No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Failing to Fight for the “Russian World”: Pre-War Social Origins of the Pro-Russian Secessionist Organizations in Ukraine
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 October 2022
Abstract
The existing literature explains the war in Donbas and the rationale for why conflict broke out there while failing to do so in other Ukrainian provinces, such as Odesa or Kharkiv. Local pro-Russian organizations could not attract considerable attention and support in the pre-war period in all parts of Ukraine, except for Crimea. The social marginalization and negligible influence of the pro-Russian organizations among the locals presumably stemmed from their weak social ties among the local population. The question is why they had such weak social embeddedness in the local societies despite relatively popular pro-Russian sympathies in these regions? Surprisingly, nobody has sought to explain the social origins of the pro-Russian movements as a source of their weakness and failure to be sparked by the anti-Ukrainian rebellion in 2014.
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Association for the Study of Nationalities
References
References
Andreeva, Darya. 2015. “Uchenyi Aleksey Samoilov. Pravoslavnyi sovetskiy imperialist.” Ukraina.ru, January 26. https://ukraina.ru/interview/20150126/1011911372.html.Google Scholar
Apukhtin, Yurii. 2018. “Russkaya vesna. Zapiski ochevidtsa.” Alternativa, September 18. http://alternatio.org/articles/articles/item/62943-russkaya-vesna-zapiski-ochevidtsa.Google Scholar
Argument.ua
. 2014. “Konets “Oplota.” Evgeniy Zhilin otvetit za banditizm, February 23. http://argumentua.com/stati/konets-oplota-evgenii-zhilin-otvetit-za-banditizm.Google Scholar
Balcells, Laia, and Steele, Abbey. 2016. “Warfare, Political Identities, and Displacement in Spain and Colombia.” Political Geography 51: 15–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bessonova, Inna. 2015. “Proekt „DNR“: „Respublika“ desyat let nazad,” 112.ua, April 23. https://112.ua/statji/proekt-dnr-respublika-desyat-let-nazad-223313.html.Google Scholar
Brenner, David. 2016. “Authority and Armed Groups in Myanmar’s Changing Borderlands.” PhD diss., London School of Economics.Google Scholar
Buckholz, Quentin. 2017. “The Dogs That Didn’t Bark: Elite Preferences and the Failure of Separatism in Kharkiv and Dnipropetrovsk.” Problems of Post-Communism 66 (3): 151–160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buntovskiy Sergey. 2016. Istoriya Donbassa: Ot pervykh lyudei do sovremennosti. Ridero.Google Scholar
Carroll, Oliver. 2014. “Why Ukraine’s Separatist Movement Failed in Kharkiv.” The New Republic, June 23. https://newrepublic.com/article/118301/kharkivs-kernes-returns-different-city-after-being-shot.Google Scholar
Clover, Charles. 2016. Black Wind, White Snow. The Rise of Russia’s New Nationalism. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Derkach, Tatyana. 2017a. “Kazaki-razboiniki: ChVK na sluzhbe u UPC MP? Chasť 3. Odesskaya eparkhiya,” Religiozno-informatsionnaya sluzhba Ukrainy, September 9. https://risu.ua/ru/kazaki-razboyniki-chvk-na-sluzhbe-u-upc-mp-chast-3-odesskaya-eparhiya_n86534.Google Scholar
Derkach, Tatyana. 2017b. “Kazaki-razboiniki: ChVK na sluzhbe u UPC MP? Chasť 6. Kharkovskaya eparkhiya,” Religiozno-informatsionnaya sluzhba Ukrainy, October 9. https://risu.ua/ru/kazaki-razboyniki-chvk-na-sluzhbe-upc-mp-chast-6-harkovskaya-eparhiya_n86997.Google Scholar
Dubovyk, Volodymyr. 2015. “Odessa: A Local Dimension of Ukraine’s Revolution, Crisis, and Conflict.” PONARS Eurasia, October 13. https://www.ponarseurasia.org/odessa-a-local-dimension-of-ukraine-s-revolution-crisis-and-conflict/.Google Scholar
Dzutsati, Valery. 2020. “Geographies of Hybrid War: Rebellion and Foreign Intervention in Ukraine.” Small Wars and Insurgencies 32 (3): 441–468.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fakty.ua
. 2014. “Kievskii sud prodlil srok prebyvania v SIZO lidera odesskogo antimaidana Davidchenko,” June 24. https://fakty.ua/183789-kievskij-sud-prodlil-srok-prebyvaniya-v-sizo-lidera-odesskogo-antimajdana-davidchenko.Google Scholar
Forney, Jonathan Filip. 2015. “Who Can We Trust with a Gun? Information Networks and Adverse Selection in Militia Recruitment.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 59 (5): 824–849.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Giuliano, Elise. 2015. “The Social Bases of Support for Self-determination in East Ukraine.” Ethnopolitics 14 (5): 513–522.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gurr, Ted Robert. 2015. Minorities, Nationalists, and Islamists: Managing Communal Conflict in the Twenty-first Century. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Horvath, Robert. 2021. Putin’s Fascists: Russkii Obraz and the Politics of Managed Nationalism in Russia. Routledge.Google Scholar
Ivanov, Denis. 2017. “Igor Markov. Ugolovnik I separatist.” Skelet.info, August 27. https://skelet-info.org/igor-markov-ugolovnik-i-separatist/.Google Scholar
Jackson William, D. 1999.“Fascism, Vigilantism, and the State: Russian National Unity Movement.” Problems of Post-Communism 46 (1): 34–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Katchanovski, Ivan. 2016. “The Separatist War in Donbas: A Violent Break-up of Ukraine?” European Politics and Society 17 (4): 473–489.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kazansky, Denis. 2010. “Prorossijskije dviženija v Donbasse.” December 28. http://frankensstein.livejournal.com/124212.html?thread=3048244.Google Scholar
KIIS
. 2015. “Geopoliticheskie orientatsii grazhdan Ukrainy: Ustoichivoe I iymenchivoe poslednikh let (Fevral 2012 – Fevral 2015).” March 18. http://www.kiis.com.ua/?lang=rus&cat=reports&id=507&page=7.Google Scholar
KIIS
. 2021. “Heopolitychni orientatsii zhyteliv Ukraiiny: cherven 2012 roku.” July 18. https://www.kiis.com.ua/?lang=ukr&cat=reports&id=1054&page=1.Google Scholar
Kozhevnikova, Galina. 2007. Radikaľnyi natsionalizm v Rossiii protivodeiistvie emu v 2006 godu. Informatsionno-analiticheskiy centr SOVA, April 1, http://www.sova-center.ru/racism-xenophobia/publications/2007/04/d10516/.Google Scholar
Kudelia, Serhiy. 2016. “The Donbas Rift.” Russian Politics and Law 54 (1): 5–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kudelia, Serhiy. 2019. “How They Joined? Militants and Informers in the Armed Conflict in Donbas.” Small Wars and Insurgencies 30 (2): 279–306.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Serhiy, Kudelia, and van Zyl, Johanna. 2019. “In My Name: The Impact of Regional Identity on Civilian Attitudes in the Armed Conflict in Donbas.” Nationalities Papers 47 (5): 801–821.Google Scholar
Kulyk, Volodymyr. 2019. “Identity in Transformation: Russian-speakers in Post-Soviet Ukraine.” Europe-Asia Studies 71 (1): 156–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuzio, Taras. 2015a. “Competing Nationalisms, Euromaidan, and the Russian-Ukrainian Conflict.” Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism 15 (1): 157–169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuzio, Taras. 2015b. “Rise and Fall of the Party of Regions Political Machine.” Problems of Post-Communism 62 (3): 174–186.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuzio, Taras. 2015c. “The Origins of Peace, Non-Violence, and Conflict in Ukraine." In Ukraine and Russia: People, Politics, Propaganda and Perspectives, edited by Pikulicka-Wilczewska, Agnieszka and Sakwa, Richard. Bristol: E-International Relations Publishing.Google Scholar
Kuzio, Taras. 2019. “Russian Stereotypes and Myths of Ukraine and Ukrainians and Why Novorossiya Failed.” Communist and Post-Communist Studies 52 (4): 297–309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuzio, Taras. 2020. Crisis in Russian Studies? Nationalism (Imperialism), Racism and War. Bristol: E-International Relations Publishing.Google Scholar
Laruelle, Marlene. 2016. “Russian Nationalist Mythmaking of the Ukrainian Crisis.” Post-Soviet Affairs 32 (1): 55–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laruelle, Marlene. 2018. Russian Nationalism: Imaginaries, Doctrines, and Political Battlefields, London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liva sprava
. 2010. “Ultrapravaya Odessa. Popytka analýza.” May 22. http://livasprava.info/content/view/210.Google Scholar
Mampilly, Zachariah, and Stewart, Megan A.. 2020. “A Typology of Rebel Political Institutional Arrangements.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 65 (1): 15–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matveeva, Anna. 2016. “No Moscow Stooges: Identity Polarization and Guerilla Movement.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 16 (1): 25–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meduza
. 2016. “Besedy ‘Sergeya Glazyeva’ o Kryme i besporyadkakh na vostoke Ukrainy. Rasshifrovka.” August 22. https://meduza.io/feature/2016/08/22/besedy-sergeya-glazieva-o-kryme-i-besporyadkah-na-vostoke-ukrainy-rasshifrovka.Google Scholar
Mishchenko, Elena. 2020. “7 aprelya – den pobedy nad ‘russkoi vesnoi’ v Nikolaeve: ka keto bylo.” 0512.ua, April 7. https://www.0512.com.ua/news/2722174/7-aprela-den-pobedy-nad-russkoj-vesnoj-v-nikolaeve-kak-eto-bylo-foto.Google Scholar
Mitrokhin, Nikolay. 2015. “Infiltration, Instruction, Invasion: Russia’s War in Donbass.” Journal of Soviet and Post-Soviet Politics and Society 1 (1): 219–249.Google Scholar
Yuliya, Mostova, Rakhmanin, Serhiy, and Vedernikova, Inna. 2014. “Pivdennyi skhid: hilka dereva nashoho,” Dzerkalo tyzhnya, April 18. https://zn.ua/ukr/internal/pivdenniy-shid-gilka-dereva-nashogo-_.html.Google Scholar
Nekhlyudov Egor. 2007. “‘Pravoslavnogo’ agenta Kremlya reshili otluchiť ot deneg,” Obkom, November 23. http://obkom.net.ua/articles/2007-11/23.1305.shtml.Google Scholar
National Security and Defense
. 2012. Vidnosyny Ukraiiny z ESi IRF: Pozitsii ta otsinki hromadyan, Razumkov Center, No. 4–5 (133–134): 104–124. https://razumkov.org.ua/uploads/journal/ukr/NSD133-134_2012_ukr.pdf.Google Scholar
National Security and Defense
. 2013. How citizens see Ukraine’s integration in the EU of the Customs Union: Focus Group Results, Razumkov Center, No. 4–5 (141–142): 98–104, https://razumkov.org.ua/uploads/journal/eng/NSD141-142_2013_eng.pdf.Google Scholar
National Security and Defense
. 2014. Problemy ta perspektyvy ukraiinsko-rosiyskykh vidnosyn ochyma hromadyan, Razumkov Center, 5–6 (148–149): 68–79. https://razumkov.org.ua/uploads/journal/ukr/NSD148-149_2014_ukr.pdf.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nikitenko Sergey. 2014. “Pochemu v Khersone net separatistov.” MOST, March 7. https://most.ks.ua/news/url/pochemu_v_hersone_pochti_net_separatistov.Google Scholar
Nitsova, Silviya. 2021. “Why the Difference? Donbas, Kharkiv and Dnipropetrovsk After Ukraine’s Euromaidan Revolution.” Europe-Asia Studies 73 (10): 1832–1856.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Novoe vremya
. 2018. “Strelbu v Odesse ustroil izvestnyi odesskiy duelyant I lider partii Stalina – SMI.” January 18. https://nv.ua/ukraine/events/strelbu-v-odesse-ustroil-izvestnyj-odesskij-dueljant-i-lider-partii-stalina-smi-2446305.html.Google Scholar
Lidow, Nicholas Hard (2016). Violent Order: Understanding Rebel Governance through Liberia’s Civil War, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Odessa Daily
. 2014. “‘Narodnye druzhi’ v Odesse: fashisty pod maskoi ‘antifashizma.’” February 24. http://odessa-daily.com.ua/news/narodnye-druzhiny-v-odesse-fashisty-pod-maskoj-antifashizma-id62395.html.Google Scholar
Osinskiy, Bogdan. 2011. “Skandal: radikalnye stalinisty promyvayut mozg uchashchimsya shkoly,” 048.ua, No. 68, May 8, https://www.048.ua/news/48820/skandal-radikalnye-stalinisty-promyvaut-mozg-ucasimsa-skoly-no68-foto.Google Scholar
Parkinson, Sarah E. and Sherry, Zaks. (2018). “Militant and rebel organization(s).” Comparative Politics 50 (2): 271–290.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Platonova, Maria. 2021. The Donbas Conflict in Ukraine: Elites, Protest, and Partition. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Populyakh, Natalya. 2016. “Donetskaya respublika: Istoki terrorizma.” Myrotvorets News, July 7. https://myrotvorets.news/donetskaya-respublyka-ystoky-terrorystycheskoj-organyzatsyy/.Google Scholar
Portnov, Andrii. 2015. “Post-Maidan Europe and the New Ukrainian Studies.” Slavic Review 74 (4): 723–731.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Relihiya v Ukraiini
. 2011. “Rukhnula ‘finansovaya piramida’ lidera Soyuza pravoslavnykh grazhdan Ukrainy Valeriya Kaurova.” November 13. https://www.religion.in.ua/news/vazhlivo/13006-ruxnula-finansovaya-piramida-lidera-soyuza-pravoslavnyx-grazhdan-ukrainy-valeriya-kaurova.html.Google Scholar
Salehyan, Idean. 2010. “The Delegation of War to Rebel Organizations.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 54 (3): 493–515.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sarafanov, Mikhail. 2015. “Sergei Moiseev: Tretiy puť Rossii – puť Tretiego Rima.” Kolokol Rossii, May 21. http://kolokolrussia.ru/russkiy-mir/sergey-moiseev-tretiy-put-rossii-put-tretego-rima.Google Scholar
Shapovalova, Nataila, and Jarábik, Balász. 2018. “How Eastern Ukraine is Adapting and Surviving: The Case of Kharkiv.” Carnegie Europe, September 12. https://carnegieeurope.eu/2018/09/12/how-eastern-ukraine-is-adapting-and-surviving-case-of-kharkiv-pub-77216.Google Scholar
Shekhovtsov, Anton. 2017. “Aleksandr Dugin’s Neo-Eurasianism and the Russian-Ukrainian War.” In The Politics of Eurasianism: Identity, Popular Culture and Russia’s Foreign Policy, edited by Bassin, Mark and Pozo, Gonzalo, 181–201. London: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Sizov, Vitalii. 2015. Kgbeshye korni „DNR,” Donetskaia pravda, August 13. http://pravda.dn.ua/article/337-kgbshnye-korny-dnr.Google Scholar
Skorkin, Konstantin. 2016. “25 let donbasskogo separatizma.” Realnaya gazeta, March 24. https://realgazeta.com.ua/25-let-donbasskogo-separatizma_-chast-vtoraya/.Google Scholar
Sotiriou, Stylianos. 2016. “The Irreversibility of History: The Case of the Ukrainian Crisis (2013-2015).” Southeastern European and Black Sea Studies 16 (1): 51–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Staniland, Paul. 2012. “Organizing Insurgency: Networks, Resources and Rebellion in South Asia.” International Security 37 (1): 142–177.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Staniland, Paul. 2014. Networks of Rebellion: Explaining Insurgent Cohesion and Collapse. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Stebelsky, Ihor. 2018. “A Tale of Two Regions: Geopolitics, Identities, Narratives, and Conflict in Kharkiv and the Donbas.” Eurasian Geography and Economics 59 (1): 28–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sukkulentov, Aleksandr. 2018. “Vystrel v nogu: Kak Moskva proigrala pravoslavnyi factor v Odesse.” 048.ua, August 16. https://www.048.ua/news/2128932/vystrel-v-nogu-kak-moskva-proigrala-pravoslavnyj-faktor-v-odesse.Google Scholar
Sukkulentov, Aleksandr. 2015. “Pozornye begletsy iz Odessy: Kto predal gorod i poshel na sluzhbu k okkupantam.” 048.ua, November 17. https://www.048.ua/news/1032694/pozornye-beglecy-iz-odessy-kto-predal-gorod-i-posel-na-sluzbu-k-okkupantam.Google Scholar
Suslov, Mikhail. 2018. “‘Russian World’ Concept: Post-Soviet Geopolitical Ideology and the Logic of ‘Spheres of Influence.’” Geopolitics 23 (2): 330–353.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Togdemir, Efe, et al. 2021. “Rebel Rivalry and the Strategic Nature of Rebel Group Ideology and Demands.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 65 (4): 729–758.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tokdemir, Efe et al. (2020). “Rebel Rivalry and the Strategic Nature of Rebel Group Ideology and Demands.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 65(4): 729–758.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
TSN. 2016a. “U Zaporizhzhi zhaduyuť ‘yayechnu nedilyu.” April 13. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jvMk9DvE5D8.Google Scholar
TSN. 2016b. “Vid vatazhka „titushok“ Kharkova do „heroya „DNR.” Shcho vidomo pro vbytoho pid Moskvoyu Yevhena Zhylina. September 20. https://tsn.ua/ukrayina/scho-vidomo-pro-separatista-zhilina-750155.html.Google Scholar
Umland, Andreas. 2020. “The Far Right in Pre- and Post-Euromaidan Ukraine: From Ultra-Nationalist Party Politics to Ethno-Centric Uncivil Society.” Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 28 (2): 247–268.Google Scholar
Sergey, Varis. 2017. “Ruslan Bodelan: o chem ne pokayalsya byvshiy khozyain Odessy.” Skelet.info, September 19. https://skelet.info/ruslan-bodelan-o-chem-ne-pokayalsya-byvshij-xozyain-odessy-chast-2/.Google Scholar
Vesti.ua
. 2016. “Evgeniy Zhilin: fakty i biografiya oplotovtsa, zastrelennogo v Moskve.” September 19. https://vesti.ua/strana/201206-evhenij-zhilin-biohrafija-i-fakty.Google Scholar
Vygovskiy, Oleg. 2016. Levye dengi Kremlya: obiedinennie “Boroťba,” Antikor, September 24. https://antikor.com.ua/articles/125804-levye_denjgi_kremlja_objedinenie_borotjba.Google Scholar
Weinstein, Jeremy. 2007. Inside Rebellion: The Politics of Insurgent Violence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Wesolowsky, Tony. 2019. “Rogues’ Gallery: Whatever Happened to The First Separatist Leaders in Ukraine?” Radio Liberty, March 3. https://www.rferl.org/a/rogues-gallery-whatever-happened-to-the-first-separatist-leaders-in-ukraine-/29800648.html.Google Scholar
Wilson, Andrew. 2014. Ukraine Crisis: What It Means for the West. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Wittek, Rafael. 2010. “Rational Choice Theory.” In Theory in Social and Cultural Anthropology: An Encyclopedia, edited by McGee, Jon and Warms, Richard, 688–690. SAGE.Google Scholar
Woldemariam, Michael (2018). Insurgent Fragmentation in the Horn of Africa: Rebellion and its Discontents, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wynnyckyj, Mychailo. 2019. Ukraine’s Maidan, Russia’s War. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Zhukov, Yuri M. (2016). “Tradin g hard hats for combat helmets: The economics of rebellion in eastern Ukraine.” 44 (1): 1–15.Google Scholar
Zhuchkovskii, Aleksandr. 2018. 85 dnei Slavianska. Sankt Petersburg: Izdatelstvo “Chernaia sotnia.”Google Scholar
Interview 1. 2021. Associate Professor at the Department of Political Science, Kharkiv National University, Interviewed by author, May. Online Call.Google Scholar
Interview 2. 2018. Political analyst originally from Donetsk and chairman of NGO Ukrainian People’s Council of Donetsk and Luhansk Provinces (UNRDL), Interviewed by author, November. Kyiv, Ukraine.Google Scholar
Interview 3. 2018. Political activist originally from Donetsk and former voluntary fighter in Artemivsk battalion, Interviewed by author, November. Kyiv, Ukraine.Google Scholar
Interview 4. 2021. Local political activist and expert from Odesa, Interviewed by author, April. Online CallGoogle Scholar
Interview 5. 2018. Former member of pro-Russian organization Donetsk Republic and fighter in Ukrainian voluntary battalion after 2014, Interviewed by author, November. Online Call.Google Scholar
Interview 6. 2019. Political blogger, journalist, and commentator originally from Donetsk, author of several books on local elites and political affairs in Donbas, Interviewed by author, August. Kyiv, Ukraine.Google Scholar
Interview 1. 2021. Associate Professor at the Department of Political Science, Kharkiv National University, Interviewed by author, May. Online Call.Google Scholar
Interview 2. 2018. Political analyst originally from Donetsk and chairman of NGO Ukrainian People’s Council of Donetsk and Luhansk Provinces (UNRDL), Interviewed by author, November. Kyiv, Ukraine.Google Scholar
Interview 3. 2018. Political activist originally from Donetsk and former voluntary fighter in Artemivsk battalion, Interviewed by author, November. Kyiv, Ukraine.Google Scholar
Interview 4. 2021. Local political activist and expert from Odesa, Interviewed by author, April. Online CallGoogle Scholar
Interview 5. 2018. Former member of pro-Russian organization Donetsk Republic and fighter in Ukrainian voluntary battalion after 2014, Interviewed by author, November. Online Call.Google Scholar
Interview 6. 2019. Political blogger, journalist, and commentator originally from Donetsk, author of several books on local elites and political affairs in Donbas, Interviewed by author, August. Kyiv, Ukraine.Google Scholar