Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-m42fx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-22T15:17:54.286Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reformed Commitment Procedures: An Empirical Study in the Courtroom

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 July 2024

Virginia Aldige Hiday
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Court proceedings and records were analyzed to evaluate statutory reform of mental commitment procedure in one state with a typical statute. A marked improvement over practice described in previous research was found: court proceedings were not rapid and perfunctory. However, the court still often deferred to psychiatric opinion even when a preponderance of evidence showed it to be unsubstantiated.

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 11 , Issue 4 , Spring 1977 , pp. 651 - 666
Copyright
Copyright © 1977 The Law and Society Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Preparation of this paper was supported by NIMH Grant MH13112 to the Departments of Sociology and Psychiatry, Duke University. Particular thanks are expressed to Management Information System—Statistics, North Carolina Division of Mental Health Services, which provided state hospital data, and to court officials who gave their time and energy to facilitate court data collection.

References

ANDALMAN, Elliott and CHAMBERS, David L. (1974) “Effective Counsel for Persons Facing Commitment: A Survey, a Polemic and a Proposal,” 45 Mississippi Law Journal 43.Google Scholar
BAZELON, David L. (1974) “Institutional Psychiatry—The Self Inflicted Wound,” 23 Catholic University Law Review 643.Google Scholar
BROOKS, Alexander D. (1974) Law, Psychiatry and the Mental Health System. Boston: Little, Brown & Co.Google Scholar
COHEN, Fred (1966) “The Function of the Attorney and the Commitment of the Mentally Ill,” 44 Texas Law Review 424.Google Scholar
COIE, John S., COSTANZO, Philip R. and COX, Gary (1975) “Behavioral Determinants of Mental Illness Concerns: A Comparison of ‘Gatekeeper’ Professions,” 43 Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 626.Google Scholar
DERSHOWITZ, Alan M. (1968) “Psychiatry in the Legal Process: ‘A Knife That Cuts Both Ways,”‘ 51 Judicature 370.Google Scholar
ENNIS, Bruce J. and FRIEDMAN, Paul R. (1973) Legal Rights of the Mentally Handicapped, vol. 1. New York: Practicing Law Institute.Google Scholar
GOODE, Stephen J. (1975) “The Role of Counsel in the Civil Commitment Process,” 84 Yale Law Journal 1540.Google Scholar
HARVARD LAW REVIEW (1974) “Developments in the Law: Civil Commitment of the Mentally Ill,” 87 Harvard Law Review 1190.Google Scholar
HIDAY, Virginia A. (1976) “Involuntary Consumers: Are the New Mental Commitment Laws Effective?” Paper presented at the Southern Sociological Society Meetings in Miami, Fla. (April).Google Scholar
KATZ, K. Martin, COLE, Jonathon O. and LOWERY, Henri A. (1969) “Studies of the Diagnostic Process: The Influence of Symptom Perception, Past Experience and Ethnic Background in Diagnostic Decision,” 125 American Journal of Psychiatry 937.Google Scholar
KNOX, Wilma J. (1973) “Attitudes of Social Workers and Other Professional Groups toward Alcoholism,” 34 Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcoholism 1270.Google Scholar
KUTNER, Luis (1962) “The Illusion of Due Process in Commitment Proceedings,” 57 Northwestern Law Review 383.Google Scholar
LITWACK, Thomas R. (1974) “The Role of Counsel in Civil Commitment Proceedings: Emerging Problems,” 62 California Law Review 816.Google Scholar
LIVERMORE, Joseph M., MALMQUIST, Carl P. and MEEHL, Paul E. (1968) “On the Justification for Civil Commitment,” 75 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 75.Google Scholar
McCORMICK, Charles T. (1972) McCormick's Handbook of the Law of Evidence, 2d ed. (Clearey, Edward W., ed.) St. Paul, Minn.: West Pub. Co.Google Scholar
MAISEL, Robert (1970) “Decision Making in a Commitment Court,” 33 Psychiatry 352.Google Scholar
MILLER, Dorothy and SCHWARTZ, Michael (1966) “County Lunacy Commission Hearings: Some Observations of Commitments to a State Mental Hospital,” 14 Social Problems 26.Google Scholar
PHILLIPS, Leslie and DRAGUNS, Jurus G. (1971) “Classification of the Behavior Disorders,” 22 Annual Review of Psychology 447.Google Scholar
ROCK, Ronald S., JACOBSON, Marcus A. and JANOPAUL, Richard M. (1968) Hospitalization and Discharge of the Mentally Ill. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
ROSEN, A. (1954) “Detection of Suicide Patients: An Example of Some Limitations in the Prediction of Infrequent Events,” 18 Journal of Consulting Psychology 397.Google Scholar
ROSENHAN, David L. (1973) “On Being Sane in Insane Places,” 179 Science 250.Google Scholar
SCHEFF, Thomas J. (1964a) “Social Conditions for Rationality: How Urban and Rural Courts Deal with the Mentally Ill,” 7 American Behavioral Scientist 21 (March).Google Scholar
SCHEFF, Thomas J. (1964b) “The Societal Reaction to Deviance: Ascriptive Elements in the Psychiatric Screening of Mental Patients in a Midwestern State,” 11 Social Problems 401.Google Scholar
SHAH, Saleem A. (1974) “Some Interactions of Law and Mental Health in the Handling of Social Deviance,” 23 Catholic University Law Review 647.Google Scholar
SHAH, Saleem A. (1975) “Dangerousness and Civil Commitment of the Mentally Ill: Some Public Policy Considerations,” 132 American Journal of Psychiatry 501.Google Scholar
STATISTICS AND PROGRAM ANALYSIS SERVICES (1973) Profile of Admissions Characteristics. Raleigh: Division of Mental Health Services, N.C. Department of Human Resources (Report No. 3-40. Series MSR-3).Google Scholar
STEADMAN, Henry J. (1972) “The Psychiatrist as a Conservative Agent of Social Control,” 20 Social Problems 263.Google Scholar
STEADMAN, Henry J. and COCOZZA, J. H. (1974) Careers of the Criminally Insane: Excessive Social Control of Deviance. Lexington, Mass.: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
WARREN, Carol A. B. (1977) “Involuntary Commitment for Mental Disorder: The Application of California's Lanterman-Petris-Short Act,” 11 Law & Society Review 629.Google Scholar
WENGER, Dennis L. and FLETCHER, C. Richard (1969) “The Effect of Legal Counsel on Admissions to a State Mental Hospital: A Confrontation of Professions,” 10 Journal of Health and Social Behavior 66.Google Scholar
WEXLER, David B., SCOVILLE, Stanley E. et al. (1971) “The Administration of Psychiatric Justice: Theory and Practice in Arizona,” 13 Arizona Law Review 1.Google Scholar