Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-vpsfw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-22T20:22:31.908Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Routinization of Debt Collection: An Essay on Social Change and Conflict in the Courts

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 July 2024

Robert A. Kagan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In an era of supposed judicial imperialism, the decline of judicial involvement in an important policy area raises questions about the dynamics of legal change. In the past thirty-five years, despite large increases in the volume of loans and delinquent debts, there has been a sharp decline in contested debt cases in state supreme courts and an apparent decline in trial courts as well. In seeking an explanation, this article concludes that for both creditors and debtors, litigation has become more costly in relation to alternative courses of action such as renegotiating payment terms, declaring bankruptcy, or writing off unpaid debts. The attractiveness of nonlitigational alternatives is attributed to (a) the “legal rationalization” of credit transactions by institutional lenders, (b) increased litigation costs stemming from enhanced debtors' rights, and most importantly, (c) “systemic stabilization”—welfare state measures, economic regulation, insurance arrangements, and market diversification that facilitates the attenuation and spreading of financial losses.

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 18 , Issue 3 , 1984 , pp. 323 - 371
Copyright
Copyright © 1984 The Law and Society Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The research reflected in this article was supported in part by a grant from the National Science Foundation Program in Law and Social Science, Grant No. GS-384-13. Much thanks is due Terri Jennings for assembling and analyzing information concerning debt collection law and practice, and to Tom Jensen, Ed Rubin, Frank Munger, Bliss Cartwright, and Rick Lempert for their substantive and editorial advice.

References

References

AMERICAN COLLECTORS ASSOCIATION (1980) Collectrends: A Fifteen Year Comparison, 1965-1980. Minneapolis: American Collectors Association.Google Scholar
ANDERSON, Roy R. (1975) “Coercive Collection and Exempt Property in Texas: A Debtor's Paradise or a Living Hell?” 13 Houston Law Review 84.Google Scholar
BARDACH, Eugene and Robert A., KAGAN (1982) Going By The Book: The Problem of Regulatory Unreasonableness. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. A Twentieth Century Fund Report.Google Scholar
BAUM, Lawrence, Sheldon, GOLDMAN and Austin, SARAT (1981-82) “The Evolution of Litigation in the Federal Courts of Appeals, 1895-1975,” 16 Law & Society Review 291.Google Scholar
BENDER, Mark (1974) “The Long Term Growth of Consumer Installment Credit,” 3 Consumer Credit Leader 6.Google Scholar
BENSTON, George J. (1977) “The Impact of Maturity Regulation on High Interest Rate Lenders and Borrowers,” 41 Law and Contemporary Problems 180 (Autumn).Google Scholar
BLINDER, Alan S. (1980) “The Level and Distribution of Economic Well-Being,” in Feldstein, M. (ed.), The American Economy in Transition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
BONN, Robert L. (1972) “Arbitration: An Alternative System for Handling Contract Related Disputes,” 17 Administrative Science Quarterly 254.Google Scholar
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF CORPORATIONS (1981) Annual Report for California Consumer Finance Laws.Google Scholar
CAPLOVITZ, David (1974) Consumers in Trouble: A Study of Debtors in Default. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
CHAMBERS, David L. (1979) Making Fathers Pay: The Enforcement of Child Support. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
COLEMAN, Peter J. (1974) Debtors and Creditors in America: Insolvency, Imprisonment for Debt, and Bankruptcy, 1607-1900. Madison: State Historical Society of Wisconsin.Google Scholar
CONSUMER CREDIT LEADER (1973), Vol. 3, No. 1 (August).Google Scholar
EISENSTEIN, James and Herbert, JACOB (1977) Felony Justice: An Organizational Analysis of Criminal Courts. Boston: Little Brown.Google Scholar
EPSTEIN, David G. (1980) Debtor-Creditor Law in a Nutshell, 2nd Ed. St. Paul: West Publishing Co.Google Scholar
EPSTEIN, David G. and Steve H., NICKLES (1981) Consumer Law in a Nutshell. St. Paul: West Publishing Co.Google Scholar
FELSTINER, William L. F. (1974) “Influences of Social Organization on Dispute Processing,” 9 Law & Society Review 63.Google Scholar
FELSTINER, William L. F., ABEL, Richard L. and Austin, SARAT (1980-81) “The Emergence and Transformation of Disputes: Naming, Blaming, Claiming …,” 15 Law & Society Review 631.Google Scholar
FRIEDMAN, Benjamin M. (1980) “Postwar Changes in the American Financial Markets,” in Feldstein, M. (ed.), The American Economy in Transition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
FRIEDMAN, Lawrence M. (1973) A History of American Law. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
FRIEDMAN, Lawrence M. and Robert V., PERCIVAL (1976) “A Tale of Two Courts: Litigation in Alameda and San Benito Counties,” 10 Law & Society Review 267.Google Scholar
FRIEDMAN, Milton (1980) “The Changing Character of Financial Markets,” in Feldstein, M. (ed.), The American Economy in Transition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
GELB, Joyce and Marian Lief, PALLEY (1982) Women and Public Policies. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
GESSNER, Volkmar, RHODE, Barbara, STRATE, Gerhard and Klaus, ZIEGERT (1978) “Three Functions of Bankruptcy Law: The West German Case,” 12 Law & Society Review 499.Google Scholar
GOODWYN, Lawrence (1978) The Populist Moment: A Short History of the Agrarian Revolt in America. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
GRACE, J. Peter (1984) “Little Things Mean a Lot, Grace Panel Found,” Wall Street Journal 24 (January 12).Google Scholar
GROSSMAN, Joel B., KRITZER, Herbert M., BUMILLER, Kristen, SARAT, Austin, McDOUGAL, Stephen and Richard, MILLER (1982) “Dimensions of Institutional Participation: Who Uses the Courts, and How?” 44 Journal of Politics 86.Google Scholar
GUCCIONE, Eugene (1984) “Debt Cost is Soaking Up Cash Flow,” Wall Street Journal 21 (January 13).Google Scholar
HISTORICAL STATISTICS OF THE UNITED STATES (1975). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Bureau of the Census.Google Scholar
JACKSON, Thomas H. (1982) “Bankruptcy, Non-Bankruptcy Entitlements, and the Creditors' Bargain,” 91 Yale Law Journal 857.Google Scholar
JACOB, Herbert (1969) Debtors in Court: The Consumption of Government Services. Chicago: Rand McNally.Google Scholar
JENSEN, Merrill (1950) The New Nation: A History of the United States During the Confederation 1781-1789. New York: Alfred Knopf, Inc.Google Scholar
KAGAN, Richard L. (1981) Lawsuits and Litigants in Castile, 1500-1700. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
KAGAN, Robert A., CARTWRIGHT, Bliss, FRIEDMAN, Lawrence M. and Stanton, WHEELER (1977) “The Business of State Supreme Courts, 1870-1970,” 30 Stanford Law Review 121.Google Scholar
Stanton, WHEELER (1978) “The Evolution of State Supreme Courts,” 76 Michigan Law Review 961.Google Scholar
KRISLOV, Samuel (1983) “Theoretical Perspectives on Case Load Studies: A Critique and a Beginning,” in Boyum, K. O. and Mather, L. (eds.), Empirical Theories About Courts. New York: Longman.Google Scholar
LAURENT, Francis W. (1959) The Business of a Trial Court: 100 Years of Cases. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
LEFF, Arthur A. (1970) “Injury, Ignorance and Spite—The Dynamics of Coercive Collection,” 80 Yale Law Journal 1.Google Scholar
MACAULAY, Stewart (1979) “Lawyers and Consumer Protection Laws,” 14 Law & Society Review 115.Google Scholar
MANN, Bruce H. (1980) “Rationality, Legal Change, and Community in Connecticut 1690-1760,” 14 Law & Society Review 187.Google Scholar
McDONALD, Forrest (1982) “The Constitution and Hamiltonian Capitalism,” in Goldwin, R. A. and Schambra, W. A. (eds.), How Capitalistic Is the Constitution? Washington, D.C.: American Enterprise Institute.Google Scholar
McINTOSH, Wayne V. (1980-81) “150 Years of Litigation and Dispute Settlement: A Court Tale,” 15 Law & Society Review 823.Google Scholar
MECKLING, William H. (1977) “Financial Markets, Default, and Bankruptcy: The Role of the State,” 41 Law and Contemporary Problems 13 (Autumn).Google Scholar
MICHELMAN, Irving S. (1966) Consumer Finance: A Case History in American Business. New York: Frederick Fell, Inc.Google Scholar
MILLER, Merton H. (1977) “The Wealth Transfers of Bankruptcy: Some Illustrative Examples,” 41 Law and Contemporary Problems 39 (Autumn).Google Scholar
MILLER, Richard E. and Austin, SARAT (1981) “Grievances, Claims and Disputes: Assessing the Adversary Culture,” 15 Law & Society Review 525.Google Scholar
MOORE, Geoffrey H. and Philip A., KLEIN (1967) The Quality of Consumer Instalment Credit. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research and Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
MORTGAGE BANKERS ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA (1981) Seasonally Adjusted Delinquency and Foreclosure Ratios. Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
PAGTER, Carl R., McCLOSKEY, Robert and Michael, REINIS (1964) “The California Small Claims Court,” 52 California Law Review 876.Google Scholar
PARENTI, Michael (1980) “The Constitution as an Elitist Document,” in Goldwin, R. A. and Schambra, W.A. (eds.), How Democratic Is the Constitution? Washington, D.C: American Enterprise Institute.Google Scholar
ROBERTSON, Ross M. and Gary M., WALTON (1979) History of the American Economy, 4th Ed. New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich.Google Scholar
ROBINSON, Roland I. (1980) “The Financing of Small Business in the United States,” in Bruchey, S. W. (ed.), Small Business in American Life. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
ROSS, H. Laurence (1970) Settled Out of Court: The Social Process of Insurance Claims Adjustments. Chicago: Aldine.Google Scholar
ROSS, H. Laurence and Neil O., LITTLEFIELD (1978) “Complaint As a Problem-Solving Mechanism,” 12 Law & Society Review 199.Google Scholar
RUHNKA, John and Steven, WELLER, with MARTIN, John A. (1978) Small Claims Courts: A National Examination. Williamsburg, VA: National Center for State Courts.Google Scholar
SCHORR, Burt (1983) “States Cracking Down on Fathers Dodging Child-Support Payments,” Wall Street Journal 29 (January 26).Google Scholar
SHUCHMAN, Philip (1977) “Theory and Reality in Bankruptcy: The Spherical Chicken,” 41 Law and Contemporary Problems 66 (Autumn).Google Scholar
SCHWARTZ, Alan (1983) “The Enforceability of Security Interests in Consumer Goods,” 26 Journal of Law and Economics 117.Google Scholar
SHAPIRO, Martin (1975) “Courts,” in Greenstein, F. and Polsby, N. (eds.), Handbook of Political Science, Vol. 5. Governmental Institutions and Processes. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
SILVERMAN, Robert A. (1981) Law and Urban Growth: Civil Litigation in the Boston Trial Courts, 1880-1900. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SMALL CLAIMS COURT STUDY GROUP (1972) Little Injustices: Small Claims Courts and the American Consumer. Washington, D.C.: The Center for Auto Safety.Google Scholar
STANLEY, David T. and Marjorie, GIRTH (1971) Bankruptcy: Problem, Process, Reform. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
STARR, Roger (1979) “The End of Rental Housing?” 25 The Public Interest 57 (Fall).Google Scholar
SULLIVAN, George (1968) The Boom in Going Bust. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
U.S. COMMISSION ON THE BANKRUPTCY LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES (1973) Report. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
VUKOWICH, William T. (1974) “Debtors' Exemption Rights,” 62 Georgetown Law Review 779.Google Scholar
WANNER, Craig (1974) “The Public Ordering of Private Relations, Part One: Initiating Civil Cases in Urban Trial Courts,” 8 Law & Society Review 421.Google Scholar
WANNER, Craig (1975) “The Public Ordering of Private Relations, Part Two: Winning Civil Court Cases,” 9 Law & Society Review 293.Google Scholar
WHITFORD, William C. (1979) “A Critique of the Consumer Credit Collection System,” 1979 Wisconsin Law Review 1047.Google Scholar
WOOD, Gordon S. (1969) The Creation of the American Republic, 1776-1787. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
WRIGHT, Benjamin F. Jr. (1938) The Contract Clause of the Constitution. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar

Cases Cited

Cass v. Gunnison, Administrator For Hewitt, 58 Michigan 108 (1885).Google Scholar
County v. Brock et al., 44 Michigan 45 (1880).Google Scholar
Cummings et al. v. Consolidated Mineral Water Co. and Industrial Trust Co., 27 Rhode Island 195 (1905).Google Scholar
First National Bank of Pocatello v. Bunting and Co., 7 Idaho 387 (1900).Google Scholar
Fuentes v. Shevin, 407 U.S. 67 (1972).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Home Building and Loan Association v. Blaisdell, 290 U.S. 398 (1934).Google Scholar
Lennon v. Parker, 22 Rhode Island 43 (1900).Google Scholar
Mitchell v. W. T. Grant Co., 416 U.S. 600 (1974).Google Scholar
North Georgia Finishing Inc. v. Di-chem Inc., 419 U.S. 601 (1975).Google Scholar
Pearce v. Maguire, 17 Rhode Island 61 (1890).Google Scholar
Ray v. Profett, 83 Tennessee 517 (1885).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
St. Louis Hoop and Stove v. Dansforth and Wife, 160 Michigan 225 (1910).Google Scholar
Sniadach v. Family Finance Corp., 395 U.S. 337 (1964).Google Scholar