Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-g78kv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-30T04:52:52.622Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Puzzle of China's Township–Village Enterprises The Paradox of Local Corporatism in a Dual-Track Economic Transition

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 February 2015

Peter Ping Li
Peter Ping Li*
Affiliation:
College of Business Administration, California State University, USA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper seeks to reconcile and synthesize the diverse views about the township–village enterprises (TVEs) and local corporatism in the context of ongoing institutional changes in China as a transition economy. Specifically, I attempt to integrate the economic, political, cultural, and social explanations for TVEs, especially the two competing views of market competition and political corruption. I focus on the puzzle of TVE efficiency as well as the paradox of local corporatism as a government–business partnership with both a positive function of public alliance for wealth creation and a negative function of private collusion for wealth transfer. I argue that the key to both the puzzle of TVEs and the paradox of local corporatism lies in China's dual-track reform paradigm (i.e. a market-for-mass track and a state-for-élite track). Lastly, I discuss the critical implications for theory building and policymaking regarding economic transition in general.

Type
Articles
Information
Management and Organization Review , Volume 1 , Issue 2 , July 2005 , pp. 197 - 224
Copyright
Copyright © International Association for Chinese Management Research 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abed, G. T. and Davoodi, H. R. (2000). ‘Corruption, structural reforms, and economic performance in the transition economies’. International Monetary Fund Working Paper WP/00/132, Washington, DC: IMF.Google Scholar
Alchian, A. A. and Demsetz, H. (1972). ‘Production, information costs, and economic organization’. American Economie Review, 62, 5, 777–95.Google Scholar
Bai, G., Li, D. D., and Wang, Y. (2001). ‘Thriving on a tilted playing field: China's non-state enterprises in the reform era’. Working Paper No. 95, Stanford Center for International Development.Google Scholar
Barnard, M. E. and Shenkar, O. (1997). ‘The return of ‘the red-eye disease’: Wage inequality in the People's Republic of China’. Social Science Journal, 34, 57–70.Google Scholar
Basu, S. and Li, D. (2000). ‘A theory of the reform of bureaucratic institutions’. William Davidson Institute Working Paper No. 161, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor: WDI.Google Scholar
Blecher, M. (1991). ‘Development state, entrepreneurial state: The political economy of socialist reform in Xinji Municipality and Guanghan County’. In White, G. (Ed.), The Chinese State in the Era of Economic Reform: The Road to Crisis. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press, (pp. 265–91).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blecher, M. and Shue, V (1996). Tethered Deer: Government and Economy in a Chinese County. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Boisot, M. and Child, J. (1996). ‘From fiefs to clans and network capitalism: Explaining China's emerging economic order’. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 600–28.Google Scholar
Brandt, L. and Li, H. (2003). ‘Bank discrimination in transition economies: Ideology, information, or incentives?’ Journal of Comparative Economics, 31, 387–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brandt, L., Li, H. and Roberts, J. (2001). ‘Why do governments privatize?’ William Davidson Institute Working Paper No. 429, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor: WDI.Google Scholar
Cai, Y. (2003). ‘Collective ownership or cadres’ ownership? The non-agricultural use of farmland in China’. China Quarterly, 175, 662–80.Google Scholar
Cao, L. (2000). ‘Chinese privatization: Between plan and market’. Law and Contemporary Problems, 63, 4, 13–61.Google Scholar
Cao, Y., Qian, Y. and Weingast, B. R. (1999). ‘From federalism, Chinese style, to privatization, Chinese style’. Economics of Transition, 7, 1, 103–31.Google Scholar
Chang, C. and Wang, Y (1994). ‘The nature of the township-village enterprises’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 19, 434–52.Google Scholar
Chang, C., McCall, B. and Wang, Y. (2003). ‘Incentive contracting versus ownership reforms: Evidence from China's township and village enterprises’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 31, 414–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Che, J. and Qian, Y. (1998). ‘Institutional environment, community government, and corporate governance: Understanding China's township)—village enterprises’. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 14, 1, 1–23.Google Scholar
Chen, H. (2000a). The Institutional Transition of China's Township and Village Enterprises: Market Liberalization, Contractual Form Innovation and Privatization. Brookfield, VT: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Chen, J. (2000b). The institutional reforms and the informal institutions in the rural areas: The capital formation and control in China's TVE’. Economic Research (in Chinese), 1, 48–55.Google Scholar
Chen, L. (2003). ‘Deconstructing local developmental state: Stateled industrialization revisited’. Paper presented at the workshop on Organizations and State-Building, University of Chicago, Chicago.Google Scholar
Chen, C.J. (2004). Transforming Rural China: How Local Institutions Shape Property Rights in China. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Ding, X. (2000). ‘System irregularity and spontaneous property transformation in the Chinese financial system’. China Quarterly, 163, 655–76.Google Scholar
Dong, X. and Putterman, L. (1997). ‘Productivity and organization in China's rural industries: A Stochastic frontier approach’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 24, 2, 181–201.Google Scholar
Dong, X., Bowles, P. and Ho, S. P. (2002). ‘The determinants of employee ownership in China's privatized rural industry: Evidence from Jiangsu and Shandong’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 30, 415–37.Google Scholar
Dong, X., Putterman, L. and Unel, B. (2004). ‘Enterprise restructuring and firm performance: A comparison of rural and urban enterprises in Jiangsu Province’. William Davidson Institute Working Paper No. 668, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor: WDI.Google Scholar
Dougherty, S. and McGuckin, R. H. (2002). ‘The effects of federalism and privatization on productivity in Chinese firms’. EPWP Working Paper No. 1–2, Conference Board, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Fan, C. S. and Grossman, H. I. (2001). ‘Incentives and corruption in Chinese economic reform’. Journal of Policy Reform, 4, 3, 195–206.Google Scholar
He, Q. (1998). The Pitfalls of China's Modernization (in Chinese), Hong Kong: Mirror.Google Scholar
Helmke, G. and Levitsky, S. (2003). ‘Informal institutions and comparative politics: A research agenda’. Paper presented at the Conference of Informal Institutions and Politics in Latin America, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame.Google Scholar
Holmstrom, N. and Smith, R. (2000). ‘The necessity of gangster capitalism: Primitive accumulation in Russia and China’. Monthly Revieiv, 51, 9, 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hu, X. (2002). ‘Transformation of property rights in China: The institutional origins’. Working Paper, Clemson University, Clemson.Google Scholar
International Finance Corporation (IFC), (2000). China's Emerging Private Enterprises: Prospectsfor the New Century. Washington, DC: International Finance Corporation.Google Scholar
Jefferson, G. H., Rawski, T. G., Wang, L. and Zheng, Y. (2000). ‘Ownership, productivity change, and financial performance in Chinese industry’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 28, 786–813.Google Scholar
Jensen, M. C. (2000). Theory of the Firm: Governance, Residual Claims, and Organizational Forms. Boston, MA; Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Jiang, C. (2000). ‘The logic of the property rights reforms of TVE’. Economic Research (in Chinese), 10, 21–29.Google Scholar
Jiang, S. and Hall, R. H. (1996). ‘Local corporatism and rural enterprises in China's reform’. Organization Studies, 17, 6, 929–52.Google Scholar
Jin, D. and Haynes, K. E. (1997). ‘Economic transition at the edge of order and chaos: China's dualist and leading sectoral approach’. Journal of Economic Issues, 31, 1, 79–101.Google Scholar
Jin, H. and Qian, Y. (1998). ‘Public vs. private ownership of firms: Evidence from rural China’. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 113, 2, 467–96.Google Scholar
Johnston, M. (1996). ‘The search for definitions: The vitality of politics and the issue of corruption’. International Social Science Journal, 149, 321–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnston, M. and Hao, Y (1995). ‘China's surge of corruption: Delayed political development, markets, and democratic reform’. Journal of Democracy,, 6, 4, 80–94.Google Scholar
Li, D. (1996). A theory of ambiguous property rights in transition economics: The case of the Chinese non-state sector’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 23, 1, 1–19.Google Scholar
Li, H. (2003). ‘Government's budget constraint, competition, and privatization: Evidence from China's rural industry’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 31, 486–502.Google Scholar
Li, H. and Rozelle, S. (2003). ‘Privatizing rural China: Insider privatization, innovative contracts, and the performance of township enterprises’. China Quarterly, 176, 981–1005.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, J., Qiu, L. D. and Sun, Q. (2003). ‘Interregional protection: Implications of fiscal decentralization and trade liberalization’. China Economic Review, 14, 227–45.Google Scholar
Li, K., Smyth, R. and Yao, S. (2005). ‘Institutionalized corruption and privilege in China's socialist market economy: A general equilibrium analysis’. Pacific Economic Review.Google Scholar
Li, P. P. (2004). ‘Guanxi and social capital as special informal institutions: Toward a holistic, dynamic and dialectical approach to theory-building’. Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the Academy of International Business, Stockholm, Sweden, July 10.Google Scholar
Li, P. P. and Chang, S. T. (2000). ‘The Asian paradox of miracle and debacle: An exploratory study’. International Finance Review, 1, 429–53.Google Scholar
Li, S. and Lian, P. (1999). ‘Decentralization and coordination: China's credible commitment to preserve the market under authoritarianism’, China Economic Review, 10, 161–90.Google Scholar
Lin, N. and Chen, C. (1999). ‘Local elites as officials and owners: Shareholding and property rights in Daqiuzhuang’. In Oi, J. C. and Walder, A. G. (Eds), Property Rights and China's Economic Reforms. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, (pp. 145–70).Google Scholar
Lin, Y. and Zhang, Z. (1999). ‘Backyard profit centers: The private assets of public agencies’. In Oi, J.G. and Walder, A.G. (Eds), Property Rights and China's Economic Reforms. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, (pp. 203–25).Google Scholar
Lu, X. (2000). ‘Booty socialism, bureau-preneurs, and the state in transition – organized corruption in China’. Comparative Politics, 32, 3, 273–94.Google Scholar
Megginson, W. L. and Netter, J. M. (2001). ‘From state to market: A survey of empirical studies on privatization’. Journal of Economic Literature, 39, 2, 321–89.Google Scholar
Naughton, B. (1994). ‘Chinese institutional innovation and privatization from below’. American Economic Association Papers and Proceedings, 84, 2, 266–70.Google Scholar
Nee, V (1992). ‘Organizational dynamics of market transition: Hybrid forms, property rights, and mixed economy in China’. Administrative Science Quarterly, 37, 1–27.Google Scholar
North, D. (1990). Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Oi, J. C. (1999). Rural China Takes Off: Institutional Foundations of Economic Reform, Berkeley, GA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Park, A. and Shen, M. (2003). ‘Joint liability lending and the rise and fall of China's township and village enterprises’. Journal of Development Economics, 71, 497–531.Google Scholar
Pei, X. (1998). The Institutional Context of China's Rural Industry and Gradual Reform. Sweden: Lund University Press.Google Scholar
Pejovich, S. (1997). ‘Law, tradition, and the transition in Eastern Europe’. The Independent Review, 2(2), 243–54.Google Scholar
Perotti, E. C., Sun, L. and Zou, L. (1999). ‘State-owned versus township and village enterprises in China’. Comparative Economics Studies, 41, 2/3, 151–79.Google Scholar
Putterman, L. (1995). ‘The role of ownership and property rights’ in China's economic transition’. China Quarterly, 144, 1047–64.Google Scholar
Rawski, T. G. (1995). ‘Implications of China's reform experience’. China Quarterly, 144, 1150–73.Google Scholar
Rozelle, S., Li, G., Shen, M., Hughart, A. and Giles, J. (1999). ‘Leaving China's farms: Survey results of new paths and remaining hurdles to rural migration’. China Quarterly, 158, 367–93.Google Scholar
Rozelle, S. and Swinnen, J. (2003). ‘Transition and agriculture’. Working Paper, the University of California at Davis, Sacramento, CA.Google Scholar
Ruf, G. A. (1999). ‘Collective enterprise and property rights in a Sichuan village: The rise and decline of management corporation’. In Oi, J. C. and Walder, A. G. (Eds), Property Rights and China's Economic Reforms. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, (pp. 27–48).Google Scholar
Scott, W. R. (2003). Organizations: Rational, Natural, and Open Systems (5th edn). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Shi, Y, Zhao, X. and Chang, Z. (2001). ‘The myth of Southern Jiangsu’. Finance (in Chinese), May Issue, 33–50.Google Scholar
Sonobe, T. and Otsuka, K. (2001). ‘Productivity effects of TVE privatization: The case study of garment and metal casting enterprises in the Greater Yangtze River Region’. Paper presented at the 12th Annual East Asian Seminar on Economics, Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Spicer, A., McDermott, G. A. and Kogut, B. (2000). ‘Entrepreneurship and privatization in Central Europe: The tenuous balance between destruction and creation’. Academy of Management Review, 25, 3, 630–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sun, L. (2000). ‘Anticipatory ownership reform driven by competition; China's township–village and private enterprises in the 1990s’. Comparative Economic Studies, 42, 3, 49–75.Google Scholar
Tian, G. (2000). ‘Property rights and the nature of Chinese collective enterprises’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 28, 247–68.Google Scholar
Tong, C. S. P. and Chan, H. L. (2003). ‘Disparity in production efficiency of China's TVEs across regions: A stochastic frontier production’. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 20, 1, 113–31.Google Scholar
Tsui, A. S., Schoonhoven, C. B., Meyer, M. W., Lau, C. and Milkovich, G. T. (2004). Organization and management in the midst of societal transformation: The People's Republic of China’. Organization Science, 15, 133–44.Google Scholar
Walder, A. G. (1998). ‘Zouping in perspective’. In Walder, A.G. (Ed.), Zouping in Transition: The Process of Reform in Rural North China. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, (pp. 16–23).Google Scholar
Walder, A. G. (2002a). ‘Markets and income inequality in rural China: Political advantage in an expanding economy’. American Sociological Review, 67, 231–53.Google Scholar
Walder, A. G. (2002b). ‘Privatization and elite mobility: Rural China, 1979–1996’. Working Paper, Asia/Pacific Research Center, Stanford University.Google Scholar
Walder, A. G. (2003). ‘Elite opportunity in transitional economies’. American Sociological Review, 68, 899–916.Google Scholar
Walder, A. G. and Oi, J. C. (1999). ‘Property rights in the Chinese economy: Contours of the process of change’. In Oi, J. C. and Walder, A. G. (Eds.), Property Rights and China's Economic Reforms. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, (pp. 1–24).Google Scholar
Wank, D. L. (1999). ‘Social networks and property rights: Enforcement, expectations, and efficiency in the urban non-state economy’. In Oi, J. C. and Walder, A. G. (Eds), Property Rights and China's Economic Reforms. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, (pp. 248–72).Google Scholar
Weitzman, M. L. and Xu, G. (1994). ‘Chinese township–village enterprises as vaguely defined cooperatives’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 18, 121–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Whiting, S. H. (2001). Power and Wealth in Rural China: The Political Economy of Institutional Change. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Whyte, M. K. (1995). ‘The social context for China's economic development’. China Quarterly, 144, 999–1019.Google Scholar
Williams, H. (2001). ‘Property rights and legal reform in township and village enterprises in China’. Asian-Pacific Law and Policy Journal, 2, 1, 227–58.Google Scholar
Woo, W. T. (1999). ‘The real reasons for China's growth’. China Journal, 41, 115–37.Google Scholar
Yao, Y (2001). ‘Government commitment and the outcome of privatization in China’. Working Paper, Peking University, Beijing, China.Google Scholar
Yao, S. (2002). ‘Privilege and corruption: The problems of China's socialist market economy’. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 61, 1, 279–99.Google Scholar
Zahra, S. A., Ireland, R. D., Gutierrez, I. and Hitt, M. A. (2000). ‘Privatization and entrepreneurial transformation: Emerging issues and a future research agenda’. Academy of Management Review, 25, 3, 509–24.Google Scholar
Zhang, Y. and Parker, D. (2002). ‘Labor and total factor productivity in the Chinese electronic industry in the 1990s’. Working Paper No. 21, Center on Regulation and Competition, University of Manchester: UK.Google Scholar
Zhang, A., Zhang, Y. and Zhao, R. (2001). ‘Impact of ownership and competition on the productivity of Chinese enterprises’. Journal of Comparative Economics, 29, 327–46.Google Scholar