Hostname: page-component-7bb8b95d7b-qxsvm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-10-04T17:09:53.471Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Informal, Inquisitorial, and Accurate: An Empirical Look at a Problem-Solving Housing Court

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Jessica K. Steinberg
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Substantive justice is often seen as elusive in courts dominated by low-income individuals. Complex court rules, coupled with pervasive lack of counsel, can make it difficult for the traditional adversary process to identify and redress legitimate grievances. This article takes on the social problem of substandard housing and examines whether inquisitorial procedure has the potential to produce accurate outcomes in a tribunal dominated by the unrepresented. Relying on in-court observations of nearly 300 hearings, and a longitudinal review of nearly seventy-five cases, this article surfaces the regularized procedures utilized by a purported “problem-solving” housing court, and theorizes that the inquisitorial features of judicially controlled investigation and enforcement may motivate landlords to repair substantiated housing code violations. This article adds nuance to our understanding of informal justice by identifying the hidden procedural formalisms that may guide alternative decision-making processes. Furthermore, it evaluates the relationship of one iteration of experimental formalism to substantive justice, and suggests that inquisitorial procedures may be correlated with improved accuracy in case outcomes.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 42 , Issue 4 , Fall 2017 , pp. 1058 - 1090
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

Abel, Richard L. 1982a. Introduction. In The Politics of Informal Justice, ed. Abel, Richard L., Vol. 1, 1–13. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Abel, Richard L. 1982b. The Contradictions of Informal Justice. In The Politics of Informal Justice, ed. Abel, Richard L., Vol. 1, 267–320. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Baker, Kermit. 2013. The Return of Substandard Housing. Housing Perspectives: Research, Trends, and Perspective from the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies Blog, February 27. http://housingperspectives.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-return-of-substandard-housing.html (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Berman, Greg, and Feinblatt, John. 2001. Problem‐Solving Courts: A Brief Primer. Law & Policy 23:125–39.Google Scholar
Berman, Greg, and Feinblatt, John. 2003. Problem‐Solving Justice: A Quiet Revolution. Judicature 4 (86): 182, 213.Google Scholar
Bezdek, Barbara. 1992. Silence in the Court: Participation and Subordination of Poor Tenants' Voices in Legal Process. Hofstra Law Review 20 (3): 533–608.Google Scholar
Bloom, Micki. 2011. Assessing the District's “Fix‐It Court.” Bread for the City Blog, July 15. http://www.breadforthecity.org/2011/07/fixitcourt (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Blumgart, Jake. 2015. Landlords Have an Edge in Eviction Cases. They Can Afford Lawyers, and Low‐Income Renters Can't. Slate Blog, December 8. http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2015/12/08/baltimore_renters_are_losing_their_eviction_cases_because_they_can_t_afford.html (accessed December 9, 2015).Google Scholar
Casey, Timothy. 2004. When Good Intentions Are Not Enough: Problem‐Solving Courts and the Impending Crisis of Legitimacy. Southern Methodist University Law Review 57:1459–1519.Google Scholar
Cenziper, Debbie, and Sarah, Cohen. 2008. Forced Out: A Washington Post Investigation into the Casualties of the District's Real Estate Boom. Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/metro/forcedout/(accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Clermont, Kevin M. 2009. Litigation Realities Redux. Notre Dame Law Review 84 (5): 1919–74.Google Scholar
Dasse, Lauren K. 2012. Wage Theft in New York: The Wage Theft Prevention Act as a Counter to an Endemic Problem. CUNY Law Review 16:97–127.Google Scholar
Eaton, Leslie, and Leslie, Kaufman. 2005. In Problem‐Solving Court, Judges Turn Therapist. New York Times, April 26. http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/26/nyregion/in-problemsolving-court-judges-turn-therapist.html?_r=0 (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Engler, Russell. 2010. Connecting Self‐Representation to Civil Gideon: What Existing Data Reveal About When Counsel Is Most Needed. Fordham Urban Law Journal 37:37–92.Google Scholar
Engler, Russell. 2013. Turner v. Rogers and the Essential Role of the Courts in Delivering Access to Justice. Harvard Law & Policy Review 7:31–59.Google Scholar
Fuller, Lon. 1961. The Adversary System. In Talks on American Law, ed. Berman, Harold J. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar
Galanter, Mark, and Cahill, Mia. 1994. Most Cases Settle: Judicial Promotion and Regulation of Settlements. Stanford Law Review 46:1339–90.Google Scholar
Glendon, Mary A., Carozza, Paolo, and Picker, Colin. 2008. Comparative Legal Traditions in a Nutshell. St. Paul, MN: West Academic Publishing.Google Scholar
Greiner, D. James, Pattanayak, Cassandra W., and Hennessy, Jonathan. 2013. The Limits of Unbundled Legal Assistance: A Randomized Study in a Massachusetts District Court and Prospects for the Future. Harvard Law Review 126 (4):901–89.Google Scholar
Grillo, Trina. 1991. The Mediation Alternative: Process Dangers for Women. Yale Law Journal 100:1545–1610.Google Scholar
Harrington, Christine B. 1982. Delegalization Reform Movements: A Historical Analysis. In The Politics of Informal Justice, ed. Abel, Richard L., Vol. 1, 35–71. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Klein, Linda. 2010. Report on the Survey of Judges on the Impact of the Economic Downturn on Representation in the Courts (Preliminary). ABA Coalition for Justice, July 12. http://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/migrated/JusticeCenter/PublicDocuments/CoalitionforJusticeSurveyReport.authcheckdam.pdf (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Krieger, James, and Higgins, Donna L. 2002. Housing and Health: Time Again for Public Health Action. American Journal of Public Health 92 (5): 758–68.Google Scholar
Langbein, John H. 1985. The German Advantage in Civil Procedure. University of Chicago Law Review. 52 (4): 823–66.Google Scholar
Lawyers' Committee for Better Housing. 2003. No Time for Justice: A Study of Chicago's Eviction Court. http://lcbh.org/sites/default/files/resources/2003-lcbh-chicago-eviction-court-study.pdf (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Lazeron, Mark. 1982. In the Halls of Justice, the Only Justice Is in the Halls. In The Politics of Informal Justice, ed. Abel, Richard L., Vol. 1, 119–63. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Lempert, Richard. 1989. The Dynamics of Informal Procedure: The Case of a Public Housing Eviction Board. Law & Society Review 23 (3): 347–98.Google Scholar
Lerner, Renee L. 2001. The Intersection of Two Systems: An American on Trial for an American Murder in the French Cour D'Assises. University of Illinois Law Review 2001:791–856.Google Scholar
Lonegrass, Melissa T. 2010. Convergence in Contort: Landlord Liability for Defective Premises in Comparative Perspective. Tulane Law Review 85:413–75.Google Scholar
Mack, Julian. 1909. The Juvenile Court. Harvard Law Review 23:104–22.Google Scholar
Mackinem, Mitchell B., and Higgins, Paul. 2009. Adult Drug Courts: A Hope Realized? In Problem‐Solving Courts: Justice for the Twenty‐First Century? ed. Higgins, Paul and Mackinem, Mitchell B., 33–49. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.Google Scholar
Menkel‐Meadow, Carrie. 1995. Whose Dispute Is It Anyway?: A Philosophical and Democratic Defense of Settlement (in Some Cases). Georgetown Law Journal 83:2663–96.Google Scholar
New Settlement Apartments' Community Action for Safe Apartments (CASA) and the Community Development Project at the Urban Justice Center. 2013. Tipping the Scales: A Report of Tenant Experiences in Bronx Housing Court. https://cdp.urbanjustice.org/sites/default/files/CASA_ES_FINAL.pdf (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
New York County Lawyers' Association. 2005. The New York City Housing Court in the 21st Century: Can it Better Address The Problems Before It? http://cwtfhc.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/NYCLA_HC_in_21st_Cent.pdf (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Nolan, James. 2000. Reinventing Justice: The American Drug Court Movement. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Northridge, Jennifer, Ramirez, Olivia F., Stingone, Jeanette A., and Claudio, Luz. 2010. The Role of Housing Type and Housing Quality in Urban Children with Asthma. Journal of Urban Health 87 (2): 211–24.Google Scholar
O'Barr, William M., and Conley, John M. 1985. Litigant Satisfaction Versus Legal Adequacy in Small Claims Court Narratives. Law & Society Review 19:661–99.Google Scholar
Ostrom, Brian J., and Kauder, Neal B., eds. 1998. Examining the Work of State Courts, 1997: A National Perspective from the Court Statistics Project. Bureau of Justice Statistics. http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/ewsc97-npcsp.pdf (accessed March 3, 2016).Google Scholar
Platt, Anthony M. 1969. The Child Savers: The Invention of Juvenile Delinquency. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Public Justice Center. 2015. Justice Diverted: How Renters Are Processed in the Baltimore City Rent Court. http://www.publicjustice.org/uploads/file/pdf/JUSTICE_DIVERTED_PJC_DEC15.pdf (accessed December 9, 2015).Google Scholar
Redlich, Allison D. 2013. The Past, Present, and Future of Mental Health Courts. In Problem Solving Courts: Social Science and Legal Perspectives, ed. Wiener, Richard L. and Brank, Eve M., 147–62. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Reyes, Emily A., and Logan, Tim. 2014. Shortage of Low‐Income Housing Pushes Tenants into Dangerous Situations. Los Angeles Times, April 6. http://articles.latimes.com/2014/apr/06/local/la-me-building-evacuation-20140407 (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Rosenheim, Margaret K., Zimring, Franklin E., Tanenhaus, David S., and Dohrn, Bernadine, eds. 2001. A Century of Juvenile Justice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Seron, Carroll, Frankel, Martin, Van Ryzin, Gregg, and Frankel, Jean. 2001. The Impact of Legal Counsel on Outcomes for Poor Tenants in New York City's Housing Court: Results of a Randomized Experiment. Law & Society Review 35 (2): 419–34.Google Scholar
Smith, Greg. 2014. City's “Worst Landlord” Lives in $1.2M Mansion While Tenants Deal with Rats, Mold, Lead Paint Among Thousands of Violations. New York Daily News, October 11. http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/worst-landlord-lives-1-2m-mansion-tenants-rats-mold-toxic-paint-article-1.1971278 (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Steinberg, Jessica K. 2015. Demand Side Reform in the Poor People's Court. Connecticut Law Review 47:741–807.Google Scholar
Stoever, Jane K. 2014. Enjoining Abuse: The Case for Indefinite Domestic Violence Protection Orders. Vanderbilt Law Review 67 (4): 1015–98.Google Scholar
Stringer, Scott. 2002. Total Collapse: How NYC Department of Buildings' Failed Policies Contributed to Crumbling Buildings. http://assembly.state.ny.us/member_files/067/20021125/(accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Super, David A. 2011. The Rise and Fall of the Implied Warranty of Habitability. California Law Review 99:389–461.Google Scholar
Superior Court of the District of Columbia. 2010. Administrative Order 10‐07, Housing Conditions Civil Calendar. http://www.dccourts.gov/internet/documents/10-07.pdf (accessed March 13, 2016).Google Scholar
Task Force to Expand Access to Civil Legal Services in New York. 2010. Report to the Chief Judge of the State of New York. https://www.nycourts.gov/accesstojusticecommission/PDF/CLS-TaskForceREPORT.pdf (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Tillman, Zoe. 2011. Housing Conditions Calendar Creates a New Forum for Tenants. National Law Journal, July 4. http://www.nationallawjournal.com/id= 1202499203863/Home‐court‐advantage–?slreturn=20160213144708 (accessed July 22, 2015).Google Scholar
Wiener, Richard L., and Georges, Leah. 2013. Social Psychology and Problem‐Solving Courts: Judicial Roles and Decision Making. In Problem Solving Courts: Social Science and Legal Perspectives, ed. Wiener, Richard L. and Brank, Eve M., 1–22. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Wolff, Nancy. 2013. Domestic Violence Courts: The Case of Lady Justice Meets the Serpents of the Caduceus. In Problem Solving Courts: Social Science and Legal Perspectives, ed. Wiener, Richard L. and Brank, Eve M., 83–112. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Yngvesson, Barbara, and Hennessey, Patricia. 1974−1975. Small Claims, Complex Disputes: A Review of the Small Claims Literature. Law & Society Review 9:219–71.Google Scholar
Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009).Google Scholar
Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007).Google Scholar
Brown v. Local 58, Int'l Bhd. of Elec. Workers, AFL‐CIO, 76 F.3d 762 (6th Cir. 1996).Google Scholar
Javins v. First Nat'l Realty Corp., 428 F.2d 1071 (D.C. Cir. 1970).Google Scholar
Oxford House‐A v. City of Univ. City, 87 F.3d 1022 (8th Cir. 1996).Google Scholar
Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009).Google Scholar
Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007).Google Scholar
Brown v. Local 58, Int'l Bhd. of Elec. Workers, AFL‐CIO, 76 F.3d 762 (6th Cir. 1996).Google Scholar
Javins v. First Nat'l Realty Corp., 428 F.2d 1071 (D.C. Cir. 1970).Google Scholar
Oxford House‐A v. City of Univ. City, 87 F.3d 1022 (8th Cir. 1996).Google Scholar