Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-m9pkr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-13T02:37:32.795Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Judicial Behavior After a Change of Regime: The Effects of Judge and Defendant Characteristics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Taavi Annus  and
Margit Tavits
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article examines the determinants of judicial behavior in the context of transition. It tests two assumptions: first, that the judges with experience from the pretransition criminal justice system behave differently from the judges with no such experience; second, that minorities are discriminated against due to their dominant position in society before the transition and stereotypical attitudes after the transition. Using evidence from trial-level courts in Estonia, we find no statistically significant effects between case outcomes, the experience of the judge, and the ethnicity of the suspect.

Type
Articles of General Interest
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 38 , Issue 4 , December 2004 , pp. 711 - 736
Copyright
© 2004 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Authors would like to thank the Estonian Ministry of Justice and the Estonian Supreme Court for access to their data. Taavi Annus acknowledges the financial support provided by the Estonian National Science Foundation grant No. 4523. Earlier versions of this article were delivered at the XIII Nordiske Statskundskabskongres of the Nordic Political Science Association, Aalborg, Denmark, August 15–17, 2002, and at the Annual Meeting of Southern Political Science Association, Savannah, GA, November 6–9, 2002.

References

References

Albonetti, Celesta A. (1997) “Sentencing under the Federal Sentencing Guidelines: Effects of Defendant Characteristics, Guilty Pleas, and Departures on Sentence Outcomes for Drug Offenses, 1991–1992,” 31 Law & Society Rev. 789–822.Google Scholar
Albonetti, Celesta A. (1998) “The Role of Gender and Departures in the Sentencing of Defendants Convicted of a White-Collar Offense under the Federal Sentencing Guidelines,” 1 Sociology of Crime, Law, and Deviance 3–48.Google Scholar
Ashenfelter, Orley, Eisenberg, Theodore, & Schwab, Stewart J. (1995) “Politics and the Judiciary: The Influence of Judicial Background on Case Outcomes,” 24 J. of Legal Studies 257–81.Google Scholar
Baldus, David C., Pulaski, Charles A. Jr., & Woodworth, George (1983) “Comparative Review of Death Sentences: An Empirical Study of the Georgia Experience,” 74 J. of Criminal Law and Criminology 661–753. pmid/6839726Google Scholar
Baldus, David C., Woodworth, George, & Pulaski, Charles A. Jr. (1990) Equal Justice and the Death Penalty: A Legal and Empirical Analysis. Boston: Northeastern Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Baldus, David C., Woodworth, George, Zuckerman, David, Weiner, Neil Alan, & Broffit, Barbara (1998) “Racial Discrimination and the Death Penalty in the Post-Furman Era: An Empirical and Legal Overview, with Recent Findings from Philadelphia,” 83 Cornell Law Rev. 1638–770.Google Scholar
Baum, Lawrence (1997) The Puzzle of Judicial Behavior. Ann Arbor: Univ. of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bugaric, Bojan (2001) “Courts as Policy-Makers: Lessons from Transition,” 42 Harvard International Law J. 247–88.Google Scholar
Council of Europe (2001) Advisory Committee on the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities Opinion on Estonia. CM (2001) 159. http://www.coe.int/T/e/human%5Frights/Minorities/. Accessed August 15, 2004.Google Scholar
Dakolias, Maria (1995) “A Strategy for Judicial Reform: The Experience in Latin America,” 36 Virginia J. of International Law 167–231.Google Scholar
Dixon, Jo (1995) “The Organizational Context of Criminal Sentencing,” 100 American J. of Sociology 1157–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dyzenhaus, David (2003) “Transitional Justice,” 1 International J. of Constitutional Law 163–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Epstein, Lee, Knight, Jack, & Shvetsova, Olga (2001) “The Role of Constitutional Courts in the Establishment and Maintenance of Democratic Systems of Government,” 35 Law & Society Rev. 117–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foglesong, Todd (1997) “The Reform of Criminal Justice and Evolution of Judicial Dependence in Late Soviet Russia,” in Solomon, P. H., ed., Reforming Justice in Russia, 1864–1996: Power, Culture and the Limits of Legal Order. Armonk and London: M. E. Sharpe.Google Scholar
Gibson, James L., & Caldeira, Gregory A. (2003) “Defenders of Democracy? Legitimacy, Popular Acceptance, and the South African Constitutional Court,” 65 J. of Politics 1–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ginsburg, Tom (2003) Judicial Review in New Democracies: Constitutional Courts in Asian Cases. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hagan, John, & Bumiller, Kristin (1983) “Making Sense of Sentencing: A Review and Critique of Sentencing Research,” in Blumstein, A., Cohen, J., Martin, S., & Tonry, M., eds., Research on Sentencing: The Search for Reform. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.Google Scholar
Hammergren, Linn A. (1997) The Politics of Justice and Justice Reform in Latin America: The Peruvian Case in Comparative Perspective. Boulder: Westview.Google Scholar
Helmke, Gretchen (2002) “The Logic of Strategic Defection: Court-Executive Relations in Argentina Under Dictatorship and Democracy,” 96 American Political Science Rev. 291–303. pmid/12174782Google Scholar
Hendley, Kathryn (1999) “Appellate Decision-Making in the Russian Arbitrazh Courts: A Three Year Assessment,” 24 Rev. of Central and East European Law 465–91.Google Scholar
Hogarth, John (1971) Sentencing as a Human Process. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huskey, Eugene (1992) “The Administration of Justice: Courts, Procuracy, and Ministry of Justice,” in Huskey, E., ed., Executive Power and Soviet Politics: The Rise and Fall of the Soviet State. Armonk and London: M. E. Sharpe.Google Scholar
Järvelaid, Peeter, & Pihlamägi, Maie (1999) 80 aastat Eesti Vabariigi Justiitsministeeriumi 1918–1998 [80 Years of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Estonia 1918–1998]. Tallinn: Teaduste Akadeemia Kirjastus.Google Scholar
Kemp, A.Walter, ed. (2001) Quiet Diplomacy in Action: The OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities. The Hague, London, Boston: Kluwer Law International.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kimmel, Toomas (2003) “Saladuslik Eesti NSV Ülemkohus” [The Mysterious Supreme Court of the Estonian SSR] Eesti P ä evaleht, 11 Feb. http://www.epl.ee/artikkel_227450.html. Accessed on August 15, 2004.Google Scholar
Kolstø, Pål, & Melberg, Hans Olav (2002) “Integration, Alienation, and Conflict in Estonia and Moldova at the Societal Level: A Comparison,” in Kolstø, P., ed., National Integration and Violent Conflict in Post-Soviet Societies: The Cases of Estonia and Moldova. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
Kramer, John, & Steffensmeier, Darrell (1993) “Race and Imprisonment Decisions,” 34 Sociological Q. 357–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kritz, Neil J. ed. (1995) Transitional Justice: How Emerging Democracies Reckon with Former Regimes. Washington, DC: U.S. Institute for Peace.Google Scholar
Kritzer, Herbert M. (2003) “The Government Gorilla Why Does Government Come Out Ahead?,” in Kritzer, H. M. & Silbey, S. S., eds., Litigation: Do the “Haves” Still Come Out Ahead? Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Letki, Natalia (2002) “Lustration and Democratisation in East-Central Europe,” 54 Europe-Asia Studies 529–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Łoś, Maria (1988) Communist Ideology, Law and Crime: A Comparative View of the USSR and Poland. Houndmills, United Kingdom, and New York: Palgrave MacMillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Magalhães, Pedro (2003) “The Limits to Judicialization: Legislative Politics and Constitutional Review in the Iberian Democracies,” Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Political Science, Ohio State UniversityGoogle Scholar
Markovits, Inga (1995) Imperfect Justice: An East-West German Diary. Oxford and New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Markovits, Inga (1996) “Children of a Lesser God: GDR Lawyers in Post-Socialist Germany,” 94 Michigan Law Rev. 2270–308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maruste, Rait (1994) “Kohtureform – kas lõpu alguses või alguse lõpus?,” [The Court Reform – In the Beginning of an End or at the End of the Beginning?] 5 Juridica 103.Google Scholar
Mauer, Marc (1999) Race to Incarcerate. New York: The New Press.Google Scholar
Ministry of Justice (2001) Statistical Report of the Courts of the 1st and 2nd Instance on the Year 2000. http://www.just.ee/oldjust/kohtud/statistical_report2000.html. Accessed September 8, 2003.Google Scholar
Müller, Ingo (1991) Hitler's Justice: The Courts of the Third Reich. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Mustard, David B. (2001) “Racial, Ethnic, and Gender Disparities in Sentencing: Evidence from the U.S. Federal Courts,” 44 J. of Law and Economics 285–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nagel, Ilene H., & Johnson, Barry L. (1994) “The Role of Gender in a Structured Sentencing System: Equal Treatment, Policy Choices, and the Sentencing of Female Offenders under the United States Sentencing Guidelines,” 85 J. of Criminal Law & Criminology 181–221. pmid/7994563CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Offe, Claus (1996) Varieties of Transition: The East European and East German Experience. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Peterson, Ruth D., & Hagan, John (1984) “Changing Conceptions of Race: Towards an Account of Anomalous Findings of Sentencing Research,” 49 American Sociological Rev. 56–70.Google Scholar
Pettai, Vello (20022003) “Ethnopolitics in Constitutional Courts: Estonia and Latvia Compared,” 11/12 East European Constitutional Rev. 101–5.Google Scholar
Quint, Peter E. (1997) The Imperfect Union: Constitutional Structures of German Unification. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Randazzo, Kirk A., & Herron, Erik S. (2003) “The Development of Judicial Independence in Post-Communist States,” 65 J. of Politics 422–38. pmid/12903643Google Scholar
Raun, Toivo U. (2001) Estonia and the Estonians. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press.Google Scholar
Riigikohus (1996) Eesti kohtunikud [Estonian Judges]. Tartu, Estonia: Riigikohus.Google Scholar
Rothstein, Bo, & Stolle, Dielind (2002) “How Political Institutions Create and Destroy Social Capital: An Institutional Theory of Generalized Trust.” Presented at the American Political Science Association Annual Meeting, Boston.Google Scholar
Rowat, Malcolm, Malik, Waleed Haider, & Dakolias, Maria, eds. (1995) Judicial Reform in Latin America and the Caribbean: Proceedings of a World Bank Conference. Washington, DC: The World Bank.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rowland, C. K., & Carp, Robert A. (1996) Politics and Judgment in Federal District Courts. Lawrence: Univ. Press of Kansas.Google Scholar
Ruutsoo, Rein (2002) “Discursive Conflict and Estonian Post-Communist Nation-Building,” in Lauristin, M. & Heidmets, M., eds., The Challenge of the Russian Minority. Emerging Multicultural Democracy in Estonia. Tartu, Estonia: Tartu Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Saar, Jüri (1999) “Crime and Crime Control in Estonia,” in Vetik, R., ed., Estonian Human Development Report 1999, http://www.iiss.ee/nhdr/1999/EIA99eng.pdf. Accessed August 15, 2004.Google Scholar
Saar, Jüri, Markina, Anna, Ahven, Andri, Annist, Aet, & Ginter, Jaan (2002) Kuritegevus Eestis 1991–2001 [Crime in Estonia, 1991–2001]. Tallinn: Juura.Google Scholar
Sampson, Robert J., & Lauritsen, Janet L. (1997) “Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Crime and Criminal Justice in the United States,” in Tonry, M., ed., Ethnicity, Crime and Immigration. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Schatz, Sara (1998) “A Neo-Weberian Approach to Constitutional Courts in the Transition from Authoritarian Rule: The Mexican Case, 1994–1997,” 26 International J. of the Sociology of Law 217–44.Google Scholar
Schwartz, Herman (2000) The Struggle for Constitutional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. Chicago and London: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Segal, Jeffrey, & Spaeth, Harold (2002) The Supreme Court and the Attitudinal Model Revisited. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simon, Rita J., & Landis, Jean (1991) The Crimes Women Commit, the Punishments They Receive. Lexington, KY: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Smith, Gordon B. (1996) Reforming the Russian Legal System. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Solomon, Peter H. Jr. (1987) “The Case of the Vanishing Acquittal: Informal Norms and the Practice of Soviet Criminal Justice,” 39 Soviet Studies 531–55.Google Scholar
Solomon, Peter H., & Foglesong, Todd S. (2000) Courts and Transition in Russia: The Challenge of Judicial Reform. Boulder: Westview.Google Scholar
Sommers, Samuel R., & Ellsworth, Phoebe C. (2000) “White Juror Bias: An Investigation of Prejudice Against Black Defendants in the American Courtroom,” 7 Psychology, Public Policy and Law 201–29.Google Scholar
Spohn, Cassia C. (1990) “The Sentencing Decisions of Black and White Judges: Expected and Unexpected Similarities,” 24 Law & Society Rev. 1197–216.Google Scholar
Spohn, Cassia C. (1994) “Courts, Sentences, and Prisons,” 124 Daedalus 119–43.Google Scholar
Spohn, Cassia C. (2000) “Thirty Years of Sentencing Reform: The Quest for a Racially Neutral Sentencing Process,” in U.S. Department of Justice, ed., Policies, Processes, and Decisions of the Criminal Justice System, Vol. 3. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.Google Scholar
Statistical Office of Estonia (2001) 2000 Population and Housing Census: Citizenship, Nationality, Mother Tongue and Command of Foreign Languages II. Tallinn: Statistical Office of Estonia.Google Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, & Britt, Chester L. (2001) “Judges' Race and Judicial Decision-Making: Do Black Judges Sentence Differently?,” 82 Social Science Q. 749–64.Google Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, & Demuth, Stephen (2001) “Ethnicity and Judges' Sentencing Decisions: Hispanic-Black-White Comparisons,” 39 Criminology 145–78.Google Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, & Hebert, Chris (1999) “Women and Men Policymakers: Does the Judge's Gender Affect the Sentencing of Criminal Defendants,” 77 Social Forces 1163–96.Google Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, Kramer, John, & Streifel, Cathy (1993) “Gender and Imprisonment Decisions,” 31 Criminology 411–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, Ulmer, Jeffrey, & Kramer, John (1998) “The Interaction of Race, Gender, and Age in Criminal Sentencing: The Punishment Cost of Being Young, Black, and Male,” 36 Criminology 763–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strohmeyer, Hansjorg (2001) “Collapse and Reconstruction of a Judicial System: The United Nations Missions in Kosovo and East Timor,” 95 American J. of International Law 46–63. pmid/11267719Google Scholar
Stotzky, Irwin P., ed. (1993) Transition to Democracy in Latin America: The Role of the Judiciary. Boulder: Westview.Google Scholar
Szczerbiak, Aleks (2002) “Dealing with the Communist Past or the Politics of the Present? Lustration in Post-Communist Poland,” 54 Europe-Asia Studies 553–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Teitel, Ruti G. (2000) Transitional Justice. Oxford and New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (2002) Concluding Observations of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination: Estonia. CERD/C/61/CO/4. Geneva: Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.Google Scholar
Valls, Andrew (2000) “Between Past and Future: Recent Work on Transitional Justice,” 4 Trames 394–411. pmid/10959766Google Scholar
Webb, Hoyt (1998) “The Constitutional Court of South Africa: Rights Interpretation and Comparative Constitutional Law,” 1 University of Pennsylvania J. of Constitutional Law 205–83.Google Scholar
Weisbud, David, Wheeler, Stanton, Waring, Elin, & Bode, Nancy (1991) Crimes of the Middle Classes: White-Collar Offenders in the Federal Courts. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Weitzer, Ronald (1996) “Racial Discrimination in the Criminal Justice System: Findings and Problems in the Literature,” 24 J. of Criminal Justice 309–22.Google Scholar
Widner, Jennifer (2001) “Courts and Democracy in Postconflict Transitions: A Social Scientist's Perspective on the African Case,” 95 American J. of International Law 64–75.Google Scholar
Zevelev, Igor (2001) Russia and Its New Diasporas. United States Institute of Peace Press.Google Scholar

Case Cited

McCleskey v. Kemp, 481 U.S. 279 (1987).Google Scholar