Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-8zxtt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-09T01:29:35.758Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

English Bards and a Scottish Previewer: David Hume

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 July 2024

Extract

‘It is a tide which has turned only once in human history. . . . There is presumably a calendar date —a moment—when the onus of proof passed from the atheist to the believer, when, quite suddenly, secretly, the noes had it’.

Thus George Moore, Tom Stoppard’s brilliant, bespectacled version of the modem moral philosopher. In Jumpers, Stoppard has managed to do with contemporary Anglo-Saxon philosophy what he did earlier in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Bead with modem literary criticism—to make of an academic discipline a playing field for his sport, and of its preoccupations so much grist for the artist’s mill. Stoppard’s wit draws the finest of lines between the serious and the outlandish; and his irreverence makes for good fun—at the expense of his earnest protagonist. But George wins us, albeit the way a warm puppy wins us; and we can summon a measure of sympathy for his plight. George moves in a world where all his colleagues benignly presume that intelligent people outgrow belief in God; and so, he feels defensive about his commitment to a deity fashioned of old by the philosophers.

It really does not matter to most believers today, I suppose, that the onus for proving the existence of God has passed to them. Believers are not so interested as they used to be in cornering the adversaries in the labyrinth of the Five Ways. What the believer may feel, however, is a certain social onus, as he rubs shoulders with that large company, now in the ascendancy, who look upon him as they might look upon a curious fossil unearthed in a Palestinian excavation.

That the tide has turned and the believer has ridden out with it to an exile in a foreign land characterizes the current Christian Sitz im Leben. Our poets sensed, three and four generations ago, that this would be the climate of the twentieth century.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © 1974 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Stoppard, Tom, Jumpers (London 1972), p. 25Google Scholar.

2 See Norman Kemp Smith's edition of the Dialogues (London, 1947)Google Scholar: here hte case for Hume's affinities with philo is carefully put forward.

3 See Copleston, F. C.. A History of Philosophy, V: Hobbles to Hume (London 1959). p. 308Google Scholar.

4 The Natural History was first published in 1757: by Hume seems to have written it in 1749–51. The Dialogues concerning Natural Religion, though published posthumously in 1779, were substantially written before 1751. The Enquiry concerning Human Understanding was first published in 1748.

5 Quotations from the Natural History and the Dialogues are from Hume on Religion. ed. Wolheim, Richard (London, 1963)Google Scholar. Page numbers in parenthesis pertain to this edition.

6 See part I. p. 112.

7 Section XI, pp. 230 ff. in Hume on Religion.

8 Hume on Religion, pp. 239–40.

9 See Natural History, pp. 55–66.

10 See Enquiry, XII.

11 Natural History, p. 56. I have regularised italics.