Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-5wvtr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-16T12:32:00.518Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

How an Authoritarian Regime in Burma Used Special Courts to Defeat Judicial Independence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Nick Cheesman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Why do authoritarian rulers establish special courts? One view is that they do so to insulate the judiciary from politically oriented cases and allow it continued, albeit limited, independence. In this article I present a contrary case study of an authoritarian regime in Burma that used special courts not to insulate the judiciary but to defeat it. Through comparison to other Asian cases I suggest that the Burmese regime's composition and character better explain its strategy than does extant judicial authority or formal ideology. The regime consisted of war fighters for whom the courts were enemy territory. But absent popular support, the regime's leaders could not embark immediately on a radical project for legal change that might compromise their hold on power. Consequently, they used special courts and other strategies to defeat judicial independence incrementally, until they could displace the professional judiciary and bring the courts fully under executive control.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 45 , Issue 4 , December 2011 , pp. 801 - 830
Copyright
© 2011 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The author wishes to thank Ed Aspinall, Hilary Charlesworth, Robert Cribb, Ben Kerkvliet, Harold Crouch, Myint Zan, Dom Nardi, and three anonymous reviewers for comments that they gave on versions of this article, and for other advice. Thanks also to Allison Ley for editorial assistance. Finally, thank you to Saowapha Viravong and staff at the National Library of Australia for making available materials without which the article could not have been written.

References

References

Ahsan, Aitzaz (2009) “Recollections of the Pakistan Lawyers' Movement,” 8 Article 2 17–24.Google Scholar
Alamgir, Jalal (1997) “Against the Current: The Survival of Authoritarianism in Burma,” 70 Pacific Affairs 333–350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burma Socialist Programme Party (1971) 1971 kunit Padama akyein Padi Nyilagan, Padi Baho Kawmidi Ukkadagyi e Meingunmya hnin Padi Siyônye Baho Kawmidi e Naingnganye Aziyinkanza [First Party Congress, 1971: Chairman's Speeches and Central Organizing Committee's Political Report]. Rangoon: Burma Socialist Programme Party.Google Scholar
Butler, William J., Humphrey, John P., & Bisson, Gordon Ellis (1977) The Decline of Democracy in the Philippines. Geneva: International Commission of Jurists.Google Scholar
Callahan, Mary P. (2003) Making Enemies: War and State Building in Burma. Ithaca & London: Cornell Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Central Organizing Committee (1966) 1965 kunit Padi Hni-hnawpahlèpwè, Ukkadagyi e Meingunmya hnin Adwedwe Adwinyehmu e Naingnganye Aziyinkanza [Party Seminar 1965: Chairman's Speeches and General Secretary's Political Report]. Rangoon: Burma Socialist Programme Party.Google Scholar
Central Organizing Committee (1970) 1969 kunit Padi Hni-hnawpahlèpwè, Ukkadagyi e Meingunmya hnin Adwedwe Adwinyehmu e Naingnganye Aziyinkanza [Party Seminar 1965: Chairman's Speeches and General Secretary's Political Report]. Rangoon: Burma Socialist Programme Party.Google Scholar
Cheesman, Nick (2009) “Thin Rule of Law or Un-Rule of Law in Myanmar?” 82 Pacific Affairs 597–613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cheesman, Nick (2010) “The Incongruous Return of Habeas Corpus to Myanmar,” in Cheesman, N., Skidmore, M., & Wilson, T., eds., Ruling Myanmar: From Cyclone Nargis to National Elections. Singapore: ISEAS.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chit Yi, Maung (1960) Koko Kyun hma Pôkma Nga [Section Five from Coco Island]. Rangoon: U Saw Lwin.Google Scholar
Courts General Letters (1959, 1963, 1965, 1966, 1972) Tayayônmya Hnyunkyahlwa. No. 15/59, 15 June. 5/63, 19 March. 6/65, 7 July. 4/66, 23 September. 9/72, 21 July.Google Scholar
Damaška, Mirjan R. (1997) “Truth in Adjudication,” 49 Hastings Law J. 289–308.Google Scholar
Del Carmen, Rolando V. (1973) “Constitutionalism and the Supreme Court in a Changing Philippine Polity,” 13 Asian Survey 1050–1061.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Director of Information (1960) Is Trust Vindicated? Rangoon: Government of the Union of Burma.Google Scholar
Fraenkel, Jon (2008) “The Context and Consequences of the October 2008 Qarase vs. Bainimarama High Court Ruling,” State, Society and Governance in Melanesia, Discussion Paper 2008/10. Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, ANU.Google Scholar
Ghias, Shoaib A. (2010) “Miscarriage of Chief Justice: Judicial Power and the Legal Complex in Pakistan under Musharraf,” 35 Law and Social Inquiry 985–1022.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gillespie, John (2005) “Transplanting Commercial Law Reform: Developing a ‘Rule of Law’ in Vietnam”, Department of Political & Social Change, Australian National University.Google Scholar
Hilbink, Lisa (2007) Judges beyond Politics in Democracy and Dictatorship: Lessons from Chile. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jayasuriya, Kanishka (1999) “The Rule of Law and Governance in the East Asian State,” 1 Asian Law 107–123.Google Scholar
Ko Ko Lay (1960) Balehe Koko Kyun [What is This Coco Island]. Rangoon: Khin Maung Yi & Sons Press.Google Scholar
Lev, Daniel S. (1978) “Judicial Authority and the Struggle for an Indonesian Rechtsstaat,” 13 Law & Society Rev. 37–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Linz, Juan J. (2000) Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes. Boulder, CO & London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mahmud, Tayyab (1993) “Praetorianism and Common Law in Post-Colonial Settings: Judicial Responses to Constitutional Breakdowns in Pakistan,” 4 Utah Law Rev. 1225–1305.Google Scholar
Mahmud, Tayyab (1994) “Jurisprudence of Successful Treason: Coup d'Etat and Common Law,” 27 Cornell International Law J. 49–140.Google Scholar
Marcos, Ferdinand E. (1978) President Ferdinand E. Marcos on Law, Development and Human Rights. Quezon City: Univ. of the Philippines Law Center.Google Scholar
Maung, Maung (1961) Burma's Constitution. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maung, Maung (1962) “Lawyers and Legal Education in Burma,” 11 J. of International and Comparative Law Q. 285–290.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maung, Maung (1971) “Sedana [Intention],” in Adu Yazawut Yôn Ayugan Apwè Siyintônmya (1965–1970) [Special Criminal Courts' Appeal Court Rulings (1965–1970)]. Rangoon: Central Publishing House.Google Scholar
Maung, Maung (2004) Taya-upade Adwedwe Bahuthuda [Law General Knowledge]. Yangon: Sitthidaw Press.Google Scholar
Moustafa, Tamir (2007) The Struggle for Constitutional Power: Law, Politics, and Economic Development in Egypt. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moustafa, Tamir, & Ginsburg, Tom (2008) “Introduction: The Functions of Courts in Authoritarian Politics,” in Ginsburg, T., & Moustafa, T., eds., Rule by Law: The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Mya Han, U, et al., ed. (1993) Myanma Naingnganye Sanit Pyaung Kala, 1962–1974 [A Period of Change to Myanmar's Political system (1962–1974)]. vol. 1, Yangon: Universities Press.Google Scholar
Mya Han, U & Thein Hlaing, U ed. (1991) 1958–1962 Myanma Naingnganye [Myanmar's Politics, 1958–1962]. vol. 4, Yangon: Universities Press.Google Scholar
Zan, Myint (2000) “Judicial Independence in Burma: Constitutional History, Actual Practice and Future Prospects,” 4 Southern Cross Univ. Law Rev. 17–59.Google Scholar
Zan, Myint (2004) “A Comparison of the First and Fiftieth Year of Independent Burma's Law Reports,” 35 Victoria Univ. Wellington Law Rev. 385–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Newberg, Paula R. (1995) Judging the State: Courts and Constitutional Politics in Pakistan. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicholson, Penelope (2007) Borrowing Court Systems: The Experience of Socialist Vietnam. Leiden & Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.Google Scholar
Notosusanto, Nugroho, & Saleh, Ismail (1968) The Coup Attempt of the “September 30 Movement” in Indonesia. Djakarta: P.T. Pembimbing Masa.Google Scholar
Nu, U (1959) “69-kyein myauk Me De Ne Akanana dwin Pa-Sa-Pa-La (Thanshin) Apwègyôk Ukkadagyi U Nu Pyawkya thi Meingun [Speech Given by AFPFL (Clean) Chairman U Nu at the 69th May Day Celebration],” News & Information Department, AFPFL (Clean).Google Scholar
Osiel, Mark J. (1995) “Dialogue with Dictators: Judicial Resistance in Argentina and Brazil,” 20 Law and Social Inquiry 481–560.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pereira, Anthony W. (2005) Political (In)justice: Authoritarianism and the Rule of Law in Brazil, Chile, and Argentina. Pittsburgh, PA: Univ. of Pittsburgh Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pompe, Sebastiaan (2005) The Indonesian Supreme Court: A Study of Institutional Collapse. Ithaca, NY: Southeast Asia Program Publications, Cornell Univ.Google Scholar
Selth, Andrew (2010) “Modern Burma Studies: A Survey of the Field,” 44 Modern Asian Studies 401–440.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shambayati, Hootan (2008) “Courts in Semi-Democratic/Authoritarian Regimes: The Judicialization of Turkish (and Iranian) Politics,” in Ginsburg, T., & Moustafa, T., eds., Rule by Law: The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Gordon (2008) “Singapore: The Exception that Proves Rules Matter,” in Ginsburg, T., & Moustafa, T., eds., Rule by Law: The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Solomon, Peter H. Jr (2007) “Courts and Judges in Authoritarian Regimes,” 60 World Politics 122–145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tate, C. Neal, & Haynie, Stacia L. (1993) “Authoritarianism and the Functions of Courts: A Time Series Analysis of the Philippine Supreme Court, 1961–1987,” 27 Law and Society Rev. 707–740.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tezcür, Güneş Murat (2009) “Judicial Activism in Perilous Times: The Turkish Case,” 43 Law & Society Rev. 305–336.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thio, Li-Ann (2002) “Lex Rex or Rex Lex? Competing Conceptions of the Rule of Law in Singapore,” 20 UCLA Pacific Basin Law J. 1–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Toharia, José (1975) “Judicial Independence in an Authoritarian Regime: The Case of Contemporary Spain,” 9 Law & Society Rev. 475–496.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trusov, Alexei. (n.d.) An Introduction to the Theory of Evidence. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House.Google Scholar
Vyshinsky, Andrei Y. (1948) The Law of the Soviet State. Westport, CN: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Williams, George (2001) “The Case that Stopped a Coup? The Rule of Law and Constitutionalism in Fiji,” 1 Oxford Univ. Commonwealth Law J. 73–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, George (2008) “Qarase v. Bainimarama and the Rule of Law in Fiji,” State, Society and Governance in Melanesia, Discussion Paper 2008/10. Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, ANU.Google Scholar
Working People's Daily (1965) Courts to Consider Govt Policy,” 16 July, p. 1, 8.Google Scholar

Cases Cited

Captain Aung Win v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) (1965–70) 292 (1969).Google Scholar
Daw Aye Tin v. Meikhtila District Area People's Court Appeal Court & One, BLR (CC) 17 (1971).Google Scholar
Daw Si Si v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 877 (1964).Google Scholar
Daw Tin Oo, U Aye Hpe & One v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 129 (1966).Google Scholar
M. Muthiah Servai v. Union of Burma, BLR (HC) 175 [in English] (1955).Google Scholar
Ma Khin Myint alias Ma Khin Nyunt Kyi v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 1 (1970).Google Scholar
Ma Khin Than v. Commissioner of Police, Rangoon & One, BLR (SC) 13 (1949).Google Scholar
Major Win Hpe v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) (1965–70) 299 (1969).Google Scholar
Maung Aung Htay Myint v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 397 (1965).Google Scholar
Maung Chit v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 20 (1972).Google Scholar
Maung Chit Hlaing & 6 v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 142 (1966).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maung Ko v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 401 (1966).Google Scholar
Maung Kyaw Tint v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 41 (1966).Google Scholar
Maung Mya Han & One v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 80 (1966).Google Scholar
Maung Nyi & One v. Union of Burma, BLR (HC) 282 (1952).Google Scholar
Maung Saw Hpe & 2 v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 57 (1966).Google Scholar
Maung Than Win alias Tin Aung & 2 v. Union of Burma, BLR (SCCAC) 61 (1968).Google Scholar
T.S. Mohamed & One v. Union of Burma, BLR (HC) 107 [in English] (1953).Google Scholar
U Aung Nyunt v. Union of Burma (Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Tachilek), BLR (CC) 578 (1965).Google Scholar
U Ba Khin v. Union of Burma, BLR (HC) 191 [in English] (1954).Google Scholar
U Ba Kyi v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 306 [in English] (1964).Google Scholar
U Htun Aung & U Htun Thein v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 190 (1970).Google Scholar
U Htun Aung Tha v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 58 (1969).Google Scholar
U Htwe alias A.E. Madari v. U Tun Ohn & One, BLR (SC) 541 [in English] (1948).Google Scholar
U Thein Zan v. Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 660 (1967).Google Scholar
U Tin Maung Han v. Socialist Republic of the Union of Burma, BLR (CC) 40 (1975).Google Scholar
Union of Burma (Dr. Pyi Soe) v. Daw Tin Tin, BLR (CC) 1075 (1965).Google Scholar

Statutes Cited

Criminal Procedure Code (1898) India Act No. 5/1898.Google Scholar
Law Granting Authorizations for the Building of a Socialist Economic System (1965) Soshèlit Sibwaye Sanit Tisaukhmu adwet Lôkpainggwinmya At-hnin thi Upade. Revolutionary Council Law No. 8/65, Union of Burma.Google Scholar
Special Criminal Courts Law (1962) Adu Yazawut Yôn Upade. Revolutionary Council Law No. 15/62, Union of Burma.Google Scholar
Special Criminal Courts Law Amending Law (1963) Adu Yazawut Yôn Upade ko Pyin thi Upade. Revolutionary Council Law No. 34/63, Union of Burma.Google Scholar
Special Criminal Courts Law Amending Law (1964) Adu Yazawut Yôn Upade ko Pyin thi Upade. Revolutionary Council Law No. 11/64, Union of Burma.Google Scholar