No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Liberation Theology: A Comparative Study of Christian and Islamic Approaches
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 January 2024
Abstract
Research into liberation theologies has rarely had an interreligious perspective. To that end, I shall carry out a comparative study of Christian and Islamic versions of liberation theology and I shall highlight the similarities and differences in their approaches. It will be a thematic study that is structured around three key mentalities which are shared by the approaches of both religious traditions. Firstly, the need to reinterpret their own religions from the perspective of the poor; secondly the interrelated emphases on action, orthopraxy and the agency of the oppressed; and thirdly a rejection of excessive other-worldliness. I conclude from my analyses with the following hypotheses: firstly, due to the lack of an authority akin to the Catholic Church, Islamic liberation theology is comparatively more likely to create the potential for social upheaval and is more likely to lead to an attenuation of metaphysical religious feeling; secondly, all liberation theologies contain latently the potential for creating millenarian outbursts; the best example to offer from modern history of this latent feature becoming manifest is in the Iranian Islamic revolution of 1979.
- Type
- Original Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 2015 The Dominican Council
References
1 Halverson, Jeffry R., Theology and Creed in Sunni Islam: The Muslim Brotherhood, Ash'arism, and Political Sunnism (USA: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010), p. 127CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
2 Mannheim, Karl, Ideology and Utopia (London: Routledge, 1936), pp. 190ffGoogle Scholar
3 Some key examples of the secondary literature (in chronological order of publication) are as follows: Brown, Robert McAfee, Theology in a New Key, (Philadelphia: Westminister, 1978)Google Scholar; Deane William Ferm Third World Liberation Theologies, An Introductory Survey, (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1986); Boff, Leonardo and Boff, Clodovis, Introducing Liberation Theology, (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1987)Google Scholar; Sigmund, Paul E. Liberation Theology at the Crossroads, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990)Google Scholar; Rowland, Christopher [ed.] The Cambridge Companion to Liberation Theology, (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1999 [Second edition: 2007])CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tombs, David, Latin American Liberation Theology, (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2002)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Petrella, Ivan The Future of Liberation Theology: An Argument and Manifesto, (Hampshire, England: Asghate, 2004)Google Scholar.
4 Cf. McGovern, Arthur F.,Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, (Maryknoll, NY: Obis, 1989)Google Scholar, especially chapter three.
5 Islamic Liberation Theology: Resisting the Empire, (USA and Canada: Routledge, 2008)Google Scholar
6 For some pertinent examples: Yilmaz, Hakan, ‘Islam, Sovereignty and Democracy: A Turkish View’ in Middle East Journal 3 (2007), pp. 477–493CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Toros, Emre, ‘The Relationship Between Islam and Democracy in Turkey: Employing Political Culture as an Indicator’ in Social Indicators Research 2 (2010), pp. 253–265CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Fadl, Khaled Abou El ‘Islam and the Challenge of Democratic Commitment’ in Oriente Moderno 2 (2007), pp. 247–300CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Mannheim,Ideology and Utopia, p. 192
8 Rowland, Christopher, Radical Christianity, (UK: Polity Press, 1988), p. 14Google Scholar
9 Berryman, Philip,Liberation Theology: Essential Facts about the Revolutionary Movement in Latin America, (USA: Temple University Press, 1987), p. 205Google Scholar as cited in Araujo, Robert J., ‘Political Theory and Liberation Theology: The Intersection of Unger and Gutiérrez’ in Journal of Law and Religion 1 (1994), p. 68Google Scholar.
10 The dominant school of theology in contemporary Sunni Islam. It stresses the inadequacy of human reason to comprehend adequately matters of morality, metaphysics or theology. Human reason is especially incapable of knowing much about the Divine Essences or about the nature of the Godhead. It emphasises instead the important role that revelation must play to compensate for this inadequacy. It also regards human free will as being incompatible with the omnipotence of God, and hence teaches metaphysical determinism. It was the school of thought that was favoured by traditionalists who were perturbed by the doctrines of the Mu'tazila school, which were more akin to rationalism.
11 A school of theology that is no longer used by mainstream Sunni scholars. However, in the Shia sect, Mu'tazlite theology continues to be used to this day. Mu'tazilite theology is generally said to be rationalist in orientation because it claims that human reason has some capability of determining the will and nature of God. Therefore it does not regard sacred tradition and revelation as being superior to reason but, correctly understood, in accordance with it. This union of faith with reason or revelation with reason has led some to compare Mu'tazilite thought to that of the Scholastics. Moreover, the Mu'tazilite school taught that human free will exists and can be used to explain the existence of evil, as it would be an affront to God's perfect justice to claim that He is responsible for evil instead of the free will of humans. The Mu'tazilah also rejected all hints of anthropocentrism in our understanding of God and in our interpretation of scripture; they therefore developed a hermeneutics that sought to interpret certain passages in the Qur'an symbolically.
12 Martin Riexinger, ‘Nasserism Revitalized. A Critical Reading of Ḥasan Ḥanafī's Projects “The Islamic Left” and “Occidentalism” (And Their Uncritical Reading)’ in Die Welt des Islams 1 (2007), p. 70
13 Esack, Farid, Qur'an, Liberation & Pluralism: An Islamic Perspective of Interreligious Solidarity Against Oppression, (Finland: Oneworld Publications, 1997), p. 11Google Scholar
14 The plural of ‘alim’ which means scholar. Ulama often refers to the entire body of legal scholars who have been taught the traditional curriculum of jurisprudence, theology, mysticism, and study of scripture and of the sacred tradition. They have the role of arbitrating legal disputes and providing legal advice for Muslims.
15 Esack, Farid, ‘Three Islamic strands in the South African struggle for justice’ in Third World Quarterly, 2 (1988), p. 476Google Scholar
16 Ibid, p. 478
17 Esack,Qur'an, Liberation & Pluralism, p.99
18 Dabashi, Hamid, Theology of Discontent: Ideological Foundations of the Islamic Revolution in Iran (New York: New York University Press, 1993), p. 111Google Scholar.
19 Şeriati, Ali, Ali Şiası Safevî Şiası (Ankara: Fecr Yayınları, 2009), p. 111Google Scholar.
20 Shariati, Ali,On the Sociology of Islam (New Delhi: Crescent Publishing, 1979), p. 120.Google Scholar
21 Şeriati, Ali, Ali (Ankara: Fecr Yayınları, 2011), p. 489Google Scholar.
22 Şeriati, Ali Şiası Safevî Şiası, p. 204.
23 Shariati, On the Sociology of Islam, p. 108.
24 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 8.
25 Ibid, p. 11.
26 Gutiérrez, Gustavo ‘The Church: Sacrament of History’ in Cadorette, Curt, Giblin, Marie, Legge, Marilyn J., and Synder, Mary Hembrow [eds] Liberation Theology: An Introductory Reader (Maryknoll, NY: Obis, 1992), p. 176Google Scholar.
27 Ibid, p. 177.
28 Ibid, emphasis in the original.
29 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 140.
30 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 12.
31 Ibid, p. 49.
32 Ibid.
33 Ibid, p. 219.
34 Keddie, Nikki R. and Cole, Juan R.I. (1986) ‘Introduction’ in Keddie, Nikki R. and Cole, Juan R.I. [eds] Shi'ism and Social Protest (USA: Yale University Press, 1986) p. 10Google Scholar.
35 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 224.
36 Ibid, pp. 71–72.
37 Ratzinger, Joseph, Instruction on Christian Freedom and Liberation (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1986)Google Scholar, §46 [by Cardinal Ratzinger on behalf of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith].
38 Ibid, §68.
39 Ibid, §47.
40 Ibid, §75.
41 Ibid, §79.
42 Pope John Paul II, Laborem Exercens (On Human Work), Available at: http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091981_laborem-exercens_en.html (accessed: 26/04/2014), §20.
43 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 17.
44 Pope John Paul II, Sollicitudo Rei Socialis (The Social Concern), Available at: http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_30121987_sollicitudo-rei-socialis_en.html (accessed: 26/04/2014), §40.
45 Rahman, Fazlur, Islam and Modernity: Transformation of an Intellectual Tradition (USA: University of Chicago Press, 1982), p. 19Google Scholar.
46 One of the five obligatory duties (or ‘pillars’) of Islam. Zakat is the duty of alms-giving which must be carried out by all Muslims who are financially capable. Its purpose is to alleviate the poverty of the most deprived members of the Muslim community. The typical minimum donation is one-fortieth (2.5%) of the value of one's yearly capital assets. In some Muslim countries the states themselves collect and distribute this tax, whereas other Muslim countries rely on voluntary donations to be made to charitable organisations.
47 Ibid, emphasis removed.
48 Dabashi, Theology of Discontent: Ideological Foundations of the Islamic Revolution in Iran, p. 115; p. 120; also cf. Dabashi, Hamid, Shi'ism: A Religion of Protest (USA: Harvard University Press, 2011), p. 269CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
49 Şeriati, Ali, Dine Karşı Din [Religion against Religion] (Ankara: Fecr Yayınları, 2012), p. 149Google Scholar; also cf. Şeriati, , İnsan [Man/The Human Being] (Ankara: Fecr Yayınları, 2012)Google Scholar, passim.
50 Enayat, Hamid, Modern Islamic Political Thought (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1982), pp. 24–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
51 Keddie and Cole, ‘Introduction’, p. 6.
52 Şeriati, Ali, pp. 208–214; Dine Karşı Din, pp. 156–160; Adem'in Vârisi Hüseyin [Hussein: The Inheritor of Adam] (Ankara: Fecr Yayınları, 2010), passim; Shariati, Ali, Hossein: Vares-e Adam [Hussein: The Inheritor of Adam] (Tehran: Qalam Publications, 1988), pp. 253–304Google Scholar.
53 Barbé, Dominique, ‘Church Base Communities’ in Cadorette, Curt, Giblin, Marie, Legge, Marilyn J., and Synder, Mary Hembrow [eds] Liberation Theology: An Introductory Reader (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1992), p. 188Google Scholar.
54 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 134.
55 Ibid, p. 129.
56 Boff, Leonardo, ‘How Can We Know Christ?’ in Cadorette, Curt, Giblin, Marie, Legge, Marilyn J., and Synder, Mary Hembrow [eds] Liberation Theology: An Introductory Reader (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1992), p. 90Google Scholar.
57 Ibid.
58 Reza Aslan, No God But God (UK: Arrow Books, 2011), p. 146.
59 Eliaçık, Recep İhsan, Devrimci İslâm [Revolutionary Islam] (Istanbul: Doğu Kitabevi, 2013), p. 35Google Scholar.
60 Ibid.
61 Eliaçık, Recep İhsan, Kur'an'a Giriş [Introduction to the Qur'an] (Istanbul: İnşa Yayınları, 2011), p. 102Google Scholar.
62 Ibid, p. 103.
63 Recep Eliaçık, İhsan; Erdem, Eren; Yılmaz, Hakkı; and Yunak, Yılmaz, İslam ve Kapitalizm: Medine'den İnsanlığa [Islam and Capitalism: From Medina to Humanity] (Istanbul: Doğu Kitabevi, 2011), pp. 27–28Google Scholar.
64 Recep İhsan Eliaçık, Kur'an'a Giriş, pp. 101ff.
65 Ibid.
66 Erdem, Eren, Devrim Ayetleri: Egemenlerin İslam’ı Değil Ezilenlerin İslam’ı [Verses of Revolution: The Islam of the Oppressed, Not of the Oppressors] (Istanbul: Kırmızı Kedi Yayınevi, 2013), p. 80Google Scholar.
67 Ibid, pp. 74–80.
68 Riexinger, ‘Nasserism Revitalized. A Critical Reading of Ḥasan Ḥanafī's Projects “The Islamic Left” and “Occidentalism” (And Their Uncritical Reading)’, p. 76.
69 Ibid, p. 75.
70 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 3.
71 Mannheim, Ideology and Utopia, p. 195.
72 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 3.
73 Ibid, p. 7.
74 Mannheim, Ideology and Utopia, p. 173.
75 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 140.
76 Araujo, ‘Political Theory and Liberation Theology: The Intersection of Unger and Gutiérrez’, p. 69.
77 Haight, Roger S. S.J., An Alternative: An Interpretation of Liberation Theology, (Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press, 1985), p. 255Google Scholar.
78 Sobrino, Jon, ‘Jesus and the Kingdom of God’ in Cadorette, Curt, Giblin, Marie, Legge, Marilyn J., and Synder, Mary Hembrow [eds] Liberation Theology: An Introductory Reader (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1992), p. 118Google Scholar, emphasis in the original.
79 Erdem, Devrim Ayetleri: Egemenlerin İslam’ı Değil Ezilenlerin İslam’ı, pp. 237–238.
80 Dabashi, Theology of Discontent: Ideological Foundations of the Islamic Revolution in Iran, p. 131.
81 Ibid, p. 145.
82 Keddie, Nikki R., Roots of Revolution: An Interpretative History of Modern Iran (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1981), p. 215Google Scholar.
83 Mannheim, Ideology and Utopia, p. 196.
84 Ibid, p. 201.
85 Dabashi, Theology of Discontent: Ideological Foundations of the Islamic Revolution in Iran, p. 385; cf. pp. 482–483; also cf. Moin, Baqer, Khomeini: Life of the Ayatollah (London and New York: I.B. Tauris, 1999), pp. 200–201Google Scholar.
86 Dabashi, Shi'ism: A Religion of Protest, p. 64.
87 McCabe, Herbert O.P. and Wiles, Maurice, ‘The Incarnation: An Exchange’ in New Blackfriars 691 (1977), p. 553Google Scholar.
88 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 73; cf. McCabe, Herbert, God Matters (London: Continuum, 1987), p. 73.Google Scholar
89 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 75.
90 Ibid, p. 77.
91 Ibid.
92 Ibid, p. 9.
93 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 138.
94 Sobrino, ‘Jesus and the Kingdom of God’, p. 109.
95 Rowland, Radical Christianity, p. 152.
96 Ibid, p. 136.
97 Ibid, p. 137.
98 Robbins, Thomas [reviewer], ‘Prophetic Religions and Politics: Religion and the Political Order by Jeffrey K. Haddan; Anson Shupe’ in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 4 (1987), p. 563Google Scholar.
99 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, p. 208.
100 Baljon, J.M.S., Modern Muslim Koran Interpretation (1880–1960) (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1968), p. 15Google Scholar.
101 Ibid, p. 100.
102 Riexinger, ‘Nasserism Revitalized. A Critical Reading of Ḥasan Ḥanafī's Projects “The Islamic Left” and “Occidentalism” (And Their Uncritical Reading)’, p. 76.
103 Ibid, p. 72.
104 Baljon, Modern Muslim Koran Interpretation (1880–1960), p. 100.
105 Rahman, Fazlur, Major Themes of the Qur'an: Second Edition (USA: University of Chicago Press, 2009), p. 108Google Scholar.
106 Baljon, Modern Muslim Koran Interpretation (1880–1960), p. 100.
107 Dabashi, Theology of Discontent: Ideological Foundations of the Islamic Revolution in Iran, pp. 192–193; cf. Motahhari, Morteza, Seyri Dar Nahj al-Balagha [Journey through the ‘Peak of Eloquence’] (Qom: Sadra, 1975), pp. 214Google Scholarff.
108 Ali Şeriati, Dine Karşı Din, pp. 140–142
109 Erdem, Devrim Ayetleri: Egemenlerin İslam’ı Değil Ezilenlerin İslam’ı, pp. 223–226.
110 Ibid, p. 226.
111 The orthodox metaphysical world-view of Islam is maintained by the Egyptian revolutionary Islamist Sayyid Qutb (cf. Khatab, Sayed, The Political Thought of Sayyid Qutb: The Theory of Jahiliyyah, London and New York: Routledge, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar and the Turkish nationalist and Islamic socialist Nurettin Topçu (cf. Ahlâk Nizamı [The Order of Morality], Istanbul: Dergâh Yayınları, 1961; Var Olmak [To Be], Istanbul: Dergâh Yayınları, 1965; İsyan Ahlâkı [The Morality of Rebellion], Istanbul: Dergâh Yayınları, 1995)Google Scholar.
112 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, pp. 83–91; and Snyder, Mary Hembrow, ‘Introduction to Spirituality and Liberation’ in Cadorette, Curt, Giblin, Marie, Legge, Marilyn J., and Synder, Mary Hembrow [eds] Liberation Theology: An Introductory Reader (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1992), pp. 221–229Google Scholar.
113 McGovern, Liberation Theology and its Critics: Toward an Assessment, pp. 47–61.
114 Roberts, Richard H., ‘Introduction: Religion and Capitalism – a new convergence?’ in Roberts, Richard H. [ed] Religion and the Transformations of Capitalism: Comparative Approaches (London and New York: Routledge, 1995), p. 8Google Scholar.
115 Doja, Albert, ‘Spiritual Surrender: From Companionship to Hierarchy in the History of Bektashism’ in Numen 4 (2006), p. 504Google Scholar.
116 Binder, Leonard, Islamic Liberalism: A Critique of Development Ideologies (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988), p. 17Google Scholar.
117 Ibid ; Yavuz, M. Hakan, Islamic Political Identity in Turkey (New York: Oxford University Press, 2003), p. 204Google Scholar.
118 Doja, Albert, ‘Histoire et dialectique des idéologies et significations religieuses’ in European Legacy: Journal of the International Society for the Study of European Ideas 5 (2000), pp. 678–679CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
119 “[O]n pourrait volontiers qualifier plutôt de “lien dialectique,” entre [les mouvements religieux et les mouvements révolutionnaires], le socialisme étant obtenu par dépassement (Aufhebung) de la religion” (Doja 2000, p679) – i.e. one could readily posit a dialectical link between revolutionary and religious movements, socialism being obtained by the sublation of religion”.