal Legacy of Impunity. http:www.amnesty.org.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 2002b. Guatemala: Human Rights Defenders Still on the Line. Press release. July 19. http:www.amnesty.org.Google Scholar
Arana, Ana. 2001. The New Battle for Central America. Foreign Affairs 80, 6: 88–101.Google Scholar
Archdiocese of Guatemala. 1999. Guatemala: Never Again. Maryknoll: Orbis Books.Google Scholar
Arévalo deLeón, Bernardo. 2001a. Transición democrática y reconversión militar en Guatemala: limitaciones y retos de un proceso inconcluso. Unpublished paper.Google Scholar
Arévalo deLeón, Bernardo. 2001b. Guatemalan scholar. Author interview. Guatemala City, November.Google Scholar
Arzú, Alvaro. 2001. Former President of Guatemala. Author interview. Guatemala City, July.Google Scholar
Balconi, Julio, General (ret.). 2001. Former Minister of National Defense, Guatemala. Author interview. Guatemala City, July.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 1996. Vice Minister of Defense and Eight Other Officers Suspended. September 19: 1–3.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 1998. Colonel's Arrest Signals Hard-line Retrenchment in Army. July 24:1–3.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 1999. The Fraternity and Its Influence. July 9: 3.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 2000. The Fraternity Rises Again. January 28: 3–4.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 2001a. Army's Slow Adjustment to Peace. August 17: 4–5.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 2001b. Army Returns to the Streets. March 2: 1–2.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 2002a. Corruption at its Peak. March 22: 1–2.Google Scholar
Central America Report (Guatemala City). 2002b. Army Proposes its Own Transformation Process. July 19: 4–5.Google Scholar
Comisión para el Esclarecimiento Histórico. 2000. Guatemala: causasy orígenes del enfrentamiento armado interno. Guatemala City: F&G Editores.Google Scholar
Espinosa, Marco Tulio, General (ret.). 2001. Former Minister of National Defense, Guatemala. Author interview. Guatemala City; July.Google Scholar
Facultad Latinoamericana de Ciencias Sociales, Sede Guatemala (FLACSO-Guatemala). 2000. Bases para la consideración de la cuestión militar en Guatemala: Documento de trabajo. Guatemala City: FLACSO.Google Scholar
Fitch, J. Samuel. 1998. The Armed Forces and Democracy in Latin America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Fitch, J. Samuel. 2001. Military Attitudes Toward Democracy: How Do We Know If Anything Has Changed? In Civil-Military Relations in Latin America: New Analytical Perspectives, ed. David, Pion-Berlin. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. 59–87.Google Scholar
Hernández Pico, Juan. 2000. The New Portillo Government: Demagoguery or Revolution Envío 19, 222–23 (January-February); 30–37.Google Scholar
Hernández Pico, Juan. 2001. Gerardi Case: Justice for a Just Man. Envío 20, 239: 36–44.Google Scholar
Hernández Pico, Juan. 2002a. Portillo Lives on Appearances While Covering up Reality. Envío 21, 246–47: 29–36.Google Scholar
Hernández Pico, Juan. 2002b. The Armed Wing of the Hidden Powers in Action. Envío 21, 249: 20–28.Google Scholar
Holiday, David. 2000. Guatemala's Precarious Peace. Current History 99, 634: 78–84.Google Scholar
Huntington, Samuel. 1957. The Soldier and the State: The Theory and Politics of Civil-Military Relations. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Isacson, Adam. 1997. Altered States: Security and Demilitarization in Central America. Washington, DC: Center for International Policy.Google Scholar
Iznardo, Francisco. 2002. Militarization in Ixcán: Thin Red Lines. Envío 21, 248: 31–35.Google Scholar
Jonas, Susanne. 1991. The Battle for Guatemala: Rebels, Death Squads, and U.S. Power. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Jonas, Susanne. 2000. Of Centaurs and Doves: Guatemala's Peace Process. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Mack, Helen. 2001. Untitled paper. In Funcion military control democrático, ed. deBernárdo Arévalo, León. Guatemala City: Amanuense Editorial, 277–86.Google Scholar
McCleary, Rachel M. 1999. Dictating Democracy: Guatemala and the End of Violent Revolution. Gainesville: University Press of Florida.Google Scholar
Misión de Naciones Unidas para Guatemala (MINUGUA). 1997. La construcción de lapazen Guatemala. Guatemala City: Editorial Serviprensa.Google Scholar
Misión de Naciones Unidas para Guatemala (MINUGUA). 2002. Status of the Commitments of the Peace Agreements Relating to the Armed Forces. http:www.minugua.guate.net.Google Scholar
Noack, Otto, Colonel (ret.). 2001. Former Military Intelligence Officer, Guatemala. Author interview. Guatemala City, November.Google Scholar
Pacheco, Guillermo. 2004. Guatemalan scholar. Author interview. Guatemala City, June.Google Scholar
Peacock, Susan C., and Adriana, Beltrán. 2003. Hidden Powers in Post-Conflict Guatemala. Washington, DC: Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA).Google Scholar
Pérez Molina, Otto, General (ret.). 2001. Untitled paper. In Función militar y control democrático, ed. deBernárdo Arévalo, León. Guatemala City: Amanuense Editorial, 381–88.Google Scholar
Pion-Berlin, David. 1992. Military Autonomy and Emerging Democracies in South America. Comparative Politics 25, 1: 83–102.Google Scholar
Pion-Berlin, David. 1997. Through Corridors of Power: Institutions and Civil-Military Relations in Argentina. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
Porras, Gustavo. 1998. Discussion. In Guatemala After the Peace Accords, ed. Rachel, Sieder. London: Institute of Latin American Studies. 12–18.Google Scholar
Porras, Gustavo. 2001. Former Coordinator of the Presidential Peace Commission (Copaz). Author interview. Guatemala City, July.Google Scholar
La Prensa (San Pedro Sula, Honduras). 2002. Ex-dictador Ríos Montt reelectó por tercer año presidente del Congreso. January 15. http:www.laprensahn.com.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2002a. Gerardi: el crimen perfecto. January 14. http:www.prensalibre.com.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2002b. Por qué hay malestar en las filas del Ejército? March 11.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2002c. Guatemaltecos reprueban gestión de Alfonso Portillo. July 14.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2002d. Investigarán a militares sospechosos de ilícitos. October 24.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2002e. Un Ejército desfasado. June 30.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2002f. Civiles y militares en retiro. August 6.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2003. Unión Europea exige reducción del Ejército. January 22.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2004a. Reducirán Ejército a 14 mil militares. March 21.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2004b. Mp: Alfonso Portillo participó en robo de Q190 milliones. July 26.Google Scholar
Prensa Libre (Guatemala). 2004c. Q18 milliones en plazas fantasma pagó Ejército. October 1.Google Scholar
República de Guatemala. 1999a. Constitución política de la República de Guatemala. Guatemala City: Editorial Piedra Santa.Google Scholar
República de Guatemala. 1999b. Doctrina del Ejército de Guatemala. Guatemala City: Ministerio de la Defensa Nacional.Google Scholar
República de Guatemala. 1999c. Reformas a la constitución política de la República de Guatemala. Guatemala City: Tribunal Supremo Electoral.Google Scholar
República de Guatemala. 2003. Libro de la defensa nacional de la República de Guatemala. Guatemala City: Centro Impresor PS.Google Scholar
Rico, Maite, and de laBertrand, Grange. 2003. Quién mató al obispo? autopsia de un crimen político. Mexico City: Editorial Planeta.Google Scholar
Rosada Granados, Hector. 1999. Soldados en el poder: proyecto militar en Guatemala, 1944–1990. San José, Costa Rica: FUNPADEM.Google Scholar
Rosada Granados, Hector. 2001. Guatemalan scholar. Author interview. Guatemala City, November.Google Scholar
Ruhl, J. Mark. 2003. Civil-Military Relations in Post-Sandinista Nicaragua. Armed Forces and Society 30, 1: 117–39.Google Scholar
Schirmer, Jennifer. 1998a. The Guatemalan Military Project: A Violence Called Democracy. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Schirmer, Jennifer. 1998b. Prospects for Compliance: The Guatemalan Military and the Peace Accords. In Guatemala After the Peace Accords, ed. Rachel, Sieder. London: Institute of Latin American Studies, 21–32.Google Scholar
Sieder, Rachel, Megan, Thomas, George, Vickers, and Jack, Spence. 2002. Who Governs? Guatemala Five Years After the Peace Accords. Cambridge, MA: Hemisphere Initiatives.Google Scholar
Spence, Jack, David, R. Dye, Paula, Worthy, deCarmen Rosa, León-Escribano, George, Vickers, and Mike, Lanchin. 1998. Promise and Reality: Implementation of the Guatemalan Peace Accords. Cambridge, MA: Hemisphere Initiatives.Google Scholar
Stepan, Alfred. 1988. Rethinking Military Politics: Brazil and the Southern Cone. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar