Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-9q27g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-22T06:47:30.291Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Legislative Reform of Child Custody Adjudication: An Effort to Rely on Social Science Data in Formulating Legal Policies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 July 2024

Phoebe C. Ellsworth  and
Robert J. Levy
Phoebe C. Ellsworth
Affiliation:
Stanford University
Robert J. Levy
Affiliation:
University of Minnesota
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

A survey of child custody cases and commentary yields the following, most depressing conclusions: everyone agrees that awarding custody is one of the trial judge's most delicate responsibilities; almost everyone is unhappy with prevailing substantive and procedural doctrines; yet no one seems to believe that the situation can be improved substantially. Too many appellate opinions begin, or end, with a plaintive plea for the reader's sympathy.

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 4 , Issue 2 , November 1969 , pp. 167 - 233
Copyright
Copyright © 1969 by the Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

AUTHORS' NOTE: This article is drawn from a report, entitled “Uniform Marriage and Divorce Legislation: A Preliminary Inquiry,” prepared for the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws. The conference, whose membership includes official representation from the fifty states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, prepares legislation on a variety of topics of interstate concern-with the goal of modernizing and making uniform legal policies throughout the United States. The report of which this article is a part is the initial product of a conference endeavor to promulgate a uniform marriage and divorce law.

In its original form, the first section of this essay was a separate paper prepared as an attachment to and as support for the statutory policy recommendations which here appear in the second section.

The authors thank the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws for permission to print this essay separately. In addition, we acknowledge our debt to Dr. J. M. Carlsmith, Stanford University, for helpful suggestions concerning methodological considerations. All recommendations are the authors' alone; the National Conference has neither approved nor endorsed any part of this essay.

References

Cases

BASS v. BASS (1966) Ga. 222: 378; S.E.2d 149: 818.Google Scholar
BOONE v. BOONE (1945) D.C. Circuit, F.2d 150: 153.Google Scholar
CLIFFORD v. WOODFORD (1957) Ariz. 83: 257; P.2d 320: 452.Google Scholar
COMMONWEALTH v. BENDER (1962) Pa. Super. 197: 397; A.2d 178: 799.Google Scholar
COULTER v. COULTER (1959) Colo. 141: 237; P.2d 347: 492.Google Scholar
GALBRAITH v. GALBRAITH (1960) Ariz. 88: 358; P.2d 356: 1023; Annot., A.L.R. 2d 74: 1073.Google Scholar
HANKS v. HANKS (1962) La. App., So. 2d 138: 19.Google Scholar
HEDMAN v. HEDMAN (1954) N.D., N.W.2d 62: 223.Google Scholar
HOLLINGSWORTH v. KOHLER (1946) Tex. Civ. App.; (1954) S.W.2d 195: 563; Annot., A.L.R. 2d 35: 629, 636.Google Scholar
JENKINS v. JENKINS (1939) Mass. 304: 248; N.E.2d 23: 405.Google Scholar
JOHNSON v. KELLY (1871) Ga. 44: 485.Google Scholar
KESSELER v. KESSELER (1962) N.Y.2d 10: 445; N.E.2d 180: 402; N.Y.S.2d 225: 1; N.Y.S.2d 236: 472 (Sup. Ct., 1963: remanded).Google Scholar
KOEPPEN v. KOEPPEN (1968) Mich. App. 11: 147;N.W.2d 160: 722.Google Scholar
In Re M___ P___ S___, (1961) St. Louis, Mo. Ct. App., S.W.2d 342: 277.Google Scholar
MAZUR v. LAZARUS (1964) D.C., A.2d 196: 477.Google Scholar
OLTMANNS v. OLTMANNS (1963) Minn. 265: 377; N.W.2d 121: 779.Google Scholar
OSTERGREN v. OSTERGREN (1962) Mich. 368: 408; N.W.2d 118: 245.Google Scholar
PAINTER v. BANNISTER (1966) Iowa 258: 1390; N.W.2d 140: 152; U.S. 385: 949 (cert. denied).Google Scholar
REA v. REA (1952) Ore. 195: 252; P.2d 245: 884.Google Scholar
ROCHE v. ROCHE (1944) Cal.2d 25: 141; Pac.2d 152: 999.Google Scholar
ROHRBAUGH v. ROHRBAUGH (1951) W. Va. 136: 708; S.E.2d 68: 361.Google Scholar
ROOT v. ALLEN (1962) Colo., P.2d 377: 117.Google Scholar
SACKLER v. SACKLER (1962) Misc.2d 33: 600; N.Y.S.2d 224: 790 (rev'd); App.Div.2d 16: 423; N.Y.S.2d 229: 61.Google Scholar
SLATER v. SLATER (1959) Ga. 215: 161; S.E.2d 109: 521.Google Scholar
In re Guardianship of Smith (1954) Cal.2d 42: 91; P.2d 265: 888.Google Scholar
In re Smith (1961) Sup. Ct., N.Y.S.2d 222: 705.Google Scholar
SOMMERS v. SOMMERS (1966) Wis.2d 33: 22; N.W.2d 146: 428.Google Scholar
WILLIAMS v. WILLIAMS (1955) Ill. App.2d 8: 1; N.E.2d 130: 291.Google Scholar

References

ALEXANDER, P. W. (1953) “Let's get the embattled spouses out of the trenches.” Law and Contemporary Problems 18, 1: 98–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
ANDRY, R. G. (1960) Delinquency and Parental Pathology. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
BACH, G. R. (1946) “Father-fantasies and father-typing in father-separated children.” Child Development 17 (March-June): 63–80.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
BACON, M. K., I. L., CHILD and H. BARRY, III (1963) “A cross-cultural study of correlates of crime.” J. of Abnormal and Social Psychology 66 (April): 291–300.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
BAKER, S. L., COVE, L. A., FAGAN, S. A., FISCHER, E. G., and E. J., JANDA (1968) “Impact of father absence: III. Problems of family reintegration following prolonged father absence.” Presented at the 45th annual meeting of the American Orthopsychiatric Association, March 20-23: Chicago.Google Scholar
BARCLAY, A. and D. R., CUSUMANO (1967) “Father absence, cross-sex identity and field dependent behavior in male adolescents.” Child Development 38 (March): 243–250.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BARRY, H. J. and E., LINDEMANN (1960) “Critical ages for maternal bereavement in psychoneuroses.” Psychosomatic Medicine 22 (May-June): 166–187.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
BATCHELOR, I. R. C. and M. B., NAPIER (1953) “Broken homes among attempted suicides.” British J. of Delinquency 4 (October): 99–108.Google Scholar
BECK, A. T., B. B., SETHI and R. W., TUTHILL (1963) “Childhood bereavement and adult depression.” Archives of General Psychiatry 9 (September): 295–302.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
BECKER, W. C. and R. S., KRUG (1965) “The parent attitude research instrument—a research review.” Child Development 37 (June): 329–365.Google Scholar
BELL, R. Q. (1964) “The effect on the family of a limitation in coping ability in the child: a research report and a finding.” Merrill Palmer Q. 10 (April): 129–142.Google Scholar
BERGLER, E. (1948) Divorce Won't Help. New York: Harper.Google Scholar
BERNARD, J. (1956) Remarriage: A Study of Marriage. New York: Dryden Press.Google Scholar
BILLER, H. B. and L., BORSTELMANN (1967) “Masculine development: an integrative review.” Merrill Palmer Q. 13 (October): 253–294.Google Scholar
BLUMENTHAL, M. (1967) “Mental health among the divorced: A field study of divorced and never-divorced persons.” Archives of General Psychiatry 16 (May): 603–608.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
BODENHEIMER, B. M. (1961) “The Utah marriage counseling experiment: an account of changes in divorce law and procedure.” Utah Law Rev. 7 (Fall): 443–477.Google Scholar
BOK, D. C. (1960) “Section 7 of the Clayton Act and the merging of law and economics.” Harvard Law Rev. 74 (December): 226–355.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BOWLBY, J. (1952) Maternal Care and Mental Health. Geneva: World Health Organization.Google Scholar
BOWLBY, J., AINSWORTH, M., BOSTON, M., and D., ROSENBLUTH (1956) “The effects of mother-child separation: a follow-up study.” British J. of Medical Psychology 29 (Pts. 3 and 4): 211–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BRIM, O. G. (1958) “Family structure and sex role learning by children: a further analysis of Helen Koch's data.” Sociometry 21 (March): 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BROWN, F. (1961) “Depression and childhood bereavement.” British J. of Psychiatry 107 (July): 754–777.Google Scholar
BRUHN, J. G. (1965) “Broken homes among attempted suicides and psychiatric patients: a comparative study.” J. of Mental Science 108: 772–779.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BURCHINAL, L. G. (1964) “Characteristics of adolescents from unbroken, broken and reconstituted families.” J. of Marriage and the Family 26 (February): 44–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BURGESS, E. W. (1950) “Predictive methods and family stability.” Annals of the American Academy of Pol. and Social Sci. 272 (November): 47–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BURTON, R. V. and J. W. M., WHITING (1961) “The absent father and cross-sex identity.” Merrill Palmer Q. 7 (April): 85–95.Google Scholar
CAMPBELL, D. T. and J. C., STANLEY (1966) Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research. Chicago: Rand McNally.Google Scholar
CARLSMITH, L. (1964a) “Effect of early father-absence on scholastic aptitude.” Harvard Education Rev. 34 (Winter): 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CARLSMITH, L. (1964b) “Some personality characteristics of boys separated from their fathers during World War II.” Stanford Univ. (mimeo).Google Scholar
CAVAN, R. S. (1934) The Adolescent in the Family. Report of the subcommittee on the function of home activities in the education of the child. White House Conferences on Child Health and Protection. New York: Century.Google Scholar
CHAPIN, F. S. (1947) Experimental Designs in Sociological Research. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Univ. of Chicago Law Rev. [Note] (1957) “Use of extra-record information in custody cases.” 24 (Winter): 349–370.Google Scholar
CHINN, W. L. (1938) “A brief survey of nearly one thousand juvenile delinquents.” British J. of Educational Psychology 8 (Pt. 1): 78–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CHUTE, C. L. (1953) “Divorce and the family court.” Law and Contemporary Problems 18, 1: 49–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CICOUREL, A. V. (1967) “Kinship, marriage, and divorce in comparative family law.” Law and Society Rev. 1 (June): 103–129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CLARK, H. H. (1968) The Law of Domestic Relations in the United States. St. Paul: West.Google Scholar
Univ. of Colorado Law Rev. [Note] (1960) 32: 397–400.Google Scholar
Columbia Law Rev. [Note] (1963) 63 (January): 168–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Conference on Divorce (1952) Conference Series No. 9. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Law School.Google Scholar
DEMBITZ, N. (1963) “Ferment and experiment in New York juvenile cases in the new family court.” Cornell Law Q. 48 (Spring): 499–523.Google Scholar
DENNIS, W. (1960) “Causes of retardation among institutional children: Iran.” J. of Genetic Psychology 96 (March): 47–59.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
DORPAT, T. C., J. K., JACKSON and H. S., RIPLEY (1965) “Broken homes and attempted and completed suicide.” Archives of General Psychiatry 12 (February): 213–216.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
DUNTEMAN, G. H. and W. D., WOLKING (1967) “Relationship between marital status and the personality of mothers of disturbed children.” J. of Consulting Psychology 31 (April): 220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
FAIN, H. (1963) “Our child custody laws and policies—are they in need of revision or change?” Proceedings, Family Law Section, American Bar Association.Google Scholar
FAST, I. and A. C., CAIN (1966) “The stepparent role: potential for disturbance in family functioning.” Amer. J. of Orthopsychiatry 36 (April): 485–491.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
FENICHEL, O. (1945) The Psychoanalytic Theory of Neurosis. New York: W. W. Norton.Google Scholar
Final Report of the Assembly Interim Committee on Judiciary Relating to Domestic Relations (1963-65) California Assembly Interim Reports.Google Scholar
FOOTE, C., R. J., LEVY and F., SANDER (1966) Cases and Materials on Family Law. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
FORREST, T. (1966) “Paternal roots of female character development.” Contemporary Psychoanalysis 3 (Fall): 21–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
FOSTER, H. H. Jr. and D. J., FREED (1964) “Child custody pt. 2.” New York Univ. Law Rev. 39 (June): 615–630.Google Scholar
FREUD, A. and D. T., BURLINGHAM (1944) Infants Without Families. New York: International Univ. Press.Google Scholar
FREUD, S. (1921) “Group psychology and the analysis of the ego,” Pp. 186–197 in Strachey, (ed.) The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. London: Hogarth Press, 1944.Google Scholar
GARDNER, L. P. (1943) “A survey of the attitudes and activities of fathers.” J. of Genetic Psychology 63 (September): 15–53.Google Scholar
GLICK, P. C. (1949) “First marriages and remarriages.” Amer. Soc. Rev. 14 (December): 726–734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
GLUECK, S. and E., GLUECK (1950) Unravelling Juvenile Delinquency. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
GOLDFARB, W. (1945) “Effects of psychological deprivation in infancy and subsequent stimulation.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 102 (July): 18–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
GOLDFARB, W. (1943) “Effects of early institutional care on adolescent personality.” J. of Experimental Education 12 (December): 106–129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
GOLDSTEIN, J. and J., KATZ (1965) The Family and the Law. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
GOODE, W. J. (1956) After Divorce. Glencoe, Ill: Free Press.Google Scholar
GREEN, B. C. (1963) “Domestic relations: parent denied return of child's custody from state because of personality conflict in parent-child relationship, application of Mittenthal, New York Family Court.” Syracuse Law J. 4 (Summer): 679–681.Google Scholar
GREENSTEIN, J. M. (1966) “Father characteristics and sex typing.” J. of Personality and Social Psychology 3 (March): 271–277.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
GREER, S. (1966) “Parental loss and attempted suicide: a further report.” British J. of Psychiatry 112 (May): 465–470.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
GREER, S. (1964) “The relationship between parental loss and attempted suicide: a control study.” British J. of Psychiatry 110 (September): 698–705.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
GREGORY, I. (1966) “Retrospective data concerning childhood loss of a parent: II. Category of parental loss by decade of birth, diagnosis, and MMPI.” Archives of General Psychiatry 15 (October): 362–367.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
OLTMAN, J. E., McGARRY, J. J., and S., FRIEDMAN (1951) “Parental deprivation and the ‘broken home’ in dementia praecox and other mental disorders.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 108: 685–694.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
PALMER, C. (1941) “Factors in suicidal attempts.” J. of Nervous and Mental Disease 93 (April): 421–442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
PARKES, C. M. (1964) “Recent bereavement as a cause of mental illness.” British J. of Psychiatry 110 (March): 198–204.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
PARSONS, T. (1955) “Family structure and the socialization of the child,” in Parsons, T. and Bales, R. F. (eds.) Family Socialization and Interaction Process. Glencoe, Ill.: Free Press.Google Scholar
PFAFF, R. A. (1961) “Domestic relations investigations.” Los Angeles Bar Assn. Bull. 36 (April): 192–195; 211–213.Google Scholar
PITTS, F. N. Jr., MEYER, J., BROOKS, M. and G., WINOKUR (1965) “Adult psychiatric illness assessed for childhood parental loss and psychiatric illness in family members: a study of 748 patients and 250 controls.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 121 (June, Supp.): i-x.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
POLLOCK, H. M., B., MALZBURG and R. G., FULLER (1939) Hereditary and Environmental Factors in the Causation of Manic-Depressive Psychoses and Dementia Praecox. Utica, N.Y. State Hospitals Press.Google Scholar
PRINGLE, M. L. and V., BOSSIO (1958) “A study of deprived children. I. Intellectual, emotional and social development.” Vita Humana 12: 65–92.Google Scholar
QUENSTEDT, U. R. and C., WINKLER (1965) “What are our domestic relations judges thinking?: Monograph No. 1, Amer. Bar Assn. Section of Family Law (July).Google Scholar
REITMAN, F. (1942) “On the predictability of suicide.” British J. of Psychiatry 88 (October): 580–58.Google Scholar
Report of the California Governor's Commission on the Family (1966) 38.Google Scholar
SARBIN, T. R., R., TAFT and D. E., BAILEY (1940) Clinical Inference and Cognitive Theory. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.Google Scholar
SCHOFIELD, W. and I., BALIAN (1959) “A comparative study of the personal histories of schizophrenic and nonpsychiatric patients.” J. of Abnormal Social Psychology 59 (September): 216–225.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
SEARS, P. S. (1951) “Doll-play aggression in normal young children: influence of sex, age, sibling status, father's absence.” Psychology Monograph 65, No. 6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SHAW, C. R. and McKAY, H. D. (1932) “Are broken homes a causative factor in juvenile delinquency?” Social Forces 10 (May): 514–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SIMON, W. (1950) “Attempted suicide among veterans.” J. of Nervous and Mental Disease 111 (June): 451–468.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
SIMONSEN, K. M. (1947) Examination of Children from Children's Homes and Day-Nurseries. Copenhagen: Nyt nordisk forlag.Google Scholar
SKARD, A. G. (1965) “Maternal deprivation: the research and its implications.” J. of Marriage and the Family 27 (August): 333–343.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SMITH, C. M. and McINTYRE, S. (1964) “Parental separation and psychiatric illness.” J. of Neuropsychiatry 5 (April): 244–246.Google ScholarPubMed
SMITH, W. C. (1953) The Stepchild. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Southern California Law Rev. [Note] (1963) 36, 2: 255–268.Google Scholar
SPITZ, R. A. and K., WOLF (1946) “Anaclitic depression.” Psychoanalytic Study of the Child 2: 313–342.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
STOLZ, L. M. et al. (1954) Father Relations of War-born Children. Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
SUEDFIELD, P. (1967) “Paternal absence and overseas success of Peace Corp volunteers.” J. of Consulting Psychology 31 (August): 424–42.Google Scholar
Symposium on the Child and the Law (1962) Univ. of Kansas Law Rev. 10 (May): 555–603.Google Scholar
TERMAN, L. M. and C. C., MILES (1936) Sex and Personality Studies in Masculinity and Femininity. New York: McGraw-Hill.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
THEIS, S. V. (1924) How Foster Children Turn Out. Pub. 165. New York: State Charities Aid Assn.Google Scholar
TUCKMAN, J. and R. A., REGAN (1966) “Intactness of the home and behavioral problems in children.” J. of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 7 (December): 225–233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
VERNON, P. E. (1964) Personality Assessment: A Critical Survey. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
WEBB, E. J., CAMPBELL, D. T., SCHWARTZ, R. D. and L., SECHREST (1966) Unobtrusive Measures: Nonreactive Research in the Social Sciences. Chicago: Rand McNally.Google Scholar
WEINMAN, C. A. (1944) “The trial judge awards custody.” Law and Contemporary Problems 10, 5: 721–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Western Reserve Law Rev. [Note] (1967) “The ‘adversary’ process in child custody proceedings.” 18 (July): 1731–1752.Google Scholar
WOOTTON, B. (1962) “A social scientist's approach to maternal deprivation,” pp. 63-73 in Deprivation of Maternal Care. Public Health Paper No. 14. Geneva: World Health Organization.Google Scholar
Yale Law J. [Note] (1963) “Alternatives to ‘parental right’ in child custody disputes involving third parties.” 73 (November): 151–170.Google Scholar
YARROW, L. J. (1964) “Separation from parents during early childhood,” in Vol. I, Hoffmann, M. K. and Hoffman, L. W. (eds.) Review of Child Development Research. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
ZILBOORG, C. (1936) “Suicide among primitive and civilized races.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 92 (May): 1346–1369.CrossRefGoogle Scholar